5 ms·
Hubble captures a black hole that is forming stars, not absorbing them
- belval 5y agoI know next to nothing on black holes/star formation and astronomy in general, but isn't this a big deal? I thought a pretty big defining factor of black holes was that nothing (not even light!) ever escaped it?
- uoaei 5y agoIt is definitely an unusual observation, but I don't think it's really that big of a deal. A strong gravitational field would pull matter closer together, possibly kick-starting the fusion process if the energy density gets high enough in a certain region. If you asked an astrophysicist what would happen to a massive dust and gas cloud near a black hole, star formation would be 2 or 3 on the list that they rattle off. > But the gentler outflow of gas from the black hole in Henize 2-10 is compressed just enough to facilitate star formation. It's a Goldilocks thing. Black hole is strong enough to have a significant gravity, but weak enough that the shell of hot dense matter it harbors doesn't completely obliterate everything that falls toward it.
- kadoban 5y agoThis is not evidence that anything has escaped the event horizon of a black hole. That _would_ be huge news (also pretty ~impossible, but still). This is just the region _near_ a black hole doing some star formation. Which is cool, but also :shrug:.
- davesque 5y agoI don't think this finding challenges any of those assumptions. I think the explanation was that the relativistic jet for smaller blackholes located at galaxy centers is moving slow enough that the compressive effects of the jet are not overcome by the speed. The compression therefore helps with star formation since the jet isn't moving fast enough to disrupt that process.
- tejtm 5y agoMight help to think of it as more of a reprieve. In that the star itself or its remains will still likely end up inside the black holes Schwarzschild radius never to be seen again except as Hawking radiation till the BH evaporates. That the environment directly outside a BH is energetic enough fling some stuff "up" does not mean the stuff can't/won't fall back "down". In this case the stuff flung "up" happens to have the necessary properties to trigger star formation further away, which is mostly an incoming shock wave and an preexisting cloud of "cold" stuff. The stuff the BH is throwing in its shock wave is not going to be "cold". So to facilitate star formation the shock wave has to be less hot / less dense than and maybe slower than a larger BH hole would produce (which would more typically shred the cold cloud to tatters instead of causing it to collapse in on itself precipitating a star)
- pdonis 5y ago> the star itself or its remains will still likely end up inside the black hole Not necessarily. Black holes don't have any more tendency to "suck things in" from a distance than any other object with the same mass.
- tejtm 5y agospace is pretty big, but I would bet eternity wins this one.
- jonshariat 5y agoAs a layperson, I always wondered this about gravity. Does it attract over infinite distance or does it have a range?
- karmakaze 5y agoThinking in continuous terms, it would be infinite and inversely proportional to distance squared. But thinking in terms of a distortion in space-time and also considering that it may be quantized, perhaps there is some limit. Also for points that are separating faster than the speed of light due to inflation gravity couldn't alter that space.
- jvanderbot 5y agoYou can orbit a black hole like any other object, and most things do, for a long, long time. Hell, the whole milky way is basically orbiting a black hole (and a lot of other mass near the center).
- fennecfoxen 5y agoAnd orbiting a black hole is just like orbiting any other object, except the surface is much closer to the center of mass.
- ben_w 5y agoAnd some of the stars close to the Milky Way’s have completed entire orbits on camera: https://www.eso.org/public/videos/eso1825e/ https://www.eso.org/public/videos/eso1825e/
- thehappypm 5y agoI recently learned about delta-V as a concept. Flying directly into the sun, for example, is basically not possible for a spacecraft with today’s technology, without dozens of gravity boosts. You need to basically undo the speed of your initial orbit, which for something in orbit around a star is huge! A black hole would be even more difficult and require more Delta-V to fly into, if you’re in any sort of orbit. So you should definitely expect tons of stuff in orbit around them!
- acomjean 5y agoSo all matter is doomed to get sucked into one of these things eventually?
- jvanderbot 5y agoAFAIK, all matter is doomed to be torn apart by the expansion of the universe.
- isomel 5y agoNo. For the same reason all matter in the solar system is not doomed to get sucked into the sun. A black hole is just a very dense objet things can fall into if they have the right trajectory. But more often than not, the trajectory will be an hyperbola or a parabola around it, and the matter don't reach the event horizon.
- pdonis 5y ago> I thought a pretty big defining factor of black holes was that nothing (not even light!) ever escaped it? Nothing ever escapes from inside the hole's horizon. But there can still be a lot of interesting things happening outside the hole's horizon as matter either falls in, or orbits the hole, or some combination of the two; and we can certainly observe things happening outside the hole. That has been known for decades.
