4 ms·
U.S. science no longer leads the world. Here’s how nation should respond
- photochemsyn 5y ago> "The nation, it says, must sustain excellence in basic research; foster a scientific workforce more diverse in race, gender, and geography; and support high-quality precollege science and math education. The board also calls for forging closer ties between academia and industry, keeping borders open to promote international partnerships, and promoting ethical research practices." The reality they don't want to address is the corporatization of many fields of academic science (entire chemistry departments at many schools are now little more than R&D divisions for the major pharmaceutical corporations, for example). This clearly impacts the goal of "excellence in basic research" as that requires social academic norms like the open sharing of research tools and data. Basic research tends not to generate patents until years later, so it becomes a non-priority for the 'academic-industrial partnership' crowd (i.e. the startup types) - and yet the report supports 'forging closer ties between academia and industry'! Industry has plenty of cash, they can set up privately financed Bell Labs 2.0 and reap all the patents without relying on federal agency money, which should go to basic research. The issue of atrocious public education through high school in the USA, such that often students have to spend one or two years in college on remedial work developing acceptable math and writing skills, can only be addressed by spending more money on education: getting better teachers by increasing salaries, and reducing class sizes by explanding schools, particularly in low-income areas. As far as related diversity issues, note there's been great progress in that area, for example CalTech didn't even accept female students in the 1960s, and today the student population is roughly equivalent gender-wise.
- gumby 5y ago> The issue of atrocious public education through high school in the USA, such that often students have to spend one or two years in college on remedial work developing acceptable math and writing skills... I want to call this out specifically: it's a real and widespread phenomenon. You can expect any given student to be strong in some areas and less so in others, so it's perfectly reasonable for the first year, or semester, to have a significant component of "leveling up". However an increasing number of students need this kind of leveling up across the board. I only have direct exposure to this phenomenon in two cases; one is a "top 5" ranked university, the other is a large "top 25" school. The students appear to emerge just fine, so this implies the admissions department is selecting the right students despite these issues, but at a cost that for many amounts to missing out on a year's worth of university class education because they need remediation in what should have been taught in high school.
- mym1990 5y agoSpending more money is certainly not the only way to help the situation. The US already spends a large amount of money per student for elementary and secondary education, and even more in post-secondary education...yet we are going nowhere. I would argue that spending the money that we currently have more efficiently is a better proposition, but government programs are going to be hard pressed to do something in an efficient manner.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoThings that correlate with this decline should be done more often? How does that work?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 5y ago> The nation, it says, must sustain excellence in basic research; foster a scientific workforce more diverse in race, gender, and geography; and support high-quality precollege science and math education. One of the items on the list is not like the others. In fact, I would bet that none of our rivals overtaking us now care about that item, and so far it doesn’t seem to have hampered their research endeavors.
- gumby 5y agoYou can bet that but I don't think the evidence bears it out. Certainly in China, Russia and in Europe there are higher percentages of female scientists than in the US and that is through deliberate effort. Furthermore this effort has helped, not hampered their research output. Just as a trivial example: we wouldn't have had COVID vaccines quickly if not for a female scientist educated in Hungary. And that's just on one axis of underrepresentation. Anything that broadens the catchment pool of candidate scientists is going to improve value of those who become scientists -- a rule which, when generalized, is a fundamental staple of capitalism.
- User23 5y agoAs far as I can tell the western push for “diversity” is a system of racial, gender, and sexual orientation preferences and not some capitalistic optimal meritocracy. For each person that would have been overlooked that the society gains, how many that would have been as good or better are denied opportunity?
- gotoeleven 5y agoNope, the higher percentage of women in science in crappy countries seems to be because they have less choices in crappy countries. https://eprints.leedsbeckett.ac.uk/id/eprint/4753/6/symplectic-version.pdf&hl=es&sa=X&scisig=AAGBfm0xrcWbSjaOYwGIpValYtXniLgxIA&nossl=1&oi=scholarr https://eprints.leedsbeckett.ac.uk/id/eprint/4753/6/symplect...
