9 ms·
U.S. is considering a radical rethinking of the dollar for today's digital world
- lota-putty 5y agoGold(Noble Metals) Standard, where are you? There is a local saying here "When fences eat crops, what can you do?" or "Fox guarding the hen-house", can you blame its instincts.
- xvilka 5y agoThe question also if they plan to allow smart contracts on this new USD CBDC or not. e-CNY, for example, incorporates[1] them. [1] https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/111648/china-digital-yuan-whitepaper-smart-contract-programmability https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/111648/china-digital-yua...
- rektide 5y agoIs this talking in any way about cutting out banks, credit card services, or payment processors? This is all just fluff talk right now is my guess. I'd feel like I'd be way more interested in trying to formalize an inter-bank payment system that works better than ACH, which seemingly will never be real-time enough to make it viable for things like point-of-sale use.
- djdjfhsje33edh 5y agoIsn't that what FedNow is trying to do?
- judge2020 5y agoPerhaps, but the marketing has been very careful to only show things like "account to account transfers, bill pay, and person-to-person transactions"[0]. There is a slight mentions of paying for services at 2:25, but it's brief. 0: https://youtu.be/WGOW_1cYgM4?t=111 https://youtu.be/WGOW_1cYgM4?t=111
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThat already exists, although is still in its early stages: https://www.theclearinghouse.org/payment-systems/rtp https://www.theclearinghouse.org/payment-systems/rtp https://www.zellepay.com/ https://www.zellepay.com/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- djdjfhsje33edh 5y agoHow would they handle theft? Would all payments (except for maybe major systemic hacks) be irreversible? Surely they couldn't blacklist stolen dollars that may have been subsequently spent multiple times. Would they mint new dollars to replace funds that have been proven to have been stolen (i.e., providing similar protection that bank and credit card customers have now)?
- Qworg 5y agoIf it truly is a dollar (which seems like what they're aiming at given UTxOs, etc), there's no recourse for the dollars (tokens) themselves - much like dollars today.
- shmatt 5y agoThey currently destroy old bills and print new ones into circulation, so destroying black listed funds and sending the legal owner newly minted ones sounds right
- errcorrectcode 5y agoSuppose some piece of infrastructure along the way lacks a checksum or ECC, and gets hit by a cosmic ray or a hardware defect. You now have +2^17 USD - txamount more or 2^19 - 2^18 USD + txamount less in said account. Throw FDIC insurance out the window because they're probably a) not going to do it and b) stick you with fees and losses.
- agucova 5y agoThis seems interesting, but I doubt this would be a vulnerability of any properly redundant digital coin.
- errcorrectcode 5y agoAnywhere non-ECC storage or computation occurs before it hits hashing or distributed, it's a SPoF.
- jtsiskin 5y ago
- TedShiller 5y agoWhat could possibly go wrong?
- reactspa 5y agoYou know how on Twitter sometimes you can "heart" a tweet by mistake (just scrolling and inadvertently tapping the heart icon), and that can be used against you years later? Donate $1 to some charity, and later it turns out this charity gave to Trump. And you'll be cancelled for life!
- koshergweilo 5y agoThis is a pretty moot point because A. All political donations are already public [1] B. Most Trump supporters voluntarily make their preference known [1]: https://www.fec.gov/data/receipts/individual-contributions/ https://www.fec.gov/data/receipts/individual-contributions/
- errcorrectcode 5y agoTuttle, Buttle. Ministry of Information charges. Also ran into this interesting history-fiction comparative analysis from 2004: http://www.oilempire.us/brazil.html http://www.oilempire.us/brazil.html
- hayd 5y agoI suppose it makes it easier to print...
- judge2020 5y agoMost inflation and money supply is handled via the interest rate nowadays as the bank's own money they lend and store has been mostly digital for decades.
- asabjorn 5y agoJust look at the promo video of the digital wallet of Bill Gates funded Thales for how this would combine with vaccine passport and ESG scores to usher in China style tyranny https://youtu.be/PxvNzzgoJX8 https://youtu.be/PxvNzzgoJX8 Of cause, because on a government controlled digital currency there would be no anonymous transaction and like the Chinese anyone with a low ESG score can be stopped from spending their cash. Yes, all across the world a social credit score called ESG is adopted by banks. https://youtu.be/8f1Z57hwbWY https://youtu.be/8f1Z57hwbWY Or what if they decide you used up your quota? No flight, no meat or no car ride for you because they won’t let you spend your money
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoThe US already has all the infrastructure for "total tyranny". If private consumer information databases already know everyone in america and their spending habits, then the Feds have that and then some. It is what makes presidential elections scarier each year: all it takes is one president with a false flag attack (or maybe not even that). Bush had the opportunity, but not really the means or the motive. Obama had the means, but not really the opportunity or the motive. Trump had the motive and means, but not the opportunity. In a more ideal world, the "social karma" would be a good thing: crypto and such tracking could enable actually effective environmental regulation and rewards. It could enable penalizing previous revenues/profits/gains for economic activity that turned out to be deleterious. For example, I would very much like to be able to reduce the value of all profits from oil by 90% historically, if I had such powers as god-emperor treehugger. Crypto could provide such powers. Of course they won't be used properly, and tyranny. But it is theoretically possible.
