22 ms·
The End of Uber with Cory Doctorow
- quattrofan 5y ago
- throwaway22032 5y agoThe article is illustrative for a number of reasons, but something stuck out to me which bugged me, which is that it's common for people on one side of an issue to throw out minor comments which would have major implications if true, but which generally feel quite unexamined. For example, cars are pitted against cycling as if one is somehow diametrically opposed to the other. But we have empirical examples of this not being the case. I live in a city which is pretty car heavy (London). It's not LA, we don't have sprawling freeways everywhere, but the road outside my house is lined with cars on either side, there are multiple ring roads that are 2, 3, 4 lane roads, the vast majority of the city centre is not pedestrianised, etc. Yet I can and do ride my bike every day, in areas both with and without cycle lanes, and so do lots of other people. The time taken for me to get from point A to point B via bicycle could not be meaningfully improved that much - if I had a direct monorail-style route it'd be a bit faster, sure. Netherlands, UK, and US stats are here: https://content.tfl.gov.uk/pedal-cyclist-fatalities-in-london.pdf https://content.tfl.gov.uk/pedal-cyclist-fatalities-in-londo... Very very roughly, NL is at 2.5 deaths or serious injuries per 10 million km cycled, UK is at about 10, and the US is at about 40. I'm going to use this data and further make an unsubstantiated claim that in the UK, London probably has fewer accidents than a more car heavy town. So yeah, it's more dangerous than the stereotypical example of a cycling paradise, but it's not some sort of hellscape. The point then is that you don't need to eliminate cars in order to create an environment in which people both have and exercise the ability to walk and cycle. You do need the roads to not be urban motorways. But something like this: https://live.staticflickr.com/7129/7667009494_ed377c00cf_b.jpg https://live.staticflickr.com/7129/7667009494_ed377c00cf_b.j... I think provides a reasonable balance. The main part is that drivers understand that cyclists are a thing that exist. In London you don't expect to drive about at 30mph everywhere because well, the road is thin, bicycles, buses, taxis, people stepping out, whatever. It's not a divided motorway, you don't own it. Another example is the idea that geometry is inherently against cars. It's inherently against cars the use of cars for commuting from a large suburban area to a small business district. But there exists no geometrical constraint that effects me driving from village/town/suburb A to village/town/suburb B. This assumes again though that you have a balanced town/country plan. If you make everything a massive big expansive road and spread out too far, then sure, cars end up predominating. I guess moderation, and the use of cost-benefit analysis, is just boring. No-one wants to campaign for it, and would anyone even listen? Is it catchy?
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>So yeah, it's more dangerous than the stereotypical example of a cycling paradise, but it's not some sort of hellscape. Last week I had somebody do a really close pass at 50 or 60 mph. It was obviously an attempt at intimidation and to some extent it worked, it did make me think about why I cycle rather than drive. That sort of thing is going to put off a lot of people which is why we need a lot more infrastructure. This is rural Oxfordshire though.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway22032 5y agoYeah, I hate cycling out in the country. It's kind of interesting. I have friends that consider this to be a fun weekend out, clean air, birdsong, etc. But to me it's just super boring (I find the city visually stimulating and like a real-world progress bar) and also quite dangerous. If I fall off my bike in the city there's a pretty good chance I'll be alright. If I fall off on an A-road I'm very very dead.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoOn the whole I don’t think the risks are that high but if you do get hit then it’s going to be serious.
- ryukafalz 5y agoThat street still looks very uncomfortable to cycle on to me, and I think the numbers bear this out: London's cycling mode share in 2020 was 3.4%. https://tfl.gov.uk/corporate/publications-and-reports/travel-in-london-reports https://tfl.gov.uk/corporate/publications-and-reports/travel... I don't think you'll ever get a significant portion of people on bikes when they have to mix heavily with cars.
- zelos 5y agoYes: I think the official injury stats are only part of the story. When I lived in London I got knocked off my bike by cars or motorbikes several times. None of them were bad enough to be reported, but they left me with bruises and scrapes. Because of that, there's absolutely no way I'd consider cycling from the station to the office now that I commute.
