13 ms·
The Crypto Backlash Is Booming
- rvz 5y agoOnce again and as predicted, we have another 'web3 is a ponzi' article. The creators of web3, and everyone else knows it is a giant scam, just like how ICOs where in 2017. All thanks to and started by Ethereum. Not sure why this article presents this as a great surprise or a new discovery. Sure, the majority of NFTs (Especially the JPEGs) are a pump-n-dump ponzi scam selling images to each other. When the NFT craze runs out of steam, 90% of all the image/audio/video types of NFTs will collapse. 10% of the other NFTs will survive with a valid use case. I don't see how the whole 'web3' narrative should apply to every single cryptocurrency and project in existence, like how this article has done. Just look at this sentence and the quote: > A person investing in crypto or a shared future on the blockchain is said to hate Earth and support the “hyperfinancialization of all human existence.” How does that apply to every single cryptocurrency as the author of this tweet has just generalized? [0] [0] https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1465682611171467269?s=20 https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1465682611171467269?s=20
- cehrlich 5y agoI agree that some legitimate use cases will survive, but I think the ratio is _much_ worse than 90/10.
- blitzar 5y ago> some legitimate use cases will survive More likely - some legitimate use cases will emerge, as I am yet to see anything to date that would fit into that category, but there is still room for the solution that is crypto to find itself a problem to fix.
- byhemechi 5y ago+1 on the ratio comment, i am yet to see a legitimate use for nfts, not just a something to speculate on
- rglullis 5y agoENS alone should be more than 10% of the market. Using NFTs for decentralized identity and authn is big. Unlock Protocol's is going for authz. There is a strong selection bias for those that report on crypto for clicks or those that want to create a narrative that we can not live without some big central authority controlling our lives.
- thematrixturtle 5y ago> Using NFTs for decentralized identity and authn is big. Tell me more? What problem does this solve that you can't do with centralized auth?
- rglullis 5y agoHave you ever thought about closing your Google Account and got discouraged when you realized that there are so many other services that depend on it? Worse, have you ever had your Google/Facebook/Apple/Outlook/Twitter account closed without knowing why? Centralized systems are amazing, until they aren't.
- dub 5y agoHave you ever had your credentials to a decentralized service stolen by a keylogger and realized that you will never, ever, under any circumstances regain control and there's no one you can talk to and nothing you can do about it? Decentralized systems are amazing, until they aren't (Even if you wanted to have a decentralized account recovery like saying you can have 3 friends band together and help you recover your account if you lose access, what happens when those 3 friends decide that don't like you as much as they like the idea of banding together to take over your identity and all your money?...)
- rglullis 5y agoYou know what annoys me the most about these discussions about crypto and systems in general? It's the fact that people can only argue in the extremes. Decentralization is a spectrum. (https://twitter.com/rlullis/status/1307420668372430848 https://twitter.com/rlullis/status/1307420668372430848) > Decentralized systems are amazing, until they aren't No, they are not. They are expensive, they require responsibility. The UX is complicated. Most people shouldn't use it and will be better off delegating all this to someone else. Thing is, it's not because something is good enough for most people that everyone should stick to it. > what happens when those 3 friends decide that don't like you as much as they like the idea of banding together to take over your identity and all your money? This argument is stupid. With decentralization, there is no reason for your identity to be something singular. There is even less reason for people to think that one wallet should hold "all your money".
- alexb_ 5y agoWhat exactly are the valid use cases that are not already better served with centralized systems?
- mateuszf 5y agoExample: Wikileaks being funded using Bitcoin when PayPal, Visa and other payment companies blocked transactions
- threeseed 5y agoThat was because, whether you agree with it or not, the US government deemed their behaviour to be illegal. And so the issue you have is not with Paypal, Visa etc unless you think that those payment companies should tolerate illegal parties transacting money. Because that is a very slippery slope especially given how much wealth in the world comes from the despair of the very poor and helpless.
- Zak 5y ago> That was because, whether you agree with it or not, the US government deemed their behaviour to be illegal. There are, and should be real-world limits on the ability of the US government to stop things from happening by deeming them illegal. In the case of Wikileaks, one such limitation is the relatively decentralized nature of the internet. The US government was able to pressure Amazon to refuse to host it, but was unsuccessful in pressuring OVH, so Wikileaks remains online. There is no Great Firewall of America, so it remains accessible within the US. Another limitation is that while the US government can and did pressure Paypal to refuse service to Wikileaks, there's no equivalent for preventing transfers of cryptocurrencies.
