6 ms·
I have felt since day 1 that "autopilot is better than the average driver!" is the most misleading fact/statistic in the industry. The "average driver" involve
by paxys 5y ago
I have felt since day 1 that "autopilot is better than the average driver!" is the most misleading fact/statistic in the industry.
The "average driver" involved in an accident includes drunk drivers, road ragers, habitual speeders, teenagers, people driving in bad conditions (rain, snow), people driving without sleep and several other risky groups that most people buying Teslas aren't part of. To be worth it, the car has to reduce my personal accident risk under the conditions I usually drive, otherwise I prefer to keep my own hands behind the wheel over handing over control to an algorithm.
- Xylakant 5y agoI think it's fair to compare to the average driver. You may be not average by virtue of not being a teenager and not driving drunk, but you're not magically immune to being run over or crashed into by one of those. So even if a hypothetical FSD capable car would not drive one yota better than you do, it cwould still make you safer by virtue of making the surrounding environment safer.
- paxys 5y agoSure the worst drivers out there utilizing assist tech like autopilot would benefit everyone, but data shows that they aren't the ones spending money on fancy cars. My comment was about me making a decision for myself. Plus in your hypothetical the autopilot can drive at least as well as me, which is also a big assumption and not something I believe with what I have seen so far.
- djanogo 5y agoIt can't be just any "average driver", they should be compared against "average driver" who just bought $40-50K NEW car.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> "average driver" who just bought $40-50K NEW car. Driver and buyer/owner are different things. Few teenagers ever buy a Tesla, but they certainly drive them. A car cannot only be safe in the hands of the rich initial buyer who lives in a nice climate. It must be safe in all the other people who that owner may let drive. It must also be safe for subsequent second and third owners, people who might not be wealthy enough to stay home when it rains or when the autopilot thinks conditions are too rough. (It was -35c on my drive to work this morning. Dark. Ice fog then blowing snow.)
- IshKebab 5y agoUhm, I don't know what insanely rich middle eastern country you're from but in most of the world teenagers do not generally drive Teslas!!
- sandworm101 5y agoHave you been to LA, SF, Vancouver or Denver? These are Teslas, not Ferraris. Lots of teenagers are driving their parent's tesla. Go look at any university parking lot and you will find plenty of 50,000$ cars.
- jeffbee 5y agoExactly right. The population has to be compared to people driving new Volvo S90 or M-B C300, cars that have IIHS fatality rates of zero.
- obmelvin 5y agoIf you are speaking about the safety features in a new car, then I won't disagree. However, if you are implying that those with a nice new car are somehow better drivers, more attentive drivers, or care more about their car then I would highly disagree. As someone who purchased a new car last year, and does greatly care about it, I'm routinely shocked by people and their clear disregard for their own vehicle. Reckless driving, texting while not even attempting to look, and the way people park their cars so close to you that they can't even get out* have all shocked me now that I'm paying more attention. * I have even stared at this guy struggling to get out of his fancy Jeep who opened his door into my car. I know this anecdotal, but all it takes is a few counter examples to show that car price etc does not have a super high correlation to how careful & considerate you are.
- heavyset_go 5y agoLook at the accident and fatality rates for drivers of luxury cars. They are much, much lower than the same rates for less expensive cars. In fact, if you break it down by vehicle model, there are several models with 0 fatalities at all.
- obmelvin 5y agoI'd be curious to see where you are able to find good data for that. To be honest, I haven't found data that shows a clear difference between luxury and non-luxury cars i.e. https://quotewizard.com/news/posts/most-accident-prone-cars https://quotewizard.com/news/posts/most-accident-prone-cars lists some luxury brands as having high rates - "Luxury sport car brands Infiniti, Lexus and Acura are among most accident-prone cars on the road." and if you look through this data from IIHS https://www.iihs.org/ratings/driver-death-rates-by-make-and-model https://www.iihs.org/ratings/driver-death-rates-by-make-and-... there are plenty of luxury cars with high death rates.
- cma 5y agoTesla's claim relied on inclusion of motorcycles one time, which seems super misleading and unfair.
- FireBeyond 5y agoMisleading, from a company that once (several days ago) claimed that they sold more cars in Australia than Camry's last year. Until someone pointed out that vehicle registration... disagreed. By nearly 30%. Then "Oops. We made a mistake and counted 3,000+ deliveries which haven't actually been, well, delivered." I hope they get spanked hard for that. Australia has very onerous "truth in advertising" laws.