- ngngngng 5y agoThis is my first introduction to The War on Cars, but I am such a big fan of this anti car movement. Strong towns was my introduction to the movement but my views were solidified through several city planning youtube channels (city beautiful, not just bikes). Before buying into this and related movements I relocated to a rural town where the vast majority of our taxes go to roads. Plowing, maintaining, building, it's all roads around here. Most of our town is convinced that our taxes are so high because of inept government or corruption but when you look at the city budget it's painfully clear that roads are just really expensive when everyone lives on 2 acres, every road is wide enough for 2 heavy duty dually trucks towing boats and potholes are unacceptable. Not to mention that when roads are high quality and wide, people drive fast. The odds of my kids getting smashed by a speeding truck are way higher than I'd like them to be. We've got to stop with the whole "everyone gets a quarter acre and a truck" mentality. I live out in the middle of nowhere and everyday construction begins on a new home, filling in every gap of what used to be farmland. All of us are 15 minutes away from the nearest anything. To be fair though, I'm sure they're all moving out here for the same reasons I did. Housing near work or transit is so scarce and expensive that it just doesn't make any sense. We're spending the same as we would in the city center on a house, but we're getting a mansion out in the country instead of a shack in the city.
- seer 5y agoI think the message of channels like “not just bikes” is that even if 2 acres and a truck for everybody was economical, its actually not desirable long term. Its just _so nice_ to live in a place with no traffic jams and your kids (and you too) are not just casualties waiting to happen.
- ethagknight 5y agoAren’t you doing exactly what everyone else wants to do? Mansion in the Sticks for me, but City Shacks for thee? Everyone is making these same decisions up and down the society economic status lines and across the US. One thing major cities could do to stave off cheap, cookie cutter expansionism is to buy up large swaths of land for city or state parks, and also cultivate those parks for high quality outdoor recreation. Such a policy would increase land price pressure (what local developer can outbid the government at scale??), particularly focusing on interstate corridors, which were built for… interstate commerce… but gets used for 40 acres and a mule commutes. The city comes away with a large land investment that it can prune as needed, or keep as a preserve as desired and directed by the govt/people. Ok, so where does an already struggling community come up with $100mm to buy 200,000 acres of land surrounding the community? Land Conservancies are tax shelters where basically rich people or businesses commit their real estate assets to the government, or invest money in the conservancy to go buy up land. The land is conserved according to the conservancy’s covenant. Hold your nose, but its the fastest way to raise $100mm to tighten up development patterns. Check out Wolf River Conservancy for a fledgling example. https://wolfriver.org/land-trust https://wolfriver.org/land-trust
- refurb 5y agoMy prediction is in 2200 (yes, 178 years from now) cars will be as ubiquitous, if not more, than they are today. Cars are like distributed computing - millions of independent transportation options are superior to top-down, limited public transportation. You’ll see countries with heavy public transport continue to adopt cars - and autonomous cars will only accelerate it.
- Sebb767 5y ago> 2200 (yes, 78 years from now) So, what's the current state of cars in your time? ;)
- refurb 5y agoWell done
- occz 5y agoCar infrastructure is far, far too expensive. The U.S is already deep under water in its maintenance, and as this problem continues to be ignored, the lower the viability of cars will be. It's actually pretty interesting to see people on the economic right being so staunchly in favor of this incredibly socialized waste of money - it's a testament to the marketing and lobbying efforts by the car industry for sure.
- cinntaile 5y agoThis depends on the region. In the EU some countries have such high gas taxes that the infrastructure could be entirely paid for, maintained and there would still be money left. In practice that money isn't earmarked for road infrastructure though. But the end user could in theory pay for it all, so that it's not socialized to everyone. It's also possible that there are tax reductions for driving a car or tanking fuel, so it's definitely not the whole picture and this would need to be accounted for.
