7 ms·
Forgive me if this sounds insensitive but I’m curious for some feedback: Were people uglier back then? Is it my own biases based on clothing and hair style? Is
by Waterluvian 5y ago
Forgive me if this sounds insensitive but I’m curious for some feedback:
Were people uglier back then? Is it my own biases based on clothing and hair style? Is it because of the type of film? Better dental today? More opportunity to adjust one’s appearance with disposable income today?
But most curiously: does anyone else have this passing thought when looking at older photos? Or am I just betraying my own shallow vanity?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thevagrant 5y agoIf you look at the war documentary "They shall not grow old" you may come to the same conclusion. A good portion of people in that era were malnourished. If I recall correctly, the documentary mentions the army had to do a fair bit to get recruits into shape (by feeding them well and putting them through training). Lack of dental and fluoridated water may be another factor. I suspect back then it was also more common to smoke.
- shagie 5y agoThe National School Lunch program was signed into law by Truman in 1946. Its purpose was stated as to "safeguard the health and well-being of the Nation’s children" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_School_Lunch_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_School_Lunch_Act https://www.thecongressproject.com/national-school-lunch-act-1946 https://www.thecongressproject.com/national-school-lunch-act... > Additionally, because this occurred in a post-war Congress, another argument to make funds permanent came from the fact that men were rejected from Selective Service during the war because of poor nutrition when they were children.
- abrookewood 5y agoThis is an excellent documentary. Thoroughly recommend it if you have even a passing interest in WW1, though it's heart-breaking. Produced and directed by Peter Jackson: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7905466/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7905466/
- ericd 5y agoIt's also a technical tour de force, they turned shaky black and white footage with variable frame rate (from early hand cranked video cameras) into almost-cinema-grade color footage, and they recreated the sound using speakers local to the areas of the soldiers, combined with lip reading. It's an incredible work.
- vidanay 5y agoIt's an indicator of the level of health and wealth in modern society. If you are able to read and reply to this thread, then you live in a country/culture where your wealth is orders of magnitude greater than those shown in the photos.
- joe_the_user 5y agoPeople smiled less in the 1930s. Smiling has increased with media exposure over time. To me, the people actually look healthier. Few extreme overbites or underbites. Decent posture, strong chins, few bellies sticking out (indicating metabolic syndrome). Edit: and sure, missing teeth. And not worrying about media, people with the missing teeth don't seem ashamed of them.
- vlunkr 5y ago> Smiling has increased with media exposure over time. That sounds really made up.
- zuminator 5y agoIt may not be far off from the truth. It's been argued that, not that people smiled less overall back then, but that in earlier times, photograph etiquette was in line with painting etiquette. You were expected to make a serious face preserved for posterity. It's only over time as photos become more spontaneous and ubiquitous that we have adopted the cultural vocabulary of smiling in response to having our picture taken, or so the argument goes. See here: https://time.com/4568032/smile-serious-old-photos/ https://time.com/4568032/smile-serious-old-photos/
- fernly 5y agoTo me, kids and younger adults look fine, put them in current fashions and they'd pass today without comment. It's the middle-aged and older ones whose faces are really ravaged by time and experience. And the teeth, oh lordy.
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoCan these old images be used, if ever it becomes necessary, to fight a growing movement against fluoridation of drinking water? Tangentially: only because the winter olympics are on, but do there exist snowboarders that have anything but perfect teeth?
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoYou have to be pretty wealthy to afford to snowboard (good nutrition, good healthcare, etc.). Then, if you get to the upper echelons of the sport you're looking at getting advertising deals, and so, looking like someone advertiser's want to use images of is probably really helpful.
- joeman1000 5y agoGoing by James Nestor’s observations and research in his book ‘Breath’: he relays that a Victorian dentist notes “the better the school, the worse the teeth”. Teeth straightness and overcrowding are ‘upper-class’ issues. Poorer people, in the authors claims, are exposed to tougher food. The increased chewing they do actually causes the palate to grow correctly and without crowding. Soft food does the opposite.