- alex_young 5y ago> Nothing ever escapes from inside the hole's horizon. Well, kind of. Hawking radiation [0] causes black holes to eventually evaporate, although no actual information from inside the horizon escapes. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawking_radiation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawking_radiation
- pdonis 5y agoI wasn't including Hawking radiation because, however likely it is considered, it's still not a confirmed prediction, and the theoretical basis for it is not rigorous (since we don't have a consistent theory of quantum gravity to back it up, just various heuristic arguments). (Also, even if it does exist, it is negligible by many, many orders of magnitude in the scenarios under discussion here.) Also, if Hawking radiation does turn out to be confirmed, it might end up that the radiation does carry information from inside the hole. The quantum effects that are involved in Hawking radiation, at least as we currently understand them, violate the conditions that ground the "no information can escape from a black hole" theorems in classical GR.
- colechristensen 5y agoNo it’s not a big deal, they just mean that far away from the black hole its effect stirs the pot a bit in a way that triggers star formation. Interesting to observe but also a pretty obvious consequence of a black hole being around.
- Shadonototra 5y agoso black holes basically mix all the space dust together, condensate everything, let it sit like a dough, and then comes a fresh star? the life cycle of the universe!
- staticassertion 5y agoExcept for the shit that falls into it. All of that mixing is happening outside of the event horizon.
- malfist 5y agoNo, this headline is very misleading. Blackholes eat everything that crosses the event horizon and nothing* ever escapes from that. But lots of thing near the black hole don't get sucked straight down. Everything a blackhole pulls on already has momentum on it's own, so the black hole's tug causes it to spin around the blackhole. Angular momentum is conserved, so what happens to most matter is that the blackhole grabs it, and slings it hard in another direction, very little actually "falls" in. The stuff it slings out tends to move in similar directions, and that can cause things to clump together and form stars. Additionally, all the spinning around the blackhole generates heat and radiation, this gets ejected in massive bursts coming out of the rotational axis of the black hole. This stream of energy can hit other dust, heating it up and causing it to condense. This can lead to a birth of a star. It's long been thought that blackholes can form stars through those methods, but this is the first time it's been observed. Not groundbreaking, but does confirm a theory. *: offer does not apply to hawking radiation
- gexla 5y agoSounds like a massive fun mud slide. You slide in with a bunch of dirt, then you get flung back out into space. But dangerous because you might get stuck in the hole or get caught by the flame thrower. If this were a theme park, it seems like it would be in VHF run by Stanley "Who wants to drink from the firehose!?" Spadowski.
- drran 5y agoThis is exactly what happening to us. Shappley attractor condensate dust from «Dipolle repeller» (big void left after attractor grabbed the dust), so our galaxy is formed, with our star and our planet. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PEAY7LNhdxM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PEAY7LNhdxM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shapley_Supercluster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shapley_Supercluster
- ldoughty 5y agoFelt mildly like a clickbait title (in my opinion) It still absorbs stars... and other matter... lots of it... but those somewhat more familiar with black holes know not everything is sucked in... black holes (commonly? -- I never looked into prevalence of this) have "jets" that push material away, often at high speed. The "revelation" of this article is that we have the first photographic evidence supporting the fact these "jets" can contribute to the creation of stars.
- pdonis 5y ago> black holes (commonly? -- I never looked into prevalence of this) have "jets" that push material away, often at high speed. This is quite common. The jets are present in most black holes that are rotating with significant angular momentum compared to their mass, which is, AFAIK, a substantial majority of all black holes that have been observed.
- eyegor 5y agoIs it even possible for a black hole (or any stellar body) to form without angular momentum? Or somehow consume all of its angular momentum without decomposing? I know that it's used in some bits of general relativity around the schwarzchild solution but I've never seen an attempt to prove that they could ever form in the first place. I'd appreciate links to research papers if you know of any.
- mr_toad 5y agoOnly if the matter that comprised it had zero net angular momentum before hand. Angular momentum is conserved. It’s totally possible in theory for a black hole to have zero angular momentum, but not so likely in practice.
- eyegor 5y agoOh of course, it's just a sum after all. Reminds me of forgetting the zero roots when solving differential equations.
- amelius 5y agoThe laws of physics are time-reversible, after all.
- snicker7 5y agoHubble is trying real hard now that JWT stole the spotlight.
- geenew 5y agoThey’re studying different wavelengths, they’re planned to compliment each other, jwst isn’t operational yet, and this article is almost certainly based on observations from before jwst even launched. What are you talking about.
- xqcgrek2 5y agoClickbait in astronomy is out of control