19 ms·
Newly declassified documents reveal previously secret CIA bulk collection
- kingcharles 5y agoWashington Post article: https://archive.md/qcJcf https://archive.md/qcJcf
- jsrcout 5y ago"No matter how cynical you get, you just can't keep up."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nescioquid 5y agoYour quotation can't be extolled enough. As a mere undergraduate in the early '90s, reading about Omnivore (and later Carnivore and later Total Information Awareness and its subsequent refinements) and the ineffectual vituperations against them, I thought that the retrenchment was only apparent, a moving back to take yet another run at the dream of omniscient preemption and thereby control. Today, nothing dies. Everything simply becomes more subtle. There is no single head to urge into the guillotine. Is there a way out, or be there no exit? What's left to do? Knock over one's king man on the board? How's that for cynicism? edit: for the down-voting Panglosians: give me your reason rather than mouse-clicks.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Today, nothing dies. Is this you summing up how your entire comment evokes a Charlie Stross novel?
- java-man 5y ago
- searealist 5y agoNow imagine these tools in the hands of communists.
- loudtieblahblah 5y ago
- drekk 5y agoThis is pretty gross holocaust revisionism. Equating the Nazis to the people that were responsible for 7/10 Nazi casualties. But hey, capitalist Russia today is a much nicer country than the USSR right? With lower infant mortality rates, higher literacy, better gender equity in things like pay or education? McCarthy's spirit truly never left the public American psyche
- southerntofu 5y ago> This is pretty gross holocaust revisionism. Not really, no. The USSR has its own history of genocides, especially against muslim communities. And both USSR and the nazis were strongly opposed to any form of social protests: the nazis called opponents "terrorists" or "judeo-bolshevik", while the USSR called them "leftists" or "counter-revolutionaries" (see also: Cronstadt uprising, Makhnovtchina). Let's not forget also that Hitler and Staline had an alliance at some point. There are quite a few differences between national socialism (nazism) and authoritarian communism, but they can't exactly be presented as opposites, as they occupy the same half (authoritarianism) of the political compass. Disclaimer: i'm advocating for libertarian communism (self-organization, not bureaucracy). I believe defending tyrannical regimes in the name of communism does not help the cause. In fact, i would even argue the USSR killed all chances of communism when the Bolsheviks started slaughtering the real revolutionaries (anarchists and anti-authoritarian marxists alike), and that they never tried to go beyond the dictatorship of the proletariat which was presented as exceptional/temporary measures against counter-revolutionary activities on the road to communism (stateless, classless society). Having a central State dictating your life and bureaucrats overseeing your work is not communism: it's State capitalism (or as Mussolini called it referring to fascism: corporatism) at its finest.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoIt's cool that things that make the government look bad are eventually legally declassified and discussed openly.
- ALittleLight 5y agoI'm sure glad that even though they've consistently done bad things in the past, they must've stopped now!
- culi 5y agoThis is one of the simplest and hardest to disagree with comments I've ever come across
- sneak 5y agoIt's troubling that those that would openly break the law face no consequences, I guess having a place that doesn't equally apply the justice system to everyone be visible about it is better than being invisible about it. They're supposed to enforce the laws equally against everyone, though, so the fact that certain powerful organizations in government are exempt and open about it is a little bit more terrifying than if they were exempt but quiet about it. It's a bit of a flex. There's literally a part of the US government that can torture people, get caught, get investigated by US Congress, hack into official congressional computers to delete evidence, get caught doing that, and then... face no consequences whatsoever. If that isn't the most powerful organization in the world, I sincerely don't know who else might qualify for that title.
- culi 5y agoIt's not really much different from White Collar vs Blue Collar crime is it though? Not to quote a certain poet,[0] but you mug someone on the street and you could face life in prison, but if you mug a whole community, the worst that might happen is you lose your job [0] https://genius.com/The-coup-fat-cats-bigga-fish-lyrics https://genius.com/The-coup-fat-cats-bigga-fish-lyrics
- Dracophoenix 5y ago
- sneak 5y agoNote for the record that this outcome/letter/press release is because they spied on Americans (which they are ostensibly not supposed to do). Now imagine how unrestrained they are when spying on the other 96% of the human population that resides on this planet, and that anything that Google, Apple (iCloud, iMessage), Facebook (WhatsApp, Instagram, including DMs), or Microsoft knows about you, they can know about you. The CIA is truly out of control.
- mrtksn 5y agoWouldn’t be that the %96 should be doing their counter intelligence? I don’t see how CIA has an obligation over non-US citizens. I tend to believe that EU’s privacy stance is primarily to do that. They are trying to forge a framework where free market can operate but keep the Europeans data in EU, under the EU jurisdiction. Europe and US are allies but they are also competitors. It’s not wise to let foreign entities run you communications. When the US fir the first time encountered that with TikTok, the first instinct was to ban it, I.e. the China way. I like the EU way better.
