5 ms·
As the underlying Twitter thread points out[1], there's a significant confounding factor here: the sample is from 2019 but might have been processed in 2020, at
by woodruffw 5y ago
As the underlying Twitter thread points out[1], there's a significant confounding factor here: the sample is from 2019 but might have been processed in 2020, at which point the Chinese government's (public) timeline for COVID's spread admits of the possibility of contamination.
I don't think that completely deflates the evidence here. But as a layperson, I would like to understand the probability of happening to find COVID in an Antarctic soil sample in 2019 versus the probability that someone accidentally contaminated the sample with early samples in early 2020. Put another way: my (lay) intuition doesn't understand why there would be COVID in Antarctic soil, whereas it does understand how contamination might happen in a lab that was actively processing samples of COVID.
[1]: https://twitter.com/jbloom_lab/status/1491297806115807233 https://twitter.com/jbloom_lab/status/1491297806115807233
- ImaCake 5y agoAs a molecular biologist. I would say it‘s probably contamination of the samples. The confidence comes from the other contaminating sequences found in the same samples; the hamster DNA (and monkey was the other one I think). Both are routinely used as cells lines in biology labs for viral research (not 100% on the viral research bit, but makes sense). The author‘s conclusion that it was COVID grown in a cell line and it contaminated the samples next to them on the sequencing chip is plausible. This kind of contamination is rare, but not very rare. As the author points out, there are multiple points of failure that could have caused it. Each unlikely but plausible.
- drukenemo 5y agoAnd that rare contamination would happen exactly with the most dangerous (at least world impact-wise), in decades? Still plausible?
- chc 5y agoIt's a little hard to informally assign probability in cases like. We wouldn't be hearing about this if it weren't SARS-CoV-2, so what are the odds that (if it is contaminated) the sample we're hearing about in this case would be contaminated with SARS-CoV-2? Pretty much 100%.
- woodruffw 5y agoThank you for the context. I don’t want to ask you to speculate out of the blue, but if you feel qualified: do you think it’s possible that COVID originated outside of a lab but that China has lied about the timeline to avoid embarrassment? That’s always struck me as a plausible scenario, one that seems to fall by the wayside in these conversations.
- 323 5y agoHow could outside a lab be more embarrassing than a lab-leak? There would be nothing to blame China about an outside the lab scenario.
- zeruch 5y agoDepends on interpretation: one infers possible security embarrassment (or exposure of a secret), the other potentially total incompetence at failure to ID/notice/contain (or otherwise manage). Depending on which members of the Politburo care more about what perception, may in fact mold towards which one they feel more "comfortable admitting to" if the evidence is ambiguous.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoFrom what I've read, they NEVER admit to anything.
- zeruch 5y agoMostly true, but there is always nagging truths that surface at which point denial becomes worse for them. It all depends on what they are allowed to get away with; if other states balk vs capitulate, there are more rounds of diplomatic chess to go through.
- notahacker 5y agoThey're denying the lab leak too. But if it turns out that, say, there was an isolated outbreak in some rural area a few months earlier known to the authorities who covered up because they thought they had it under control (whilst also knowing it was new and SARS-like and worthy of study at their coronavirus lab) that would be hugely damaging for the Chinese government even if it spread naturally
- tripletao 5y agoWhat do you mean by "probably"? My understanding is that it's unquestionably contamination, since no one is suggesting the virus was actually in Antarctic soil. The only question is the provenance of the contaminating sample, the likely possibilities being: 1. Virus cultured in a lab, in monkey or hamster cells but with virus originating from a human patient. This wouldn't be evidence of lab origin of the virus. It would still show that China is concealing important facts about the early origin of the pandemic though, since the recovered viral genome is among the most ancestral (closest to the closest-known bat viruses) known. It should thus have been scientifically noteworthy enough to publish, but that genome was unpublished until these Hungarians dug it out. 2. Virus cultured as part of a scientific experiment, before the beginning of the pandemic. That would be the "smoking gun", but nothing yet allows us to distinguish between this and case (1). Sangon Biotech's customer records might answer this, since they know when the sample was sequenced and what other customers' samples were sequenced around the same time. Those aren't too easy to get, though. I've seen speculation that Illumina's cloud services may contain significant information within reach of American subpoena, but no concrete action. Other comments speculate that an infected lab technician could explain the reads, but that wouldn't explain the hamster and monkey DNA.
- ImaCake 5y agoI was just hedging my statements really. The rest of what yoy say addresses other important considerations well so I don’t have anything else to add.
- bewaretheirs 5y agoSee also https://github.com/jbloom/PRJNA692319_public https://github.com/jbloom/PRJNA692319_public particularly the end of README.md: "On Feb-8-2022, I e-mailed the Chinese authors of the paper to ask about the sample deletion and restoration. They e-mailed back almost immediately. They confirmed what they had told Istvan: they had sequenced the samples with Sangon Biotech (Shanghai) after extracting the DNA in December 2019 from their samples. The suspect that contamination of the samples happened at Sangon Biotech. They deleted the three most contaminated samples from the Sequence Read Archive. They do not know why the samples were then 'un-deleted.'" (end quote)