7 ms·
This appears to be the synthetic jet fuel from Virent. It is made from light carbohydrates and other small organic molecules by their "Bioforming" process. Th
by pfdietz 5y ago
This appears to be the synthetic jet fuel from Virent. It is made from light carbohydrates and other small organic molecules by their "Bioforming" process. This removes oxygen from the molecules by reaction in solution with hydrogen gas and a ruthenium catalyst. The resulting hydrocarbon molecules are then put through a reforming process where they are linked together and isomerized to get the right distribution of molecular weights.
I've followed this process for a while. It yields more energy than ordinary biomass approaches, since it can also incorporate the energy of the hydrogen input stream. This is good, because biomass has terrible efficiency at conversion of sunlight to fuel. No CO2 need be produced; the oxygen is carried away as water. One can think of the biomass as more of a carbon source than (just) an energy source. It also tolerates a wider variety of input molecules than enzyme-based approaches.
https://www.virent.com/products/jet-fuel/ https://www.virent.com/products/jet-fuel/
https://www.virent.com/technology/bioforming/ https://www.virent.com/technology/bioforming/
- hbarka 5y agoI saw this news while on a public place watching NHK Newsline. Interestingly I couldn’t find it on Google search under News or All. The very interesting part is that the feed stock used to make the liquid fuel comes from common garbage waste. Have we finally found a place for the tons of household garbage we generate? The company cited as the supplier was Fulcrum Bioenergy in Reno Nevada. https://fulcrum-bioenergy.com/ https://fulcrum-bioenergy.com/
- Reason077 5y ago> ”Have we finally found a place for the tons of household garbage we generate?” Fossil-derived plastics make up a significant portion of household waste. From a climate perspective, it might actually be better to bury plastics in landfills rather than burn them as fuel.
- usrusr 5y agoThe mirror argument is that from a climate perspective, as long as we are still burning low energy-per-co2 fossils like lignite for energy (spot the embarrassed German) it might be a net reduction if we burn those high energy future landfills instead. Plastics are very useful, perhaps we should consider it wasteful to leave any well-to-atmosphere paths where the carbon did not go through a stage of making itself useful as plastics? Hard to find any numbers, because the CO2/MWh stats of incineration plants always contain a considerable fraction of renewable on the input and that would have to be removed from the equation an all sides (input, CO2 output, energy output) for a useful answer. I'm not enough of a chemist, but I suspect that the process the article is about could also habe potential for the creation of raw materials from bio stocks for plucking into the conventional plastics pipeline? This, combined with landfills (instead of incineration/highly processed incineration) could end up being the most viable carbon capture approach: instead of jumping through hoops trying to capture for the sake of it, it would harness our insatiable demand for plastics consumption. Are there any plant-based plastics already that don't don't with the friendly "degradable" label?
- regularfry 5y agoProbably the most common plant-based plastic is PLA. Or at least, that's the one I come across most often. While technically it's compostable, you need an industrial composting process to do it. It's not something you can just throw in the ground and dig up as usable soil a year later. And it's entirely possible that there would be ecosystem-unfriendly additives in it unless you were careful. This runs the same risk as we currently see with recycling: because it all happens behind closed doors, the door's wide open for the worst sorts of environmental fraud where the claimed process actually only happens on a small fraction of the input, and the rest is just dumped. We really need plastics that can be broken down at the home level so people can take ownership of the process directly.
- regularfry 5y agoThere's a reasonable argument that turning them to biochar would enable us to enrinch soil enough to make it globally more efficient at capturing carbon. That would do both: the carbon in the plastics gets captured, and a carbon capture mechanism gets boosted. The thing you've got to remember about plastics though is that only a relatively small fraction of the carbon involved in producing a lump of plastic is actually in the plastic itself. The production process emits a lot more. If what you end up doing is creating a demand for more raw plastic to be produced, that's a massive net loss.
- throwawayboise 5y agoIf it works as jet fuel it should also work as diesel fuel, as jet fuel is bascially high-grade diesel. That could be a benefit to railroads and long-haul trucking where batteries are not practical, as well as passenger cars, since the fuel delivery infrastructure is already well established.
- adrianN 5y agoIt's unlikely that a process that needs biomass as input scales to all the applications you listed.
- kadoban 5y agoIt depends. Small organisms can potentially scale really well. If yeast, bacteria or algae can do what you want, you have at least some hope of scaling that up arbitrarily.
- aunty_helen 5y agoThere's a problem with microorganisms that can live in diesel. That is, they can live and grow in diesel. https://www.google.com/search?q=diesel+bug https://www.google.com/search?q=diesel+bug
- kadoban 5y agoI think the idea is the microorganism you output some precursor(s) that you'd then process. If not, I guess you could pasteurize whatever it is, after filtering and such. Doesn't seem like it should be too much of a problem.