- threeseed 5y ago> There are, and should be real-world limits on the ability of the US government to stop things from happening by deeming them illegal. It already exists: the legal system. > there's no equivalent for preventing transfers of cryptocurrencies Money laundering, child trafficking, drug profiteering, terrorism etc. they all come with costs. And doing nothing to stop them is not good for anyone.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoDoesn’t Stephen Diehl CTO for a private blockchain startup? https://twitter.com/dystopiabreaker/status/1470126927818067969 https://twitter.com/dystopiabreaker/status/14701269278180679...
- nsotelo 5y agoAre there any valid use-cases? For any suggestion I've heard, it always seems that a relational database or PKI would be better.
- me_me_me 5y ago> All thanks to and started by Ethereum. I think the scam goes all the way back to electricity and Edison! Its a little bit disingenuous to blame etherium for NFT, its like blaming email for nigerian prince spam.
- vinnie-io 5y agoit is though. an NFT is just a crypto currency with a total supply of 1. and ethereum contracts allow the creation
- me_me_me 5y ago> it is though. What is this? A game of 'it is', 'it isn't'? NFT is not a crypto with total supply of 1, its not even a crypto, its at best a by-product of crypto transaction.
- doorman38 5y agoTotally bro! Edison and Tesla were SO concerned about “scamming” money out of you (over a 100 years ago). That makes total sense….lol. Mind you they were rich AF too. That’s absolutely hilarious, I’m sorry. But you’re right about NFT’s not being ETH’s fault by the way, on that I agree with you. But it still happened. By the way, why (like in all reality if being brutally honest) did we need to have NFT’s to begin with? The answer is we didn’t. People saw a “get rich quick opportunity” (even though very wrong), and went after it. That does not make it right or give it a real world use case, sorry, it really doesn’t. Yet, on the flip side, I pay my rent, most of my utility bills, and basically all purchases (Amazon, eBay, Uber/Uber Eats, Airbnb, American Airlines, and about ten others that compromise about 90% of all them) with Bitcoin (BTC). And that takes me about 5 minutes. Is that not real world? If not, please enlighten me, what is then?
- me_me_me 5y agoI am not defending NFTs, just saying that you cannot blame technology for what it was used for. Nuclear fission was the idea/tech, it was used to create A-bombs, and clean nuclear energy. Nuclear fission like smart contract is an idea, how its used it up to people.
- spinchange 5y agoWhat else is there to the narrative? This stuff is predominately solutions in search of problems and they are not innovative except for trying to financialize and/or securitize every conceivable digital artifact imaginable. It sucks comprehensively like at the ideological origin points.
- danaris 5y ago> Not sure why this article presents this as a great surprise or a new discovery. Because even if the circles you move in are all very well aware that NFTs are a massive scam, very obviously many people haven't yet realized that—after all, it's still working.
- byhemechi 5y agoi still do not like the entire concept of cryptocurrency and the blockchain. it's no more decentralised than the internet and the idea of unrestricted currency is bad. we have banking regulations for a reason.
- Zak 5y agoWe have many of the current banking regulations because, as it turns out, the same organization claiming to securely store other peoples' money and wishing to gamble using that money is a conflict of interest. Someone has probably invented fractional reserve banking for crypto, but most crypto users don't want to deposit their crypto into such a system. Many banking regulations exist to mitigate the impact of that conflict. The other major class of banking regulation has to do with governments monitoring transfers of money. I'm not entirely convinced a weakening of their ability to do so would be a bad thing.
- headsoup 5y agoI think the hope of Bitcoin is for countries where regulation and corruption impact one's ability to transfer and manage their money through banks, they have a separate, isolated system not vulnerable to that. But cryptocurrency doesn't fix this, it just pretends to by throwing everything out of the window. I think what would ultimately work is a global 'bank' that implements all the safeguards the current system has without governments being able to touch them. That means it has to work within their legal frameworks, but also have high integrity and security to avoid the corruption... Which is probably fanciful, much like the idea crypto will fix it.
- Duralias 5y ago> governments monitoring transfers of money. Since there has been tax introduced for crypto, why couldn't the government do it for crypto as well? Most crypto I am aware of is as public as can be, if you were forced to verify your identity then they could directly track your transactions as well. And any somewhat anonymous crypto could just be made illegal, you could theoretically still use it, but you'd still have a log that says you got money from nowhere, which I think could warrant an audit if done a lot.