- seer 5y agoHah I still remember watching one of the TopGear specials in Africa, and them comparing domestic roads (pothole ridden) to ones made by chinese apparently “uk quality”. Looking at that “shitty african road” I was like “hey thats a normal second grade road in Eastern Europe where I live. Moral of the story - cars are tough and can handle much (much) worse roads that US and eastern europe think of “normal” roads. I prefer cycling myself and don’t really like cars, but “failing US road infra” just sounds so naïve…
- nottorp 5y agoHmm I have no idea what Uber promised in the US, but where I am it's just a more convenient taxi. And it's pretty useful for that.
- deepsun 5y agoMoreover, in some countries, regular taxi companies and taxi aggregators quickly developed similar systems. So there's no difference between Uber and them, except that local companies know their market better.
- cloudfifty 5y agoThe difference is that it's cheaper by Uber pushing down labour costs, a.k.a the driver's compensation. But since that reason isn't as pleasant, vague rationalizations are used instead.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoAs a traveler, I want to install one app that works everywhere.
- deepsun 5y agoYep, would be more convenient. Same would be cool to have single air carrier. And the same car model, that just works the same everywhere.
- twelve40 5y agoThat would be very convenient indeed, but for whatever reason, that didn't happen. I keep running into many places where Uber is hard to find or non-existent, Turkey, parts of Mexico, Russia, I'm sure there are more.
- mdoms 5y agoThis is why when I travel internationally I only eat McDonalds and shop at H&M.
- JKCalhoun 5y ago
- Proven 5y ago[dead]
- bouncing 5y agoPerhaps an unpopular opinion, but hear me out: the issue of social and physical comfort in public transit is probably at least as important as the issue of efficiency. In public transit, the expectation of adhering to a social contract is almost non-existent. Women deal with creepy gropers, everyone deals with the smell of urine, and of course there's the ubiquitous annoyance of music played over phone speakers (or worse, bluetooth). If you want people to prefer to take transit, and you should want that, you need to deal with the lack of a social contract on public transit. That means, in other words, that behavior not tolerated in a private business (such as a bar or restaurant) can't be tolerated on public transit either. For urban liberals, that means confronting some uncomfortable choices. A public space (and transit is public) is supposed to be open to all, but if we want public spaces to be livable, that probably means smells and behaviors are more tightly regulated in public, either through direct enforcement by transit police (unlikely) or more social pressure (also unlikely).
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>In public transit, the expectation of adhering to a social contract is almost non-existent. That's not the case in the UK or the rest of Europe. Of course there are occasional nut jobs out there but the fact that so many people use public transport controls that sort of behaviour.
- arethuza 5y agoI've encountered far more "nut jobs" driving in Scotland than I have on public transport... Edit: The only awkward scene I ever witness on my occasional commute into Edinburgh by train is when two laptop users sitting across from from each other accidentally touch screens - of course, both people immediately apologise. It's hell.
- alamortsubite 5y agoThis point is underappreciated, and the nut jobs in cars are also more dangerous.
- 5y ago
- scottcorgan 5y agoY'all writing these articles consistently forget about rural areas that both have no consistent internet and no Uber-type services. No food delivery, no grocery store (drive 45 min hour for a real grocery store). The ideas are great and ideal, but ...
- alamortsubite 5y agoIn the interview they discuss Uber in the context of cities. Which makes sense, because if you look at a heat map of Uber activity, rural areas don't really register. So it's not that anyone's ignoring rural areas. They're just irrelevant to the topic at hand.
- jpindar 5y agoIs there a heat map of Uber activity? That might be interesting.
- occz 5y agoOk, so let's implement them only in the non-rural areas, where the large majority of the population in Europe and the U.S lives.
