17 ms·
BBC licence fee to be abolished in 2027 and funding frozen
- open-source-ux 5y ago'Linear TV' (broadcast TV) is dead and the BBC probably have known this for some time. The idea of a TV schedule feels antiquated today amid unprecedented on-demand content. On commercial streaming services, only prestige series (seasons) are released weekly, everything else gets a whole series released in one go. (The BBC already does this on iPlayer for some series.) It's worth remembering that the BBC is a Public Service Broadcaster (PSB) and does vastly more than YouTube or Netflix. - News: the world's largest news organisation - TV: everything from drama to documentaries to kids programmes - Radio: national radio stations (covering every music genre + speech), 40+ local radio stations, and the World Service. - Kids TV: ad-free TV kids programmes with strict guidelines on commercial influences and product placement. - Education: massive educational content for schools (Bitesize) that has no commercial equivalent. (Who else other than BBC would launch the micro:bit project in schools with all the related educational resources to support it?) - Music: promotes new music artists, funds 5 orchestras, runs the world's largest classical music festival (the Proms). Provides live music festival coverage (Glastonbury, Leeds, Reading etc) - Accessibility: 100% of recorded programmes subtitled, + a proportion of audio-signed and signed programmes The list goes on. Even simply browsing the BBC news website is one of the few news websites in the UK that is ad-free (if you are outside the UK browsing the BBC website, you're probably seeing ads). Not all the above will disappear with a different funding model, but it's likely that the BBC will be slimmed down. (And that is something BBC critics will want to see happen.) Aside: Nadine Dorries is minister for 'Digital, Culture, Media and Sport' - the BBC falls under the remit of this department. Dorries didn't even know that Channel 4 (another PSB in the UK) does not receive any public funds (it is funded by advertising). When this was pointed out to her when facing other politicians, she babbled incoherently unable to admit her error. Make up you own mind about the calibre of this politician: https://www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/nadine-dorries-channel-4-public-service-broadcaster-302429/ https://www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/nadine-dorries-channe...
- ur-whale 5y agoIf, as you say, they're so indispensable and useful, they should have zero worries making their money like everyone else instead of plundering the public by force, including those would don't want to consume what they produce.
- dbbk 5y agoThis "linear TV is dead" mantra is just not true, and not supported by data. Linear TV is still extraordinarily popular in the UK across all age demographics. The most viewed shows last year got over 10m viewers. Young people watch Love Island live at huge numbers. You're not going to get an 80 year old binge watching Countryfile on Netflix. Not everyone wants to switch to that viewing model.
- open-source-ux 5y agoGood points. However, on-demand streaming has changed people expectations around content availability. A weekly show on linear TV makes sense when it's topical (e.g. Countryfile or news-related), if it's a reality contest with a finale (e.g. Love Island, The Apprentice) or a prestigious drama with cliff-hanger ending. Even the idea of TV channels makes little sense today unless those channels reflect a genre or theme (e.g. The Arts Channel or the Horror channel). I suspect most people in the UK would struggle to describe the purpose or differences between BBC channels. Streaming services (including iPlayer) reflect what probably makes sense to most people - the genre or theme of the programme. BBC linear channels are increasingly irrelevant.
- themihai 5y ago>> Time now to discuss and debate new ways of funding, supporting and selling great British content. Perhaps it's time for the BBC to "beg for money" from the government every 4 years and do something in exchange for that(i.e. less critical to gov actions, more propaganda etc).
- lampe3 5y agoSo they become state tv? Then why have them at all? Why not call it <INSER_CURRENT_RULING_PARTY_NAME> TV?
- jokethrowaway 5y agoState TVs don't necessarily represent the current party. I've seen plenty of examples of state TVs siding with the opposition in various countries. Media and journalists mostly have a left bias and when there is a right government they won't side with the government, unless the government is a de facto dictatorship and you can't go against it for safety concerns (Russia comes to mind). Not that I justify state TVs at all - I'm against all forms of taxation - but bias is not one of the issues imho.
