9 ms·
Yemen's bifurcated monetary system
- Guthur 5y agoAnd this is inflation illustrated. When they talk about inflation being a rise in prices they are talking bullshit it is simply that they created more fiat currency and so devalued what was there before, as perfectly illustrated. The importance of this distinction is that when your currency devalues its because the goverment (central bank branch thereof) consciously choose to print more and devalue it for you.
- pavlov 5y agoThere are other causes of inflation, and a commodity-based currency makes it harder to control. You can see this in action in the historical inflation chart for the pound sterling (GBP), where data is available since 1750: https://www.in2013dollars.com/UK-inflation https://www.in2013dollars.com/UK-inflation The gold standard was suspended in 1931. You can see wild swings between inflation and deflation before that year (with an overall trend towards inflation, as the pound did lose value over the centuries). Most economists believe steady low inflation is preferable.
- aftbit 5y agoHowever most of the inflation that happened to the GBP between 1750 and 2022 happened in the last 100 years. £100 in 1750 was worth £400 in 1922 and £24000 in 2022. That's 4x in 172 years vs 60x in only 100 years.
- pavlov 5y agoI think the WWI experience soured the British political class on the gold standard: wild inflation during the war, followed by serious deflation when it was time to rebuild. The swing is impressive in that buying power chart. Also, I'm sure the average British voter likes what has been achieved in the past hundred years and prefers inflation to having no money in a rigid class society.
- notahacker 5y agoYep. Having 15% inflation cancelled out by 15% deflation is superior to relatively consistent 2% inflation for rich people who don't need to spend their money, and prefer to preserve their wealth over decades without risking investing it in something productive. It's not for people who can afford 15% less food that year, or people trying to invest money in actual businesses.
- overtomanu 5y agoeven the northern rial inflated because the dollar inflated. but i think theres no doubt that money printing did cause inflation
- dang 5y ago"Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html The more generic topics tend to be more predictable, and they also tend to suck the smaller, more specific topics in like black holes. The result is repetitive discussion about the same few things, which is bad for curious conversation. Past explanations: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=generic%20discussion%20by%3Adang%20-flamewars%20-flamewar&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20black%20hole%20-pigment&sort=byDate&type=story&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- hammock 5y agoThere is something missing in this story, which is the unified Houthi resolve to not accept post-2016 bank notes. And that resolve is not without cost - one example being the awareness campaign around serial numbers, and I'm sure there are many others. Without that resolve, the money is "fungible" again. If the same thing were to be tried in the US, you'd have to have everyone in a given region (say, Florida) agree that only pre-2022 dollars would be accepted, or else it wouldn't work - all the money would still be fungible. And they'd have to have a reason to do that. The widespread availability of inter-regional ecommerce makes it even more complicated, because what would really stop a Floridian from taking advantage of that? What are you going to do, stop trucks at the Florida border and make them show proof that the bill of sale was paid in pre-2022 dollars? Also, obviously, only works in a cash-based society. There are no serial numbers on the dollars in your checking account.
- aeternum 5y agoEven a subset of merchants is enough to produce an effect. I've been to a few countries in which many merchants will accept USD but only notes in good condition as the banks give them a hard time if the bills are torn or marked up. Some merchants would trade the marked up/torn USD at a discount to face value while others would simply refuse to accept those bills. The interesting thing was how quickly I too considered the torn bills less valuable even though I could easily take them back to the US where they were completely fungible.
- notch656a 5y agoSounds like a good opportunity for someone to buy up bills from these money changers at a discount and then perform some international arbitrage.
- notahacker 5y agoEven as someone who once got asked to name my own exchange rate if I could swap rupees for some British currency the local kids had begged for their "coin collection", I don't think there's much profit in moving damaged banknotes from Myanmar to the US (or even Cambodia)! Damaged dollars naturally find their way into the hands of tourists who won't have difficulty spending or exchanging them when they leave the country
- cryptica 5y agoThis is the clearest evidence we have of a government trying to sabotage the monetary system of a country to steal the proceeds of its citizens' labor via inflation. Thankfully for some citizens of Yemen, they can opt out of being exploited by choosing their salaries to be denominated in and paid with 'Old Rial' currency.
- Sporktacular 5y agoInteresting but doesn't mention that the deliberateness of the effort by KSA/UAE to devalue the YER as an economic weapon so as to destabilise the Houthi control of the North. The result has been widely reported, and avoidable, economic famine and loss of life savings, as well as a mildly increased, but ineffective, pressure on the Houthi administration. The effort to ever more closely approximate the older notes is going to continue for this callous reason, more so than the South's purchasing power reason given, which would only make sense in the presence of large trade flows with the North anyway.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoInteresting piece but I found the chart confusing. I don't know how you would do it better but the way the chart was done suggested to my mind that the devalued notes has actually gone up in value and I only sorted it out by reading the explanation very carefully -- that the "going up" green line actually represents "It takes more of these to get a dollar than it used to."
- WalterBright 5y agoOnce again, we get a lesson in the true cause of inflation. No, it is not supply chain issues, profiteers, speculators, wage-price spirals, energy prices, etc. It's simply an excess of money created by the government, so the government can spend money without raising taxes.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI had a similar thought. Like when Spain imported so much silver from the Americas and prices went up. If supply of goods and services stays stable while money supply increases, the result is price increases. I don't know why this seems so hard for some people to understand.
- WalterBright 5y agoPeople don't understand because they don't want to understand. Biden is just the latest President in a long line since Wilson who doesn't want to admit what causes inflation, because that would mean their spending policies are to blame. It's better to blame everything else.