- foxyv 5y agoI think the name of the concept "Anti-Car" is a bit misleading. A lot of people in power want to get cars off the road, but forget the important part, which is "People need to have alternatives that are BETTER" Well run public transportation is always better than a car. Cheaper, easier, faster, and less stressful. The goal is for people living in urban areas to not need a car. Not for them to have to go without a car. People living in rural areas would still need cars. We've built our cities so that you absolutely need a car to get where you need to go. Strong towns and Not Just Bikes aren't advocating for the end of cars so much as a re-think of our urban planning. Imagine driving into town from 45 minutes out and having zero traffic and parking right next to the grocery store. Or even better, being able to drive 15 minutes away to the nearest walkable town, with affordable housing and a market with everything you need. Not needing to drive 45 minutes because car centric infrastructure killed the town and forced everyone to drive hours to a car clogged metro area funded by new development just to get groceries until road maintenance kills that city too.
- walterbell 5y agoWEF video envisioned carless human lives rebuilt around "neighborhood hubs" that are 15-min walking distance from their home offices, containing gym and bars, but no restaurants since those would be replaced by ghost kitchens. They envisioned biometric ID of each human by their heartbeat. WFH opens the door to workplace surveillance policy being applied to home-workspace activity. https://twitter.com/wef/status/1427721919483326470 https://twitter.com/wef/status/1427721919483326470 Definition of 15-min city: https://www.cnu.org/publicsquare/2021/02/08/defining-15-minute-city https://www.cnu.org/publicsquare/2021/02/08/defining-15-minu... & https://hub.beesmart.city/en/strategy/the-15-minute-city-nurturing-communities-for-smarter-cities https://hub.beesmart.city/en/strategy/the-15-minute-city-nur... This may come to fruition in private charter cities like Telosa, https://www.cnn.com/style/article/telosa-marc-lore-blake-ingels-new-city/index.html https://www.cnn.com/style/article/telosa-marc-lore-blake-ing... & https://cityoftelosa.com/ https://cityoftelosa.com/ > A so-called "15-minute city design" will allow residents to access their workplaces, schools and amenities within a quarter-hour commute of their homes. Although planners are still scouting for locations, possible targets include Nevada, Utah, Idaho, Arizona, Texas and the Appalachian region. Neighborhoods of existing US cities may also be candidates, https://www.movebuddha.com/blog/15-minute-cities/ https://www.movebuddha.com/blog/15-minute-cities/ > One popular concept hailing from Paris is the 15-minute city. It’s a city in which, wherever you live, everything you need is located within a 15-minute walk or bike ride away ... which of America’s largest cities have the greatest potential for transitioning into a 15-minute city?
- throwaway22032 5y agoThis comment does a good job of citing why the 15-minute city concept feels kind of "off" to me. It's ostensibly a good idea. I actually probably could live it, I'm 15 minutes walk from essentially everything I'd need. But whenever I read 'marketing material' it always just sounds like some way to ensure that the proletarians exist less. Use less resources, basically just corral most people off into these little life simulators. If you deleted long-distance transport like cars tomorrow I could still _do_ most of the things I need in order to subsist, but you would have immediately essentially just turned off the reason I get up in the morning.
- selfhifive 5y agoPlaces where cars and motorcycles/scooters arrived at the same time have more people using motorcycles/scooters. They're cheaper, more fuel efficient, and easier to park.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoAnd where there's weather to support that. Motorcycles are death traps in places that have winter.
- alamortsubite 5y agoTo be fair, so are automobiles. Stopping distance in wintry conditions can go up by an order of magnitude. 4WD/AWD does little if anything to ameliorate that, though some drivers seem to believe it does, based on my observation. Would you rather be crashed into by someone who thinks their 5000 lb pickup or SUV makes them invincible, or a kid on a moped? At least the moped operator has some skin in the game.
- flerchin 5y agoNo it's not even close. 20x more likely to die per mile driven.
- bobbylarrybobby 5y agoI think their point is that while motorcycles are deadly for their riders, cars are still deadly, just not for the occupants.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI know what you're saying, but I think I take issue with "death traps". In my younger, poorer years, I had only a motorcycle (and before that a 10-speed bicycle ... if that dates me) to get to work and community college in the middle of a Kansas winter. I rode very, very slowly. And spilled once or twice (at low speeds). The highways were of course out of the question (but I avoided the freeway regardless of the weather). But, yeah, I might have been about the only person out there on a bike/motorcycle in the worst of the blizzard.