- pydry 5y agoThe BBC couldn't have been more blatantly favoring the incumbent party in the last election. Everything from measurably giving critics of the opposition 2x the airtime of supporters to editing footage to cut out their audience booing the prime minister. They are critical of the government sometimes (e.g. right now) but their editorial line follows what the investor owned press is saying. They havent been independently critical since their independence was curtailed after the David Kelly whitewash, IIRC. Where they lean "left" it is by placing prominence on issues like women's rights, gay rights, veganism, pronoun politics, etc. and other "leftish" issues nonthreatening to powerful interests (a form of left https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recuperation_(politics) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recuperation_(politics) ). They downplay strikes and most protests (including antivaxxers).
- foepys 5y ago
- Incerto 5y agoThis is long Long long overdue. Fantastic news.
- pseudolus 5y agoThe following pretty much lays out the mentality behind the cuts: "The source added that 'the days of state-run TV are over' and praised the growth of US-run companies such as Netflix and YouTube." Yes, let's run to our algorithmically run and siloed future.
- iso1210 5y agoNothing to do with stuff like this: Michael Fabricant, the Conservative MP for Lichfield, has said that the BBC has launched a “coup attempt” against Boris Johnson after hearing a news bulletin which criticised the PM over lockdown parties held at No. 10. Speaking yesterday, Mr Fabricant said: “BBC Radio 4 Bulletin leads this morning with a manufactured story of what some MPs have said to the BBC. This is not news reporting an event. This relentless news creation is a coup attempt against the prime minister”. It would be like CNN quoting a democrat senator saying that the democrat president is terrible. Yes, that's news.
- sbuk 5y agoIs there any irony is his surname?
- spongeb00b 5y agoI legitimately thought I was looking at a parody when I first saw a still from a TV interview of him
- _moof 5y agoWait'll you see his hair.
- makomk 5y agoThat's obviously pissing off the government right now, but honestly it's the least of the problems with their Covid-19 news coverage. They kept on pushing both false and misleading claims about the UK doing worse at stuff than other countries, in at least one case that I know of for a month in an article linked from the BBC news front page after they became aware it was false. (The government made a big deal about reaching 100,000 Covid tests in a day and the BBC wrongly claimed Germany had done this a month earlier. In reality they'd mistaken Germany's stat for their lab capacity to process Covid tests - which was basically irrelevant because everything else, from the ability to swap people to the availiabily of consumables to even just returning test results, was more of a bottleneck there - for actual Covid testing done, and Germany wouldn't hit this until like a month later. Then when people complained they took it down for a day, supposedly discussed the complaints with senior staff, and then decided to reinstate it and kept it for a month whilst using Covid as an excuse to not respond to complaints. They then quietly memory-holed it from the article and used that as an excuse for not publishing a correction. A previous version of the article also did a similar thing by wrongly comparing the UK's daily stat to France's weekly one - that did get a correction, which was quietly memory-holed too after a few days. Obviously this played right into all the usual narratives about our lying Brexit-supporting leaders.) There's also obviously a lot of decisions during the pandemic where all options had downsides, and the BBC News coverage was very biased towards the downsides of whatever the government did - this became particularly clear when the government changed their mind and suddenly they flipped to going after the thing they were cheerleading before. One that HN is likely familiar with is the NHS contact tracing app using Bluetooth on mobile phones. Initially that didn't use Google and Apple's framework and the BBC coverage pushed the downsides of that heavily, making it sound like there was no good reason to do it and the claim that Google and Apple's framework made results less accurate was just something the government was pushing. Literally the day the new app using that framework launched, they started downplaying the downsides of the old app and found a experts to claim the new app was less accurate and excluded a bunch of people on earlier Android versions - again, these were inherent downsides of choosing that option. Everything was like this, from lockdowns to vaccinations. Even when the government picked some kind of middle ground option, the Beeb ran articles with some groups attacking the government for not doing less, then with others attacking them for not doing more, and both were always set against the government rather than against each others' demands. Often they'd even rewrite an article on their website and flip it from pushing heavily for one to pushing hard for the other after it'd been published, which is just weird. There was also the incident where one of their high-up reporters retweeted a particularly partisan tweet pushing the idea Boris was literally a criminal murderer who should go to jail over the UK's handling of Covid, which rather hinted at why their coverage was like this.
