6 ms·
One major distinction this glosses over is the difference between making it so you can't read something (e.g., banning it), and making it so you aren't required
by josephcsible 5y ago
One major distinction this glosses over is the difference between making it so you can't read something (e.g., banning it), and making it so you aren't required to read something (e.g., removing it from the curriculum). Only the former is censorship.
- tandymodel100 5y ago
- api 5y agoOutside extreme examples like child porn or speech that is copyright violation I am not aware of many cases of actual prohibited speech in the US. Schools however are a grey area because attendance is mandatory and the state sets the curriculum.
- rayiner 5y agoIt’s not a gray area at all. Public schools are a public service paid for by tax dollars. The government excluding certain things from the curriculum doesn’t implicate freedom of speech any more than it excluding certain bus routes implicates freedom of movement.
- beebmam 5y agoForced curriculum on students, at all, is no different than re-education camps; state sponsored indoctrination that both political parties (currently) support. All education should be consensual
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoYou're essentially saying school vouchers, and then the government doesn't choose the curriculum at private schools. In a public school there isn't anyone else there to choose the curriculum. Everyone there is a government employee.
- beebmam 5y agoNo, I'm arguing that forced schooling in general is an unethical act, on par with communist indoctrination, and there should be no government run schools at all
- Sebb767 5y agoHe actually handles that distinction early in the article as a quote: > [...] he noted that there exists not just a right to speak but a right to hear. “To suppress free speech is a double wrong. It violates the rights of the hearer as well as those of the speaker.” But this is of course a gray area. You don't have to listen to anything anyone has to say, but it's also possible to sideline something enough that it is effectively censored without being outright forbidden.
- josephcsible 5y agoI don't see how that quote addresses it. Wouldn't the relevant right be a "right not to hear", which he doesn't mention? > You don't have to listen to anything anyone has to say If you're a student, and it's in the state mandated curriculum, then you do. > it's also possible to sideline something enough that it is effectively censored without being outright forbidden. I 100% agree with this.
- Sebb767 5y ago> I don't see how that quote addresses it. Wouldn't the relevant right be a "right not to hear", which he doesn't mention? You're right, I misread your comment. He really does not differenciate this clearly, despite having examples for both cases.
- rayiner 5y agoThat’s completely inapposite to the point being made above. Choosing a curriculum is about curation—it has nothing at all to do with free speech, neither in the legal sense, nor in the broader “free speech values” sense.
- klyrs 5y ago> Why does Professor Sachs make this assertion? On November 12, the governor signed a bill that makes it unlawful to include “instruction relating to critical race theory in any portion of the district's required curriculum ... or any other curriculum offered by the district or school.” Now do the steel man (emphasis mine)
- josephcsible 5y agoIsn't this still the same distinction? That's still just saying that nobody can force students to learn about critical race theory, not that they can't go read about it on their own if they want.
- klyrs 5y agoNo, it says that critical race theory cannot be offered. That's specific and distinct from required.
- josephcsible 5y agoAh, I see: that affects whether it's allowed to be taught in an elective class or not. Yes, to fully oppose censorship, we should allow critical race theory to be taught in optional elective social studies classes. But then we should also allow optional elective science classes to teach that evolution is wrong, because to do otherwise would be censoring the young-Earth creationists.
- klyrs 5y agoIf you can find a way to teach that without violating the Establishment Clause, sure. The only way forward I can see here would look like a comparative history of religions course, which would teach various creation stories from a neutral viewpoint. And that doesn't seem to be what those campaigning for anti-evolution education have been looking for. Curious if you've got any fresh ideas, though.
- 5y ago
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoYou are correct. Not sure why you're getting down voted. Just because Pinocchio isn't in the curriculum doesn't mean it's banned. You can still get it in the school library. Not in curriculum != Banned
- tandymodel100 5y ago
- imgabe 5y agoI don’t remember the case, but I read somewhere that the Supreme Court drew a distinction between deciding not to add something vs taking away what was already there in regards to school libraries. Assuming this is referring to Maus, it wasn’t a part of the curriculum, it was just a book that was available in the library. The school board removed it from the library, clearly in an effort to limit access to it.
