7 ms·
> This is a GREAT one: “As a white man, I’d ask what they’ve done to find qualified women and minorities for the role I’m interviewing for.” I can't help but f
by bawolff 5y ago
> This is a GREAT one: “As a white man, I’d ask what they’ve done to find qualified women and minorities for the role I’m interviewing for.”
I can't help but feel that asking questions during an interview that encourage the interviewer to hire someone who is not you, is a bad strategy for actually getting the job.
- gear54rus 5y agoYeah this one works both ways all to well haha. Mah boi probably realizes it too and that's why he's asking it.
- loudtieblahblah 5y ago
- Juliate 5y agoGetting _the_ job, not necessarily. Getting a job in a decent and self-aware team, on the other hand, yes, that's a good strategy. The question is both a direct and an indirect one.
- grammarnazzzi 5y agoA decent and self-aware work team is one who treats each other as equals and respect and keeps their political beliefs outside the work environment. An iterviewee who brings race into the discussion clearly doesn't understand work/personal boundries and is going to be a liability.
- beebeepka 5y agoThat makes sense to me. Discussing non work related politics with coworkers seems like a bad idea. No idea why that was downvoted. I had a weird interview last year. After about 30 minutes talk, the guy started shifting to politics and expressing his ideas about Europe, the UK, refugees, etc. I didn't want the job anyway so I told him that I don't agree with his (barely contained) right wing opinions. He immediately told me that things are not going to work, and I agreed. Having early 20 somethings doing interviews alone is asking for trouble. Talking about politics during an interview strikes me as a recipe for disaster by creating a highly homogeneous environment. I like variety
- Juliate 5y agoDiversity in the workplace is a work issue. If that’s political, well, work _is_ political too (and even work organization becomes quickly political).
- grammarnazzzi 5y agoOnly if diversity is relevant to whatever value the business is providing or it's mission. Healthy work issues are centered around whatever's going to help the company succeed. People want coworkers who produce and are positive. It affects everybody's livelihood.
- Juliate 5y agoDiversity is always relevant in business, as business is a part of society, which itself is very much diverse. That's the whole point. Cutting oneself out of society, being a person or a group, has never been a good idea in the long run.
- Juliate 5y ago1. Being self aware does not mean that you’re good but that you know where you can improve. 2. That’s precisely the (indirect) point. An interviewee that brings this question WANTS to be seen as a liability by a team/manager that understand the question as a “outside-of-work-boundaries-political-belief, and WANTS to understand how a diverse team articulates the answer.
- danaris 5y agoSorry, the work environment is inherently political these days. I'll "keep my political beliefs outside the work environment" when it's no longer political to say that - Women, queer people, and minorities should be hired, treated, and paid the same as straight cis white men - Abusive and exploitative treatment of workers is unacceptable - Every human being deserves to be treated with dignity and respect, regardless of where they are on a corporate org chart You say people should "keep their political beliefs outside the work environment" as if the managers, directors, C-suite, etc aren't imposing their political beliefs on us every moment of every day.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wreath 5y ago> - Women, queer people, and minorities should be hired, treated, and paid the same as straight cis white men No they should not. They should be paid similar to someone with similar work experience, skills, potential and likability. It has nothing to do with someone's skin color or sexual orientation.
- Juliate 5y agoYour statement does not contradict parent.
- wreath 5y agoYou misunderstood one of the two statements.
- Juliate 5y agoOr, you don’t understand from your perspective how the two are not contradictory. Unless, there’s something unexpressed in either of those. For instance, a more or less official/understood work policy not being effectively equal regarding skills, in hiring, because of (un)acknowledged bias. Or, an understated motive to do more than only fair hiring or affirmative action to counter a acknowledged bias in hiring.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y agoHave the people in this thread ever actually interviewed and hired people in the last decade? It's a super softball question that gives that gives the interviewer a chance to brag about any small advancements they've recently made. In 2022, if a hiring manager didn't have a decent response to this question locked and loaded, it would be a super red flag.
- awakeasleep 5y agoThis is a shibboleth virtue signal. Neither side takes it at face value
- WithinReason 5y agoI wonder if we're headed to a point where this kind of self-selection basically creates companies consisting of either people who are all about DEI, or people who only care about skills/qualification, then the market will decide which one is the winning strategy.