- tsol 5y agoI've heard this before, but it isn't really true any more. We all eat soft, processed foods now with little differences between classes. Although we also have much more advanced dentistry, so it isn't necessarily very obvious either
- 5y ago
- Spooky23 5y agoCountry people were farmers or farm workers. Farm prosperity varies a lot, but always involved back breaking physical work, the type of work that breaks your body. The poorer the farmer, the harder the work. They also had big families that were hard to feed, and at best had occasional access to a doctor in private practice who had a limited array of tools. My grandparents families were farmers back in Ireland, born just after the First World War. My maternal grandfather was the 4th oldest son, and my grandmother the 9th child and 3rd daughter. They were fortunate in that their family owned (and still owns) the farm, but unfortunate in that they had no job prospects of any kind at home. Literally. In spite of relative prosperity, they didn’t have running water and parts of the houses had dirt floors at the time. My grandfather had a great story about seeing an electric light for the first time — in 1925/6 in a pub where a salesman was demonstrating a battery lamp. These fold were poor, often worked for most daylight hours, wore homespun clothing often, had no electric light, makeup, etc. The men often died young and the women had 2-3 times more children than today. Glamour was not an everyday consideration!
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoIn short, life was harder and there were more important things to worry about.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lostmsu 5y agoWith 2 exceptions with gum problems people on the pictures look totally fine to me.
- Jedd 5y agoIn addition to the reasons provided, I'd posit two additional contributing factors: An absence of readily accessible - nay oppressively omnipresent - pop-culture & advertising, pushing infeasibly perfect images, and A relative scarcity of mirrors. Yes, 'proper' mirrors had been invented a hundred years before this era, but even by the early 20th century they'd still have been a luxury item, especially for people in this kind of pervasive poverty.
- snek_case 5y agoAnother thing that was lacking back then is digital cameras, or even affordable chemical film. At the time, photography was a lot more expensive, and you probably only got one shot of a person. Today, we can get a preview on a digital camera's screen and we can take as many photos as we want, and then edit them afterwards. That just leads to better looking photos being presented.
- kingkawn 5y agoIt’s you
- dullcrisp 5y agoI looked through the photos after seeing this comment expecting to see some ugly people, and now I'm afraid to look in a mirror.
- WalterBright 5y agoI don't think they're any worse or better than today. Except that dental care has improved a lot! The working mens' clothes look very comfortable to me.
- moonshinefe 5y agoI didn't notice a huge difference, but your comment reminded me of something my grandma said in her later years (she died around 2018 and was well into her 90s, so she grew up in the 30s). "All the young people these days are so gosh darned good looking" as if it blew her away, lol. So maybe there's something to that, I don't know.
- heavyset_go 5y agoSun damage is probably responsible for most of it.
- the_af 5y agoI honestly don't understand how you can see ugly people in enough of those photos to consider remarking on it. I mean, some are homely and some are regular looking, but others are quite good looking. I see plenty of ugly young people in photos today. This isn't a feel good or a "good old days" kind of comment. I honestly see beautiful people in many of those photos.
- chrisbrandow 5y agoI had a related thought as the commenter above. I was just struck by how the hardness of those years clearly was visible on most of those folk. It clearly detracted from their physical appearance. Beauty != their value and uniqueness as people.
- the_af 5y ago> Beauty != their value and uniqueness as people. I totally understand that and I'm not conflating both. I truly mean that many of the people in these photos look good to me. Not "beauty inside", but actual physical beauty. Obviously not all of them, but enough that a remark about people being uglier back then seems out of place to me.
- chrisbrandow 5y agoMoney helps you look better in a lot of ways. A few of those pics show the impact of dental health alone, but also persistent hunger and stress clearly wear/break down aspects of beauty.
- dougmwne 5y agoWho are you comparing them to? People posing for the 'gram? Celebrities? Tinder photos? Beauty influencers? But yeah, dental care, sunblock, and a shower can go a long way.
- antupis 5y agoAlso stress is probably whole different level than modern day people.
- throwawaycities 5y agoFunny my thought was I didn’t see very many obese people, and that if the people in these photos were looking at photos of modern society they would probably wonder why so many people are overweight. I know it was the depression, but I’m going to go out on a limb and say that’s not the reason (I don’t imagine any of them were obese prior to the depression). Anyway, your point could be just a bias…I’d say spend some time scrolling through something like “people of Walmart” photos and see if you change your mind.
