20 ms·
Automation is reaching more companies
- marcodiego 5y agoSome people point many factors as a "need" for basic income. Automation is one of them. Without basic income, robots (as an analogy for automation) will benefit only its owners.
- anonporridge 5y agoI conceptualize a UBI as a dividend, where every citizen has exactly one nontransferable ownership share of the nation state and has the right to share in it's profit.
- nickpp 5y agoYou can get that today by simply buying into one of the many low cost ETFs available following the S&P500 index. No need to wait for the State to do it for you.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> You can get that today by simply buying into one of the many low cost ETFs available following the S&P500 index No, you can't get an equal share with every other citizen that way, especially if you are a lower-class worker without substantial surplus income.
- nickpp 5y agoYes, it’s not equal and not free either. But we have it working today.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Yes, it’s not equal and not free either. But we have it working today. I mean, it's literally not working, even a little bit, for the vast majority of the people who would be net beneficiaries under a UBI. This is “let them eat cake” levels of out-of-touch.
- nickpp 5y agoThe greatest mass-pulling out of poverty I personally witnessed in my lifetime was when the communist states of Eastern Europe moved to capitalism. More of that, please.
- yazaddaruvala 5y agoCapitalism is very good at allocating capital and as a result innovating to increase the "ceiling" of the human experience. Capitalism is very bad at increasing the "floor" of the human experience. Almost by definition, there is some threshold, X% of the population, where the marginal reward is no longer worth the effort (in lay terms - its not "worth it" to R&D and innovate to build amazing and cheap products for poor people). Trickle down economics typically doesn't happen[0]. This band typically is the target and victim of rent seeking - i.e. stagnation with a higher long-term price than innovation. Historically, Capitalism has always just exploited the floor through rent seeking until that "floor" dies a few decades later, then continues to exploit the new "floor". UBI is a focus on improving that "floor" of the human experience (different than other government programs by reducing stigma and increasing guarantees). If you can think of it, I would love to hear about a way to incentivize Capitalism to increase the "floor" of the human experience. If you want more capitalism, we need to figure out how do we incentivize more "Altruistic Capitalism" (maybe a different name?). There are some companies kinda starting to do this, I've heard them called "For Purpose Capitalism"/"For Purpose Companies" e.g. Tom's shoes, etc. [0] https://usafacts.org/articles/internet-access-students-at-home/#:~:text=However%2C%2034%25%20reported%20not%20having,not%20available%20in%20their%20area https://usafacts.org/articles/internet-access-students-at-ho.... and this is in the USA in-spite of charity, government subsidies and regulations for getting more access to the internet.
- anonporridge 5y agoAssuming you're not living as a poverty level wage slave and regularly have to choose between buying food and medicine, then sure.
- nickpp 5y agoIndeed, getting people out of poverty is a different issue, an issue no redistribution system has solved yet.
- beaconstudios 5y agoThat's just objectively not true - welfare systems stop people from becoming homeless or starving in the street all the time. Libertarianism/neoliberalism is the ideological model that doesn't care about the poor - social democracy isn't perfect but it is an improvement over just letting people die.
- nickpp 5y agoIt’s not about caring, it’s about results. Capitalism is the only system that pulled both countries and people out of poverty, because it’s the best system at motivating people to create value. Redistributing systems are naturally demotivating. The balance is being tried indeed but it’s a slippery slope in a democracy where people just learn that they can vote more money in their pockets.
- beaconstudios 5y agoSocial democracy is still capitalism, it just redirects some taxes into a welfare program. If eliminating poverty is the end goal then we need a safety net for those who fail.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Social democracy is still capitalism It's still capitalism in much the same way that capitalism is still feudalism.
- sharkjacobs 5y ago> every citizen has exactly one nontransferable ownership share of the nation state > buying into one of the many low cost ETFs available following the S&P500 index There are some pretty big differences between these
- nickpp 5y agoThere is an even bigger difference in that one exists and works today while the other requires a huge experiment in the way modern society works.
- judge2020 5y agoA better analogy is that you already an ownership share in the nation state with citizenship - you have voting rights, a court system that works for you, you benefit monetarily by having a secure military and police force (thus not needing to directly pay for bodyguards or protection from some sort of mafia).
- gremlinsinc 5y agoI conceptualize it as a cryptocurrency w/ single identity, a max wallet amount (10 million perhaps -the rest is taxed 100%), and a utilization score...basically where those who make more transactions and hold less in their wallet get more UBI paid into it... then there just needs to be a mechanism to make the coin 'stable' to where 1 coin is about a loaf of bread... it'd need to maybe have separate account types though and gets a little murky around how businesses accept the coin.... and how that plays into the max-limit (goal being to limit inequality..and basically have a max un-equalness, where you've essentially "won the monopoly game" and now you can go out and help others win too...).
