15 ms·
Before wave of train thefts, Union Pacific laid off some of its police force
- jrockway 5y agoSo for the pictures that have been all over the news this week... did the train derail before people started stealing stuff from it? Could Union Pacific have just maintained their infrastructure better and avoided this whole thing?
- josephcsible 5y agoDidn't the derailment happen after the thefts?
- skyde 5y agocould the thief be the laid of police officer :) Seem likely to me
- pstuart 5y agooutsourcing the actual work for scale
- pessimizer 5y ago> The Union Pacific Police department has jurisdiction over the 32,000 miles of track Union Pacific owns. Many of these “special agents” used to patrol this now infamous stretch of track. According to the source, the number of patrolling officers has been cut from 50 to 60 agents to eight[...]
- friendlydog 5y ago
- mulmen 5y agoUP is making arrests though, even with fewer officers. The problem seems to be the LA Prosecutor not... prosecuting. So would it really matter if UP sent more people to the prosecutor? Were the layoffs a response to the lack of effectiveness in the prosecutors office?
- User23 5y agoIsn’t messing with rail a federal crime? Where is the U.S. Attorney?
- jeffbee 5y agoThat might be true, or it might be cop propaganda. I mean, a press release from the cops is literally cop propaganda. We know from recent reports in New York that the NYPD is just going around refusing to investigate crimes or make arrests, and telling everyone who will listen it is the DA's fault. Their propaganda campaign is organized by the police union, which is nationally coordinated and not politically neutral. So when you read reports, written by cops, about these issues, unless they come with substantial documented evidence, I think you should treat those claims as skeptically as you treat press releases from the CIA, or Putin, or whoever. These claims have no inherent credibility.
- cassac 5y agoI find it reasonable for the cops not to make arrests if nobody is going to prosecute. I don’t consider that propaganda for the police to say as such. If the DA openly says they won’t prosecute a certain crime why would I expect the police to arrest for it? And of course the cops would have a cop bias, and teachers have a teacher bias, and service works have a service worker bias and on and on. Everyone looks out for their own across all cross sections of their identity. What’s different is it seems cops get no additional cross sections anymore. Once they are a cop their ven diagram shifts to 100% cop and now they are vilified.
- pessimizer 5y ago> I find it reasonable for the cops not to make arrests if nobody is going to prosecute. You find it reasonable for people to be paid and not do their jobs? They're not paid to administer justice, they're paid to do what they're told.
- cassac 5y agoI never said they are paid to “administer justice” but I do expect them to prioritize their activities. Making arrests for things that won’t be prosecuted is a waste of time. I’m honestly not even sure what you are advocating for. J walking is a good example of something I expect them not to bother with 99% of the time but it is a law nearly everywhere. To enforce that in a major metro could use all the cops every day. Huge waste of time.
- gruez 5y agoThe article was good in the first half, but then steadily goes downhill in the second half. >The letter also attempted further to politicize L.A.’s no-cash bail policy / Special Directive 20-07 Is this supposed to be bad? It seems to be bad faith to accuse someone of "politicizing" something when it's plausibly related to the topic being discussed. >(“Studies show that prosecution of the offenses driving the bulk of misdemeanor cases have minimal, or even negative, long-term impacts on public safety.”) ...with no sources provided. >Even though, according to LAPD data, property crime is down. That's not really as slam dunk as it suggests. If the government openly states that they're not going to bother prosecuting minor property crime, it seems reasonable that a fair chunk of the victims will be dissuaded from reporting the crime, driving property crime statistics down. >“These individuals are generally caught and released back onto the streets in less than 24 hours. Even with all the arrests made, the no-cash bail policy and extended timeframe for suspects to appear in court is causing re-victimization to Union Pacific by these same criminals.” Community activists think otherwise, supporting the DA’s no-cash bail policy this... doesn't say much. I'm sure for any topic you can find "community activists" for your preferred side. >stressing that further criminalizing people of lower socioeconomic status for non-violent crimes isn’t a real solution. The criminals criminalized themselves when they committed the crime, not when the law decided to prosecute them. >A connection worth questioning can be found with the controversy surrounding Emanuel Padilla. No, I actually don't see the connection here. Are they accusing UP of falsely accusing/prosecuting people? Are they just saying the previous DA sucks and the current DA is good? Are they just bringing it up because the case has something to do with trains?