- supernova87a 5y agoI was just about to comment on exactly this. The number / fraction of obese people in these photos is tiny compared to the people you see in modern US life now.
- whatshisface 5y agoWhat's your reference for attractiveness, your own friends and family, or IMDB? If the latter, therein lies the answer.
- scythe 5y agoYou're witnessing a few things, I think: - the culture of modesty affected both men's and women's dress and grooming habits, women somewhat more, but men also quite significantly - stylistic haircuts were not available in rural settings without professional barbers/hairdressers - clothes were not as stretchy; cotton and wool were coarser, nylon more rigid, polyester and spandex nonexistent - the economics of the time favored thicker, more durable fabrics over thin, friable, wears-a-hole-after-one-year fast fashion fluff - sun exposure, particularly among white people in the United States (which is much sunnier than Europe), was rarely avoided or mitigated, particularly among the working class - childhood nutrition was worse, particularly among the lower classes in the period between the first wave of enclosure/monoculture/industrialization of agriculture and the dawn of nutrition science (hence fortification) - these are images that the government did not want to show people, of course there's a higher prevalence of unattractive people!
- learc83 5y ago> sun exposure, particularly among white people in the United States (which is much sunnier than Europe), was rarely avoided or mitigated, particularly among the working class Sure farmers in the 1930s had more sun exposure than your average office worker does today. But it was certainly not rare to avoid or mitigate sun exposure. Look at the pictures. Notice the bonnets, hats, and long sleeves that the people working outside are wearing. My great grandmother (working class, born in 1912) always wore long sleeves, long pants, and a hat to do work outside. Even in the middle of July in Georgia. This was normal. https://flashbak.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Roy-Stryker-FSA-black-hole-photos-213.jpg https://flashbak.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Roy-Stryker-... https://flashbak.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Roy-Stryker-FSA-black-hole-photos-13.jpg https://flashbak.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Roy-Stryker-... https://flashbak.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Roy-Stryker-FSA-black-hole-photos-30.jpg https://flashbak.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Roy-Stryker-... > these are images that the government did not want to show people, of course there's a higher prevalence of unattractive people! Read some of the comments above by ars. That’s not actually what happened. Almost every picture has another slightly different version that was published. These weren’t censored, it was just an editor editing.
- beachy 5y agoDental hygiene has come a long way since then. Photos of British troops in WWII often show terrible looking teeth, not just on one unfortunate but whole groups of people.
- userbinator 5y agoTo me, the people in these pictures look absolutely normal and natural, unlike the ridiculously "enhanced" (often by the camera itself) photos which are far more common today. More opportunity to adjust one’s appearance with disposable income today? These are from The Depression, so there'd certainly not be much in the way of wearing cosmetics. Frankly, I think the modern trend of making people's skin almost plastic-like in appearance looks very weird and unnatural.
- vogt 5y agoI applaud you for at least being introspective and considered when asking this question, even if I didn't necessarily feel the same while looking at them. Some of the folks replying to you would be better served to approaching their responses similarly.
- Fricken 5y agoI saw 2 instances of bad teeth, otherwise I'm not sure what you're referencing. They all look pretty normal for their age to me.
- t-3 5y agoIt's just you. They all look like normal people to me.
- dncornholio 5y agoPeople were way more beautiful then IMO. Nothing is hidden, you see so much in each of their faces. Nothing is fake. I love it.
- verisimi 5y agoI think there are some people with missing teeth, they look grubbier - everyone seems to be struggling, I don't think we are seeing privileged people. But what is also interesting to me is that there weren't any wonky faces, lopsided smiles, droopy eyes.
- verytrivial 5y ago> Were people uglier back then? I think in the same way then as now, media is selective in amplifying certain ideas of human asthetics. There are millions of similarly poor, hard-working people now who don't spend a lot of time tweaking their image. These people are not in your Insta feed either. (But I think this specific set of photographs sought out a more unbiased view of whomever was working in these areas, and I can see why people were and are furious about the casual destruction of these records!)