- giantg2 5y agoHow does the economics look for that? It would seem many would be disincentivized to work, which would raise wages in order to attract work, which would make the basic income worth less.
- yunwal 5y agoWages would presumably raise prices only in industries that can't be heavily automated. As a result, industries that are automatible will have lower prices, while industries that require human labor will have inflated prices. In the end, those who make close to minimum wage are probably better off, since they can afford more of the automated things, and those who automate things are probably better off since they have more people to sell to. Those who are well off but don't automate things will probably be about even, since they'll need to pay more for human labor, but will receive UBI and automation benefits.
- giantg2 5y agoThis doesn't make sense to me. Rising wages means more competition over the same resources, leading to inflation. Even inflation in some industries/products will affect the CPI. Where would the UBI come from? Presumably it would be from those who automate. This means your claim of lower prices will likely be marginal - the people need to support themselves whether they or a robot does the work. So UBI would mostly offset.
- gremlinsinc 5y agoUBI would hopefully come from land-value taxes. This has been debated a lot and seems to be one of the best methods. Another would be making every American turn in their bank accounts into a single account, and slap a limit on how much you can have in there.... whether that's 50 million or 20 billion... piss off the billionaire class for sure, but who cares. Inequality shouldn't be that out of whack anyways and having a max speed on it could encourage better equality. Personally if I had UBI I'd work more on side-projects and try to get some recurring income coming in...I'm still trying to do that but it's harder w/ all the distractions of doing client/freelance work..and the depression when I can't meet bills because I'm having a ADHD poor-motivation month, or anti-social-can't be bothered w/ marketing to find new clients month... both of which seem like every month since the Pandemic began... I'd hope a lot more people would actually go into science fields and do research when they can afford to go to school and have a guaranteed home and basic necessities... Honestly a utopia to me would see 95% of kids becoming scientists and technologists, the rest in the arts... and everything else being automated and we work on solving things like aging, space travel, and climate change.
- mountainriver 5y agoI donno, we already have automation doing a lot of things today. Lack of work is only due to lack of imagination and tools like this make us more capable than ever. The universe is infinitely complex and large, there is plenty for people to do.
- giantg2 5y ago"Lack of work is only due to lack of imagination" How so? It seems one needs capital to start new things, time to use their imagination (as opposed to seeking necessities), and then customers able to pay for whatever the new thing is. I think there are tons of constraints in feasibility.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoI think he's saying something approximately like: there are likely jobs we can't think of yet that will pop up. They always have. Imagine if you went back in time 200 years and explained how current farming and current manufacturing work, and explain that's how it will work in 200 years time. A reasonable person would likely assume hardly anyone was working in this future state, that there would be no jobs.
- giantg2 5y agoTo a certain extent that is true. But it matters where those jobs are eliminated. Usually the jobs that replace lower jobs or offset the automation are higher level. Do we actually believe that everyone in society is able to work the higher level jobs? I would think the jobs would need to align to the population's potential.
- pizza234 5y agoTo a certain extent, high level jobs of today are low level jobs of tomorrow. Imagine what one can do today with just a mobile phone, compared to what could be done 50 years ago. Nobody could translate in all the languages 50 years ago; today, anyone do it, without any particular cognitive requirement.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Without basic income, robots (as an analogy for automation) will benefit only its owners. With basic income, that's still true. With fair (rather than preferentially lower) taxes on capital income, that potentially changes, whether or not you have basic income; funding BI with it is just a way of making sure that the taxation isn't redirected back to benefit the same elites.
- 0xy 5y agoThis would be a plausible argument if automation of farming agriculture resulted in 90% of the population being destitute (the vast majority of humans used to work in agri). On the contrary, extreme poverty is at the lowest level ever since agricultural automation was introduced. So, I don't buy this argument. Huge, society changing automation has happened already. We didn't need UBI, and people were lifted out of poverty in huge numbers. This time around, factory and transporation automation will drive the price of commodity goods like food and electronics to just above the cost to create them. After we have an end-to-end automated food production line (from farms, to trucks, to warehouses, to supermarkets, to homes) then the price of food will be so cheap that it's almost free. That's aside from the fact that UBI is not possible economically (it would plunge the disabled into poverty by reducing their welfare, as well as tank the entire government budget). Most UBI proposals would cost in excess of 100% of the US government budget. Which means, no more healthcare, no more roads, no more firefighters.