- WalterBright 5y agoI'm not in favor of book banning, but that book shouldn't be allowed in a library.
- imgabe 5y agoWhy not? I’ve heard of it but never read it. I just know it’s widely acclaimed and about the Holocaust.
- sixstringtheory 5y agoI’ve never seen/read it, curious to know why you think it shouldn’t be allowed in libraries.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 5y agoP.S. That was sarcasm.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dgellow 5y agoI get the irony but in the current context that doesn’t really read as a joke.
- pseudalopex 5y ago> Assuming this is referring to Maus, it wasn’t a part of the curriculum. It was.[1] [1] https://www.wate.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/42/2022/01/Called_Meeting_Minutes_1-10-22.pdf https://www.wate.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/42/2022/01/Cal...
- TulliusCicero 5y agoAlso, when it comes to publication, plenty of stuff used to be essentially banned by 'platforms', it just wasn't obvious because "user-generated content" was barely a thing (letters to the editor) in comparison to people posting on Facebook and Youtube and Twitter and Tiktok. Random people being able to post content for thousands or even millions to immediately see, with no explicit gatekeepers prior to submission; this is largely a recent thing. And it makes sense that of course everywhere has rules, bare minimum basically nobody likes people spamming stuff, for example, even in cases where it's legal. If you create a message board about model trains and some rando starts constantly spamming ads for their series of NFT's, I guess banning them is technically 'censorship', but you could also call it 'the bare basics of maintaining a functional community'. I think that for platforms like Twitter and Facebook, perhaps it may make more sense to end up a situation more like newspapers, where you have more reputable papers like the NYT, WaPo, and WSJ that have stricter rules, and then you also have the National Enquirer or other random outlets that have little to no standards. If Twitter and Facebook want to have somewhat tighter rules where they censor people, that's fine, the people being censored should then just have options of other platforms with different or fewer rules. Just seems like the problem to me is that people expect these mega platforms to be all things to all people, when that's probably not realistic.
- raxxorrax 5y agoFacebook and Twitter ban for political reasons, which is entirely different than banning spam. Banning spam is a strawman in this discussion. I don't think there is constructive discussion on that basis. Free speech protects good faith debates.
- TulliusCicero 5y ago> Banning spam is a strawman in this discussion. I don't think there is constructive discussion on that basis. It's not a strawman, as many people assert that platforms should just let anything not-illegal stay up. You may not believe this, but there are others who I've seen assert it. > Facebook and Twitter ban for political reasons, which is entirely different than banning spam. It's not the same, but the issue is that once you're past the border of "we'll only ban illegal stuff", you're now in the realm of much more subjective decisionmaking. In practice, many forms of speech could be classified as both political, and harassment/bullying/other bad stuff, which is what usually happens with Facebook. In their case, they don't want to get into the political sphere, but they do want to bad blatant misinformation, and in practice that does overlap with politics.
- pyuser583 5y agoI think we really need to have a “who controls the curriculum” conversation. When I was a teacher, we could chose from whatever the books the school had a ton of lying around. Not a good way to make a selection. At the same time, people are freaking out when parents want a say I what books their children are evaluated on. If it was up to me, we’d focus on the classics: Homer, Virgil, Shakespeare, Milton, Dickens, Dostoyevsky, etc.
- coffeeblack 5y agoAnd then there is the new “cancel culture” that does not target the speech itself, but the reputation of the author. By using horrific accusations and smears, the author’s reputation is destroyed, so that people don’t want to hear the speech anymore, based on the lies they heard about the author.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- GolfPopper 5y agoAnother confusing facet of the debate is a significant number of participants who equate not being given an audience or a trivially-used press (in the form of a popular website) with being censored.