- gumby 5y agoWhich countries do you consider non “crappy”?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sysOpOpPERAND 5y agowe are behind in a lot of areas, i am starting to wonder if it's because of our barrier to entry (college fees). i've also been told that we don't teach math in the most intuitive way in k-12. a lot of professors say they have to reteach math to students. many colleges and universities have dropped asking for testing scores from high school realizing they will have to reteach them anyways, kind of interesting to see but kinda sad that we have let our education system slip this far
- Isthatablackgsd 5y agoIf they would stop with the hardcore requirements (memorization of equations, paper-and-pen only, no open books, etc) with mathematics when we could be successful with this subject. Technology advanced so much that mathematics learning is extremely behind with the advancement. We have Khan Academy, Mathway, etc. We have great resources online for us to figure out the mathematics. But nooooo, they believe we will use trigonometry, calculus and paper&pen in the real world which rarely happens (ok maybe once in a lifetime). The last time I used my calculus in the real world is actually my undergraduate year.
- Datenstrom 5y agoI have used calculus and trigonometry regularly throughout my entire career. It is the foundation of everything I work on and I would never have been successful without it.
- Isthatablackgsd 5y agoMy apologies if my comment wasn't that clear. What I mean that the paper and pen is the primary requirements. We have the technologies that would calculate for us, those are the tools that we have available for us to use. But Educational Institutions disagreed with that and prefers us to use the paper&pen. So they would prefers to put us so much stress because we have to memorize them for the test instead of the available tools we could have use for it. The last time I used the paper&pen was in my undergrad. I use mathematics in Excel, Mathway, Search bars/launcher (Spotlight, Wox, Alfred, etc), Google. Those are the tools that I use frequent because it eliminate 99% human errors. They could taught us how to use the tools effectively, not forcing us to do the memorization and likely to fail the course. Fortunately, universities are noticing the issues with students struggle to pass Mathematics because there are lot of pathway that have higher mathematics requirements whereas it shouldn't be in the first place. Some fields have higher mathematics requirements when it is barely used in the field. They should stop at Algebra 1 (I believe that is arithmetic algebra) as a minimum for all degrees. If the pathway have a strong mathematics use, then go for whatever they requires for the degree. OR they could, you know, teach us how to use the tools online effectively instead of forcing us to go off the books. My field is in language and cultural studies which use minimal of mathematics.
- hackerlytest 5y agoAnti science and anti intellectualism are getting confused with being woke and anti establishment. Not surprised at all at this result.
- ratsmack 5y agoThat is a portion of the problem, but there are many other factors. I believe the cost of tuition has become a large factor lately. Also, the quest for knowledge has been replaced with a quest for a degree purely for monetary gain and status.
- gumby 5y agoI know you have to use available metrics, but I find it hard to consider number of patents a metric that describes the number of patents. In some countries, like the US, it is typical for a patent to have many claims; in others, such as Japan, it's common to have one or a small number of claims, and to file several patents where in the US there would be a consolidated one. Additionally, patents are really only useful in a few fields (notably pharmaceuticals) where in others (e.g. computing) they are mostly a waste of time.
- gumby 5y agoToo late to edit; I meant “hard to consider number of patents a metric that describes anything other than the number of patents.”
- namelessoracle 5y agoNumber of papers published as a metric? Really? I dare say that most of the papers being published would better serve to advance scientific knowledge if they were used as kindling to provide heat to primary school students.
- gnulinux 5y ago> I dare say that most of the papers being published would better serve to advance scientific knowledge if they were used as kindling to provide heat to primary school students. Reading blatantly anti-intellectual statements like these are very appalling in HN, and I dare say this attitude has been exponentially increasing in the last couple years. I was essentially unheard-of back when I first signed up here. Will you be able to explain us why you're of this opinion, so it has at least more substance?
- KoftaBob 5y agoI don't know if their argument of "quality over quantity" can be interpreted as anti-intellectual necessarily. If anything, I think that can be seen as pro-intellectual and against stats/funding-chasing.
- pyoeos 5y agoIt's anti-intellectual to blindly assume that the majority of papers published right now are high quality.