- regularfry 5y agoThis is the problem algae farms all run headlong into: sunlight density. The energy output you get from doing anything with the biomass can't exceed the received sunlight energy times the photosynthetic efficiency of your microorganisms. And that efficiency might not be as good as solar cells. The way this process does an end-run round that with added hydrogen is interesting, though.
- geenew 5y agoCould you clarify: is this a replacement for traditional hydrocarbon based co2 producing fuels that does not produce co2 gas as an output when burned? That seems almost too good to be true. If the above is true, how does the cost, or the ability to scale up compare to traditional hydrocarbon fuels? Something like that doesn’t seem impossible; there is so little coverage of chemistry in science news that the whole field is something of a blind spot for me.
- conradev 5y agoIt means you can pull CO2 out of the air to make biomass (plants), then you can add (renewable) energy to the biomass to make it into fuel. When you burn the fuel, the CO2 is put back into the air.
- ehnto 5y agoWould you consider that carbon nuetral, or is more carbon released than what is taken in?
- usrusr 5y agoBarring any nuclear processes, everything is carbon neutral as long as no fossilized combustibles are taken from the ground and released back into the eternal cycle of carbon neutral processes.
- pfdietz 5y agoOr fossil carbonate. Production of cement releases CO2 even with non-fossil energy.
- xyzzyz 5y agoNo, it will still produce CO2, but the production process pulls CO2 out of the air, so it all nets out to zero.
- 5y ago
- analog31 5y agoWhere's the hydrogen come from?
- adrianN 5y agoHydrogen is easy enough to make from electricity and water. Efficiency is pretty good too.
- edhelas 5y agoAnd where the electricity come from ? Ah yes, hydrogen is 95% made from fossil fuels for now. "But soon we will make it from solar panels and wind turbines". Power-to-h2-to-power is 30% efficient. Please.
- pfdietz 5y agoIt would come from renewable sources. With electrolysers getting cheap, this will pair very well with such intermittent sources. Power-to-h2-to-power is much better than 30% efficient, btw.
- edhelas 5y ago"Would" :) Sure, let's bet our future on that. Source for the "much better than 30%" efficient ? I want something that is deployed and in production. Not some kind of startup-that-will-change-everything tech.
- pfdietz 5y agoIt's a safe bet that hydrogen can be made without fossil fuels. Since hydrogen is essential to maintaining current world population (via manufacture of nitrogen fertilizer), if that were false we'd be doomed.
- edhelas 5y agoSo you didn't answered my question regarding your sources. Here's mine: - The technology to convert power to hydrogen and back to power has a round-trip efficiency of 18%-46%, according to data that Flora presented from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and scientific journal Nature Energy. In comparison, two mature long-duration technologies, pumped-storage hydropower and compressed air energy storage, boast round-trip efficiencies of 70%-85% and 42%-67%, respectively. Flow batteries, a rechargeable fuel cell technology that is less mature, have a round-trip efficiency of 60%-80%. https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights/podcasts/451-research-episode-49 https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights... - https://www.volkswagenag.com/en/news/stories/2019/08/hydrogen-or-battery--that-is-the-question.html https://www.volkswagenag.com/en/news/stories/2019/08/hydroge...
- crznp 5y agoTheir fuels burn the same as conventional fuels (that seems to be the point). The fuel needs carbon to have the right properties and when you burn it, the carbon atoms have to go somewhere. CO2 is the best option, carbon monoxide and soot are worse. It sounds like the change is not how it burns, but how the feedstocks are generated. If the carbon is being pulled from the air (instead of the ground) at the start, then the overall process can be "low life-cycle carbon emissions relative to fuels from crude oil" (from the bioforming link).
- labster 5y agoH2O is actually a significant greenhouse gas from jets. Water is the most significant, giving Earth +30°C of warming, but most of the time we’re maxed out on that already. Still, in the dry upper troposphere, contrails make a pretty sizable contribution to AGW. Even in a carbon-neutral system, where you emit your GGs makes a difference.
- bushbaba 5y agoTIL. Thnx for sharing. Does that make h20 worse or better than co2 as an aviation byproduct in respect to global warming.
- bacheaul 5y agoLong term, CO2's worse, but that's probably not the best way to look at it. Excess H2O (water vapor) falls out of the sky as rain, so it's fairly constant (ie. "maxed out"), and its long term concentration levels are a function of CO2 equivalent gases in the atmosphere. So if you increase CO2 levels, H20 levels will naturally increase as well, and vice versa.
- labster 5y agoWater gives slightly more radiative forcing than CO2 from airplanes, and the effects of NOx are negligible. But of course the water disappears from that altitude in hours, while CO2 has a long atmospheric residence time. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04068-0 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04068-0
- DamnGirl 5y agoyou make it sound like we should use it in cars...
- titaniumtown 5y agoVery fascinating. Thank you.