- vkou 5y ago> That's not really as slam dunk as it suggests. If the government openly states that they're not going to bother prosecuting minor property crime, it seems reasonable that a fair chunk of the victims will be dissuaded from reporting the crime, driving property crime statistics down. The main reason people report property crime is because insurance requires a police report. If you were a victim of property crime, your odds of ever seeing your stuff back a decade ago, and today aren't meaningfully different.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- filed 5y ago
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThis article is heavy on the victim-blaming. Are we really supposed to shift some of our blame to the company suffering the thefts? When the LA Prosecutor has made it clear that they aren't prosecuting the thieves, it almost doesn't matter how many or how few patrol officers Union Pacific has. If there are no consequences, catching someone in the middle of a theft is only a minor delay and inconvenience.
- vkou 5y agoDepends on whether it took reasonable precautions. If you left a pile of gold bars in an unlocked shed at your vacation property, that you visit three times a year, I can be sympathetic to you if someone steals them, but I'm not quite so sympathetic that I'm ready to volunteer my taxes to fund 24/7 security for your shed. I'm not an expert on what's reasonable when it comes to railway security (and neither are you), but from my layman's take on it, firing 85% of their security, and observing a 160% increase in theft seems like a "Union Pacific problem", not a "me problem". They do seem to have a financial incentive, to the tune of 52 salaries to try to turn it into a "me problem."
- kyrra 5y agoYou do realize that the thieves are using bolt cutters and breaking into a containers. Some container owners are now welding their containers closed to prevent contents from being stolen. Union Pacific is also turning information over and helping get people arrested, but they're back on the street within 24 hours.
- Lammy 5y agoYes, capital is complicit in building a society that allows people to suffer to the point that they need to steal to survive. Artificial scarcity is artificial: https://www.bostonfed.org/publications/economic-education/wishes-and-rainbows.aspx https://www.bostonfed.org/publications/economic-education/wi...
- Manuel_D 5y agoThere's plenty of shortages caused not by capital, but by government. Like restrictive zoning and price controls suppressing housing construction. I fail to see how UP railroad is complicit in the scarcity that may be driving some to steal from trains.
- hogepiyo 5y agoSame state where the governor had the wisdom to make shoplifting below $1000 a misdemeanor and the prosecutor can't be bothered to do their job. But yeah, blame the rail company, I guess?
- abrookewood 5y agoIt's not like blame is binary ...
- KennyBlanken 5y agoLowering the penalty for shoplifting to a misdemeanor would make it more appealing than the potential 20 year federal sentence that would come from federal prosecution) that robbing a train carries...not encourage robbing trains. But yeah, blame the state, I guess?
- khuey 5y agoa) that wasn't the governor b) California's felony theft threshold of $950 is still the 12th lowest among the states
- josephcsible 5y ago$950 being a misdemeanor isn't unreasonable on its own. It becomes unreasonable when you combine it with misdemeanors not being prosecuted, so it's not fair to compare the threshold in places that do prosecute them with places that don't.
- khuey 5y agoSure, but the problem there isn't the law, it's the cops and prosecutors.
- josephcsible 5y agoI'm saying that if you know you have a bad prosecutor, you should hold off on passing that law.
- quacked 5y agoI used to live in an apartment complex across the street from a gas station in Houston, TX. It was owned by an older subcontinental Asian (Nepali?) man and his family. I'd go in about once every two weeks. One day, I came in and that family was gone; they'd been replaced by a younger cohort of either Indian or Pakistani men and women. The new owners were polite and professional, but far less friendly. Soon after, bulletproof glass went up between the registers and the customers, the product selection became more sparse, and the warm yellow lights were replaced with bright LEDs. Eventually I inquired why the gas station had changed, and the man at the register explained that there were several armed robberies during the time period that I'd been living there. I was surprised; this gas station was in a fairly decent part of town near NASA, and there was a tennis club right next to the apartment complex. I used to walk barefoot from my apartment to the courts. I'd never heard sirens or ever noticed that anyone had been robbed. It must have taken 6-10 young men fewer than a combined 60 minutes across several robberies to completely alter the dynamic of the gas station. Their hour's worth of work caused hundreds of hours in transfers, equipment moving, inspections, storage, and installation. The experience of shopping at that gas station became unpleasant, and I avoided the station when I could. Soon after, I moved to a richer, nicer, quieter neighborhood down the road (for unrelated reasons--the apartment complex had a pest problem.) But I often think about that shop; there are now children growing up in that apartment complex who think that "gas stations" include bulletproof glass and wary stares, instead of warm lighting and friendly greetings. That's their vision of society; even if those children are not criminals themselves, they expect to be treated like them. They're like children who don't remember plane travel before 9/11, except instead of the hold-up at the TSA, it's a hold-up in a gas station. This is what I think about when I hear about large-scale property crime like these train thefts. Sure, it's just property. But it is the docile, rule-following, peaceful majority (to which I and the rest of HN belong) that creates and finances all the property that ends up stolen and destroyed; allow this stability of commerce to be interrupted by wanton theft or violence and they will flee, retreat into themselves, hire private security forces, and produce less. Poverty may encourage crime, but crime always creates poverty.
