9 ms·
How the gut differentiates artificial sweeteners from sugars in mice
- blakesterz 5y agoIs is often the case... [in mice] The team anesthetized mice, perfused sucrose or sucralose directly into their guts, and then analyzed the response of neurons that make up the vagus nerve using calcium imaging. On average, 40.7 percent responded to sucrose only, 22.2 percent to sucralose only, and the remainder to neither stimulus, explaining how the vagus nerve is able to react differently to the two substances.
- dang 5y agoOk, we've inmiced the title.
- incrudible 5y ago> Animals and humans prefer sugar over artificial sweeteners in experiments, and that could be because a specific gut sensor cell… I have an alternative hypothesis: It is because sugar tastes better. In your mouth, on your tongue. Evolutionarily, this could be explained by sugar not being a calorically worthless synthetic compound that happens to taste sweet and may act as a laxative.
- iqanq 5y agoAs an example, many sweeteners are known for their crappy aftertaste.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThat wouldn't exactly distinguish them from sugar.
- dboreham 5y agoDo you mean High Fructose Corn Syrup?
- thaumasiotes 5y agoNo.
- astrange 5y agoStevia's weird herbal aftertaste makes it good for root beer, though. I think monkfruit is the best alternative sweetener I've tasted.
- ledauphin 5y agotry erythritol. it's very similar to monkfruit, and cheaper everywhere I've looked.
- Semaphor 5y agoIt’s 60% as sweet as sugar, while monkfruit is several times as sweet. And it behaves different when heated. But unlike monkfruit, it’s legal in the EU ;)
- astrange 5y agoI mean, I don't really add sweeteners to things myself so I'm just judging ingredient labels. Was going to comment on sugar alcohols' well known… laxative effects, but apparently erythritol is better about that so that's interesting.
- Semaphor 5y agoI love it in cola. It’s a perfect fit, and I’m sad that it’s very rare to find stevia sweetened sugar-free cola (so far I found one in Germany, and they apparently decided that normal coke is not sweet enough…)
- bradknowles 5y agoNote that Stevia is a problem for people who have had kidney stones. It contains high amounts of Oxalate, which is the chemical that is at the core of the most common form of kidney stone. Spinach and Almonds also contain a lot of Oxalate. Ask me how I know.
- Dylan16807 5y agoIf basic search results can be believed: A 100 gram serving of spinach has 645mg of oxalate. A one ounce serving of almonds has 122. Replacing an ounce of sugar with stevia gives you 6mg. Stevia is high in oxalate per gram, but it's hundreds of times sweeter than sugar. How low do you need to go? I see one site recommending staying under 200mg of oxalate per day.
- rootusrootus 5y agoSome of the newer formulations aren't half bad. Starting with Coke Zero, but now things like Dr Pepper and Pepsi have 'Zero' versions that are surprisingly good. I haven't dug into what they changed to make it work. The bottle of Pepsi Zero sitting in front of me says it still uses aspartame, but it doesn't have that bitter aftertaste I've come to associate with anything sweetened with aspartame.
- mkoubaa 5y agoI'm curious why virtually all soda labels I know of went to a new better tasting "zero" branding at exactly the same time
- idontknowifican 5y agodiet is now a bad word, zero isn’t, so now we’re all zero and not diet. obesity solved
- 1xdevnet 5y agoMy understanding was more that Coke Zero was originally targeted at men, who apparently viewed "diet" sodas as being for women. [0] "We're positioning Coke Zero as a defender and celebrator of guy enjoyment." It doesn't hurt that it's a chance to reformulate without people complaining about the change like "New Coke" (which was allegedly based on the Diet Coke of the time[1]) and so the Zero branding has likely expanded across the Coca-Cola lineup and other brands to expand that reach and introduce changes - and incidentally give them a chance to mess with their agreements with bottlers the same way as when they switched to high-fructose corn syrup [2] [3]. [0] https://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/should-mens-products-fear-a-womans-touch https://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/should-mens-products-fear-a-woman... [1] https://casetext.com/case/coca-cola-bottling-co-v-coca-cola-co-3 https://casetext.com/case/coca-cola-bottling-co-v-coca-cola-... [2] https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Real_Thing/jfGzHxGnfocC?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=isbn%3A081297364X&pg=PA149 https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Real_Thing/jfGzHxGn... [3] https://www.pressreader.com/usa/houston-chronicle-sunday/20120122/310977108683609 https://www.pressreader.com/usa/houston-chronicle-sunday/201...
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI think soda with sugar is disgustingly sweet, but I like the taste of aspartame.
- dawnerd 5y agoI absolutely can't stand the mouthfeel for "sugar" sodas, both the real cane sugar and HFCS variants. It's disgusting. All these newer "zero" versions have pretty much nailed the taste without the gross mouthfeel.
- jliptzin 5y agoI have always actually preferred the taste of Diet Coke to regular coke.
- porknubbins 5y agoSo this is potentially support for all the parents who say sugar causes behavior changes in their kids right? Another win for trusting anecdotal evidence you personally observe over the ivory tower “we have no evidence that…” as a way to live because biology at least is very complex.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThat is WW2 propaganda used to justify sugar rationing. The behavior changes are a learned response because their parents have trained them that acting up is an expected outcome from sugar consumption.
- porknubbins 5y agoIt can be true that it was WWII propaganda and a learned behavior exacerbated by parents signaling and there is a biological reaction to sugar. I don’t have kids so just know what I hear, but if sugar is affecting the vagus nerve that could affect behavior.
- bildung 5y agoAs many studies clearly point it the opposite direction, isn't it way more probable that parents whish for their kids to be more calm than their default state actually is? Kids are usually pretty active and in demand of attention, while parents of young kids are usually sleep deprived and stressed out. The energy level of your average satiated toddler simply is staggeringly high. We know from practically every field of human behaviour that even experts, when not guided by strict predefined rules, are simply unable to objectively assess social situations. E.G. in educationals settings, even experienced teachers sensitized for the topic are usually unable to correctly observe how their praise-punishment ratio is or the ratio of interacting with boys/girls or with loud and quiet students. It simply isn't reasonable to assume that parents, completely untrained in objectively evaluating these kinds of settings, assess the effects of sugar consumption correctly.
- parentoftoddler 5y ago
- prawn 5y agoI always thought it would be interesting if someone released a 24-can case of a particular soft drink that started with the full, sweetened version and then gradually decreased can-by-can to the diet equivalent. Might be a journey in weaning yourself off sugar in drinks if you drank them in order.
- crate_barre 5y agoI suspect a country like China could do this for ‘the greater good’ without anyone knowing for a number of things.
- nightfly 5y agoI'd rather have the sugar or not at all then the bad taste of diet soda.
- ShortStretto 5y agoI'm someone that prefers the zero/no sugar stuff for it does not leave sticky residu on my teeth. I also did not do a side-by-side comparison but in my opinion the aftertaste of (specifically pepsi zero) is better than the sugary version.
- fredestine 5y agowhere do u live? if it is in usa it is true because they use corn syrup. other parts of world has normal sugar in it.
- consp 5y agoConsidering I have the exact opposite, this is highly personal not fundamental.
- _qua 5y agoI think it's nearly impossible for an average person to taste the difference between Coke Zero and regular Coke. It's not jsut a little sugar in soft drinks, it's an enormous amount and it's worth switching to diet.
- danielyaa5 5y agoI just did keto and was shocked at how much I liked eritythol but we’ve still got a ways to go