- autoexec 5y ago> Without basic income, robots (as an analogy for automation) will benefit only its owners. The way tech has been heading I'm guessing robots will primarily benefit the manufacturers. Sure, the wealthy will be able to afford to replace workers with machines and use robots for domestic labor, but the entire time those devices will be spying on their "owners" and reporting everything back to the manufacturers and the state. All of that data will be used by companies to make themselves richer at every opportunity and used by the state to keep uppity citizens in line or discredit them before they can threaten the establishment. I can't say if we'll need basic income or if such a scheme would work (I'd like to see even one example of it working in a society somewhere) but no mater what it means for the workforce I'd be willing to bet the future of automation is going to enrich a very small number of people at the expense of the vast majority
- giantg2 5y agoTime to discuss the paradigm shift in how people, especially the ones traditionally in these low paying jobs are supposed to support themselves in the next generation.
- nsxwolf 5y ago"Deploying the robot allowed a human worker to do different work, increasing output" Sounded like this was win/win here.
- giantg2 5y agoPossibly, but doubtful if we view the full effect. It says that it eliminates the need to hire new workers. What is the next generation to do if the jobs don't exist?
- hourislate 5y agoSeed the Solar System.
- giantg2 5y agoLet's talk about realilistic stuff. Do you think that minimum wage workers are suited for being astronauts? Maybe a small subset can be trained for it, but many probably cannot.
- nsxwolf 5y agoWere they even planning on hiring more workers? And if the robot job scales to 2 robots, isn't it also possible that the other job scales to 2 humans?
- hellisothers 5y agoThe article also quotes them as saying they’re not going to lay people off but also probably not going to hire more employees given this option so future workers are left out. And I imagine that position won’t age well as they may not backfill people who leave if not actively lay people off sooner than later.
- anonporridge 5y agohttps://archive.is/1UJcQ https://archive.is/1UJcQ
- mikewarot 5y agoIf only they hadn't sabotaged the Universal Basic Income that Richard Nixon proposed back in the 1970s, this would be pretty much good news, instead of more to worry about.
- itisit 5y agoI think UBI will be necessary at some point, but I'm not thrilled with the idea of millions of us spending all their waking hours on Netflix and DoorDash.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoClearly the solution is to force people into meaningless toil instead.
- nickpp 5y agoIt’s not meaningless is someone else is willing to pay you a wage to do it. It may be repetitive, boring and crappy, but it has a meaning for the employer.
- zippergz 5y agoHonest question: why? If the things that need to be done in society are getting done, why does it matter what other people spend their time on?
- nickpp 5y agoBecause a society in which everything that needs to be done is getting done - is stagnating. A progressive society always discovers (or invents!) new things needing to be done. And somebody needs to do those things.
- fuzzer37 5y ago> Because a society in which everything that needs to be done is getting done - is stagnating Is that really the worst thing in the world? In an age driven by hyper consumerism and buying new shiny iPhones and other gadgets, do we really need to do more? Can't we just be happy with our accomplishments as a human race and just enjoy? I for one would welcome a stagnant society.
- SllX 5y ago> The robot arm performs a simple, repetitive job: lifting a piece of metal into a press, which then bends the metal into a new shape. And like a person, the robot worker gets paid for the hours it works. So they hired Bender Bending Rodriguez. Fair enough. More seriously, seems like the job market is in a perfect storm for more robots to be hired in workers’ steads. They’re not subject to “vaccine or testing mandates”, in fact they won’t even get COVID, they’re not going to unionize, and they’re not going to quit on you.
- LinuxBender 5y agothey’re not going to unionize This assumes we keep them just complex enough for the job. If computer scientists and developers make Bender too smart or cloud connect them, they may decide to hold a union vote. There was a trial in the science fiction show Star Trek the Next Generation to decide if Lt. Commander Data an android had rights and he won. Curious how far away such a scenario might be.
- SllX 5y agoAt this point my bending friend, that’s still a hypothetical that remains in the “believe it when I see it” phase of development.
- phkahler 5y ago>> They’re not subject to “vaccine or testing mandates”, in fact they won’t even get COVID, they’re not going to unionize, and they’re not going to quit on you. No, but in this article they are being rented by the hour. Once you become dependent on them, their price will go up to whatever some outside company wants it to be - probably a bit above minimum wage and that's only in places where the work area hasn't yet been redesigned with the robot in mind. This will be danger until the robots become more of a commodity item, but that may eventually happen.
- SllX 5y agoMaybe, but at this point in time I have no reason to think that the robot market will be uncompetitive and insulated from other sectors of the economy. Robot-rentals only need to be cheaper than the cost of the employee and deliver the same or approximately the same value to be competitive. Wages are also not the only cost of employees.