- gray_-_wolf 5y agoThe DEI people seem to me like they have a tendency to try to enforce their view via legislation. So I'm skeptical about the "market will decide" part.
- gray_-_wolf 5y agoCould someone comment on the down votes? The legislation is happening already, so I'm not sure why this is so controversial.
- late2part 5y agoI didn't downvote you but I'll have a go. The rabid activists who are pushing their agenda of mandated quotas for special interest groups do not like it when you or others like you suggest logic and rational things that don't support their agenda. Hence, the downvote. More goodthink, citizen!
- WithinReason 5y agoMaybe in the US, but then in comes down to competition with China
- stjohnswarts 5y agoReally like a lot of things, it's both.
- peakaboo 5y agoDiversity has nothing to do with company culture being good or bad in most cases. Example: Let's say the company has 100 employees and 90 of them are white and 10 of them are black. As a white engineer, it won't help you if they invite more black people to work there. It's much harder to know if 90% of them are assholes and diversity will never help with that.
- bawolff 5y agoIn my experience it can be a bit of a canary. People who are assholes tend to be extra-assholey to out-groups (which often is minorities). If members of minority groups don't want to work somewhere it usually means that the people who work there are assholes.
- bequanna 5y agoMaybe you didn’t intend it this way, but your statement is pretty much the default liberal argument of the past several years: “everyone who does or says something I don’t like is racist.” As a result, calling someone “racist” has pretty much lost all meaning.
- peakaboo 5y agoI know this is the classic thinking about these things. But working in a company where they keep bringing in new employees that are rude (the "strong woman" template), it has given me something to think about. It's just not a given that reducing out-groups makes a company culture better. It can make it worse to include those groups sometimes. It's just hard to know before. But it's morally right to not exclude people so I'm of course supporting that. Just saying it may not be a sign of a good culture even though we may think it is.
- bigbillheck 5y ago> keep bringing in new employees that are rude (the "strong woman" template), I've been working professionally for decades and I don't think I've seen this 'template' at all. And to be honest I'm wondering if this is a case of the 'same behavior is perceived as ruder in women than in men' effect.
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoYup this is “what the hell” for me. I’m Asian
- stirfish 5y agoSame, "what the hell", then I followed the link to twitter to see if it was a joke or troll, then another "what the hell" I'm black
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoMy brother from another mother!!! Welcome!
- throwaway058527 5y ago
- ianai 5y agoIt reads as outright deranged in your quote.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- remram 5y agoIf you're already interviewing, they are unlikely to restart the whole process based on that question, they will answer it and keep going.
- wobbleblob 5y agoWhy? I bring that up in every job interview. None of them have ever found it objectionable. In my experience, except for some startups, it's something every company in tech is at least thinking about. As an industry we are wasting so much potential. How many great candidates end up not interviewing with you when they see your entire tech staff consists of white and asian men aged 25-35?
- AwaAwa 5y agoAs a visible minority, any such policy has me running for the hills. I'd like to be considered for my skill, because I know that I'll be working with people of a similar cut. Granted its an archaic notion. Checking out from work, and checking in to DEI is probably a more financially successful endeavor.
- sershe 5y agoI think it's a GREAT one; if the company engages in practices that are borderline illegal and immoral (considered so even by their supposed beneficiaries [1], and rejected by one of the most left-wing states [2]), it's probably a toxic place to work. The entire DEI industry belongs to Golgafrincham Ark Fleet Ship B. It's good to know in advance if a company is taken over by this malignant growth. [1] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/02/25/most-americans-say-colleges-should-not-consider-race-or-ethnicity-in-admissions/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/02/25/most-americ... [2] https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_16,_Repeal_Proposition_209_Affirmative_Action_Amendment_(2020) https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_16,_Repeal_Pr...
- stjohnswarts 5y agoThis would definitely be a bad sign for me during an interview, I would say "next" pretty quickly. I have enough to deal with at work I don't need a social warrior that is more worried about the woke twitterati rantings than helping me get next week's bucket of issues done.
- q1w2 5y agoNot only that, asking this question is a red-flag for the company to disqualify you. Employees who are obsessed with diversity and social justice often create toxic environments and can even be a legal or security liability to the company.
- xboxnolifes 5y agoThat's the point. If the question led you to not get the job, it's not a job you would want in the first place.