12 ms·
How the World Went from Post-Politics to Hyper-Politics
- sdoering 5y ago> An English translation only came about in 2017, already at the close of the ‘populist’ decade. As a citizen of Germany I would have classified Trump as the epitome of populist politics (not that there are a myriad other examples around the world). Not sure what to make of the phrase 'populist decade' and what specific context or definition I seemingly am lacking.
- Apocryphon 5y agoNot to mention Trump's victory kicked off a lot of copycats and fellow travelers, from Bolsonaro to Zemmour. The populist wave might have waned quite a bit, but it's far from over.
- asplake 5y agoIn the UK I would say that the Iraq war, the credit crisis, and Brexit hollowed out politics and we were left with populists – Corbyn on the left, Johnson in the right – and a great loss of trust in the political process. There’s a shakeup happening right now (Corbyn gone and Johnson likely to follow) but it’s way too early to tell how long it will take for faith to be restored. Maybe it’s just my politics, but it seems to me that whatever your politics, the lack of a functioning middle leaves us all worse off. I know a number of Americans that feel the same, though whether there are enough of them to make a difference I don’t know.
- makomk 5y agoI can't see faith in politics returning in the UK unless the successor to Johnson gets very lucky. The trouble is, right now we're facing a major cost of living and energy crisis that's the direct result of policies which had bipartisan support from the entire mainstream establishment, such as pushing for renweables in a way that actually just makes us highly dependent on natural gas whilst blocking any new natural gas sources in the UK or funded by the UK finance industry that could make up for the decline of the current ones, and trying to stop Covid without regard to the cost to the economy (which most people wrongly understood to just mean big corporations and the super-wealthy). Also, a lot of pressure on Johnson comes from the press and opposition claiming that any competent leader should be able to achieve things that are likely impossible and that no-one else in the Western world has, like solve the cost of living crisis, prevent large numbers of people from dying of Covid, and stop new Covid variants from coming into existence by vaccinating the world. It's amazing how many people falsely think the UK has the worst Covid deaths per capita in Europe rather than middle of the pack, just because all the headlines carefully cherry-pick whatever narrow figure makes the UK look worse. Then there's all the endless articles about how much other European countries are doing to protect people from high energy costs which mysteriously neglect to compare how much they're actually paying for power. And of course, the current vaccines can't stop new variants both because they don't stop Covid spreading nearly enough and because most of the unvaccinated global population already has natural immunity anyway, plus the UK doesn't have a pharmaceutical industry big enough to supply the world (we're not an empire anymore!) Any successor to Johnson will have expectations placed on them that they couldn't possibly live up to, which is probably why no-one is keen to try and take his place. There's also been a lot of attacks on the government lately for "wasting" money by buying more PPE than ended up being used in the end. Imagine trying to do any kind of emergency planning when the political climate is like that.
- pasabagi 5y ago> worst Covid deaths per capita I think the point is that the countries that have worse deaths-per-capita are poor (eastern european states), conspicuously dysfunctional (Belgium), or both dysfunctional and unlucky (Italy). The UK was positioned to do well (it's an island, has a national health service, very low vaccine hesitancy, had lots of warning), and yet did badly both on deaths and the economy. The story of the UK and covid was one of unforced errors, not of an impossible challenge. PS: probably most importantly, the UK has a relatively young population (median age 40, vs Italy at 46, Germany at 49, etc).
- makomk 5y agoOne of those Eastern European states - the Czech Republic - was actually the big European success story everyone in the UK press pointed to as proof that the UK should've been able to do better if we had competent leaders. They ended up with the worst Covid deaths per capita in Europe until their neighbours overtook them, and yet I'm sure they still contribute to the belief the UK failed. In reality it seems like they were the ones who got lucky early on and had the chance to do well but failed to take advantage of that, with issues like poor vaccine uptake there. On the other hand, the cities which got hit next after Italy were New York and London, both of which had lots of travel from Milan due to Fashion Week right around the time there was massive undetected community spread there. That's definitely unlucky.