- nomading 5y agoAs someone who is pro-crypto and has been working in the space for 5-6 years, I have never felt so embarrassed and disillusioned as the past few months. I wish the market had stayed quiet and NFTs had never entered the mainstream. Now it's 99.9% scams and ponzi schemes. It's even worse than the ICO bubble and the whole thing will come crashing down again soon. You'd think people learn, but the get rich quick pitches are just too attractive to the average American who doesn't understand technology or finance.
- imron 5y ago> Now it's 99.9% scams and ponzi schemes Now?
- nomading 5y agoYes, there was a period of time, mostly after the ICO crash, where the market was relatively quiet and most people in the space worked on interesting technological problems. I don't want to get into arguments about the usefulness of blockchains and web3, but the intention of developers was not to scam consumers, at least not explicitly or from the outset. Now the intention of most projects is explicitly to rug pull and scam people, mostly due to the NFT craze.
- antocv 5y agoJust cycles repeating. Remember 2013 then it was all kinds of shitcoins when the term shitcoin was most used, happened. Peercoin, FeatherCoin, AmsterdamCoin, TitsAndAssCoin. They all pumped and dumped. Somebody looking into crypto late 2013 would have found 99% scam coins. Same thing in 2017, 99% scam ICOs. Today its 99% NFT and token scams.
- beardyw 5y agoJust because you can create a new currency it doesn't mean it's a good idea. https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/685739-if-the-management-consultant-said-tersely-we-could-for-a https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/685739-if-the-management-co...
- 5y ago
- shimonabi 5y agoWhat a naive piece. No exploration of the underlying technology, just "he said, she said". I'm not even angry. I'm just sad that I have to watch my friends lose a lot of money on obvious scams.
- stillbourne 5y agoSorry but they don't need to talk about the technology to uncover that its implementation is a scam. It's like saying you have to talk in depth about the workings of phrenology or homeopathy before you can say its bullshit.
- jqpabc123 5y agoBlockchain is really just an accounting system. So ignore blockchain; take it out of the picture, and what do you have left with crypto? People inventing/printing an endless supply of money for their own benefit. In what way is this *not* a scam? But, but, but central banks do the same? Yes, they do --- but with a very different purpose and understanding. They try to maximize the positive effects on the entire, overall economy --- realizing this is the best way to maximize their own. If they fail in this, they can be replaced. Checks and balances. "Digital" currency is a good idea that can and will eventually happen. But "crypto" currency is really just a system of misguided and misplaced trust --- you trust that unregulated "exchanges" are fair and honest and reasonable and acting in the public interest without any checks and balances. And if they are not, you have no recourse.
- 3pt14159 5y agoI used to think the good parts of crypto could be salvaged. I now don't. The people joining at this point are either naive or corrupt. I don't think people like Vitalik would join today because the entire scene has changed. There are no limit to the number of these coins. If the Bitcoin maximalists had won out, maybe there would be a different future where the world could standardize on a single protocol, but they didn't win out. So whether it's new coins, new NFTs, new this or that. It doesn't matter. It's a pump and dump. And once the marks get wise to one type of pump and dump, you change it around a bit and pump and dump something else. Real problems are not being solved by crypto.
- shafyy 5y agoI'm curious if people like Vitalik feel trapped, or worse yet, that they have created a monster? If they don't feel bad, I wonder how they justify the cognitive dissonance. The right thing for Vitalik would be to recognize that this is not going to turn into what he imagined it to be, and to publicly speak out against it. Instead, he's trying to justify everything and secretly hopes that he somehow can still turn it around. "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds."
- 5y ago
- cryptica 5y agoBut how will the corporate elites bribe people into compliance with their agenda without crypto?
- bhouston 5y agoThis is definitely a backlash. I see a lot of specious arguments and strong statements that are usually generationizations focused on the negative. Like everything about crypto is a scam or money laundering, or that NFTs can never work in any way, definitely not interoperable metaverse assets, and all are destorying the environment. People don't think clearly about this any more. It feels how many committed Democrats talk about Republicans and vice-versa -- all nuance is lost and the other side is evil and there is no middle ground or understanding at all. If you slam crypto or NFTs on Twitter, you will get tons of likes. If you mention that there is a lot of work towards more environmentally friendly NFTs via L2 and other environmentally friendly blockchains that by definition means that it also has low fees and this addresses one of the core criticisms, I find that people just shift towards a different anti-NFT argument, or call me a name. I think that a lot of people are anti-NFT because they hate them and all these explanations for the exact reason why they suck shift once you start talking to these NFT haters and engaging them. It is okay, you are allowed to hate NFTs, but the core technology is actually really powerful and I expect it to completely explode within the gaming community when these low and no-fee blockchains take over from the very inefficient Ethereum L1 NFTs. Although in the later versions of NFTs and cryptos they will more and more resemble the traditional banking institutions (often real-names, hosted key accounts, fully audited, and probably at least somewhat reversible transactions and various limits to prevent fraud), rather than the Wild West they currently are.
