10 ms·
My kids attend a university in Canada and live in residence on campus. They have had incredibly strict rules around masking and gatherings. It's clear that they
by criddell 5y ago
My kids attend a university in Canada and live in residence on campus. They have had incredibly strict rules around masking and gatherings. It's clear that they are only considering one variable - number of infections - and it seems like they aren't considering any other factors.
For example, in the dorm there is a common area with a piano. Because of COVID, playing that piano is banned. Even if there was a reasonable danger of contracting COVID from a piano, there are also mental health benefits to playing music. It doesn't feel like the piano ban is in the best interests of the people who live there and I don't think the people who set the rules care because they can't measure that. They can only measure infections.
- uxp100 5y agoReminds me of (now takeout only) restaurants which have their bathrooms closed "for covid," or public drinking fountains which are still closed "for covid." Not really much to due with covid at this point I suspect. So it may not really be about measuring infections at all, but that played piano makes noise and requires tuning, and so administration would rather just not, and now there is an excuse.
- moritonal 5y agoMany places have used Covid as an excuse to regress and implement desired polices. Take for example the Tate Modern, a museum in London. Under the argument of COVID you must have a ticket to enter (previously free). You can get a ticket by scanning a QR at the door, you simply have to give an name and email. You can see how they got to that place, so they can control the density of visitors which is important because of COVID, but it's also something they've wanted for years.
- umvi 5y ago"never let a good crisis go to waste"
- ceejayoz 5y agoI'd imagine that's also for contact tracing.
- nradov 5y agoNo one is actually doing meaningful contact tracing anymore. It was a compete failure and waste of resources.
- afavour 5y agoBut is there still a requirement to get that data? It might not be the Tate’s choice.
- autokad 5y agocontact tracing only works when a pandemic is in the hundreds, maybe a few thousand tops. After that it becomes too intractable to trace and also yields little benefit.
- 908B64B197 5y agoOn the west coast I've seen parking at municipal parks completely closed "for covid". Yet the parks remain open. This means people just park in the streets around the parks. What’s that supposed to achieve?
- abfan1127 5y agoits the public health equivalent of the broken window fallacy.
- toomanybeersies 5y agoI would've said it was more a case of Goodhart's law: > When a metric becomes a target, it ceases to be a good metric The public health equivalent of the broken window fallacy would be maximising the spread of disease in order to boost the medical industry.
- rhino369 5y agoAnd if its anything like American colleges, the draconian restrictions don't actually stop the students from crowding into over-packed apartment and house parties over the weekends.
- dboreham 5y agoThis has been my son's experience : masks required in the classroom but the students spread disease (not just COVID -- Flu and colds as well) rampantly in the dorms.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway22032 5y agoThis is the fundamental issue with coronavirus mitigation measures. There are circumstances in which "drop everything" makes sense - if coronavirus were ten times more fatal, we'd do it naturally. But in general, looking at life from a perspective of "what is the minimum possible quality of life we can have" is depressing and fundamentally incompatible with the human spirit. I tend to think that people who operate in this way are subhuman, in the genuine sense of the word - they seem more like bureaucratic automatons than living beings with spirits and hopes and dreams. Like, yeah, I will take the risk of contracting coronavirus to play the piano, because I want the piano in my life. The piano is what life is, life is not simply breathing and eating.
- laserlight 5y ago> if coronavirus were ten times more fatal, we'd do it naturally. What if people didn’t? What then? How would that be different from today?
- spookthesunset 5y agoFor two years we’ve been asked to park our problems and to act like literally all that matters is the spread of Covid. Nothing else matters. Just a myopic fixation on the spread of one highly infectious respiratory virus. Even a year after vaccines we are still being asked to treat Covid like it is the #1 priority in our lives. More important than our well being, our mental health, our communities, our children, or anything else. Heaven help you if your value system is incompatible with such an idea. Be prepared to be yelled at, called names, lose your career, and become marginalized.
- giantg2 5y ago"Even a year after vaccines we are still being asked to treat Covid like it is the #1 priority in our lives. More important than our well being, our mental health, our communities, our children, or anything else." Depends on where you live. There are many rural/red areas that are basically back to normal.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stewbrew 5y agoWhen people play music, they sing. Singing in a crowded room isn't really a good idea when there is an infectious visus around.
- nradov 5y agoThe virus will always be around. Are you proposing a permanent ban on singing?
- stewbrew 5y agoI'm not proposing anything. I was just trying to give a possible rational for this rule.
- criddell 5y agoIt likely wouldn't be crowded. They have pretty strict rules about the number of people that can gather in any room. Also, these people all live together. They are touching the same surfaces, breathing the same air, sharing the same bathrooms, etc... But you are right - singing would increase the risk of infection. Still, I think the risks from the current version of the virus to a vaccinated group of young people (who are still required to wear masks!) is small enough that the piano should be available.
- spookthesunset 5y agoWhy is it up to anybody to decide what risks people are able to take? We have freely available vaccines. Let people decide for themselves… There is more to life than Covid.
- spookthesunset 5y agoThis argument falls flat on its face. There is always infections viruses going around. Covid is not the first nor will it be the last. Who gets to decide what is okay and isn’t anyway? Some myopic “experts” who barely feel the negative impacts of their prognostications? What about other types of experts? What would “music experts” say about shutting down the piano? Covid doesn’t live in a vaccum.
- huetius 5y agoThis one-dimensional approach is especially bad since the emergence of omicron, where number of infections doesn’t even capture the level of COVID danger.
- simonw 5y agoPresumably the piano ban was brought in last year, when people though that Covid spreading through surfaces was a big problem - and that piano ban hasn't been re-considered now that we know that Covid is mostly spread through inhaling shared air.
- rightbyte 5y agoThe piano thing feels like a "we gotta do something" from a board with very little power over things that would limit transmission. Maybe they have a separate dorm board. It is like where I live, the library closed becouse that was the only thing the county could close. And there is like never more than 10 people there at the same time for a huge building. They could just have closed the cafeteria and remove the reading chairs. Etc.
- speedgeek 5y agoI strongly suspect that playing the piano is banned due to the possibility of social gatherings of people in close proximity to each other listening to the piano - not contracting covid from the piano itself.