12 ms·
I went to the University of Waterloo and took a "Intro to CS for non-math students" course. The thing was designed and taught by CS faculty, so naturally they
by Waterluvian 5y ago
I went to the University of Waterloo and took a "Intro to CS for non-math students" course. The thing was designed and taught by CS faculty, so naturally they taught you the basics of programming using math.
I spent more time re-learning high school math than actually learning programming. And not because it was directly related, but because some lessons were like, "write a function in Java that factors a quadratic." So 90% of that tutorial was me re-learning what the heck a quadratic is and how to factor it.
The experience really sucked and I gave up on university programming courses and just started learning it all practically and on my own terms.
Edit: Enjoy this wonderfully styled course page: https://student.cs.uwaterloo.ca/~cs125/S08/Resources/Admin/CourseOutline.shtml https://student.cs.uwaterloo.ca/~cs125/S08/Resources/Admin/C...
- artificial 5y agoI like learning files and sockets once the syntax is a familiar and then branching out to error handling followed by more advanced topics and then circling back around to testing. Project based learning resonates best with me, hands on cements knowledge rather than pure theory.
- kamaal 5y agoThe real question is in asking, what are you going to use the programming language to build? If you are going into a Math heavy domain, you are going to use a programming language to solve math problems, and hence involves learning Math. This the same problem, with whiteboard leetcode style problems in interviews. Most people fail to understand why they have to put in months to years of practice into a domain to which doesn't concern with their everyday work. On the other hand there is tremendous shortage of people with skills for real world problems and applications.
- Waterluvian 5y agoYeah. I've been writing code as a job for a decade now and have never needed to factor a quadratic equation. I really just needed a course that helped me get introduced to programming (which I ended up using a LOT in the domain I went to school for: geography and remote sensing). (Every time I write something like this I immediately feel defensive about being an impostor. Someone saying, "how can you not know that? You should know that. You must not be doing _real programming_.)
- mlyle 5y ago> Yeah. I've been writing code as a job for a decade now and have never needed to factor a quadratic equation. A lot of people never touch algebra again. Some of us end up touching it a lot. This is a bit of a tricky thing, in that: - A whole lot of practitioners have very limited continuous math and deep CS needs, so some of these requirements are artificial barriers to some extent for many jobs. - But is it reasonable to give them CS degrees without at least basic competence? - Plus, part of the point of a university education is to round-out students and expose them to many things...
- Waterluvian 5y agoTo be clear, this course was exclusively "CS for NON CS/math majors." If you were in CS, you were not allowed to take it. They also offer a lot of "math for non mathies" courses, which would have been a great place to teach quadratics.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoYes, but I doubt you had write code to factor a quadratic equation because it's a solved problem and you have libs that will do it for you. Imagine if you had been given an exercise of such a low level nature for every single topic you might touch in IT in the future. You would have had to code a function to do UTF8 decoding, JPEG rendering, TCP/IP error correction, font rasterization, ray tracing, PEG parsing, an USB driver, data diffing, model training, etc. Also, you don't learn much about programming by creating a function to factor a quadratic equation. You seldom learn about types, side effects, algo complexity, or even about collections, iteration, branching, memory, debugging, etc. You just learn to badly translate a very specific, narrow problem to the language you use.
- Jtsummers 5y ago> Yes, but I doubt you had write code to factor a quadratic equation because it's a solved problem and you have libs that will do it for you. It is not totally unreasonable to expect students in an intro to CS course to have some basic competency in algebra (university dependent). Giving them a problem in a domain they're already familiar with (or that where familiarity can be expected) lets them, in theory, focus on the algorithm/data structure side without having to also be taught the domain. Most of the exercises in a first CS course are solved with libraries (standard in some languages, or 3rd party in others). That doesn't mean it's not useful for developing the knowledge the course is aiming for. Do you also think we shouldn't teach arithmetic and should only teach using calculators? (You may, actually, I know people who think that way.)
