3 ms·
Similar to a fractal, the difference between an organism and a superorganism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superorganism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superorg
by kibwen 5y ago
Similar to a fractal, the difference between an organism and a superorganism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superorganism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superorganism) depends on how close you zoom in. It's easy to think about an ant colony as a superorganism, and from there to think about human civilization as a superorganism, and then the entire Earth's biosphere as a single superorganism. Then you can go the other way and think about how every human body is its own superorganism; your body is composed of approximately as many human cells as non-human cells (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_microbiome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_microbiome). You are an entire ecosystem.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe human body and the ant colony are units of reproduction; an individual ant, like an individual cell, cannot reproduce. Only the colony or the human can do that. Human societies aren't like that; the humans are free to reproduce on their own. It is a mistake to generalize from the ant colony to human society, much less to the entire world.
- picture 5y agoWould human reproduction to human societies be similar to mitosis to cells? Or does the unit of reproduction require mixing genes
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Or does the unit of reproduction require mixing genes[?] No, there are clonal organisms. > Would human reproduction to human societies be similar to mitosis to cells? No; all the cells in a body divide on the terms the body sets and they die when the body does. (Or earlier, when so directed.) The only way for them to reproduce is indirectly, through the production of gametes. They do not and generally cannot have an independent existence. Human reproduction within human societies is the analogue of a cell within the body becoming cancerous. At that point, the cancer's uncontrolled mitosis is a form of independent reproduction, though it tends not to work out for the cancer because they almost never develop a way to leave the body, and end up killing themselves. There are some exceptions, such as HeLa and the cancer that lives in Tasmanian devils.
- kibwen 5y agoI don't agree that societies don't reproduce. A society grows as its population of humans increases, and eventually the population grows large enough that it splits into multiple societies, e.g. the depletion of local resources via overpopulation leads to diasporas setting up new societies elsewhere, and these new societies tend imitate the familiar structures of the original society. IMO, that's reproduction.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> I don't agree that societies don't reproduce. You'll notice that what I said was that humans do reproduce.
- kibwen 5y ago> an individual ant, like an individual cell, cannot reproduce. Only the colony or the human can do that. Human societies aren't like that
- thaumasiotes 5y agoYes, that is a quote from me. It matches my description of what I said. (Of course, it matches it even better if you don't cut it off in the middle of a sentence:) > Human societies aren't like that; the humans are free to reproduce on their own. It doesn't match your description of what I said. What are you trying to say?
- kibwen 5y agoSo then you do think that human societies can reproduce, despite appearing to say that human societies, unlike humans and ant colonies, cannot reproduce? Can you re-word your statement to clearly indicate what you believe?
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> despite appearing to say that human societies, unlike humans and ant colonies, cannot reproduce? This is not even an attempt to approximate what I said. I said that humans are composed of cells which cannot reproduce, colonies are composed of ants which cannot reproduce, and human societies -- unlike humans and ant colonies -- are composed of humans which reproduce independently of the society. When I specifically indicate that what distinguishes human societies from ant colonies is that ants can't reproduce and humans can, what else could that mean? This makes nonsense of the idea that a human society could be viewed as a superorganism. They don't have the coherence; they are constantly subject to betrayal by the humans of which they are composed. There are historical processes which look like the reproduction of a society: in the wake of Alexander the Great, northern India received a bunch of Greek colonists who built theaters, spoke Greek, practiced Greco-paganism, and wrote a lot of history, which marked a big contrast with the existing societies which built stepwells, spoke Sanskrit, practiced Buddhism, and wrote almost no history. And then the Greeks took up Buddhism. And they started speaking Sanskrit. And they stopped writing history. And they stopped building theaters. But they didn't go anywhere. If societies were superorganisms, that couldn't have happened. The loss of Greek culture in India would have simultaneously been the loss of all the Greeks.
- pphysch 5y ago> Human societies aren't like that; the humans are free to reproduce on their own. It's not nearly that simple. If you take away "society" (running water, sewage, electricity, traffic lights, medical treatment, fresh diverse food, security, etc) most people would die off and the few survivors would find childrearing very burdensome. The study of how human organizations can reproduce themselves and maintain vitality, rather than dying off when a leader or generation dies off, is critically important. Classical biology doesn't have a monopoly on "reproduction".
- pfisherman 5y ago> … like an individual cell, cannot reproduce. The prokaryotes beg to differ. If we are talking about human cells then the cancer cells would also like to raise an objection.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoI already mentioned cancer in this thread.
- carbonguy 5y ago> The human body and the ant colony are units of reproduction; an individual ant, like an individual cell, cannot reproduce. Only the colony or the human can do that. I honestly don't know if you're trying to be rhetorical here or what, but individual cells DO reproduce and individual humans do not.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoA human cell dividing is not reproduction in the evolutionary sense, unless the cell is cancerous. It is reproduction in the same sense that my shoes can reproduce by means of me buying another pair when the first pair wears out.