- pasabagi 5y agoWell, that's the other thing: there was a time when the UK did have top-tier per-capita death rates, so that's where the idea came from that the UK was 'number one'. In regards to CR, you would expect the Czech republic to do worse than the UK. They have an older population, somewhat poor state, and a horrible vaccination rate (63%). The continuing perception also probably comes down to the personality of Boris Johnson. You can't go around shaking hands, calling it 'kung flu', party through the lockdowns, then expect people to see you as an ideal leader in an emergency situation.
- 5y ago
- turbinerneiter 5y agoI think it is very interesting that you think the lack of middle is the problem. From my left-leaning view, the middle is exactly the problem. E.g. "the third way" that the Democrats, Labour and SPD in Germany were following. Or Blair going into Iraq based on lies. The financial crisis. To me, all these are a result of the middle. The leftist parties didn't do what they were supposed to do - oppose wars, regulate economy to ensure stability and fairness. To me, the middle means that whatever we vote for, whoever is in charge, nothing really changes. Every time left parties manage to win an election, they start to compromise and don't actually do the things they promised. If the left is unhappy that everything is to right, and the right is unhappy that everything is to left and the middle thinks it doesn't even exist, then I don't know what the hell is broken. Modern governments just seem to fail at being a positive factor in peoples live. It's all crumbling, it's all cost overrun, it's all compromise that is worse than both competing ideas. I often feel like all the tings that were done during my parents time are just deemed impossible now. Like NASA used to be able to put people on the Moon, and now they don't even have a manned platform anymore.
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoBrexit did not result in populists. It is the result of populists latching on to the greatest intraparty political divide in generations. It's unambiguously, purely a populist position, wilfully divorced from data and focussing on sovereignty and self-determination and Britishness. It never made a technocratic case for itself at all, and in general the core Brexiteers excelled in avoiding making a technocratic case -- it was always going to be hard Brexit because every technocratic argument was successfully shot down as appeasement. Every single major sales pitch for Brexit was populist in nature; no convincing sales pitch for good governance, economic success or long term growth was ever made. It's always about being free of Them, which is an essentially populist position.
- asplake 5y agoThe hollowing out created the conditions for it, and another wave of politicians have gone, continuing the process
- YEwSdObPQT 5y ago> There’s a shakeup happening right now (Corbyn gone and Johnson likely to follow) but it’s way too early to tell how long it will take for faith to be restored. I was unemployed for 9 months (which drained me of my savings), couldn't visit my grandmother because of the instability created by the repeated lock-downs and uncertainty. It almost financially ruined me. I can't afford to fix my car, I had to get into more debt to just get my hot water running. At the same time politicians, media personalities and the like went out boozing, sleeping with their mistresses and doing exactly what they like. Everyone of them should be thrown in jail for what they have done. There shouldn't be any trust put in the political process. I hope it won't be restored ever. People shouldn't trust any politician at all nor the democratic process. Time after time these people have failed the people (all the political parties) spectacularly. The system itself selects for the very people that you don't want. > Maybe it’s just my politics, but it seems to me that whatever your politics, the lack of a functioning middle leaves us all worse off. The "functioning" middle is what has led us to this place. There is a famous quote from Noam Chomsky which is apt: > The smart way to keep people passive and obedient is to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum. The idea functioning middle is sold to people because most people believe in being reasonable and fair minded. This unfortunately is misleading. What it really means is "business as usual". Business as usual brought up the Iraq war, endless wars in the middle east, financial crisis after financial crisis where everyday people get shafted. I don't want to be represented by any of them. You also don't really get to choose who you get represented by anyway. You get a very small say in who represents you. If I wanted someone to represent me, I would hire someone myself.
- denton-scratch 5y agoCorbyn's no populist. He's often described as a populist; but in fact he is and always[0] has been on the left wing of Labour, a centrist party. Socialism != populism. [0] He's been a Labour backbencher since 1983, and his policies didn't change much over the intervening years.
