4 ms·
With our current technology, could we make a useful radio link to a planet 11 light years away? If so, about when would that have become possible? Last 20 years
by h2odragon 5y ago
With our current technology, could we make a useful radio link to a planet 11 light years away? If so, about when would that have become possible? Last 20 years? My gut says it's still not possible we'd have trouble picking anything out of the noise and the power requirements would take more energy than we manipulate as electricity.
- throw1234651234 5y ago"Look at it this way: the sun to that system barely emits enough energy to make that planet visible to our technology. So, if that planet wanted to send us data, they would have to send as much energy as gets reflected by that planet in our direction. Since you said "as advanced as ours": We're not capable of producing that much power. Not even remotely. So they're not capable of doing that, either. A star is amazingly powerful. Let's look at this way. The estimated power of the sun is something like 1026 W." Thread on SO here: https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/22617/can-we-communicate-with-tau-ceti https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/22617/can-we-commu...
- O5vYtytb 5y agoIf I understand correctly, it's not the light reflected off the exoplanet that we detect, it's the slight dimming of the stars light as the exoplanet transitions between the star and our telescope. I'm not sure what this has to do with a communications link though. It's not like we need as much energy as a star, we can use a directional link like a laser. Sure it'd still need to be massive but while I don't have the math in front of me, it seems like something we could build.
- throw1234651234 5y agoYou are talking about detecting planets as they revolve around the star. As you said, if the planet rotates on an axis that "blocks" a tiny, tiny fraction of the star as we observe it, we see the dimming (that goes away as the planet passes) and can assume a planet and some parameters. You are also right that the conversation is about COMMUNICATION: 1. You either dim the star with a Dyson swarm, or 2. You pulse more power than the star outputs as background noise briefly Neither is all that viable.
- O5vYtytb 5y agoWhy can't you use a laser with a relatively high power? Should be easier to differentiate that from background and star light? Or something more exotic like sweeping wavelengths.
- marcosdumay 5y agoHum... All the other answers on that thread are variations of "yes, we could, here's an example of how" with the examples varying from one widely impractical idea to "here is how we do something similar by accident today, we just have to control it". If we had to overpower the Sun to communicate, we wouldn't use radio on Earth either.
- throw1234651234 5y agoHaving followed that answer for years and read quite a bit, I am fairly certain that the "yes, but" answers are wrong. It's as simple as "you can't see a flashlight when it's being flicked on and off behind a lighthouse lamp". I am very interested in the topic.
- marcosdumay 5y agoWell, I'd suggest a basic introduction to optics. You seem unaware of the existence of lenses and mirrors. "What kind of mirror we would need to send a signal 10 light years away" is a much more reasonable question. And one of the answers there is about it.
- throw1234651234 5y agoYou mean mirror that's out of the way of the sun and is huge, or a mirror swarm. Do elaborate how you imagine this working in practice.
- ninjanomnom 5y agoIf we had to emit light just like a flashlight vs a lighthouse, aka roughly equivalent wavelengths, you'd be right, however we only have to beat the sun in a single wavelength. An extreme uv laser is probably the easiest option there. We also only need to beat the sun's output in a single pinpoint (in cosmic scale) Also to damage the example a bit, we can easily detect a flashlight shining from behind a lighthouse. Our eyes are just logarithmic and suck at detecting smaller absolute differences like that. Isaac Arthur does a good video on this topic and talks about some of the specifics of such a beacon starting at around 14 minutes https://youtu.be/DHoOjIEcRV8?t=829 https://youtu.be/DHoOjIEcRV8?t=829
- tjpnz 5y agoI haven't read enough on the subject to know the answer to that question, so here's another one. How do we know that ET uses radio for communication? They might've moved onto something else. Tachyons or gravitational waves might make good candidates but those are just the ones we know about. For those two we do have instruments sensitive enough to detect potential WOW signals, just not a lot of will for them to be used for that purpose.
- joe__f 5y agoIt may be possible to use gravitational waves to transmit signals, although gravity is hugely more challenging to manipulate than electromagnetism because it's purely attractive and interacts much less strongly with matter, making this very unlikely in my opinion. Another theoretically plausible but very unlikely signal carrier could be neutrinos. 'Tachyon' is a name used to refer to any theoretical particle which travels faster than the speed of light; as far as I'm aware all current experimental evidence rules out the existence of tachyons.
- PeterisP 5y agoOut of all the physical phenomena we know about, EM (various aspects of it, radio or lasers or whatever) is the best way to transmit information across space. Tachyons are fictional, there's no reason to assume they exist. Gravitational waves require exceptionally large amounts of energy to generate; we can't transmit with them, and for a more advanced civilization which does have that capability, using the same amount of energy for a focused/directional EM transmission would be much easier to detect; because gravitational waves (unlike EM) radiate equally in all directions but EM can be directed to a particular recipient. Neutrinos are similar to EM but worse, as their transmission/power characteristics are pretty much the same but it's very difficult to detect them.
- tjpnz 5y agoToo late to edit my comment but regarding tachyons what I really meant was neutrinos. Clearly I've been watching too much Star Trek.
- analog31 5y agoA massive object flying at a substantial fraction of the speed of light would be better for communication over very long range. Sure, the overall latency would be greater, but a massive object doesn't suffer from the inverse-square law if you know where you want to send it, and doesn't need a larger antenna to make it more directional. If it's some kind of programmable or even intelligent machine, then it could adapt to the evolution of conditions at its destination upon arrival, and engage in many iterations of short distance communications before sending data homeward. It's like why we sent human envoys during the era when communication speeds were limited by horses and ships. ET has probably given up on long range radio for their local comms, just as we have. The bulk of our comms go through waveguides (electrical cables and optical fibers). Even our radio comms have relatively short range, and are designed to be virtually indistinguishable from noise. It's as if we've wrapped ourselves in a primitive Dyson sphere.