9 ms·
> You can point to the decline of organized religion and with it traditional gender roles, but then what explains the relative stability in post-Christian Europ
by rayiner 5y ago
> You can point to the decline of organized religion and with it traditional gender roles, but then what explains the relative stability in post-Christian Europe?
As far as I can tell, Europe isn’t all that post-Christian. Even countries that have low levels of people actively practicing religion still carry a strong cultural legacy from Christianity: https://www.europenowjournal.org/2019/10/02/the-catholic-ness-of-secular-france/ https://www.europenowjournal.org/2019/10/02/the-catholic-nes...
Counterintuitively, America’s lack of a generous welfare system tends to destabilize traditional gender roles. Among women with children under 18, 56% would prefer a “homemaker” role if they were “free” to do either: https://news.gallup.com/poll/186050/children-key-factor-women-desire-work-outside-home.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/186050/children-key-factor-wome.... Contrast with just 26% of men. 39% of women without kids would also prefer to stay home if they had the choice. Even out of women who are currently employed, but have children under 18, the majority would prefer not to work.
Contrast say the Netherlands. It is an egalitarian, post-Christian place, for example, but 60% of working Dutch women only work part time, versus 20% of working Dutch men.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- irrational 5y agoWho wouldn’t prefer to stay home if they had the choice? I could spend my days traveling, hiking, going to the beach, reading, working on hobbies, learning new skills, cooking, etc.
- tablespoon 5y ago>> Among women with children under 18, 56% would prefer a “homemaker” role if they were “free” to do either: https://news.gallup.com/poll/186050/children-key-factor-wome https://news.gallup.com/poll/186050/children-key-factor-wome.... Contrast with just 26% of men. 39% of women without kids would also prefer to stay home if they had the choice. > Who wouldn’t prefer to stay home if they had the choice? I could spend my days traveling, hiking, going to the beach, reading, working on hobbies, learning new skills, cooking, etc. "Homemaker" does not mean "staying at home, doing whatever you want."
- bluecalm 5y agoHomemaker role doesn't mean spending your days travelling, hiking or going to the beach.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoDepends on how many children you have.
- nanomonkey 5y agoMetaverse Homemaker Addition allows you to do what every you want between wash cycles.
- rdtwo 5y agoCan confirm had to do homemaker job on top of paid job I’d prefer to be at my normal job
- corpMaverick 5y agoYes, me too. But, would you still feel the same if you had to stay home to take care of kids and a working spouse ?
- wolverine876 5y agoAnd having very few adults to talk to, no status, no career advancement (in fact, the opposite), and little recognition.
- ericd 5y agoEh? There are plenty of other parents and nannies at the park taking their kids out, if you want to talk to someone.
- barry-cotter 5y agoNannies are of a different social class. Most middle class people are much less likely to have real relationships with people who can’t relate to their problems. Same as rich people tend to have rich friends. “Talking to someone” isn’t community. Colleagues provide an ersatz community for people who don’t have a real one in their life. You need a steady cast of characters and ideally repeated, purposeful interaction.
- rjsw 5y ago> Nannies are of a different social class. I don't think that is true in Europe. They are probably a fair bit younger than middle class mothers which could be a barrier to being friends.
- barry-cotter 5y agoIf the people employing nannies didn’t have more money than their employees the relationship wouldn’t exist at all. The only way I’m familiar with middle class young women nannying is as au pairs, in other countries. But there are people who nanny for decades. They are not the same social class as their employers. My own experience of living in Europe is confined to Germany but middle class German girls mostly don’t even work part time jobs in university, never mind taking a year off before university to work as an au pair, in a foreign country. They do not nanny. Spanish friends made it sound like the same was true in Spain too. Students do not have jobs at university.
- thematrixturtle 5y agoI think you misspelled changing diapers, doing laundry three times a day, spoon-feeding broccoli puree, scraping dried broccoli off the floor, shopping while trying to contain a squealing octopus, etc.
- coryrc 5y agoOr watching and helping form your own child into him/herself, meeting your friends for casual lunches in the park while your kids play, playing goofy games, having time to make nutritious meals instead of heating frozen foods, etc.
- cgriswald 5y agoGrandparent was responding to the ridiculous notion that being a homemaker is like being on vacation with kids. No one is disputing there can be benefits to being a homemaker or having one in the family.
- coryrc 5y agoBeing on vacation with kids is far harder than being at home with kids!
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoInterestingly, you're both right. Turns out you have to take the bad with the good, or more accurately TANSTAAFL
- stickfigure 5y agoIt's... really not that bad? Actually, it's pretty fun. I work from home, wife doesn't, that makes me the defacto stay-at-home dad. It's definitely playing the startup game in "hard mode" but I love not missing a thing.
- zdbrandon 5y agoAlso work from home and 100% disagree. Can hardly get anything done with a 4 month old.
- npip99 5y ago"Who wouldn’t prefer to stay home if they had the choice? I could spend my days traveling" It's not travelling... If you're staying at home...
- dan-robertson 5y agoTo what extent is this just people not liking their current job? That is, what percentage of homemakers would rather be employed, and how would the opinions of employed women change if their choices in the poll were current job/appealing alternative job/homemaker?