- doe88 5y agoRelated pod episode (Jäger guest of Bungacast) https://bungacast.podbean.com/e/235-political-ritalin-ft-anton-jager/ https://bungacast.podbean.com/e/235-political-ritalin-ft-ant...
- Apocryphon 5y agoThis article speaks more specifically about how Western European politics have changed, not "the world", and not very much about how American politics changed, either. And I think this is indicative: > In the years after 2008, the political Ice Age which had followed the collapse of the Berlin Wall began, steadily, to thaw. This ignores that the process of transitioning towards hyper-politics has been going on for quite some time in the U.S. from Gingrich's hyper-partisan speakership in the '90s to the War on Terror (remember that?) throughout the '00s, not to mention the brief spark of the anti-globalization movement in the late '90s during the WTO protests, there was a lot going on before the great recession. The End of History ended on 9/11, far before 2008, and certainly before 2016!
- pasabagi 5y agoThe war on terror was bipartisan, though, and supported by political parties across the spectrum around the world. The UK's (nominally) social democratic Labour party pushed it, for example. I think the real demarcation line is that until very recently, there was exactly one political prescription: deregulate, reduce tax, and reduce state expenditure. The only question was, how much? Every major political party essentially agreed with this basic formula, which had the attached slogan 'there is no alternative', and if you suggested an alternative, the media would castigate you for being some kind of pie-in-the-sky radical. Trump, amongst others, kind of blew that whole idea up.
- Apocryphon 5y agoThe War on Iraq had initial bipartisan support but became a hyper-partisan issue, maybe less so politically than it was as a cultural war. There were immense antiwar rallies prior to the invasion. It became a defining wedge issue in popular culture. "Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists." But I'm speaking specifically about the U.S.
- pasabagi 5y agoI'm not sure I'd call it 'partisan'. Opinions were divided, but in terms of 'party politics', especially mainstream party politics, I don't know. Kerry voted for the Iraq war, for instance. along with a majority of Democrats. I'd imagine positive votes were correlated with party influence, too. Regarding popular culture, you're totally right. I think on a grassroots level, politics never went away. It just got excluded from public discourse.
- uniqueuid 5y agoHighly recommended book on the roots of populism and the current state of politics including democratic backsliding: Jan-Werner Müller: Democracy Rules [1] [1] https://www.foreignaffairs.com/reviews/capsule-review/2021-04-20/democracy-rules https://www.foreignaffairs.com/reviews/capsule-review/2021-0...
- spaniard89277 5y agoDemocracy is essentially populist, because elites fight for votes through media. Parties optimize their selection process for those more suited to deal with public opinion. Reaching as many votes as possible forces parties to draw their discourses around the lowest common denominator, which dumbs it down a lot. The competition is fierce, so small by small step parties push the boundaries. There's an inverse correlation between the results in the last election with the incentive to push the boundaries. So if you're losing by a wide gap, dumb it down and appeal to emotions even more. Then your competition is forced to react, hopefully not quick enough. I've been a consultant in a company for political parties for a brief period of time in my country, and the level of technification and specialization is on par, if not better, with the best marketing campaigns in the private sector. I laughed when I saw the scandal about cambridge Analytica. IDK in the US but in Spain microtargeting and segmented audiences were already being used by that time. It didn't feel right to me so I left before I made a year in it. It wasn't only my job, it was the people I had to speak with, the feeling after the meetings that we were in the hands of completely idiot sociopaths.
- unfocussed_mike 5y ago> Democracy is essentially populist, because elites fight for votes through media. Democracy is by no means essentially populist. It is when it is in its sickly stages, maybe. It's also by no means necessarily dependent on elites; again that is an indication of the failure of democracy (and the arrival of money as speech). It is very fair to say that few of the older democracies are keeping populism at bay -- India is failing at it, Britain has failed at it, Turkey has failed at it, etc.