- criddell 5y agoI think you also need to consider just what is meant by “computer science”. Is it programming? My daughter is studying comp. sci. right now and there seems to be a ridiculous amount of math and math proofs and very little programming in her program (she’s still in her first year). The spend a considerable amount of time proving stuff using big-O (and theta and omicron etc…) and surprisingly little time applying those ideas. I think what you wanted (and what should be offered to everybody) is a course designed to teach programming and programming concepts.
- weaksauce 5y agocomputer science is not programming though it often involves doing that. it's a math degree with many different topics all related to computing and math. So yeah if they wanted to learn how to program java that's a completely different track. they generally don't teach you much programming or other practical things at a university track. you need to know it but it's ancillary to the degree.
- l33t2328 5y agoA computer science degree isn’t a math degree any more than a physics or chemistry degree is a math degree. Classes like Computer Organization, Operating Systems, Networking, Databases, Software Engineering Fundamentals, the first year programming sequence, etc. could hardly be considered math courses.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thorajeu83 5y ago
- weaksauce 5y ago> Classes like Computer Organization, Operating Systems, Networking, Databases, Software Engineering Fundamentals, the first year programming sequence, etc. could hardly be considered math courses. so a math degree has to have every single course be a math course? do they not take literature? Networking had me prove the theoretical limit of networks using calculus and other things, databases had us using relational algebra and other proofs... it certainly wasn't `select * from users;` kinda course. it's a math degree at least at my university and most reputable ones it is. are all classes 100% pure math? no of course not but the emphasis is math.
- strangemonad 5y agoLong story short, if you want to do something off the beaten path, you need to get to know some of the faculty. I also went to Waterloo but as a cs undergrad. I was also a student rep on the undergrad curriculum committee (this was all some years ago). You’ll notice that all the non Math / CS major classes are completely different offerings. Non math majors can only take those “other” cs classes and likewise math majors can’t take them and must take the classes intended for CS students. Unless things have changed, very few faculty tech these non cs major CS classes (mostly sectional lecturers). My overall impression (at the time) was that these classes weren’t that great. They mostly taught you to program (in Java) but exercises were grounded heavily in math problems but didn’t really teach math. If you really want to get a good sense of “computer science” (the discipline) rather than just learn to program, I’d try and get to know the profs that teach 135 and see if you can get a specific override exception. You could possibly do the same for 136. Going deeper down the cs course tree is a bit harder. Part of the challenge is the depth and pacing you want to offer majors doesn’t always align with the broader overview non majors are looking for. Eg you might want a single course covering algorithms and data structures rather than 3-4 courses and you might not care about the math involved to prove amortized costs. If you want to go beyond 135/136 there are a few possible paths that come to mind and involve finding cross appointed faculty and seeing if they might sponsor you for an override into their class offering. If you’re in psych, the cog Sci route would get you to know people who are cross appointed with AI folks, arts used to have cross appointed faculty with the computer graphics lab (Craig Kaplan is a friendly face in the CGL). Physics obviously has overlap with the quantum computing lab. I don’t know any of current the undergrad ce advisors but J.P. Pretti might be able to point you in the right direction
- mcguire 5y agoRoughly the same was true at UT Austin when I was there. They introduced CS-for-non-majors classes, but I don't know anyone who would have touched them with a 10-foot pole.
- fredophile 5y agoI can't say I'm too surprised. Waterloo is unusual in that they offer a Bachelors in Math in addition to the more standard B.Sc. and B.A degrees. Computer Science majors there graduate with a B.Math.
- alibero 5y agoWaterloo also offers a BCS which has fewer math requirements than the BMath: https://cs.uwaterloo.ca/current-undergraduate-students/majors#BCSvsBMathCS https://cs.uwaterloo.ca/current-undergraduate-students/major... The BMath option is only required if you want to have a double major in CS and a different area of math. Otherwise the BCS is strictly more flexible: you have 5 fewer math courses and 5 more electives (which you may use to take math courses if you really want to). From my experience most people are graduating with BCS unless they really like math.