- R0b0t1 5y agoSame with assuming that prestigious schools are more likely to produce amazing research. I have found the absolute worst papers from otherwise respectable ivies. A case of someone buying their PhD, I assume.
- robbedpeter 5y agoThis. Journals aren't science. They aren't even good for science. They create the wrong incentives for scientific publishing and are a primary driver of the replication crisis. Open forums with science publishing for the sake of science should be the direction of travel, but we see a trajectory towards gatekeeping infected by corporate profiteering.
- pfortuny 5y agoThis is not science. Sorry but could not help it.
- onphonenow 5y agodeleted
- User23 5y agoThe Chinese consider the US’s current diversity self-flagellation to be very much one of their strategic advantages[1]. The paper is from the US point of view, but it’s the best I have on the Chinese one. I think it’s blindingly obvious that unity is superior to division, and a society ordered toward unity will be more vigorous and persist longer than one ordered toward diversity. Fortunately, I don’t have to convince anyone. A grand natural experiment has been running for the past six decades. I predict that within our lifetime the USA will not be a functioning world power. It does concern me what’s going to happen to all the nukes when the country is torn apart by its own internal contradictions. [1] https://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/selection/2013-anonymous-strategicconsequencesofchineseracism.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/selection/2013-anonymous...
- SubiculumCode 5y agoThere is good science being conducted in China, but there is a high proportion of faked, nonsensical, or just clueless papers coming from that country as well..so much so that I often hesitate to cite relevant papers coming from China if they were not published with co-authors from non-Chinese institutions.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoWell presumably the US is not falling behind in the one area that matters: diversity of the people working in science.
- gotoeleven 5y agoAlso we got rid of those nasty master branches!
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoThe latest in fictitious 'missile gaps'?
- panzagl 5y agoSpeaking of high status, low wage jobs...
- irrational 5y agoI get this reference. I'm just not sure if you mean scientists or science journalists.
- KoftaBob 5y ago> China has overtaken the United States as the world’s leader in several key scientific metrics, including the overall number of papers published and patents awarded. Considering how meaningless "number of papers/patents published" is on its own, and ESPECIALLY how meaningless it is coming from a country like China that has perfected the art of bullshitting/padding stats...this article is next to worthless. I don't know what's a worse explanation, that the author is naive enough to believe that's a useful metric, or that they intentionally used that metric to instill fear.
- HarryHirsch 5y agoProbably the second one - 25 years ago you didn't see Papers from China, 15 years ago you saw some that were not very good, and now you see many good ones.
- gotoeleven 5y agoWell we've been flushing standards of competence down the toilet in the pursuit of various political aims. I guess now we're at the suprised pikachu face phase of our journey.
- 8bitsrule 5y ago>poor students of color ... Asian students on standardized tests ... inexperienced science and math teachers. This isn't terribly new in the U.S. Depending on the school district and state laws, the qualifications of 'science teachers' may be minimal. (In some places, STEM teachers who are also coaches are likely to be preferred.) Partly because of the big difference in pay, partly because some school admins aren't motivated to care. Then the 'teaching to the test' crutch came along. Ay-yi. Understandable exodus of quality.
- cafard 5y agoNot terribly new: 50 years ago (and a few months) a friend of mine rearranged his 11th grade schedule to switch chemistry sections. The wrestling coach teaching the one he left, in reviewing the metric system with the students, had defined "milligram" as "one million grams." I trust it was a mere slip of the tongue, but it did not build confidence. On the other hand, my recollection is that coaches taught Algebra I, Plane Geometry, and Trig without causing any scandals. [Edit: corrected the spelling of "wrestling".]
- lern_too_spel 5y agoExactly this. I don't understand how people can believe pre-college education in the United States has fallen off a cliff. It has always been generally awful and very slowly improving. SAT scores have been steadily rising in all cohorts, even as more people have taken it. The US benefited in the post-war period by draining Europe of its top scientific talent, which catapulted it to the top by a wide margin. There is no reason to expect that level of dominance to persist.
- Koshkin 5y agoThe launch of the Webb space telescope is an evidence to the contrary.