- tpush 5y ago> [...] I expect it to completely explode within the gaming community when these low and no-fee blockchains take over [...] What use do block chains have for gaming that can't already be done more efficiently?
- bhouston 5y agoSupporting efficient blockchains for in-game assets, those blockchains with near zero fees, enable (1) robust secondary markets as well as (1) interchangeable assets when desired (such as avatar customizations.) Right now the game industry tends to offer walled garden and fractured solutions here.
- Rastonbury 5y agoBacklash? Wait till the bubble pops and witness the meltdown. Just go into see the discussions by self described degens. People putting paycheck by paycheck into NFTs.
- mightyRodri 5y agoLine go Up
- pg_bot 5y agoIf you look at the art, it's all just derivative permutation based animal nonsense, self referential crypto memes, or stolen intellectual property. There's nothing of value there. If you look at the "smart contracts", you find that the majority of NFTs are just links to urls hosted on a server somewhere else. So what you are actually buying is akin to a pamphlet advertising where the Louvre is, when what you thought you've bought was the Mona Lisa. The content behind the URL can change at a moment's notice. Want to put the full content on the blockchain or even a hash of the content? Look at the gas fees for ethereum and tell me it's worth it. Everything in the NFT space is going to zero.
- cogman10 5y agoI subscribe to the theory that this is a money laundering scheme. Create a crypto with "art rules" for the value of every asset and now you've got things whose valuation is completely arbitrary and, oh look, some anonymous wallet wants to give me 2 million dollars for the blinking led asset! Yes, IRS, I got my money from this art auction! Anyone falling for a "legitimate" reason these things exist is a fool.
- pjc50 5y agoIt's also a market which can sell security-like things while believing it's exempt from SEC enforcement, so you can just have celebrities flog it on TV: https://maxread.substack.com/p/mapping-the-celebrity-nft-complex https://maxread.substack.com/p/mapping-the-celebrity-nft-com...
- sshine 5y agoYou don't need NTFs to launder money through art. :) https://edition.cnn.com/2020/07/29/business/art-money-laundering-sanctions-senate/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2020/07/29/business/art-money-launde...
- cogman10 5y agoOh, I'm not defending the art industry. I'm saying that NFTs are the worst aspects of the art industry in a form that can be exploited by single individuals without producing a physical item. In short, they allow for ultrafast laundering because you don't have to go to art auctions, or generate paper trails, or whatever. Hell, you don't even need valid URLs (though it'd probably look a little fishy if all of your URLs pointed to the 404 collection).
- EL_Loco 5y agoI absolutely hate, hate this NFT scam. I even hate all the metaverse talk. I've been watching every iteration of VR since the early 90s, and it still looks like a gimmick. But how is vaccine tracking, with temperature information, lot numbers, location, etc, being logged to a secure, fast, carbon-neutral DLT not a good use case? Maybe not any better than a regular database owned by the vaccine buyer, but I can see quite a few benefits (many different buyers, each with their own quirky, sometimes less robust database, for an example). A lot of people are losing money with this moon propert...NFT fad, but I'm seeing quite a few use cases of real value popping up here and there. The example above is not my area of expertise, so I might be wrong, and would really like to hear a good rebuttal, but it's difficult. People seem to eithe love crypto/DLT too much or hate it too much to even bother discussing beyond "The whole entire planet will use crypto for everything" or "There's not a single use for this crap".
- rsynnott 5y ago> But how is vaccine tracking, with temperature information, lot numbers, location, etc, being logged to a secure, fast, carbon-neutral DLT not a good use case? Trust isn't an issue; a conventional database will be perfectly fine. Like, if you wanted to sell a product for tracking vaccines (assuming, for a moment, that health services and other large vaccine buyers don't have decades-old systems for this which everyone already knows how to use, which, if course, they do) why would you bring The Almighty Blockchain into it?
- EL_Loco 5y agoAround eight years ago, there was a power failure in my town (a small town in a third world country). The freezer that stored the local health facility's vaccines stopped working for two days because the backup generator was broken. After some investigation, it was found that when power was restored, the health officials altered the temperatures on the database to show that everything was fine and the vaccines kept their temperature in proper range for those two days. If it had been logged to a DLT with an immutable ledger, this wouldn't have happened. That's the reason I'm particularly interested in this use case (something that was done in the UK recently), because kids ended up taking these expired vaccines.