- kepler1 5y agoThe people who suffer most from those in charge tolerating crime are the poor and less privileged -- through direct crime, and negative effects on their communities -- as well as especially children (problems that affect families always affect kids the worst). What policymakers and people who think they mean well need to understand is that the actions/policies they promote, believing that they're reducing the stigma or making it more "equitable" by reducing the penalties for crime, end up hurting most people instead of solving the problem. They get to feel better that they didn't lock up so many people of color (to use today's fad grouping), but the greater community who are poor and less privileged are actually the ones paying for the crimes now being overlooked/ignored. The rich can/will move away and leave these places to suffer on their own. The poor, who most rely on government to protect them, watch as their concerns and safety get swept under the rug of feel-good defund-the-police policies as those in charge have no idea (or actively ignore) what they've incentivized.
- pengaru 5y agoThe railroads have a long and notorious history of power-abusing police forces. Lots of folks here blaming lack of jail time / LA DA's actions. If we look at the history of the railroad, they are more than capable of protecting their interests - and it hasn't historically been via fear of jail time. They deserve zero sympathy thanks to past abuses and can stop this in an instant if they wanted.
- imgabe 5y agoWhatever you believe the causes of society’s problems are “just let people steal stuff” is not going to bring about a solution.
- wolverine876 5y agoCan you give evidence of anyone saying that? The only people who say it are reactionaries spreading disinformation.
- imgabe 5y agoWell, my first clue is that there's all these people stealing stuff. Then the authorities decline to prosecute, in other words, they let them steal stuff. I admit I am making an assumption that they are doing this with the belief that it will solve some of society's problems. I'm giving them the benefit of the doubt that they are not actively trying to make things worse.
- Wiseacre 5y agoYou are making quite a few assumptions. So what will you do when you booked a thief but the jail is at staff capacity?
- imgabe 5y agoSounds like you’re making an assumption that the jail is at capacity. Nobody said anything about the jail being full. What’s your plan if the jail is at capacity ? Stop enforcing the law? Anarchy?
- Wiseacre 5y agoThe assumption being made is on your part for saying you know why "they let crime" happen.
- 5y ago
- hk1337 5y agoIt’s a pretty typical cycle where security or law enforcement is concerned. Everything is great, crime is down, someone comes up with the idea that since there’s less crime we need fewer officers, then crime goes up because there’s fewer officers.
- ambericanonion 5y agoI"d quite like my own police force as well. Do i just hire some people and give them uniforms, or is there some red tape involvex?
- coding123 5y agoI met a guy that was in the "security business" he said he shot someone and had to move 10 states over because the guy he shot has family that finds him occasionally and does drive by shootings every now and then. Be careful about getting into that business.
- Apocryphon 5y agoGoes to show it's not just S.F. and Bay Area law enforcement that's not prosecuting certain crimes, despite popular portrayal.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Gasc%C3%B3n https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Gasc%C3%B3n - the DA of LA was the DA of SF for 8 years before his current role. Seems like he wanted to give his new town a little taste of Frisco.
- wanderingmind 5y agoHow does this posting abide by HN rules that says off-topic as "Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon."
- jeffbee 5y agoThe pearl-clutching panics from earlier this week got over 1000 comments and were on the front page for hours. It would not have seemed like the right venue, but apparently it is.
- bagacrap 5y agoI hope this situation is a new phenomenon, granted I don't really know whether this exact thing was prevalent before the whole defund the police/decriminalize crime movement
- sirmarksalot 5y ago
- ryan_lane 5y agoThis company has done layoffs, which make their patrols less effective. Due to less patrols they have higher thefts. The crimes are federal, but the company is classifying them in a way that puts them under local jurisdiction. This is a PR story, meant to distract you from the fact that the company has opened themselves up to these thefts, and is using cop propaganda to do so.
- IMAYousaf 5y agoThe real theft is the cost to build more rail today.