- rdtwo 5y agoRobot managers are the future. Low value work isn’t worth using robots for
- breadzeppelin__ 5y ago> Does not compute. Please phrase your standup response in the form of "Yesterday I _____. Today I will _____. I have ____ blockers."
- anonporridge 5y agohttps://marshallbrain.com/manna1 https://marshallbrain.com/manna1
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anonporridge 5y agoTrue until it isn't.
- rdtwo 5y agoThe promised that AI would replace dangerous work but instead it ruthlessly manages disposable workers till they get damaged and then disposes off them because that’s cheaper than actually automation.
- giantg2 5y agoPerhaps they will have more "company culture" than human managers.
- hourislate 5y agoWhat a boon for small businesses. Standing at a punch press is not only tedious but can be dangerous work. That person who did that could spend their time inspecting the stamped parts, loading the material and supervising the robot instead of wearing themselves out doing a repetitive task. Automation doesn't have to replace the complete manufacturing process, just the easy parts.
- deelowe 5y agoThose bits can be pretty easily automated as well.
- giantg2 5y agoOstensibly, if those are necessary jobs, then they are already staffed.
- phkahler 5y ago>> That person who did that could spend their time inspecting the stamped parts, loading the material and supervising the robot instead of wearing themselves out doing a repetitive task. Automation doesn't have to replace the complete manufacturing process, just the easy parts. Automation always reduces labor costs. If the company wants to spend the savings on a human doing something else that's an option, but the notion that automation creates more jobs is false.
- henryfjordan 5y ago> the notion that automation creates more jobs is false This is true in the first-order analysis but history has shown that people with free time will find a way to use their newfound time to create new industry. It wasn't all that long ago that >50% of people were farmers. We don't have 50% unemployment now that we have mega-combines and all the other machinery that has made it so <1% of people need to farm. We won't have 50% unemployment when the robots come to do factory jobs and drive trucks.
- phkahler 5y ago
- msoad 5y agoIt's so fascinating that physical labor seems to be the main concern when it comes to robots doing it better/cheaper than humans. If anything, we know that automation is coming after office desk jobs first. Those jobs are much easier to automate. Language models can read a manuscript and spit out a summary/judgment with much better my friend that has read so many books and evaluate book projects. The "robot" has read more books, can memorize more of the manuscript as it reads it and does it much much much faster. Maybe publishing houses are not comfortable replacing her with an AI but it will eventually happen.
- anonporridge 5y agohttps://marshallbrain.com/manna1 https://marshallbrain.com/manna1
- fekunde 5y agoThis story has stuck with me since I read it many years back. And then seeing it come to life in so many ways where machines are "optimizing" processes and workflows for humans is scary.
- newhouseb 5y ago100%. Even before you need language models, though, there's an insane amount of "digital manual labor" that involved people shuttling files around and validating / cross referencing data in ways that would be done far more correctly and efficiently by software. In my opinion, low code tooling threatens many more jobs than AI does in the short term.
- mxuribe 5y ago> ...low code tooling threatens many more jobs than AI does in the short term. THIS 100%!
- Msw242 5y agoI don't buy it. Low code can make ICs much more productive, but you don't fire the other three... They have a ton of institutional and domain knowledge. You just find things for them to do that wouldn't have been worthwhile without the leverage that came from low code.
- deeg 5y agoIs this really much different from regular automation? It's a robot that performs a menial, simple task. Feels like click bait to me. Edit: new title is much better.
- TechoChamber 5y agoSo I worked on robots for a fair bit of my career before quitting because the reality just didn't mesh with the hype. I've worked on self-driving cars, computer vision applications for automated surveillance, physical robots for warehouse automation similar to what is being described in this article, and more. This is ignoring all the problems with these systems. Workplace injuries are completely ignored, and I have never worked somewhere with a physical robot that did not harm someone at some point, no matter how seriously safety was taken. The reality is, with current tech (which is always improving!) that robots are more dangerous - full stop. https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-54355803 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-54355803 It talks about the simplicity of these systems which is true, but the problem is they're so simple something as weird as changing the color of the box can completely break the system with no resolution. I made up that example because I can't talk about real things that broke the workflow for warehouse automation companies due to NDAs, but they were equally stupid. Basically if you wanted to change anything then the robot usually had to be scrapped and redesigned, which costs millions and takes months or even years. It mentions the theoretical gains of using cheaper robots to replace expensive labor, and this is how these systems are sold to everyone who has never really worked with robots. Speaking for the robotics company, the upfront cost of the robot was usually more than they ever recouped from revenue. When you factor in the cost of maintenance (these robots are monitored by people that make a lot of money), not to mention the R&D then it never turned a profit. Speaking for the warehouses, they would frequently complain about the robots breaking, the inability to get work done, and the biggest complaint was "it's worse than the humans it's supposed to replace." The technology just isn't there yet. I don't know when it will be. If you are interested in research then robotics is a fascinating field. If you are trying to make money by solving real problems that aren't subsidized by VC then it's demoralizing as hell. Most robotics companies never make a good product. Amazon has Kiva Systems which work great, but you'd be surprised that most of their competitors still never figured out how to have positive margins on their products. iRobot had the Roomba which is still going strong with lots of competitors. There are a handful of companies that sell robotic arms that make money. There are a handful of companies that sell sensors that make money (a lot less than you'd think). There are contracts you can get with the military that usually go nowhere. Rodney Brooks, who cofounded iRobot, failed with his cobots approach at Rethink Robotics. There are lots of other failures I haven't mentioned as well. Robots have a long way to go before they're seriously competing with humans.