- pseudolus 5y agoThe backlash might be booming but there are still enough stories out there about people minting millions to sustain the hysteria. Today the New York Times ran a story - "They Made Millions on Luna, Solana and Polygon: Crypto’s Boom Beyond Bitcoin" [0] - that will probably prompt some people to invest in obscure cryptocurrencies in the "if they can do I can do it too" belief. This is eerily similar to the stories run by numerous print and online publications in the early 2000's highlighting the massive amounts of money that people were making day trading. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/07/technology/cryptocurrency-luna-solana-polygon.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/07/technology/cryptocurrency...
- vmchale 5y agoThe uncritical articles are a problem regardless of any pro-crypto bent one might have. Nothing about underlying technology or why something might be new/good.
- JSavageOne 5y agoThis is not interesting or worthy of an article, The Atlantic must be having a slow day. Everything popular always has its most ardent haters, just look at any big tech company like Google, Facebook or popstar like Justin Bieber, Drake, etc. This is not unique to crypto. Anything that attracts such enormous wealth is naturally going to attract the get-rich-quick schemers, scammers, charlatans, moonbois, etc. Any bold new concepts and grandiose claims like web3 and NFTs will be met with skepticism just like anytime a popular tech platform redesigns its UI or algorithm. Virtually all of the extreme vitriol is pure nonsense and entirely misplaced. People bashing NFTs because jpegs of apes are selling for millions are completely missing the point. It's equivalent to bashing the email protocol because of the existence of spammers, or hating tech in 2001 because of pets.com. A grammy-winning artist yesterday wrote a nice thread about how NFTs have changed his life by enabling him to better monetize his work [1] Not to excuse scammers/spammers and charlatans because obviously that stuff is irritating. I personally despite the crappy NFT art collections selling for millions, NFT profile pictures, Ponzi-like play-to-earn crypto games as much as any hater. But I'm also aware that nobody is forcing me to buy a digital ape or play Axie Infinity, and that stuff is only a tiny fraction of what NFTs and crypto enable. It's important to realize that we're still in very very early stages, not even the first inning of the web3 decentralized future, so at this point much of the talk is just prophecy. But there's no doubt in my mind that crypto, smart contracts, and decentralized technology (eg. IPFS) enable a ton of applications that were not possible before. Rather than fixating on bored apes, I'd rather focus on the real innovation (eg. with defi, zero knowledge proofs, DAOs, NFTs with real application, IPFS) and join in on building the future. [1] https://twitter.com/RAC/status/1490431018792226817 https://twitter.com/RAC/status/1490431018792226817
- MSFT_Edging 5y agoCould you provide some examples of "enable a ton of applications that were not possible before? Bonus points if the examples are not "DRM with more steps", "P2E game", or "artificial scarcity in the metaverse is a good thing"
- drexlspivey 5y agoSay you are a game developer and you are creating a game like WoW or EVE online where items can be traded via an in-game market. You can design the whole system from scratch yourself or plug in to the various blockchains and use the dev cycles elsewhere. You could represent each item with a 32byte id and each player’s inventory with a wallet. Bonus: say a new WoW private server spawns up (there are tons of these around). You can offer the option to a player to “migrate” from another server and keep all their items. All they have to do is provide a digital signature from the original server to show that they own the items.
- jonathan-adly 5y agoJust fyi, for the crypto builders in this thread. A lot of people here mined like 100 Bitcoin early then never got it and sold for $3 and turned bitter and grumpy. You can disregard their bitterness and continue solving and building interesting things. Crypto has been around for 12 years now.
- FranksTV 5y agoBernie Madoff started forging documents in the early 1970s and turned himself in in 2008. Twelve years is nothing.
- jonathan-adly 5y agoBernie was the chairman of the Nasdaq, the thing you want to preserve by fighting all crypto.
- lpcvoid 5y agoYou can be against boundless capitalism and bitcoin at the same time, strange huh?
- Kbelicius 5y agoBy the time WWW was 12 years old it was populated by the likes of Amazon, Google, Netflix... 12 years is a lot on the internet.
- jonathan-adly 5y agoAnd Bitcoin market cap and participation is about the same as Google 12 years in :)
- GoodJokes 5y ago
- lamontcg 5y agoThere's been a crypto backlash for a long time, and it comes and goes in waves. I don't think we've hit peak-crypto yet.