- onion2k 5y agoThe Webb telescope is a direct collaboration between 14 countries of which the US is one, with further input from many other countries through the European Space Agency, NASA, and the Canadian Space Agency. To call it a US project does a huge disservice to many scientists and engineers around the world. https://webbtelescope.org/about https://webbtelescope.org/about
- avazhi 5y agoThe Webb was in development for more than a decade. Given that the article is discussing high school and first year college students, there’s going to be a latency period. I’d guess by the mid-2030s the effects will start to properly manifest, with concomitant hits to research output. Also don’t forget that even with its horrendous STEM situation, America has been the global hegemon for 70 years. One could argue that science education has been worse than the OECD average for half of that time, but being the global hegemon has meant that international students have filled the gap. With the rise of China, education and migration to America will no longer be the status quo for many Asians. America’s loss is China’s gain, something that looks to be a recurring theme of this century.
- avazhi 5y agoThis article misses the point. It is partly America’s obsession with STEM diversity (and the resulting lack of purely meritocratic advancement) that has created this current crisis. The Chinese certainly don’t delude themselves into thinking that gender or racial diversity are important for much of anything - access to Chinese university or employment is meritocratic. It’s true that China is not as racially heterogeneous as the US, but that fact doesn’t support the inference that you can’t compare the two. The fact remains that the world’s rising superpower is not concerned with diversity, human rights, or many of the other virtue signalling calling cards that are heavily prioritised in America and couched as sine qua nons of national success. Perhaps it’s time for America to grapple with which of either its superpower status or human rights record is more important to it. Prima facie it increasingly can’t have both. “The nation, it says, must sustain excellence in basic research; foster a scientific workforce more diverse in race, gender, and geography; and support high-quality precollege science and math education. The board also calls for forging closer ties between academia and industry, keeping borders open to promote international partnerships, and promoting ethical research practices.” Race, gender, and geographical diversity, and ethical research practice have nothing to do with advancing America’s research prowess. See: Nazi Germany and Jim Crow America, neither of which were concerned with diversity or ethics in research. And open borders is different of course from simply saying that America should have a robust visa system for qualified candidates. American bureaucrats seem to think that if they can only tick off all the buzzwords, GDP will rise and American innovation will soar.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoIf one or more identifiable groups are underperforming and dragging progress, smart governments understand this is a problem to be solved instead of ignored. China gets many things wrong, but they are not wrong about this, as you presume. https://www.universityworldnews.com/post-mobile.php?story=20210723152007327 https://www.universityworldnews.com/post-mobile.php?story=20... https://www.scmp.com/tech/tech-trends/article/3141834/gender-equality-china-will-give-female-scientists-priority https://www.scmp.com/tech/tech-trends/article/3141834/gender... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_action_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_action_in_China
- zthrowaway 5y agoThis is not surprising and will continue to get worse. The Chinese pump out far more scientists than us, and the small amount of the ones we have in comparison are handicapped by thought policing in the new age of political correctness. Not to mention how you need to publish papers that appease to certain powers that be to get any funding for anything. We pay teachers like shit, and there are no incentives for more teachers to be created. Colleges are way too expensive, discriminating against Asian's for example, and are now removing merit-based testing. Our obsession with diversity and forced equality of outcomes. I could go on. We're pretty screwed.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoIt's surreal that the "I'm being censored" hysteria among the privileged class has caused people to sincerely believe that there is more thought policing in the US than in China.
- zthrowaway 5y agoThis wasn't clear from my rambling above, but I don't think we are thought policed more than people in China, not at all. They are certainly limited in what they can do in other ways. But us having to appease to mobs or change scientific findings to not upset some subset of emotional people on Twitter is not progress, it's yet another cut in a death by a thousand cuts spiral we are in right now as a country. It would be nice to not have that added to the pile.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoTwitter is not a platform for science. If you believe useful scientific findings are being hindered by what people are writing in 280 character missives, I have a hard time believing you understand how science happens. What matters is funding, and what drives funding is the government, which has largely military objectives, and industry, which has largely profit objectives. Nobody gets research funding from Twitter.
- 5y ago
- jsnodlin 5y agoThat’s what happens when you restrict the best and the brightest from joining our universities and staying on on H1Bs afterwards.