- asabjorn 5y agoYes. That’s exactly why you want a system where the means are not there to institute tyranny, and there is a separation of power where multiple powerful hierarchies check each other. My point isn’t that some of this can’t be done now, but that this tech is a force multiplier as evidenced with how China use this kind of tech for social control Systems like this that are marketed assuming an enlightened selfless group control it fails to take human nature into account. It never worked before and with the means we have no it will fail spectacularly. Certainly the WEF and it’s Young Global Leaders haven’t shown selfless restraint so far. Eg Boris Johnson, Trudeau, Markel all were caught partying while forcing everyone else to do the opposite. They all become wealthy while in power.
- edrxty 5y agoI don't think I want the Fed to have access to every recipient and source of every dollar I ever spend. That database can only be misused.
- ryanmarsh 5y agoToo late. The Fed requests ad-hoc reporting of all kinds and the banks comply. In addition to raw transaction flows which the Fed does in fact receive in many cases. People have no idea what all those people at the Fed do and people who work there are not free to discuss it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- silisili 5y agoAgreed. They'll play this as a safe something, but it's really all about taxes. So many people and even industries today run afoul of taxes. If you didn't know or disagree, you've never worked or lived around the less privileged. Example: I called to have my windshield replaced last month by a local company. The guy said 'if you pay cash, 307 dollars. Credit card you need to add tax and fees, so 350.' Also, at least in the southeastern US, nearly every gun store heavily dissuades you from using anything but cash.
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoOf course, for the windshield company to be legal, they need to add sales tax to cash sales as well.
- Supermancho 5y ago> I don't think I want the Fed to have access to every recipient and source of every dollar I ever spend. That won't matter much when people inevitably start to trade in a physical proxy.
- brjiro8 5y agoGovernment is just humans. There’s no reason to believe any organization of humans has your personal interests at heart. Ostensibly politicians can be replaced. Despite believing government to be inherently corrupt, we still seem to think the ledger of ownership is inherently correct and incorruptible. The mental gymnastics everyone goes through to demonize government and accept privatization which locks them out of accounts, absconds funds, and offers no path to remediation, resulting in posts here hoping a Big Tech Corp worker happens to be browsing is pretty stunning display of how media has influenced our beliefs
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoHaving kept my finger on the pulse of cryptocurrencies on and off over the last few years, I'm very interested to see how CBDCs are marketed to society. I feel like it could be a new peak in political two-faced-ness (no mean feat given very recent history, but also merely an extrapolation of the current trend line).
- beaned 5y agoI have a fear that in our current political climate, the introduction of CBDCs at scale will fracture digital money into Democrat money (CBDCs) and Republican money (crypto), and maybe even our economy into Blue and Red, every single economic action tinged with suspicion of either "censorship" or "racism," "communist" or "fascist" (though, to be political, they're the same thing), "self sacrificial" vs "hateful," etc, depending on which one chooses to use.
- programmarchy 5y agoKeen insight but not sure the factions would be aligned by political party, or if there’d be some other fracture line like corporatist (neo-liberal/neo-conservative) or populist (Bernie/Trump).
- beaned 5y agoYes, this could be, too. Already some communists and capitalists are united in seeing crypto as the peoples' money.
- JetAlone 5y agoSplit it four ways. UCPD (United Communist People's Dollars; it's an absolute inflation station, but in its defence, people just haven't really tried it yet), GrillBuxx (on the George Foreman standard), Diversynergium (On the front of the commemorative card it says "We celebrate our diversity; the concept is profitable." in latin) and Conspiracoin (A coin that goes up in value the more people discuss whether or not it should be shut down).
- errcorrectcode 5y agoHell f'ing no. Traditional and inverse totalitarianism in one go. This would be "amazing" for taxation, mining people's habits, and financial crimes but brutal to individuals who can be located or shut-out of the economy entirely. The unbanked would also be left twisting in the wind.
- choward 5y agoThis would be a great idea if our government wasn't complete corrupt and we could trust it. I find it hard to believe that the people pushing it are acting in good faith.
