10 ms·
Yes. In the EU product "denatured alcohol" for most purposes is likewise treated with the same agent. This replaces the widespread use of methanol and similar p
by tialaramex 5y ago
Yes. In the EU product "denatured alcohol" for most purposes is likewise treated with the same agent. This replaces the widespread use of methanol and similar products which are poisonous (yes even if you call the product "meths" it probably isn't methanol in the EU today). The rationale is that poisoning people is not an appropriate reaction to attempted tax avoidance. Alcohol is only "denatured" because booze is taxed, there's no technical reason to use poison, and so the EU took the poison out, for the same reason it doesn't execute or torture criminals.
- cwkoss 5y agoDoes this bitterant leave a residue when the alcohol evaporates? That seems like one benefit of methanol vs bitterant: all of the alcohol can still evaporate without depositing bitterant as a side effect. Are there bitterants that evaporate similarly to alcohol but are not toxic?
- arghwhat 5y agoWe use isopropyl alcohol, which is not denatured, whenever high purity is required.
- dont__panic 5y agoOr in a pinch, 99% grain alcohol. Source: some friends make drinks with grain alcohol, and then don't want it any more after they make those drinks (gee, I wonder why?). Provides an essentially endless supply of alcohol for cleaning purposes for me.
- kunai 5y agoIf you're using alcohol for cleaning 70% concentrations are better as they actually kill and lyse pathogens at that concentration, while 99% will just desiccate them, allowing for reactivation when in a moist environment.
- lstodd 5y agoMy hands, from working with NF/USP Isopropyl alcohol tend to disagree. It desiccates, defats, and generally kills everything in sight.
- kunai 5y agoOf course alcohol is a powerful solvent at any concentration, but there are definitely studies[1] that demonstrate 70% being a bit more effective at disinfecting. [1]: https://www.webmd.com/first-aid/ss/rubbing-alcohol-uses https://www.webmd.com/first-aid/ss/rubbing-alcohol-uses
- morganvachon 5y agoThat's always been the rule of thumb that I learned growing up too. My dad kept 90% or stronger concentrations for cleaning electrical contacts and other industrial uses, and 70% for first aid and sanitizing, because that's what each was made for.
- pvpatel1001 5y ago
- pvpatel1001 5y agoindented 2
- pvpatel1001 5y agoindented 3
- lstodd 5y agoWell, today I learned. Thanks.
- Scoundreller 5y agoYou probably mean 95% grain alcohol if you’re making cost-effective non-toxic drinks with it.
- dont__panic 5y agoYes, just checked and my current bottle is actually 190 proof, good call. But I swear I've gotten a bottle covered in Russian text that claimed 198 proof before. Not sure how reliable that is, to be fair.
- 323 5y agoThe bitterent used is so powerful, the concentration is like 0.01 ppm. So unless you are in a clean room, there will be more dust from air which deposits. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denatonium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denatonium
- rasz 5y agoTry cleaning glasses with it - leaves nasty stains.
- legulere 5y agoHere in Germany they add Butanone, which evaporates at very similar temperatures as ethanol so it’s very difficult to purify the ethanol even with a lab setup.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- southerntofu 5y ago> for the same reason it doesn't execute or torture criminals. I don't disagree with the idea, but to be precise torture and execution at the hand of police and secret services is still a thing in the EU. Especially since the covid lockdowns started almost two years ago, it seems police murders have raised significantly in some parts of the EU (like France).
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoThe best data I could find was the following https://wp.unil.ch/space/files/2021/12/SPACE-II_2020_Final_report_211206.pdf https://wp.unil.ch/space/files/2021/12/SPACE-II_2020_Final_r... Council of Europe Annual Penal Statistics – SPACE II – 2020 - so evidently 2021 not published yet. that is the full report maybe take this https://wp.unil.ch/space/files/2021/06/KeyFindings_Probation-and-Prisons-in-Europe-2020_210527.pdf https://wp.unil.ch/space/files/2021/06/KeyFindings_Probation... which is the keyfindings and a quicker read. Figure 3 on page 5 (in the keyfindings document) - Probation and Prison population rates (per 100,000 inhabitants) on 31st January 2020 shows the median prison population is 103 per 100,000 where probation is concerned on 31st January 2020, there were 1,512,765 probationers under the supervision of the 31 probation agencies of the Council of Europe member states which use the person as the counting unit for their stock of probationers... which would lead to a probation population rate of 311 probationers per 100,000 inhabitants. However, when the European median value is estimated on the basis of the population and the number of probationers of each country, it corresponds to 149 probationers per 100,000 inhabitants in Table 3 on page 16 shows Composition of the probation and prison populations on 31st January 2020 and mortality during 2019. Is your suggestion that some part of these deaths are killings by the EU authorities as a part of policy / extrajudicial killing, or do you mean that there are other deaths that are not in this table. If so - your sources for this claim please?
- kdunglas 5y agoThe OP is probably referring to this well known article (in French): "In 2020, 27 deaths as a result of law enforcement response, including 12 during containment" https://basta.media/recensement-interventions-policieres-letales-27-deces-2020-causes-circonstances-IGPN-IGGN https://basta.media/recensement-interventions-policieres-let...
- jessriedel 5y agoWhether it's reasonable to use poison as a disincentive needs to depend on how often people consume it, accidentally or purposefully. If it's extremely rare, then this is a reasonable use case, even if we don't think poisoning is a reasonable punishment for tax avoidance (because, indeed, the poison is not intended to be a punishment). Likewise, we put up physical barriers like metal posts and concrete walls to dissuade drivers from crossing certain lines even though it would obviously be outrageous to punish a driver for crossing a lane line by smashing their car. As long as drivers strike these very rarely, it's reasonable to use these as disincentives. By all means, if we find disincentives (like bittering agents) that are just as effective with even less risk, we should use them. But claiming that poison is being used as a punishment for tax avoidance is unjustified.