- rkk3 5y agoIDK there are lots of games you can play with accounting when you have as much cash flow Uber has and not operating at a profit is more of a tax-avoidance strategy than a 70B dollar scam on public market investors... It's also wild how much money they need to commit to lobbying on the state and local level against union interests.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y ago
- alamortsubite 5y agoThe government and corporations can simultaneously be complicit. If the interview doesn't touch on this, it's fair to point it out, but turning it into the subject of a rant seems a bit much.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoMaybe corporations just want to sell their products, and governments help them if they think it benefits the people. Like maybe the government noticed rents are high in the city, so they thought with cars people could afford nice homes in the countryside? Even if that reasoning might have been wrong in the end, it just seems off to attribute everything to nefarious motives. It's the whole language - conspiring instead of cooperating, for example.
- truculent 5y agoI think the focus on corporations is just because the focus of this episode is specifically on Uber. I don't think any serious anti-car movement would fail to place blame with the government.
- coldtea 5y ago>Leftists are always victims (of the "bezzle" according to Cory Doctorow). Someone made them buy cars and move to the suburbs. Someone built cities in an unsustainable way. And so on. It was never their own free choice, they are never responsible for anything themselves. Similarly how liberals are always blaming themselves, like people in an abusive relationship/family that have learned it's their fault, and are always eager to bend over and take abuse.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoFair point, but even in an abusive relationship the solution is to take on responsibility and get out of the relationship, not whine until somebody frees you from it. With regard to cars, bicycles already exist. I personally have never owned a car in my life.
- jsemrau 5y agoShameless plug but... called it : https://medium.com/@jsemrau/nobody-will-talk-about-uber-in-5-years-cd372981c85a https://medium.com/@jsemrau/nobody-will-talk-about-uber-in-5...
- WJW 5y agoDon't want to be a nitpicker, but that article is from ~5 years ago and here we are talking about Uber. That seems to be the opposite of "called it", no? :)
- jsemrau 5y agoYou read the title of the article? It literally says that Uber won't be as relevant as it was assumed to be in 2016.
- WJW 5y agoYes, the joke was that I took the title of the article literally and it says "nobody will be talking about uber". Yet, at least us two are talking about it and so is the rest of this HN page. Therefore, "nobody" cannot be literally true.
- jsemrau 5y agoYou are not wrong. Uber is still a multi-billion dollar company that provides useful services to many people. I used them last week to order food. In 2016, Uber was dominating the news cycle left and right. And by comparison, it has become quiet around the company.
- ThinkBeat 5y agoI hate the anti car movement. I live in Oslo. The city has declared an all-out war against cars for the last 10 years at least. They have done some productive things, some annoying things and some downright sadistic things as far as driving. Removing damn near all city parking spaces. Regulating away even more. There is still some parking in garages and private lots but it is $$$$. Plus with the constant development in the city (Unrelated to the citys activities) you never know what roads will be closed temporarily and semi permanently (years) As one example: The national government decided that their safety required that an important underground car tunnel had to be closed to rebuild it 2 meters farther down. [1] That is going to take a while. If you live downtown and you have a bike it is kinda nice. Except we have winters (should not surprise many) when travelling by bike a good option. (Yes there is a tiny minority who risk life and limb by biking all year around) Most people dont ride a bike if the weather is bad even during the summer. Oslo is also far from flat. Riding around in Amsterdam or Denmark its pretty flat. Makes riding a lot easier. In Oslo we go up and down, up and down etc. This is mitigated in part by a sharp increase in bikes with electric engines. (Which I am not a huge fan of since it takes a near zero polluting vehicle and bang on a not ideally green battery) I think spending so many millions of dollars to make Oslo better for bikes is an unfortunate strategy. If they instead spent the money in improving and expanding public transit (something sorely needed) it would benefit a lot more people all year round. I