5 ms·
Pricing electricity so low that bitcoin mining is profitable during peak hours is absurd. We should tax the hell out of every ounce of carbon emitted and use m
by scotty79 5y ago
Pricing electricity so low that bitcoin mining is profitable during peak hours is absurd.
We should tax the hell out of every ounce of carbon emitted and use money from this tax to pay basic income so that people are able to live with increased prices. Free market will sort the rest out
Energy is so cheap that some renewables could be decomissioned if not for bitcoin: https://www.reuters.com/technology/costa-rica-hydro-plant-gets-new-lease-life-crypto-mining-2022-01-11/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/costa-rica-hydro-plant-ge...
- sigmaprimus 5y ago>>> We should tax the hell out of every ounce of carbon emitted and use money from this tax to pay basic income so that people are able to live with increased prices. Free market will sort the rest out Sarcasm?
- gambiting 5y agoI don't see why you think this is sarcasm. Sounds very reasonable to me.
- cyphertruck 5y agoHow will taxes improve the environment? They will give politicians more power to oppress, snd since governments are the largest polluters in the world the environment will get worse. Which they will use as an excuse for more taxes. See the pattern? —— This comment has two further comments, both of which ask questions. But since this comment is heavily downvoted, I cannot reply to the replies to answer the questions. In short: no such thing as “negative externalities”, thats just make-believe to whitewash oppression and poverty creation. Taxes are not a market signal by definition. Its interesting how blithely people accept using violence to force others to comply with their wishes. If you really wanted to reduce CO2 you would support safe clean nuclear. But CO2 isnt causing warming- its historically low, earth started at %100 CO2. Plants evolved to need levels 5 times higher than present. Increased CO2 would improve the environment. We had an ICE AGE at 10 times higher CO2 then now. ETC. Unfortunately Government propaganda has replace science education.
- scotty79 5y agoTaxes infom the market about externalities. Taxing carbon emission significantly sends price signal to every actor in the market that uses products and services that have carbon emission upstream to maybe reduce usage of such products and services or switch to another.
- ogogmad 5y agoGovernments have a role in taxing negative externalities. What alternative do libertarians like you have? Forgetting whether or not you believe in climate change, if it does indeed exist as a possibility, what would libertarians like you do about it? Your comment is blatant virtue signalling -- it's taking a moral high ground without providing any alternatives. [edit] At least you've provided an alternative now: nuclear energy. Then again, you only did it when pushed to.
- espadrine 5y agoI also don’t think it is sarcasm, but I don’t think it is reasonable. > We should tax the hell out of every ounce of carbon emitted and use money from this tax to pay basic income so that people are able to live with increased prices. So far so good. > Free market will sort the rest out Under free market, the basic income will cause a further price increase, rendering the effort moot. Subsidizing energy, as Kosovo and Kazakhstan have been doing (resulting in the same consequences on coin mining and crackdown), is necessary, and thus so are the consequences.
- hectormalot 5y agoNo it doesn’t. Example, imagine you currently have a energy bill of $1000p.a. With the proposal above, we’ll move you to a $3000p.a. bill with CO2 taxes. And, we’ll give you $2000p.a. to compensate for the increased energy bill. Would you really just keep paying more for energy because you have that? The payback period on solar panels just went *0.3, batteries just became a affordable option for day/night balancing, many alternative investments in renewable energy just became profitable. Many people will use that opportunity to get ahead financially. I think that’s what GP meant with “the free market will sort out the rest”
- espadrine 5y agoI’m not exactly sure we are disagreeing. > we’ll give you $2000p.a. to compensate for the increased energy bill. Would you really just keep paying more for energy because you have that? In the suggested policy I was replying to, the $2k would decrease if I (and many others) switched to renewable. That loss would muddy the gains, discouraging the switch. Besides, the methods you are describing tend to have high upfront costs. Hence, the need for subsidizing instead, something very close, but without a negative-feedback-loop incentive. To be fair, while that is a reasonable policy (and why so many countries enact it), I would favor requiring each company to be individually carbon-neutral, with an exponential penalty. As a result, it is not a tax which could weaken the vulnerable, and yet it forces companies to choose between reducing their negative externalities, and bankruptcy. But computing carbon-neutrality is hard.
- sigmaprimus 5y agoWell it is either sarcasm or ignorance to say that Taxes, UBI and a Free Market could ever exist in the same economy or be part any economic device. I'm thinking probably ignorance as the comment also thinks that raising the costs of energy used to produce BTC will somehow make it less profitable to mine when in fact it will simply increase commodity value and most likely drive more interest and increase speculation thus consuming more energy.
- imtringued 5y agoYou give everyone equal amounts of co2 tokens. CO2 pollution costs tokens. You have now democratized CO2 pollution. Every single person gets to decide how much pollution they want in the world. Replace pollution tokens with dollars and taxes and you have the same democratic system.
- qsort 5y agohttps://ec.europa.eu/clima/eu-action/eu-emissions-trading-system-eu-ets_en https://ec.europa.eu/clima/eu-action/eu-emissions-trading-sy...