- zarzavat 5y agoIf you spy on allies without apology you may find out later that they don’t consider you to be an ally any more. That is a recipe for isolation.
- mrandish 5y agoNot just CIA, the overall surveillance state from national to state agencies to local law enforcement is so pervasive, all-encompassing and hidden (or under-reported), it's pretty terrifying. And that's just the technically "legal" stuff without all the rampant abuses of using private sub-contractors, other government's agencies (Five Eyes), gag orders, etc to get around "inconvenient" limitations.
- nyolfen 5y agoi'm going to be real with you, almost nobody on earth cares about their government spying on foreign nationals. if the CIA has any popular legitimacy it is because they spy on foreign nationals.
- aeturnum 5y agoThis reminds me that, despite the prissy and offended denouncements from the Air Force and DOD (War Department?), the only fiction in Dr. Strangelove is the characters. All of the systems depicted were built. https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/almost-everything-in-dr-strangelove-was-true https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/almost-everything-i...
- pasabagi 5y agoIt was worse than that: in Doctor Strangelove, General Buck Turgidson was at least waiting for Truman's say-so before doing anything irrevocable. In real life, there's this anecdote about Curtis Lemay: SAC had reconnaissance aircraft flying secret missions over the Soviet Union twenty-four hours a day. “If I see that the Russians are amassing their planes for an attack, I’m going to knock the shit out of them before they take off the ground.” Sprague was shocked. “But General,” he countered, “that’s not national policy.” Sprague remembered LeMay responding, “I don’t care. It’s my policy. That’s what I’m going to do.” https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1995/06/19/the-general-and-world-war-iii https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1995/06/19/the-general-an...
- aeturnum 5y agoIt's funny because the open source arms control community (like Martin Pfeiffer[1]) works really hard to inform people of how few safeguards our nuclear policy has. But even those anemic safeguards (the idea that only the president can arbitrarily launch nukes) have frequently been illusory! I genuinely think we way-under-rate how closely we escaped nuclear annihilation in the last 100 years. [1] https://twitter.com/NuclearAnthro https://twitter.com/NuclearAnthro
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoWhat is the data in question? I don't see it mentioned in the article.
- roywiggins 5y agoThis is the report I think (it's pretty heavily redacted): https://www.cia.gov/static/63f697addbbd30a4d64432ff28bbc6d6/OPCL-PCLOB-Report-on-CIA-Activities.pdf https://www.cia.gov/static/63f697addbbd30a4d64432ff28bbc6d6/... The program is apparently bulk collection of financial data.
- owlninja 5y agoThanks...I am still a bit confused and thought the post URL would lead me to something more informative judging by the reactions here.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoIf there is one thing I've learned on the Internet it's that reading the article is not a prerequisite for having a strong reaction and commenting on it.
- roywiggins 5y agoI'm not sure actually reading the PCLOB report is very informative. I certainly don't have the context to understand it fully, and of course a lot of it is blacked out. Reading these sorts of disosures and putting them into context requires a LOT of domain knowledge that I don't have. Wyden being pissed about it is a decent sign that it's something to be worried about though, he's spent a lot of time on this stuff.
- roywiggins 5y agoThe letter from Wyden and Heinrich explains it a bit. The issue is that other foreign bulk collection has some oversight from Congress and the judiciary. Bulk collection authorized under FISA (The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act) is reviewed by the FISC (a special secret court) and every so often the court will find that the NSA or FBI has messed up and needs to fix its procedures around US persons. Those programs are also briefed to the House and Senate intelligence committees who can, at least in theory, exercise oversight, even if in secret. This CIA program has no particular statutory authorization and is being justified under an executive order from the 80s. It wasn't disclosed to anyone in Congress. It isn't being even notionally overseen by the FISC. It's just a bunch of CIA people justifying their own procedures to themselves. https://www.wyden.senate.gov/download/hainesburns_wydenheinrich_13apr21_final https://www.wyden.senate.gov/download/hainesburns_wydenheinr...
- twayt 5y agoI can’t interpret posts like this to understand whether I should care or not. This kind of headline could mean anything from something benign to something which seriously threatens privacy. Anyone who actually knows about this, what’s the TLDR?
- roywiggins 5y agoI think this is the report that was declassified. It's pretty heavily redacted (and long). It's talking about a program collecting bulk financial records, targeting ISIS. https://www.cia.gov/static/63f697addbbd30a4d64432ff28bbc6d6/OPCL-PCLOB-Report-on-CIA-Activities.pdf https://www.cia.gov/static/63f697addbbd30a4d64432ff28bbc6d6/...
- fsociety999 5y agoThis executive order was signed in 1981… Shows how afraid people are to mess with the CIA. They shouldn’t even be allowed to operate in the United States let alone collect information on American citizens. One thing I’ve always wondered is why Snowden exposed the NSA mass surveillance, but didn’t say a word about the CIA despite having worked for both agencies. It is, of course, possible he didn’t know about the CIA collecting data, but I find that pretty hard to believe.