- scarmig 5y agoWomen generally report more job satisfaction than men do; you'd expect a higher proportion of men preferring homemaking to their jobs if that was the dominant factor.
- rayiner 5y agoI suspect it’s a sliding scale—working is probably relatively more compelling if you’re a cancer researcher than if you’re writing up the paperwork for home mortgages. But way more people do the latter than the former, right? And most people doing the latter aren’t qualified to do the former (and that’s okay). I think that often people with remunerative, intellectually stimulating jobs overlook the perspective of women who have (and are realistically only qualified to have) jobs we would probably regard as more mundane.
- itronitron 5y agoYou mention a lot of statistics. If there is a point you wanted to make could you clarify it?
- rayiner 5y agoI stated the point in the beginning of the paragraph in which I cited the statistics: > Counterintuitively, America’s lack of a generous welfare system tends to destabilize traditional gender roles.
- symlinkk 5y agoThat traditional gender roles are good for society
- lostcolony 5y ago
- zozbot234 5y agoGender roles are driven by more than just religion or tradition. It's not clear that they're good for society (if anything, open societies which don't coercively enforce these norms tend to be more creative and innovative) but what they are is good enough for the many, many people, including women (might even be a majority) who prefer them. Any ideal of freedom of choice for all genders should absolutely include these 'old-fashioned' choices.
- rayiner 5y agoI suspect it’s a coupled system—tradition and religion both shape and reflect preferences. I think it’s bad for society when women have gender roles forced on them. But I think it’s also possible—especially for the self-selecting group of highly educated people who tend to think and write about these issues—to overlook how many women would simply rather take care of their kids, at least while they’re young, compared to the work they’re qualified to do.
- nautilius 5y agoNote that 'cultural legacy' is completely different from 'organized religion'. Celebrating 'Christmas' as a family get-together is completely different from celebrating the arrival of the messiah and deriving your complete moral compass from that.
- throwaway894345 5y agoTo be fair, you can interpret “cultural legacy” as “celebrating the same holidays” or as “having similar morals even if they are divorced from religious faith”.
- nautilius 5y agoYes, but a superficial and accidental partial overlap between atheist and religious morals is meaningless.
- throwaway894345 5y agoI disagree that it’s superficial or accidental.
- nautilius 5y agoYou’re not alone. Many religious people cannot fathom that something outside of and independent of their moral system exists. Take the old discussion of atheists as satanists. What is that joke again? “No, we don’t believe in any of your imaginary friends.“
- throwaway894345 5y agoI don’t see how that fits into the context of this conversation. Are you sure you responded to the right person?
- nautilius 5y ago
- jolux 5y agoPolling is one thing but the economics on this are extensive and they mostly reject your suggestions here. Female labor force participation is U-shaped with regards to GDP (https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w4707/w4707.pdf https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w4707/w4707...), once you reach the middle part of the curve it starts to increase again as GDP increases, probably because employment becomes more lucrative to women than raising children or staying at home. If there is an effect here it can't be all that significant, if you look at wealthy countries with larger welfare states than the US most have a female labor force participation rate at least as high.
- leto_ii 5y ago> 60% of working Dutch women only work part time, versus 20% of working Dutch men I would attribute this more to cultural aspects (there's something of a ravenmuter [1] issue in the Netherlands as well), but even more importantly, to basic economics. Kindergarden is very expensive, women get some maternal leave while men basically get none, so there's significant pressure on the mother to stay at home with the kids for longer. When they return to the workforce after some years of childcare, they do so to lower salaries than they would have had otherwise, hence part time work becomes more attractive. I don't deny that there's a natural tendency for women to be more nurturing, but I don't think that's the main force driving this disparity. [1] https://m.dw.com/en/rabenmutter/a-6616009 https://m.dw.com/en/rabenmutter/a-6616009
- danans 5y ago> Counterintuitively, America’s lack of a generous welfare system tends to destabilize traditional gender roles. I don't think that's so counterintuitive. Generous welfare systems give more people the opportunity to pursue the work lifestyle they would like to rather than the one they would have to to make ends meet if the generous welfare system didn't exist. That's a totally different scenario than gender roles being enforced by religious or cultural restrictions. That also promotes traditional gender roles but doesn't give individuals a choice in the matter.
- sstoks 5y agoWhat's is the desired conclusion of your comment? That women prefer to be homemakers more than men do so we should go ahead and do that and leave men to work? Please explain because I have no idea where you're going with this.
- industriousthou 5y agoI think he’s pointing out the irony in conservative views. They bemoan the erosion of traditional gender roles, but undermine those roles by opposing a generous welfare state. But, I mean, obviously it would be good if most workers made enough to support a family with a single income.
- jjav 5y ago> 56% would prefer a “homemaker” role if they were “free” to do either I would imagine approximately everyone would prefer a homemaker role if it was possible. I had the fortune of taking multiple years off to spend with my child at home, it was the best time ever. Unfortunately savings don't last forever so eventually had to go back to the soulless grind of daily status report standups and endless useless meetings.