- McTossOut 5y ago
- roenxi 5y agoThe article sayeth: > ...as part of emergency measures to ease a crippling energy crisis. They aren't identifying "electricity is too cheap" as the problem. And it doesn't sound like the climate crisis is on their radar right now.
- ewindal 5y agoIncreasing the energy prices isn’t a solution. It’d affect to poor disproportionally, while also being greatly destabilizing for society at large. It’s basically a flat tax for heating your home. Norway recently experienced its highest energy prices ever, in large part because of tighter coupling with the European market. Some people got bills 10x of previous years. Using less energy simply isn’t an option here, otherwise you freeze to death, or damage your home. It led to a massive political outcry that was easily exploitable by populists. You can’t go back on decades of energy policy in that short a time frame, and you can’t do it without easing the tax burden somewhere else. The current government in Norway is polling extremely low. So low they probably won’t recover by the next election in 3 years. And they didn’t even cause the spike in energy prices here. I dread to imagine what would happen if a government intentionally hiked the enrgy prices just to stop bitcoin miners…
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- scotty79 5y agoThat's why poor (and for simplicity everybody) should be subsidized to counteract the effect of taxing carbon. Then this tax will only influence economy making ways of doing things that don't emit carbon insanely competitive.
- iqanq 5y agoIt's not a free market if we tax it to distort it.
- WA 5y agoIt’s not a free market if some costs are externalized to society instead of priced in. Like pollution.
- iqanq 5y agoThere is absolutely no way to set a fair price for something like that. We have no way of knowing the cost, if there is any at all.
- cube2222 5y agoSure there is. The cost of emitting a ton of carbon should ideally be the cost of capturing a ton of carbon. Managed in a free market kind of way. Same way you pay i.e. for electricity. If you can get somebody to capture it for 1$, well, good for you. If there are only buyers for -10000$, then that's your problem. We're not there yet as far as carbon capture goes, but I do think we'll get there.
- iqanq 5y agoWhich is exactly what I said. We don't know how much it will cost to capture that carbon, so we can't set a price, so it's unfair to set any price. What if we figure out something good to do with that carbon, and capturing it becomes profitable? Should we return all that money to those it was stolen from?
- cube2222 5y agoCurrently we deem it not desirable, so it's alright to me if we price it very high, thus stimulating investment in this area to bring the cost down or even make it profitable.
- 5y ago
- 0x_rs 5y agoIt's an odd leap from electricity prices to carbon tax to basic income. And with free market as a cherry on top! There are better, more effective ideas that are effectively ignored rather than disrupting the economic and financial systems in place and letting "free market sort it out" as if it were ever possible in such a scenario. For one such example, immediately ban or heavily tax the sale of massively polluting vehicles such as SUVs, that as a category pollute as much as UK and Netherlands combined [0], making road circulation safer in the process too, and riding the wave of EV getting more adoption. But this won't happen, since it's a successful industry with a strong lobby behind it. And as per usual, concrete is the major culprit of CO2 emissions. That's where one could look for opportunities (such as reprocessing plants where emissions are redirected) and stricter regulations. Don't increase prices like so many in Germany feel would be the right thing to do, it only impacts those who can't afford better housing (insulation, heating efficiency). 0. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/sep/01/suv-conquered-america-climate-change-emissions https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/sep/01/suv-conquere...
- DennisP 5y agoIt's not an odd leap at all. The core problem is that we don't pay for the externalities of fossil fuels. If we fix that, then the next question is what to do with the money, and a simple, efficient, and equitable answer is to return it to the population, equal amount per person. That's why carbon fee-and-dividend is a popular proposal with the support of a lot of economists.
- lapinot 5y agoI'm all in to ban SUV. But by doing that you're gonna threaten the masculinity and sense of identity of a large set of people. Intelligent politicians will use this to drift the debate into elite green progressists vs working class who just want a piece of the cake. To not get into this minefield lets not forget that corporations acount for a very large part of energy use and that perhaps useless transport of useless goods should be restricted, also restricting putting energy-intensive electronics in gadgets that don't need them.. There are tons of measures that can target corporations that will be easier to control, have more measurable and predictable outcomes and won't contribute to desintegrate the social cohesion and will stop the working class from getting eaten up by the far right.
- laurent92 5y ago
- geertj 5y ago> Pricing electricity so low that bitcoin mining is profitable during peak hours is absurd. Electricity is not just a discretionary commodity, it serves an essential need enabling our modern society. It makes no sense to increase electricity prices and hike up inflation for the common person in an effort to dissuade crypto miners. If we really wanted to go that way, a better solution IMO is to introduce two electricity rates, one for things that perform useful services (by broad positive impact to society) and one other for PoW crypto mining.
- scotty79 5y agoIt's not to dissuade bitcoin mining. It's to move us away from emitting carbon as fast as possible. Crypto is just sideshow. Carbon emission are not priced according to their future impact. We need to price it correctly. And it's better to overcorrect rhan undercorrect. The only downside is that this pricing will propagate into the economy (as it should). When it reaches people that can no longer afford to live we can prevent them from dying by giving them money we got from tax.