- new_guy 5y ago
- iso1210 5y agoBBC Tech salaries are awful, even by UK standards. Good luck for getting more efficient when you're not paying anyone to disrupt workflows.
- johnday 5y agoJobs at the BBC are often seen as having more value than pure pay, because of two related factors: (1) The BBC is a British institution and supporting it is seen as a worthwhile act. The same effect is what keeps teachers' and nurses' pay artificially low; (2) Jobs at the BBC have historically been seen as "for life", because of the entity's perceived stability. I'll be interested to see what happens to both of those factors over the next decade.
- gigabates 5y agoThis is in a large part because of the fact that salaries are paid with "license payers' money" and the scrutiny that comes with this.
- bennysomething 5y agoGood. Currently I'm forced to pay for content I dont consume.
- iso1210 5y agoI don't need to pay for a license fee because I don't watch TV. I watch Netflix, amazon, apple, disney etc. I still pay it because I'm listening to radio 2 at the moment, and have the news website in the background. While legally I don't need a license fee for that, it feels wrong to not be contributing. Unless you're some weird boomer still paying £600 a year for a sky subscription to watch shit TV broken by adverts, I'm not sure why you'd pay a license fee (unless of course you actually watch BBC output)
- ThePadawan 5y agoGreat to here that this works in the UK. The Swiss equivalent has simply declared that "any device capable of using the internet" can also receive television programs, and thus isn't exempt. So no one with a computer or smartphone is exempt. (At least this "solves" the apparent problem that UK residents can't watch some UK TV content online for free, while the rest of the world can)
- hadrien01 5y agoI have the exact same position here in France. I don't have to pay the TV license because I don't have a TV, but I still do because I consume so much content made by public media organisations (Franceinfo, Arte, Radio France, etc.).
- Nextgrid 5y agoI'm in the same position as you (don't watch license-requiring content, but appreciate other BBC content such as their website) but I refuse to pay the license out of principle as to not encourage/support their bullshit approach at enforcement. I disagree with the idea of generating insane amounts of paper waste (and sometimes sending crooks in-person) to threaten less scam-savvy people into paying for a license they don't need, especially when said people might be lower-income that can't afford paying for a license "out of charity" if they aren't required to by law.
- ssddanbrown 5y agoI like much of what the BBC do and produce, especially BBC news, but the licence fee has always felt like a relic from the past with a bad strategy of enforcement (With their threatening letters and misguiding terminology as to when a license is required). Their actual broadcast service is lacking in some areas too. On BBC One HD I still get a blank place-holder screen for local news, advising to switch to the non-HD channel, which is just bizarre at this point, 10 years after support for HD viewing. I hope the BBC continues to survive, just with a more modern funding approach.
- ssddanbrown 5y agoFor those interested, this website provides a great listing of TV licensing letters: http://www.bbctvlicence.com/ http://www.bbctvlicence.com/
- Nextgrid 5y agoIt is insane that this kind of bullshit is tolerated. I don't believe any other company would get away with frequent, regular threats and misrepresentation of their level of authority.
- iso1210 5y agoI think a lot of the problem is the aged technology where the regional news is routed via each region. Even just upscaling the local output requires massive changes, and any money for Engineering is rarely invested in old fashioned technology like over the air broadcasting, There's then the spectrum costs, especially on satellite, to broadcast an extra 13 HD channels.
- ssddanbrown 5y agoI'd be happy with upscaling but sure, can understand that may be difficult. I haven't renewed my license in a while but every-time I visit my parents they're watching the non-HD channels due to not getting the local news on HD.
- deleted 5y ago
- OwlsParlay 5y agoGetting rid of the licence fee is long overdue, but strangling the BBC as part of cutbacks is just sad.
- aaaaaaaaaaab 5y agoI don’t know a single person who pays the TV loicense anyway…
- chrisseaton 5y agoThe BBC's version of the article at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-60014514 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-60014514. > The BBC has declined to comment. Nothing more BBC than the BBC writing an article about the BBC saying that the BBC haven't commented.
