4 ms·
I like this trend of cancel-culture people cancelling themselves instead of others.
by josephcsible 5y ago
I like this trend of cancel-culture people cancelling themselves instead of others.
- sharken 5y agoMakes me want to cancel Neil Young for a good while, even though he makes great music. The Corona vaccine works well, but being critical of the vaccine is a healthy thing. Thankfully we are moving towards treating the flu and Corona virus the same way. Omicron has made that transition a lot easier.
- josephcsible 5y ago> Makes me want to cancel Neil Young for a good while, even though he makes great music. If you do this, you've stooped to their level. Don't do this. Be better than them.
- sharken 5y agoYou are quite right of course, i do think Neil Young is making a big mistake here. Am looking forward to seeing a lot less COVID stories, there are bigger issues that humanity needs to deal with.
- MisterSandman 5y agoI understand that view, but Joe Rogan did a lot more than just criticise the vaccine.
- dekhn 5y agoThe problem is that joe rogan is actively undermining the public health mission, not that he is being intellgently critical of vaccines in a healthy way.
- peteradio 5y agoThe public health mission did an end-run around public discourse. The turbulence caused by that is absolutely the fault of the public health authority.
- kova12 5y agoFor a worthy cause people were willing to give their lives. A couple of naysayers can not affect it in any meaningful way. If you can undermine a mission with one measly podcast, that might mean your mission is not in a good place to begin with. Rogan routinely hosts people with very diverse views. Why wouldn't NY and JM go to Rogan's program and debate him? Why don't YOU go to his program and debate him if you are so certain you have a strong position? If you ask me, I'd say it's very sus, almost like they know they got nothing to say
- chrismcb 5y agoWhat is the public health mission and how is Rogan undermining it?
- meowtimemania 5y agoIf enough artists that I listen to leave Spotify, I would begrudgingly cancel my subscription and follow them to a different platform. I hope that doesn’t happen but imagine if Taylor Swift removes herself from spotify again :/
- vnchr 5y agoI’d just shake it off, shake it off.
- capguy255 5y agoI like this trend of cancel-"cancel culture" activists attempting to compel speech and showing their hand that this was never really about "free speech."
- josephcsible 5y agoImagine that a private company bought an entire city. Should we take away people's right to protest in that city, since doing otherwise would be compelling speech by the company?
- api 5y agoI like this trend of conservatives discovering the concept of monopoly and advocating anti-trust. Of course I assume this will only apply to narrow issues such as right wingers being deplatformed. For any other issue they'll go back to a maximalist interpretation of corporate property rights.
- josephcsible 5y ago> Of course I assume this will only apply to narrow issues such as right wingers being deplatformed. This argument goes both ways. Don't most people who think Big Tech should be allowed to keep censoring people because of the First Amendment, also think that the First Amendment shouldn't apply to corporations when it comes to Citizens United?
- api 5y agoPerhaps but it's a bit more complicated. Citizens United is more about money than speech per se. You can't prevent members of corporations from speaking whatever they want as they are people, but corporations acting as corporations can bankroll political campaigns and push propaganda in ways very few individuals can afford. It gets even worse when you consider that many corporations are international entities whose interests may not be aligned at all with those of US voters. It's a bit like letting people overseas come into the US and contribute to campaigns and run political ads without limit. In fact it more or less allows this since it's trivial for a foreign individual (or state actor) to use a corporation as a front. Personally I think Citizens United is a threat to national security. If we were still in the Cold War you'd have the USSR contributing hundreds of millions of dollars to PACs and DC think tanks after laundering it through byzantine financial relationships with US front companies. I'm just referring to the hypocrisy of right wingers suddenly discovering the issues with monopolies (and narrow oligopolies) when it affects them. You'd be hearing nothing about big tech from the right if they hadn't deplatformed people on the right.
- electrondood 5y ago"cancel culture" is a dumb euphemism for "consequences for your actions." If you use your soapbox to cause harm to others, people are free do decide how to respond to you and vote with their IP and money.
- icare_1er 5y agoDoes not really apply to woke-mobs bringing down statues or burning books.
- josephcsible 5y ago> "cancel culture" is a dumb euphemism for "consequences for your actions." If by "actions" you mean "saying things you disagree with" and by "consequences" you mean "trying your hardest to permanently deprive them of their livelihood", then sure.
- krapp 5y agoBeing banned from a service is not an attempt to permanently deprive anyone of their livelihood. No one has ever starved to death in the street because their Twitter account was closed.
- josephcsible 5y agoCancel culture is more than just getting people banned from Twitter. Consider this example of when the cancel mob got somebody fired, and then when he found another company that was willing to hire him, the mob immediately turned on it: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-20/vmware-staff-blast-hire-of-ex-aws-executive-who-had-faced-probe https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-20/vmware-st...
- krapp 5y agoAnd now he's destitute and living under a park bench, a pariah shunned by society? He seems to be doing just fine. The article you posted doesn't even say his new employers refused to hire him because of "the mob." You're not exactly proving cancel culture to be the life-destroying force you made it out to be earlier.