- avianlyric 5y agoYour situations are not comparable. It's impossible for a human to tell the difference between methanol and ethanol using our readily available senses. Once the methylated spirit is removed from its container there's nothing to warn someone the alcohol is poison that will probably intoxicate, then kill or blind them. Methylated sprits substantially increase the risk of death for no other advantage than to prevent tax evasion. It's the equivalent of deciding the punishment for tax evasion is to execute one in every hundred tax evaders. Physical barriers on the other hand are both obvious to car drivers, there's no situation where a car driver believes a physical barrier might be safe to drive into, and more importantly, physical barriers are used to protect other road users, not punish people. So you're trading an increased risk of death to prevent bad driving, you're increasing the risk of driver death to reduce deaths caused by bad driving. If drivers regularly strike a barrier that protects a school, it would be completely unreasonable to remove that barrier, and allow drivers to strike children instead.
- arpa 5y agoEven more so, counterfeit drinks contaminated with methanol have killed people who accidentally bought and unknowingly consumed said drinks, even in bars! Becherovka incidents come to mind. so you're not killing tax evaders, but rather random innocents.
- 323 5y agoDrinking this medical disinfectant denaturated alcohol has become a meme in Romania, where very poor people drink it because it's so cheap - $1.5 for 1L of 70% ABV (almost twice Vodka strength which is about 40% ABV). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdZuHPjJtgs&t=1825s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdZuHPjJtgs&t=1825s
- oblio 5y agomitilicu' :-))
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI've seen alcoholic patients try to drink alcohol 70% antiseptic solutions in the emergency room.
- RealityVoid 5y agoWhile Mona is a disinfectant, it _is_ ethanol, only the production method differs, it's obtained through industrial processes (or so it was explained to my by someone who worked at some industrial alcohol synthesis factory) as opposed to fermentation and distillation. Drinking methanol will fucking blind or kill you, so... a bad idea overall. Interestingly a valid treatment for methanol poisoning is ethanol: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanol_toxicity#Treatment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanol_toxicity#Treatment
- shmoe 5y agoIf I remember it overloads the uptake of the methanol or something along those lines. Crazy stuff.
- andai 5y agoVery interesting. It's not the methanol that's toxic but its metabolites, so the ethanol slows down the liver's metabolism of methanol, stretching it out to the degree that the metabolites do not reach an unsafe concentration? Also, "The preferred antidote is fomepizole, with ethanol used if this is not available." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanol_toxicity#Treatment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanol_toxicity#Treatment >Fomepizole is a competitive inhibitor of the enzyme alcohol dehydrogenase, found in the liver. This enzyme plays a key role in the metabolism of ethylene glycol, and of methanol. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fomepizole https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fomepizole
- chrisshroba 5y agoI'm sorry for my ignorance, but could someone give more context on this? I don't understand what "denatured alcohol" is, how it relates to tax avoidance, or what illegal use people are finding for it?
- wodenokoto 5y agoYou tax alcohol for consumption but not for cleaning products, like rubbing alcohol. Now you need to figure out a way to stop people from consuming cleaning products.
- xyzzyz 5y agoRubbing alcohol is often isopropyl alcohol instead of ethanol, which makes it even more toxic.
- andai 5y agoMore toxic than what? I assumed you meant than methanol (which is added to ethanol-based cleaning products in the Netherlands), but then I read this on the Wikipedia page for isopropyl alcohol: >Isopropyl alcohol, via its metabolites, is somewhat more toxic than ethanol, but considerably less toxic than ethylene glycol or methanol. (Can't link link to the page due to mysterious iOS bug...)
- xyzzyz 5y agoThan ethanol (or denaturated ethanol).
- naniwaduni 5y ago"Even more toxic" is not usually the preferred phrasing for comparing with ethanol; it implies you're comparing with something that's already quite toxic, and ethanol, while indeed toxic, is not normally considered quite toxic enough that we don't need to go out of our way to stop people from drinking it.
- exmadscientist 5y ago> there's no technical reason to use poison Yes, there is. Methanol and ethanol are very chemically similar and small amounts of methanol in your ethanol is usually acceptable from a chemical standpoint. But denatonium benzoate is not like ethanol, and can be a contaminant that destroys the process. To get around this, you either have to find old-fashioned methylated spirits in very high purity, pay the alcohol taxes (which are stratospheric on 200 proof...), or file a crapton of paperwork to buy ethanol tax-free because you're doing chemistry things with it, not drinking it. The latter is what big operations do, but it's a giant pain in the ass if you are not a big operation and you just need moderate volumes of high purity alcohol for your critical cleaning operations....
- AlotOfReading 5y agoLabs aren't buying their stuff at Walmart, so I don't know why they'd by affected by any remotely reasonable law. The supply houses can keep selling methylated alcohol, but let's get the unnecessary poisons off store shelves and out of consumer cabinets.
- exmadscientist 5y agoNo disagreement from me. I'm just saying there is a technical reason to use methanol denaturants sometimes.
- Shared404 5y ago> exmadscientist Username checks out, any fun stories to share? I find most people who've worked in lab's have at least one.
- exmadscientist 5y agoNot as many as I'd like. Or maybe I just need to become a better storyteller.
- 5y ago
- 3np 5y agoWell, for Sweden there's the national monopoly, so denaturing it means being able to sell it for private establishments like hardware shops... And also not requiring an ID check and being > 20yo to buy. The reasoning is public health. You can argue that it's not a preferred solution but there's definitely more than tax to it.