- yumraj 5y agoGiven what I’ve been hearing/reading about autopilot I’m more worried about being hit by one of them than a human driver.
- rightbyte 5y agoNo. I'm not going to boast about how good of a driver I am (I am!!), but lets say I am a median driver. I would want a FSD to be better than a median driver. Not the average crash/mile stats that include all kinds of long tail idiots doing the most damage. * ... alcohol-impaired driving crashes, accounting for 28% of all traffic-related deaths in the United States. * Drugs other than alcohol (legal and illegal) are involved in about 16% of motor vehicle crashes. https://www.cdc.gov/transportationsafety/impaired_driving/impaired-drv_factsheet.html https://www.cdc.gov/transportationsafety/impaired_driving/im... So 44% intoxicated to some degree (unless the stats overlap). That number is not even including reckless drivers not driving under influence, teenagers that just got the license, bad health elderly etc.
- larksimian 5y agoMy problem is that the median driver is much much better than the mean driver and tesla os comparing against means. The damage done in a car distribution is heavily skewed towards people that get in fatal crashes or total a car. I'd randomly guess like 20-30% of drivers are below mean. Most people won't total a car, vast majority will never kill anyone. If you get median people into an autopilot car that's got a mean safety record we end up pulling the average down, the road becomes less safe. And luxury sedan buyers tend to be one of the safest demos on the road, which makes the problem even worse.
- xapata 5y agoMedian vs mean of what measure?
- ajross 5y ago> several other risky groups that most people buying Teslas aren't part of. This is a fallacy. Ask any demographic you like if they're road ragers, drunk drivers, etc... and they'll deny it. Everyone is sure that rare and terrible outcomes will never happen to them because of their own behavior, including the people to whom it happens! It's probably true that middle aged premium car owners are safer on average, but you don't get to rule that stuff out by fiat. In fact there have been a few "Autopilot Saves Passed Out Driver" stories over the past few months, where Tesla drivers were clearly impaired. As for this particular paper: this is just P-hacking folks. You can't take a vague dataset[1] and then "correct" it like this without absolutely huge error bars. Why correct based only these variables? Why did they all push the results in one direction? Why not gender? Why not income? Why not compare vs. like cars? This isn't good statistics, it's just more statistics. If we want the real answers we should get a better data set (which, I'll agree, would likely involve some regulatory pressure on manufacturers). [1] And, to be fair: Tesla's safety report is hardly comprehensive and provides no data other than the aggregate numbers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI just think a lot of Tesla drivers see themselves as elite drivers or something when we all know that's not true if you step back away from the situation.
- Majromax 5y ago> You can't take a vague dataset and then "correct" it like this without absolutely huge error bars. That ship has already sailed; Tesla makes active safety claims based on that dataset. To hold research to your standard here would be to say that Tesla can make its claims, but nobody can challenge those claims. > Why did they all push the results in one direction? If you have two correction steps, then a priori you'd expect a 25% chance that they both act in the same direction. I don't think this is very remarkable. > Why not gender? This probably would be a reasonable addition. I doubt it would change the results much, but we have the well-known fact that insurance rates differ for men and women, so it may be relevant. > Why not income? First, is this data even generally available? If the data doesn't exist, then we can't control for it. Second, should we expect crash rates per mile driven to differ greatly by owner/driver income? A priori, I wouldn't think this demographic quality to have a strong impact. > Why not compare vs. like cars? I think "personal vehicle" is a reasonable comparative category. Would we expect collision rates to differ greatly between more specific categorizations? For the sake of the overall conclusion, would we expect Tesla-equivalents to be particularly crash prone in the broad dataset? Any statistical analysis will have its limitations, but when we're talking about life-safety claims from a manufacturer I think we should have wide latitude to look at critical evaluations of the original data.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stjohnswarts 5y agoSo basically everyone in a car? :)
- mrtksn 5y agoIf I remember correctly, they also cover the easy part of the road and make the human take over at tricky situations. So at the end of the day, you have spotless records for the autopilot that was driving many many miles on the straight line and humans having accidents at short intersections or construction sites. This translates into very favorable numbers for autopilot when presented as accidents per miles driven.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoIf it were the case that autopilot was benefiting from dumping all of the difficult parts on the humans, you would expect to see much higher than average rates of accidents per mile on the human driven parts, because they're only getting the hard parts. This tends not to be true, so I'm doubting it's a real effect.