- monkeydust 5y agoEvery time I read one of the 'automation' pieces I think of the book Manna. If you haven't read it do so, great and short read available here: https://marshallbrain.com/manna1 https://marshallbrain.com/manna1
- joey_bob 5y agoWhich part of Manna does this remind you of?
- antoniuschan99 5y agoI’ve been watching a lot of factory tour videos (most are in China) on YouTube. Especially the electronics kind. I notice that the ones pre-2015 are full of humans and now it’s a lot more machines. On one hand, automation will help bring back manufacturing competitiveness in the West because the capital expenditure is going down (a dobot mg400 which is ~$4k) and labour is essentially $0. On the other hand, what will happen to all the low cost labour in the developing nations? Such as the migrant workers in China? Forget about here in North America where UBI is a possibility - I think we can agree UBI is not possible in low income countries. One thing about all this is that Trades or service jobs such as salons - I don’t see that being automated anytime soon. Btw whenever the topic of Amazon workers comes up I think about the movie Nomadland. Check it out if you haven’t watched it yet.
- dahart 5y ago> I think we can agree UBI is not possible in low income countries. This got me wondering, what is the best analysis of whether UBI is feasible economically for a given country? How low is too low? Does it boil down to something like the difference between average per capita income and average per capita GDP? Or something else; is it possible to afford UBI even if GDP is lower than personal income?
- antoniuschan99 5y agoIf the country is past the middle income trap? . Or if there’s already a universal something (eg. Universal Healthcare)?
- dahart 5y agoI didn’t know what the middle income trap was. I just looked it up and Brazil is one of the 2 examples used on Wikipedia. It appears from a little bit more Googling that Brazil’s GDP is much higher than it’s average income, suggesting that it could afford a UBI, no? (Edit: South Africa is the other one, and it too appears to have higher GDP than income in comparable adjusted PPP dollars.) I might contend that all countries might be able to afford universal healthcare, that universal healthcare is actually less expensive than private for-profit medicine regardless of the size of the economy. While people do contend that publicly funded healthcare might be more expensive, it seems like the main argument these days is that the quality of public healthcare is lower than free-market healthcare. Unfortunately, the US is one of the biggest and best examples of being both more expensive and worse quality than a decent sized list of countries with public healthcare.
- tjbiddle 5y agoOh, wow. Wasn't expecting hardware automation by the title. Figured this would be a piece on how a lot of soloproneurs and SMBs are beginning to use No-Code tools like Integromat and Zapier. I'm an ex-software developer, and I even prefer to use Integromat these days as opposed to writing something myself.
- gidorah 5y agoI am an accountant. Automation is for sure coming for a lot of my jobs. What I have seen is that automation guts out the middling jobs. So, you still need data entry clerks, and you still need "strategy" type roles. But the middle ground are the ones that go, or rather, you don't recruit for those roles. The machines get them.
- thinkagainbro 5y agoIt is honestly the same in tech. The idea/product guy is still there and so are the people piecing it together. But the people in the middle: task masters, documentation writers, manual testers, etc are always being automated away. The middle jobs are under attack. Future jobs will just be feeding the AI til it no longer needs us.
- chris-orgmenta 5y agoLots of comments, as usual for this topic, suffering from what I call "The broken glazier fallacy". In "the broken glass fallacy", windows are smashed. In "the broken glazier fallacy", it's the glaziers who essentially have their arms broken (or at least, their modern tools are confiscated). Automation does not harm the economy or populace at large. The issue is not automation, but the *speed* of automation. We just need to create new jobs faster than we displace then.