- csa 5y agoThe narrative on HN seems to be about how this is not good/useful for digital currency users in the US. This is straight up a competitor for the digital yuan (Chinese RMB), and the most valuable use cases from a US federal perspective are international uses (mostly developing countries). Some ideas: - The USD is used as a default currency in many places for many transactions, but there is friction in the system, especially for small payments, and especially with hostile regimes. - The USD as a default currency gives many benefits to the US (e.g., essentially free money). - China and the US are and will be battling for the market of the default currency of non-domestic microtransactions with digital currency. This is just a part of that battle. - There may be some benefits (or not) for domestic users of the eUSD, but that is not the main purpose of this currency. If the eUSD doesn’t resonate for you, then consider that you may not be the target market. - Note that this currency will most likely be presented/marketed in a very different way than I am suggesting above, and this will be more for political reasons than anything else. Edit1: Note that when taken in this light, certain aspects of the eUSD like non-distributed ledger, centralized control, etc. should make more sense. Edit2: Here is a link with more info: https://www.mauldineconomics.com/frontlinethoughts/a-giant-consumptive-force https://www.mauldineconomics.com/frontlinethoughts/a-giant-c...
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoIf China wanted more people around the world to use its currency, freely floating its exchange rate on the market is a must. That the RMB is not freely convertible like the dollar is is a huge hurdle to its international adoption. American cash usage is already way way down and has been falling for the last 3 decades. That this is often because of expensive banking and credit card interchange networks has to be of some concern to the US government, those fees add up to extra friction in the economy, and a digital currency looks really appealing even for domestic use (see what happened with using WeChat for payments in China).
- csa 5y ago> If China wanted more people around the world to use its currency, freely floating its exchange rate on the market is a must. That the RMB is not freely convertible like the dollar is is a huge hurdle to its international adoption. In some circles, especially for very large cross-border transactions, this is definitely true. That said, for microtransactions in developing countries, this is less of an issue. China will go out of its way to make this a stable and easily convertible currency for folks in these markets.
- DevKoala 5y agoHow would this stop individuals who can obscure wealth through trusts and other international financial engineering? It seems like a ploy to go after the little guy while negating to take a look at tax evasion schemes for the individuals who control the biggest chunk of wealth.
- Proven 5y ago
- georgyo 5y agoI'm trying to figure out the why, and the ones in the article do not make a lot of sense to me. Dollars in things like Venmo are already digital currency. I have some balance and I can send that balance to various places. How will this actually help under banked people? Would the people who don't have a back account today want to use digital cash? Fees are big issue, but they are for most part baked in and keep many people employed. It seems it would very difficult to make a policy change that would harm visa and Mastercard. Offline transactions are very unlikely to happen as well, people will double spend if transactions work offline. They only leaves surveillance as the goal. Being able to track cash transactions that works otherwise be untraceable.
- Barrin92 5y ago>I'm trying to figure out the why, because it disintermediates the entire payment sector, and every single dollar going into the pockets of banks /payment processors is going to go to consumers, or be returned to the public. It'll help underbanked people because by virtue of being a US citizen, or whatever jurisdiction we're talking about, you'll have free access to a costless payment system. It'd also unify and standardize payments across an entire currency zone, getting rid of the bazillion API / interface issues that the currently glued together system has. The benefits are pretty obvious. As to employment, if we're going to create employment through bullshit jobs we might as well set up a toll booth every ten meters until there's no unemployment or have people roll stones up and down mountains.
- erentz 5y agoIf you just want one government owned and operated payment system what does that have to do with having a CBDC?
- Barrin92 5y agothat's literally what the CBDC is for, creating a public payment system. Just like you walk into a store and pay with dollars, you can whip out your phone and pay with e-dollars. The practical effect is that it'd replace the for-profit payment industry.
- trixie_ 5y agoWould this be any different than a government issued stable coin? This has the potential to greatly simplify the entire banking infrastructure. It would also make it harder to lend what you don’t have. Current banking balances are easily fudged. Stable coins are real records you can only lend if you have them. I could see this driving up interest rates on savings accounts similar to how crypto savings accounts have decent returns.
- xeromal 5y agoIt's similar except centralized, but I guess there are cryptos that are centralized?
- netheril96 5y agoMost stablecoins are indeed centralized.