have been a strong advocate for public transit most of my life and a staunch rider for most of my life. I dont live downtown. It is terribly expensive. I cant afford to. Until a few years ago where I was involved in an accident and I am no longer able to ride a bike, or use public transport. I am restricted to travelling by car. (or taxi if I could afford it). The nature of my injuries do not qualify me for the nationwide disabled person program where you get a sticker in your car that makes the city easier to handle by car). Due to the anti car movement, freedom/options has been severely downgraded. There are museums, cultural events, restaurants, and people to visit that I simply cannot do anymore in any practical sense. I miss that. I know it is selfish. But if you were in my shoes, you would find it annoying as well Believe me. Huge shopping malls outside downtown usually have a lot of parking and accessible but it's not at all interesting for em. Aside from myself, for my father and 10.000s of other senior citizens who are not in the best of health they suffer from the same issues. As do thousands of others who are in some way disabled but do not qualify for the national standard. (There are still a lot of senior citizens who benefit from it. It is not black or white) Anti car movement seems best for rich, healthy young people. Rich in that they can usually afford to live downtown or right next ot a subway station. Health because you do need to be in decent health to ride a bike. even ebikes. Young in that all physical activity is easier when you are young. (lets say less than 50) So from embracing it, I have gone on to hate it. It is not inclusive. As an ironic aside: The city wants to move towards 0 cars in the city or as close as they can get. HOWEVER, there are toll stations anywhere and the city has become dependent on the income from them. When Covid was in full effect and a lot less driving was taking place the city had budget problems. They do not have a plan on how to replace that income (yet). [1] https://www.bygg.no/vil-senke-ring-1-under-regjeringskvartalet/1250084!/ https://www.bygg.no/vil-senke-ring-1-under-regjeringskvartal... I dont live downtown because it is far too expensive.
- jackyinger 5y agoI thought the “geometry hates cars” premise had a lot of promise. I’m a bit disappointed that it turned out to be a footnote to a long discussion of Uber. Maybe fuel for a blog post? There are some great urban planning and architectural directions this could be taken.
- fknorangesite 5y agoIt's a common phrase/point in anti-car activist circles; it's already background knowledge for the guest, the host, and the audience. Hence the "I mean, I don’t have to tell The War on Cars this" that Doctorow prefaces it with. For example: https://humantransit.org/2016/07/elon-musk-doesnt-understand-geometry.html https://humantransit.org/2016/07/elon-musk-doesnt-understand...
- mchusma 5y agoI couldnt really read this article due to the tone beyond the introduction where they talk about the business model. They talk very dismissively about the whole thing, but I believe the business model was clear for Uber. Build a new transportation network to replace our current taxis, then other things, using technology. Once self driving cars are a reality, they have a strong position to be dominant. Their real issues have been execution once (losing to doordash should have never happened) as well as the delay of self driving cars. Both started happening really once they ousted Travis. The pandemic also hurt their core business dramatically.
- Marazan 5y ago"Being a minicab firm" is a business model. It is not a multi billion pound wave of the future business model. Self driving cars doesn't help them in any way.
- the_greyd 5y agoThat's Cory's whole schtick - he critiques big corps. I follow him a bit and most times his analysis is good and other times he dismisses things that don't fit in his ideological viewpoint.
- disgruntledphd2 5y agoI mean, it's easy to grow when you're selling dollars for $0.90. That's all Uber have ever done, and I find it astonishing that they haven't gone broke yet.
- whakim 5y ago> Once self driving cars are a reality, they have a strong position to be dominant. Everyone presumes this but it may not actually be true. I used to work with perhaps the most preeminent tech journalist covering Uber/Lyft/self-driving cars, and he would always point out that even if self-driving cars became a thing, would Uber now have to own a massive fleet of cars?
- bathtub365 5y agoUber will set up a program where you rent your self driving car to them while you aren’t using it. This lets them have their customers keep paying maintenance and depreciation (and only the ones who actually do the math will realize it costs them money).