- mrtksn 5y agoHumans don’t disengage and let the machines handle the situation but machines do it all the time. Do the machines disengage at tricky situations or straight lines?
- spywaregorilla 5y agoThe statistics are there to read however, and suggest your reasoning is not correct. Case A: Non Tesla Human drives 999 easy miles and 1 hard mile Case B: Autopilot drives 999 easy miles, and human drives 1 hard mile If the effect size of the hard mile is so large that its skewing the statistics, you would expect the Telsa human driver to have a horrendous per mile accident rate relative to the non tesla human driver. What's most likely is that the accidents following a human handoff get correctly allocated to the Autopilot and the effect size being described is not actually that significant.
- mrtksn 5y agostats for easy miles and hard miles? link please? Humans don’t crash at every tricky situation but Tesla claims that humans are horrible drivers and their cars gives the control to the humans when when something happens.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoSo how much better than the median randomly assigned uber driver does it need to be?
- jjulius 5y agoI don't disagree with your broader statement about autopilot's safety relative to other drivers, but... >The "average driver" involved in an accident includes drunk drivers, road ragers, habitual speeders, teenagers, people driving in bad conditions (rain, snow), people driving without sleep and several other risky groups that most people buying Teslas aren't part of. ... what? Tesla owners absolutely can be habitual speeders, people who drive without sleep, road ragers, and drunk drivers. Can you please explain your thought process behind this claim? I really don't understand why anyone would assume that Tesla owners are less likely to have those traits than non-Tesla owners.
- vletal 5y agoYeah, seems like a typo a GPT-3 would do. The claim seems to be that Teslas do not drink before driving, not Tesla owners, right?
- w-j-w 5y ago
- sudosysgen 5y agoBecause they are buying an expensive, new car, meaning higher income, meaning that those things are less likely : https://academic.oup.com/alcalc/article/46/6/721/129644 https://academic.oup.com/alcalc/article/46/6/721/129644
- capableweb 5y agoIn my person experience, the "drunk drivers", "road ragers", "habitual speeders" groups seems to be over-represented in expensive cars rather than cheaper cars. Poor people cannot afford to crash their car while rich people can.
- paxys 5y agoData released by the DOL and insurance companies does not match with your personal experience. There's a reason 18 year olds driving shitty cars pay through their nose for liability coverage.
- beambot 5y agoConfounding factors matter. E.g. I would not be at all surprised if drivers of high-end BMWs have lower deaths per mile due to older population, more affluent, etc.
- FireBeyond 5y agoHuh. Citation needed that drivers who buy, say, a Model S, particularly one with Ludicrous mode are less likely to be "habitual speeders" than the average driver. This has come up before. When the new FSD beta started, people started claiming that safe driving was a function of vehicle price, and therefore Tesla drivers, especially those who had paid for FSD, were more likely to be safer. When I noted that my current vehicle costs more than a Model S, based on the logic, Tesla should be recruiting me to beta test FSD, well it was hard to find a refutation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tshaddox 5y agoBut that's not really contradictory, is it? If you believe that you're a better driver than autopilot, just don't use it, or buy another car. It's not at all dishonest or deceptive marketing (if the claim is factually accurate, of course).
- llamataboot 5y agoI agree with this, and have also been accused of being a Tesla hater, but OTOH someone has to pave the way for the future in which none of /those/ people have to drive either, and our cities aren't taken over by surface parking for cars that move two or three times a day at most. If we're not gonna switch to sane urban planning, may as well bring on the robo-taxis that can go anywhere
- sgustard 5y agoIn my case, I'm happy to engage Autopilot even though I'm under no illusion that it makes me safer. It's just a very useful convenience feature. OTOH: Tesla could still claim that if you replace all the distracted/drunk drivers in beat-up cars with new Teslas running Autopilot, the roads would be safer.
- faeyanpiraat 5y agoI've been using taxis in my city for like 50 times, and I've never even felt remotely in danger, except when I was in a Tesla taxi. The driver were well composed, calm and seemed rational, but we've had 5 (!) near crash situations in a 15 minute drive, simply because the car can accelerate into spots opening up in moderately dense traffic so quickly that nobody can expect it. The car enables a completely novel driving style which people need getting used to.