- mtgx 5y agoHe was an NSA contractor, not a CIA one.
- dboreham 5y agoAccording to Wikipedia Snowden was a CIA employee between 2006 and 2009.
- noarchy 5y agoWell he is speaking about it now: https://twitter.com/Snowden/status/1491961623132651521 https://twitter.com/Snowden/status/1491961623132651521
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- at-fates-hands 5y agoSerious question: We know Snowden took a LOT of documents related to spying on US citizens. I only remember seeing a few things that were released publicly. Is there still a lot more stuff he's going to release, or has released, just without much fanfare? I'm genuinely curious because I remember people on both sides really freaked out about what he was going to release and I just haven't seen the supposed troves of information he was going to release. Is it mainly just because its irrelevant so many years on now?
- digisign 5y ago
- midislack 5y ago
- olliej 5y agoBut any back doors required by the EARN IT Act totally won’t be abused
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ctoth 5y agoSaw the title, thought "This is probably Wyden," clicked the link... Yup. Say what you will about the guy he's remarkably consistent on this sort of thing. I think that's admirable.
- yucky 5y agoYeah him and Rand Paul who disagree on almost everything else, tend to be the most consistent Senators on issues like this.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoNote that since it wasn't immediately apparent to me what or when the data was collected, this is about bulk collection of financial data in order to combat ISIL. Given the timeline of the report, https://www.cia.gov/static/63f697addbbd30a4d64432ff28bbc6d6/OPCL-PCLOB-Report-on-CIA-Activities.pdf https://www.cia.gov/static/63f697addbbd30a4d64432ff28bbc6d6/..., it makes it sound like they looked into activities in the 2014 timeframe.
- olliej 5y agoIt doesn't matter what information they were looking for: "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects,[a] against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.[2]"
- simondotau 5y agoYeah but they had secret courts issuing secret warrants. Or something. So they’re fine.
- hedora 5y agoYeah, there’s a secret law saying that it’s all good. Trust Us.
- olliej 5y agoIf you can't trust shadowy organizations with a track record of lying or misleading congress, who can you trust?
- beckman466 5y agoI trust you.
- sneak 5y agoNo, this isn't the FISA stuff (which, while still unconstitutional, claims authority from the FISA Amendments Act, and, yes, the secret rubber stamp FISA court), this is worse: this is the CIA doing something completely unrelated via an executive order interpretation. This doesn't even go to the FISA court, and they didn't tell the congressional oversight committees about it (all of whom have clearance to know/hear).
- imwillofficial 5y agoI mean, we all kind of saw this one coming.
- imwillofficial 5y agoI found the three people surprised by this news.
- joelbondurant1 5y ago
- fallingfrog 5y agoIt doesn't matter how the public votes or what people think- they're going to do whatever they want, whenever they want, and because it's all secret, there will never be any accountability for it. Vote all you want, the CIA is impervious to democracy.
- lbriner 5y agoThe elephant in the room is the ability for the President to issue executive orders that can more often than not impinge on liberties that should be protected by the Constitution. The CIA will always want more power, that is the nature of the secret services but if the people are bothered, why isn't there more talk of curtailing what the President is allowed to do unilaterally?
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoIf eg. a CEO of a company signs something illegal, and in turn the company does something illegal, the CEO is criminally on the line. If the president signs something illegal (unconstitutional in this case), why does nothing happen?
- harry8 5y agoBecause they /all/ do it. Every single president. To prosecute looks political but more importantly if the current president prosecutes, they'll be the defendant next time the other side is in and they'll be guilty as sin. Why do they all do it? Might be a better question to ponder.
- ben_w 5y agoIf every president (or other leader, this isn’t just about the USA) genuinely needs the power to do certain things which are against the constitution of their nation, the correct solution is to change the constitution to reflect reality. If a government allows its employees to get away with doing things which are against that government’s own rules for their own operation, then a few bad apples spoil the whole barrel. If you need government spies secretly looking on certain citizens without the targets being aware of it via a warrant, make sure they can’t ever be used like Nixon. If you need government assassins, you definitely don’t want them used the way Nixon used government spies.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoJust look at the (absolutely absurd) list of presidential pardons each has performed on the way out...adds lots of color to this story.
- silvercove 5y ago
- Cosmin_C 5y agoWhen I access the post it sends me to the following page --- Sorry, a potential security risk was detected in your submitted request. The Webmaster has been alerted. Reference ID: *.****.*****.**** You can proceed to www.senate.gov. If this problem persists, please contact the Office of the Secretary Webmaster at webmaster@sec.senate.gov. --- All right, keep your secrets.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- elliotpage 5y agoI like how this is framed as "previously secret" when it has been glaringly obvious for years.