- ThalesX 5y agoWhat are some examples of democracies that are keeping populism at bay? I live in a country that became democratic around when I was born. I don't feel that as a young democracy we're doing a particularly good job at keeping populism at bay; I'd go so far as to say we're failing at it.
- 5y ago
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoIn two words: Vladislav Surkov.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agois that the guy in the Adam Curtis docs?
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoYep.
- goatsneez 5y agoIn a hope this to be an impulse to hear some good opinions. I would say, after reading the comments here, that an echo chamber has emerged reacting to this title. Trump and all other leaders (who have not yet or never will be voted in, but are popular nonetheless with 1/4 to 1/2 roughly of population) are legitimately demanded. Is it that all commenters feel the other people's opinions that lead them to cast votes to this "unpopular" political figures are wrong, or misguided, or? Is there no populism left, right and center? Who is not populist and according to which set of criteria can (is) this objectively determined?
- csours 5y agoI've noticed that people really want to feel righteous; particularly about their political choices. This leads to an arms race where each point of view must be backed up by a theory of righteousness or morality. This leads to situations where some people cannot even say the phrase "Black Lives Matter", and where "Wokeness" is a crisis. Every crisis must have a counter crisis. I don't think this is particularly new, but I think social media has magnified the personal impact. I don't think that "both sides" thinking is relevant or helpful; I do think that stories of personal experience based on shared principles can help. Among other things, strong partisan divisions are currently a winning way to raise money.
- zozbot234 5y ago> This leads to situations where some people cannot even say the phrase "Black Lives Matter" What? People say it all the time. If anything, you get argued with if you try to say "Black Lives Matter, but Non-Black Lives Just Might Matter Too", and it's hard to describe that as anything but an arms race of self-righteousness.
- throw8932894 5y ago"world" did not went anywhere. Most countries are still normal and do not do politics over Twitter.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoNot really hyper-politics, virtually hyper-politics. Practically, IRL, people are not acting politically very much. Not more than 15 years ago around me at least. And certainly not the ones that are screaming on the internet. Anecdotally, those who are politically active in my circle (choosing what they buy, protesting, helping a category of living beings, writing to politicians) are actually not active on social media. They don't have time or energy for that, so they prioritize. If you don't know them, you don't know about what they do. So there is a lot of political outrage, virtue signaling, pavlov reacting and tribalism. But I don't think in reality people are hyper politics. They talk a lot of about the fashionable rant du jour, but have no dept, and it's not followed by actions. The article is mentioning that medias are becoming hyper politics, and on that I can agree. Social medias, but even sites for fun like imgur. And the corporation world as well, because a temporary outrage can make people superficially act against them for a limited amount of time, which will impact trust. In an economy where value is decorelated from what you really do, an ephemeral spike can tank you. But on the long run, those same people will forget about everything quickly, and revert back to their old patterns. They are not politically commited, they are just being even more manipulated than before.
- spaniard89277 5y agoYou are right, but people can step into problems because if their political beliefs in their jobs. Or suddenly being passively forced into behaviours if they don't want to lose your job. I guess this is the case in the US for republicans, for what I read and the personal accounts I get. Some people are trying hard to get this into Spain too, with less success.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoThis has always been the case. If you tried to serve a black customer in many places in the MLK era, it would have been trouble for your job. In France, the big blue collar companies have on constant display political messages from the various left leaning CGT and Lutte Ouvrière. You may very well be pressured to join. I my clients companies at least, I don't see the trend going up or down. It's pretty much as political as it used to be.
- ksec 5y agoIf I could sum it up with two issues, it would be Economic Inequality and housing.