- dang 5y agoPresumably related: Boston Fed releases report, source code of digital currency prototype study - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30233755 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30233755 - Feb 2022 (154 comments)
- _xnmw 5y agoThis is exactly what I want: a trusted centralized database for no-fee instant domestic and international transfers - I want this NOW. A million times better than any crypto scam, because: 1. I trust the USG. 2. The value of a currency comes from the issuing entity, and acceptance by merchants, not speculation on a blockchain (or any other technology). 3. Since it is centralized it will be reversible in court if hacked or mistakenly sent. 4. Since it is centralized it will be able to handle millions of transactions per second assuming they don’t screw up the technology. If they get this right it will simultaneously render all crypto useless (except for crime) AND actually deliver on the false claims of crypto which never materialized in the past 10 years.
- netheril96 5y agoIt won’t render crypto useless because it is still subject to inflation unlike Bitcoins. The idea that Bitcoin protects owners from dollar inflation can be false, but as long as many believe in that notion, eUSD cannot replace Bitcoin.
- fastball 5y agoBitcoin was invented to specifically avoid centralization, so it definitely doesn't solve the same problems.
- McAtNite 5y agoI disagree on the idea that it would render crypto useless. In one aspect this would absolutely fail to address an entire section of the crypto market - privacy. You can attempt to make the tired “if you have nothing to hide” argument against it, but I don’t think that will change a privacy conscious person’s mind to suddenly accept centralized spending tracking by the gov. The other area this would utterly fail to address would be the existence of a central authority. Failure to understand why people in crypto look so negatively at centralization is a failure to understand why Bitcoin exists in the first place, and how it was a direct response to the 2008 crash and subsequent reaction of the USG. I’m sure a portion of the modern day crypto “investors” would migrate to whatever the USG puts out, but it certainly wouldn’t be embraced by a large part of the overall crypto community.
- quantified 5y agoSuperficial and ignorant. Need journalists who don’t just repeat press releases with clearly labeling as such. > With a digital dollar, you could in theory eliminate those middlemen. If you wanted to buy a sandwich, for instance, you could transfer money from a digital wallet directly to a cashier. Cash has no ?middleman. You trade one set for… how direct is the transfer? Who is extracting the money from your account, depositing into theirs? Can you invest them and get returns? Put them in the bank and get returns?
- gorbypark 5y agoCash actually has a ton of middlemen, if you consider the lifecycle of most cash. From printing it, transporting it, counting it, etc. I bet each $20 bill is handled dozens of times in it’s lifespan by a person who is not the owner of it (think bank tellers, cashiers, armoured car drivers, the people that load ATMs, etc).
- quantified 5y agoThere are participants. Question of how you define “middle” and in between whom. When you pay the deliveryperson, florist, kid who shoveled your driveway in cash, there are zero participants between you and that person. How you got that cash depends on a physical supply chain. Generally, going to an ATM is pretty easy. Our payment system is currently the worst of both: only electrons and magnetic regions, but lots of them in the way siphoning off their cut.
- t8y 5y agoWont this have a huge impact on all banks? If I had this I'd shut down my bank account and just have this + investments. Banks offer too low yields to be worth while. I think digital currencies are the future but it would have a huge affect on banks and payments companies.
- WriterGuy2021 5y agoThe U.S. isn't an entity capable of consideration. There's some wizard of oz style trickery going on here. If you pull back the curtain, you'll find a gaggle of corrupt bureaucrats pulling levers that control the illusion of the state. Who wants money with surveillance and control built into it? Imagine a future where you post some wrongthink on social media and your dollar crypto wallet is automatically disabled by a precrime AI. No thanks.
- pmontra 5y agoWell, it can get worse in the way you write but we must be careful right now. PayPal freezes accounts, states know every single bank transfer, credit cards companies ban some kind of businesses. Add more examples.
- throwaway4good 5y agoDoes anyone know how this would work? Would it just be a pointer (a digital key sitting on your device) to an account at the central bank holding your dollars? Or is something more elaborate? Would it allow anonymized holders of digital USD? If not how would they handle know-your-customer (KYC)? If so, how would they prevent evil people like Kim Jong Il or Carrie Lam holding USD?
- pmontra 5y agoThe first two questions: cash is anonymous, a digital money transfer could be anonymous or not depending on the design. I don't think governments want anonymous transfers but they might not give that information to the party that receives of the money. That is, they know I paid 10$ to that shop but the shop doesn't know who I am. The last question: some people have rooms full of 100$ bills. Some of them are evil. Examples https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/russia-says-afghan-president-fled-with-cars-helicopter-full-cash-ria-2021-08-16/ https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/russia-says-afgha... https://www.cnn.com/2019/09/08/africa/sudan-al-bashir-trial-witness-intl/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/09/08/africa/sudan-al-bashir-trial-... A technology people's fallacy is to expect technology to solve social problems. They are best solved socially.
- bigyellow 5y ago