- pmayrgundter 5y agoSurprised by Doctrow's flinged claim that Peter Thiel advocates against women voting.. seems absurd and well, didn't stand a quick sanity check: https://mobile.twitter.com/juliagalef/status/1054898254649802752?lang=de https://mobile.twitter.com/juliagalef/status/105489825464980... Edit: Thanks for the responses.. made me go read more. Here's the source article for his original quote: https://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/education-libertarian/ https://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/educatio... And apparently he got a lot of flack for that comment on voting and so replied a couple weeks later: https://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/05/01/peter-thiel/suffrage-isnt-danger-other-rights-are/ https://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/05/01/peter-thiel/suffrage... "It would be absurd to suggest that women’s votes will be taken away or that this would solve the political problems that vex us. While I don’t think any class of people should be disenfranchised, I have little hope that voting will make things better." That was directly linked from the original article, and happened over a decade ago. That's enough for me; Doctrow seems either to be parroting a falsehood or simply incorrect.
- vanusa 5y agoOh sure, he's not "against" women voting. He just says that their doing so is bad for democracy. The point is - Thiel is crank, and if needs to sugarcoat the true import of what he's really saying: "We'd all be better off if women's suffrage never happened" -- that's just Thiel being Thiel.
- ifyoubuildit 5y agoMaybe you're aware of more than just the linked tweet and that's why I'm not seeing what you're seeing. Some reasonable interpretations of that quote: 1) We would be more capitalist (whatever that means) if welfare beneficiaries and women were not able to vote. 2) Libertarian initiatives would succeed more often. Neither of those seem to me to obviously translate to "We'd all be better off if women's suffrage never happened". For one thing, the quote seems to be missing anything that says those groups shouldn't be voting. But again, I'm only looking at the words on the page.
- 5y ago
- elbasti 5y agoUber's story is actually very rational. When Uber started, we all thought it was a winner-takes-all market. The theory went something like this: 1. The more drivers are on a given platform, the more value users will derive from the platform in the form of cheaper rides, shorter waits, etc. This will result in more riders. 2. The more riders are on a platform, the more value drivers will derive in the form of higher utilization and more overall income. 3. Therefore, all drivers and riders will naturally gravitate to the winning platform. It's a winner takes all market. QED. Honestly, at the time (and I'm old enough to remember that time), the theory made sense. But it was wrong. The reason the theory was wrong is that there is actually zero cost for drivers in having multiple apps open at the same time. The switching cost is zero (actually, it's negative--we'll get to that in a second). And so point (3) doesn't happen. The reason switching cost is negative is that it actually costs money to start driving (and to convince people to become drivers). People quit jobs, and get/fix cars, and invest in a bluetooth headset, whatever. So Uber was actually subsidizing every other platform's drivers. So instead of an extremely defensible market you end up with a race to the bottom, with no barriers to competition. While in retrospect the mistake and dynamics are obvious, at the time it seemed like a reasonable, risky, ambitious bet. At some point these dynamics became obvious to Uber, which is when they started investing in self driving cars (never gonna work), uber eats, etc.
- clairity 5y agoto be more precise, it's not that switching cost is zero, it's that the marginal cost of switching is small. the initial switch into ridehailing is a huge cost, particularly around opportunity costs, but adding another app is a relatively small difference. it's not negative though. you still have the cost of signing up, taking your car to get evaluated, getting trained, figuring out how/when to get paid, etc. it adds cognitive and accounting overhead, and you run into contention issues between the apps, creating negative rider feedback that you must balance against the increased income potential. i do agree generally that there is little defensibility in ridehailing, and that's why uber (and lyft) tried to employ its supplier power to create competitive advantage/barriers. for instance, uber eats wasn't an expansion so much as a flanking move to lock in drivers on uber by increasing utilization.