- fredophile 5y agoInteresting. At the time I was picking universities that wasn't an option they offered.
- ww520 5y agoThat’s what programming is. Programming is applying computerized solutions to different problem domains. To make a successful problem, you have to learn about the targeted domain and sometimes become an expert in it. In this case the problem domain is quadratic factoring.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThis isn't helpful for say econ majors who want to build econometric models though. The class sounds like it is specifically for non cs majors so it doesn't really make sense to get into theory that might not apply to their studies.
- ww520 5y agoRight. Sometimes we are forced to go outside of our comfort zone. A software engineer might not care much about insurance actuary, bank money transfer, railroad signal rules, or econ supply/demand curves. But when the job calls for creating programs to do those areas, he better learns those fast, on the fly. That class taught an important reality of software development. You have to be willing to learn something you're not familiar to get the job done, and how well you understand the problem domain directly affects how well the program is developed. So the class was not tailored for the econ major, but at the college level, students need to learn that no one is going to hand a solution on a silver platter for your problem.
- alasr 5y agoIMHO CS, software engineering and computer programming are very different but closely related fields. Each field focus and work on different (but complementary) set of activities in order to efficiently solve a computation-based automation problems. Based on the scale and complexity level of software artifacts, you'll see an individual, a small team or very large team are working on a given challenge/problem[1]. CS is, with mathematics as its foundation, focused more on the abstract and computational aspects[2] of a computational problems/challenges. As expected, CS solutions are usually very generic and independent of any specific programming language, it presents its solution in abstract forms and along with some code (written in some programming language). From CS's point of view, the coding part of its solution is primarily[3] for demonstrating that the solution of a specified problem is computable and efficient (for some practical purpose) and can be verified independently if needed. Now, computer programming languages are just one of the tools which helps us write those codes to "communicate" our solutions to computers and fellow programmers (who, as part of the team, need to understand in order to help developing and maintaining the software program). And, there're other alternative programming languages available which practically does the same job (though some of them are more appropriate and suitable than others, due to reasons/concerns outside the scope of a particular programming language[4]). Having said all the above, I think I understand the core of the problem(s) you (and students in similar position as you) described here, in your post. I think I've faced similar challenges while trying to understand some non-CS course (for example, accounting and finance). Being new to any field of STEM/business/..., it's easy to get pulled into non-important areas of studies instead of focusing on the core ideas/concepts of the course. And I believe it's always course instructor primary responsibility making sure that core concepts/ideas are made very clear at the course and individual lectures level and, similarly, corresponding supporting concepts/activities which make up the course and its core concepts. NOTE: I've few more thoughts on the subject; however, I think, my current post is already getting too long so I stop this post, at this point. --- [1] - Btw, as you may already know, team size alone doesn't indicate that they're working on a easy or difficult problem. Sometimes it's just a consequence of some financing/time constraints or inefficient team management. [2] - For example; data model, data structure and algorithm. [3] - Other benefits are secondary and can be considered as bonus. [3] - Reasons/concerns related to either CS or software engineering.
- ska 5y agoA couple of things worth considering 1) CS::software development is a bit like physics::mechanical engineering 2) CS at waterloo definitely skews to the cs-is-part-of-applied-math thinking in many ways. Other university CS programs are very different. I'm not saying a "practical programming for non math/cs types" course isn't a good idea, just that really isn't what you signed up for.
- inetsee 5y ago"Enjoy this wonderfully styled course page" I have the Tranquility! extension on my browser, which turns that web page into something quite readable. The web page as it is is the complete opposite of something readable. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tranquility-1/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tranquility-1...
- 908B64B197 5y ago> The thing was designed and taught by CS faculty, so naturally they taught you the basics of programming using math. I would have honestly made the same assumption that students interested in programming would have no problem with high school level math. Maybe an intro course aimed toward the business school wouldn’t be as math-heavy? 6.001 was notorious for starting out with examples from calculous and required some proof reading. But it wasn’t aimed at anyone. It’s tougher to enroll in 6.001 than most other intro courses.