- chiefalchemist 5y ago> And yet, despite people being intensely politicised in all of these dimensions, I have to take issue with this and ask: Says who? Or where? The media - who rightfully should not be trusted - tells us we're all so polarized. And that's gospel? Are there extremes? And is it good for politicians and "journalists" to build narratives around them? Yes, of course. That aside, at least in the USA, the two party system - which is not required by the Constitution - leaves little grey area. You are either Red or Blue, or so you are told (by the parties and the politicians) it's that simple. (Hint: Often, no it's not.) Nothing is complicated. Nothing is nuanced. Just Red or Blue. That's silly. But rather than try to surface the finer points we are fed narrative after narrative of oversimplification. Don't talk. Don't discuss. Red or Blue. I'm not so sure about "intensely" (e.g., there were Obama voters who eventually voted for Trump), but we are definitely shortly encouraged to take a binary position in a non-binary reality.
- eric4smith 5y agoWhich is why it’s a perfect time to check out of national political issues. They don’t affect 99% or your lives anyway and the 1% that it does effect is tiny. Hopefully people will wake up and understand that what matters is your action in your own home and business - that has the most changes on your life. All the SJW stuff, BLM and all that stuff does not really change personal lives. And what improves the earth most of all is when your personal life improves - because it improves everyone else’s lives around you.
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoWhat if it eventually does affect you in real life? I.e vaccine and mask mandates, Misgendering law, abortion, defunding the police, etc.
- eric4smith 5y agoYou need a life.
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoI have a life. Maybe you need a backbone?
- denton-scratch 5y agoTribune is a centre-left ginger group within the UK Labour Party. As such, it's not surprising that they would rail against "horizontalism" and "movementism" (what's movementism?)
- pmyteh 5y agoThe Tribune Group (of MPs) is a centre-left ginger group. It's named after the magazine (indirectly; after an earlier and more left wing MPs group) but they don't control the magazine itself. The magazine is now owned by Jacobin, IIRC, and has a more left-wing editorial line than the MPs group.
- denton-scratch 5y agoThanks - I am now better informed!
- mattbrewsbytes 5y ago> Today everything is politics I attribute this to political parties and their media campaigns which includes sound bytes from interviews, jabs at each other via social media, etc. not just during election season. I think there is solid reasoning that the vast majority of the public doesn't differ on much, when it comes to policies, so the divisive politics are used to push people towards one party or another - at least here in our two party system in the US. The 1% donate/fund (via PAC's, etc.) the political candidates and expect legislation that will favor their interests/companies. It takes 10's of millions of dollars (maybe over $100 mil) to effectively run a campaign for some seats in Congress. Candidates aren't getting that amount from individual middle class donors. This isn't a conspiracy theory, its just how it works. The 1% and politicians don't want their status changed and use money to keep it going. The political divisiveness keeps the 60% of the people that are in the lowest financial brackets divided. I think the US is approaching a point where people (probably not software/startup people) are sick of the financial divide. Sick enough that they might get off their keyboard driven outrage. If they found common ground and united together, the 1% doesn't stand a chance. It doesn't take much effort for politicians to find issues to get people riled up about. Social media makes their job much easier too. That's why we see outrage and protests about masks, when that subsides as a divisive topic they will go back to old topics like guns, etc. What if there were protests about workers rights (i.e. healthcare, wage inequality, time off, etc.)?
- titannet 5y agoI would suggest that it is one form of politics becoming more and more professional. With help by professional staff politicians like Obama or Merkel have perfected the art of pleasing the majority most of the time while never taking any attackable position. One way to draw voters away from that is taking on "populist" positions. I have yet so see another way.
- HKH2 5y agoObama took many attackable positions, but he is neoliberal and so is most mainstream media.
- oofnik 5y ago> Questions of what people own and control are increasingly replaced by questions of who or what people are, replacing the clash of classes with the collaging of identities. This is the main issue as far as I'm concerned. What the author refers to as hyper-politics is basically the unfortunate and dangerous re-emergence of transcendental concerns into the strictly temporal mechanisms of 20th century political organization. This is extraordinarily concerning. For more on the emergence of contemporary hyper-politics from an American perspective, I found Joshua Mitchell's "American Awakening" particularly helpful.
- FuriouslyAdrift 5y agoAs power moved from local to national, perceptions became more import than realities.