- carapace 5y agoWow, that was quite a ride! I think the most interesting subject is the question of just how are we going to manage the climate shift? It seems to me that we have all the technology we need already, and it's a matter of organization and motivation. We even have negotiation and communication technology (I'm thinking of things like Nonviolent Communication here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonviolent_Communication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonviolent_Communication ) that we can utilize.
- 2ion 5y agoI feel justified for being pro car egostically by looking back at the pandemic. When employers and politicians herded workers through tightly packed public transport with zero effective protection (partially due to lack of discipline, partially due to lack of investment), I felt save & secure in my movable tin box. Yes, I am paying a lot for that box. And, do realize, that public transport is and will be for the plebs. Even if it's green. Not spoken in derogative manner, it's just that. Noone of high enough status is going to bike or limit themselves in any way, shape, or form. If they do bike, they'll be taking the car when you aren't looking or helicopter in. That probably still is going to solve the problem of mass transit, but the few who are not mass are going to continue to enjoy unlimited individual and privat transport whereas the rest of us won't. It's a decline in a dimension of freedom and not recognizing and admitting that fact is dishonest.
- SergeAx 5y agoI wonder how a real self-driving taxi may look like if optimized for size. Something like Smart For Two, with upper part folding inside when not in use by humans. This way it may be stored in a vertical carousel or otherwise optimize available parking space vertically while charging. I briefly thought about golf cart with folding tent shade above, but it is not that viable: climat control would be too complicated. But it may be actually a lower-grade variant for adequate weather or undemanding passengers.
- voakbasda 5y agoUber is one of many VC-funded businesses that set out to intentionally flout the intention of the laws where they operate. They find a loophole and drive through it with a dump truck. They expect to litigate when challenged to extend their runway. If they fail, the founders walk away with millions and get to do it all again. This kind of behavior is a huge disincentive to people that actually want to follow the spirit of the law. I mean, who wants to play a game where the other participants are flagrantly unabashed cheaters? Who wants to try to raise capital honestly, when liars can thrive? I have plenty of ideas and skills to launch viable startup businesses, but I'm not will to lie, cheat, and steal to compete. And like it or not, that's pretty much exactly what it takes to create a business like Uber.
- kingcharles 5y agoIndeed. Uber is of the "ask forgiveness, not permission" model. Sometimes, SOMETIMES, this is the only way to get things done. Especially when you're building at the speed of the Internet. Trying to lobby for changes in the law in advance would be a fool's errand as legislators work slowly, and usually only reactively. Don't blame the player, blame the game.
- voakbasda 5y agoOh, I absolutely blame the game. The fish rots from the head down. But the players here are rotten too. Just because a person legally can do a thing does not mean that a good honest person should do that thing.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoThen what, in your opinion, is one to do? Not every law, whether in spirit or letter, is written for the best interest of the governed. The crypto wars of the 90s are a testament to that and are now rearing their ugly head yet again. Working one's way around unstated assumptions is one of the rights acknowledged by the Constitution in the form of the 10th amendment. It remains one of the few safeguards against the self-righteousness political bodies tend to exhibit.
- SergeAx 5y ago> Transportation is a public good This is a single point that got my attention. He says that we, society, should run transportation for a net loss, because it benefits everybody, and especially benefits poor, who can't afford living close to their work. This is sounds about right, but at the same time it creates an incentive to live even farther, because farther is cheaper. Imagine me, a poor man, already settled for my current commute from point A to point B for two hours, and point A suddenly gets a better transportation, and I have one hour to myself because of that. I may spend it to my health or my family, but at the same time I may choose to cash this hour out by moving to point C, where I still have a two hour commute (because it is one hour from point A), but rent is cheaper. So this would be basically a subsidy, but there's another nuance. Rent at point A will go up because of better transportation. This is the most sure thing in the whole reasoning, because everybody old enough just saw things like that: subway station opens, and rent around it goes up. Moreover, there's a construction of higher class condo starts immediately, even before the opening. So in the end said subsidy goes to the pockets of landlords and development companies. What am I missing here?