- notch656a 5y agoSame story everywhere. Fixing inflation is a long and painful process; more so the worse inflation already is. There's no way inflation can be unwound in one election cycle without popping asset prices. No politician is gonna want to unwind this in a timely manner because it will mean their certain downfall (and by the time we see the payoff, in several years, people will have already forgotten the fiscally responsible steps taken by the politicians which initially looked painful).
- zamadatix 5y agoI think that's obvious as well but only because you specified "goods and services stays stable" whereas the parent comment specified they were irrelevant. There is more than one cause of inflation, it has to do with the ratio between the quantity of goods/services and the quantity of money not just the value of one or the other. Lately I think the majority has been due to the money supply changing but that doesn't make all of the other factors false causes that didn't contribute.
- RobertoG 5y agofrom: https://sanaacenter.org/publications/analysis/8674 https://sanaacenter.org/publications/analysis/8674 "The Sana’a-based branch continued to operate under Houthi control, having kept the vast majority of the central bank’s staff, informational archives and purview over Houthi-held areas, which include the country’s largest population centers, commercial markets, and business and financial hubs." So, you split the country in two, one with "the largest population centers, commercial markets and business and financial hubs" but the loss of value of the currency is because the poorer side print more notes. I suppose that when you have a hammer everything looks like a nail, and when you have a website about "sound money" everything supports your theories.
- refulgentis 5y agoThe article doesn't say that, thankfully, I was looking for that error as well: they carefully note that its because one side has a fixed money supply, the other does not.
- aatharuv 5y agoThis is the exact same thing that happened in Iraq after the first Gulf War back in 1991. The northern part of the country, defacto-ruled by the Kurds had their own version of the Iraqi dinar, known as the Swiss dinar, as it had been printed by a Swiss bank note printer. Due to the sanctions the central Iraqi government had to resort to locally printed bank notes of poorer quality for new notes. However, these notes couldn't reach Iraqi Kurdistan which had a fixed money supply. The Swiss dinar was soon worth 150 of the new Iraqi dinars. Both of these have since been demonetized and replaced with a unified Iraqi-dinar, after the toppling of Saddam's government.
- RobertoG 5y agoWell, following this view, I suppose that there is not point in sanctioning Russia as they are threatening them, as sanctions can't cause inflation.
- aatharuv 5y agoSanctions can certainly cause inflation. They just cause less inflation if the government (Iraqi Kurdistan) isn't printing any more paper, or more inflation if the government (the rest of Iraq) decided to print its way out of debts. And sanctions can certainly cause inflation if it becomes more expensive to import goods (or make them locally instead).
- RobertoG 5y agoBut what if it's the other way around? What if, because sanctions or war or whatever causes inflation, governments, in order to avoid the worse outcome of what would happen if they stop working totally, have to create more money. Then, inflation is what creates money, not the other way around, and the narrative should be a very different one.
- Laforet 5y agoRussia had double digit inflation rate in 2015 after sanctions over Ukraine came into effect. It was only kept below 5% through a combination of devaluation, austerity and high interest rates, all of which have ramifications. Americans love to complain about their 7% inflation rate in 2021, and that is just about the average in Russia over the past couple of decades.
- LatteLazy 5y agoI thought one of the issues the confederacy had was that as it shrunk geographically, the money supply remained the same, and you got high inflation without even being able run the usual deficits...
- einpoklum 5y agoLet's remember that Yemen is under effective blockade by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia with the US and gulf allies; and that people are starving and dying because of this fact - in addition to the bombardment of civilian targets, and civilians, by KSA. And this was the case already 4 years ago, see: https://www.dw.com/en/yemen-is-the-biggest-humanitarian-disaster-in-the-world/a-46622229 https://www.dw.com/en/yemen-is-the-biggest-humanitarian-disa... and some recent UNHCR info: https://www.unhcr.org/yemen-emergency.html https://www.unhcr.org/yemen-emergency.html so, with respect to the interesting financial situation - bear that in mind.
- shmerl 5y agoSo how do they get ballistic missiles during the blockade?
- bane 5y agoThere's a different, but very funny story involving another currency, the Maria Theresa Thaler of 1780 (MTT). It was originally struck during the reign of Maria Theresa over the Austro-Hungarian empire from 1740-1780 -- the year of her death. However, it became a major trade currency during her lifetime and the MTT (specifically ones with 1780 on them) became accepted throughout various parts of the world even until today. The funny thing is, millions of MTTs have been minted up through the 20th century (some estimates put it near a billion coins). They have slight variations, depending on minting details and a few other odds and ends. As a result, MTTs dated 1780 are the only ones accepted. For many years they were also heavily counterfeited creating a major oversupply of them, but also since various countries have continued to produce them conflating what a "counterfeit" is with actual money (the value is mostly in the metals, and counterfeits will use cheaper materials). They're fun for collectors to pickup, and they're usually worth about the $20 or so the metals in them are worth. https://britanniacoincompany.com/blog/the-maria-theresa-thaler/ https://britanniacoincompany.com/blog/the-maria-theresa-thal... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maria_Theresa_thaler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maria_Theresa_thaler https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2380057.m570.l1311&_nkw=maria+teresa+thaler&_sacat=0 https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2380057.m...
- sbayona573 5y agoOne extrapolation is: this is what is happening with Bitcoin and the US Dollar. Got to do some mental gymnastics but it makes sense.
- james-redwood 5y agoIn Zimbabwe most merchants accept a variety of currencies: namely American dollars, Botswanan Pula, South African rands, and the new Zimbabwean dollar. There are of course more that are accepted. I’ve gotten away on more than one occasion using Euros and pounds. It leads to a gigantic forex black market and pain all around in rather unexpected ways.
- johnnyApplePRNG 5y agoPlease do go on.