- odiroot 5y agoThis is great journalistic integrity. I applaud them for that.
- chrisseaton 5y agoReporting on yourself is the polar opposite of journalistic integrity. Reporting on yourself but not even noting to the reader that you're reporting on yourself is worse yet. Writing a named-author analysis piece about yourself, which they have here at the end of the article, is reaching insanity level. The BBC shouldn't report on the BBC.
- gruez 5y ago> Reporting on yourself is the polar opposite of journalistic integrity. 1. are there any news outlets that abides by this rule? 2. if I get my news from listening to BBC on the radio or whatever, then am I just out of luck? >Reporting on yourself but not even noting to the reader that you're reporting on yourself is worse yet. I get how including a disclosure makes sense if the affiliation isn't obvious (eg. washington post reporting on amazon), but do you really need a disclaimer to let the reader know that the BBC in the article is the same BBC that wrote the article?
- chrisseaton 5y ago> are there any news outlets that abides by this rule? Maybe not - but others are their own business, rather than funded by a tax on the people like the BBC. And the BBC do seem to be particularly weird and breathless about reporting on themselves. They've edited the article in place and they're now quoting insider knowledge from an anonymous tip-off... that they've given themselves. It's like that in other areas as well - people working at the BBC once commissioned a sitcom about... people working at the BBC. And when they report on the winner of one of their game shows as news, or when they report that it's a headline that someone said something in an interview from their own interview shows. > if I get my news from listening to BBC on the radio or whatever, then am I just out of luck? For getting objective reporting on the BBC then yeah you are, either way. Is that surprising? Obviously they can't objectively report on themselves. I think they should possibly have a headline on the front page, but it should link to another outlet's reporting. But then choosing the outlet isn't objective either.
- gundamdoubleO 5y agoI remember receiving a fair amount of threatening letters about the TV licence as a student, shortly after I moved out of my parents place to attend university. It was extremely confusing and made me a little anxious. Not only did I not own a TV or watch TV of any kind, even online, any effort to make this clear fell on deaf ears and the threatening letters continued. Eventually it became normality and I learned to drone them out of my conscience but it was such a strange concept to me back then. I'm just thankful I never got anyone knocking on my door demanding to check my room.
- Nextgrid 5y agoI would love for someone to come and visit. I'd take great pleasure in wasting as much of their time as possible and make them believe I'm about to sign up for a license via them (they get commission) just to get these assholes' hopes up. Unfortunately Capita (the company license management is subcontracted to) must really be unlucky with the "investigators" they employ because according to their letters over a dozen "investigations" have been open against me but I have yet to see anyone. /s
- dazc 5y ago'Wasting much of their time' though would likely result is someone justifying his/her job by going along with it. Much the same with HMRC (UK tax authority) there is no matter too trivial that they are not willing to spend limitless amounts of time and energy investigating - purely because they can.
- Nextgrid 5y agoI believe the goons are underpaid and make the bulk of their money through commissions (which also encourages their shitty - and potentially fraudulent & unlawful behavior), thus wasting a lot of their time without taking out a license in the end will make a loss for them.
- nickkell 5y agoOne friend at uni had his TV with him, but refused to pay the license fee, completely ignoring the numerous letters we all received. A couple of other friends in our halls hid it whilst he was gone for the holidays and left a fake letter informing him it had been confiscated for non-compliance. Very amusing (for everyone else) when he returned!
- in3d 5y agoSome trivia: TV detector vans https://hackaday.com/2021/01/18/tv-detector-vans-once-prowled-the-streets-of-england/ https://hackaday.com/2021/01/18/tv-detector-vans-once-prowle...
- fiftyacorn 5y agoI have issues with the BBC - especially its partisan news reporting on the current government and its performance during the Scottish independence referendum, but would still like it to exist I find BBC drama is consistently of a high quality - and unlike the paid services i can watch 6 episodes and its pretty much ended. Everything on netflix/prime is like 10 seasons of 20 episodes Sad times - but im sure Rupert Murdoch will be happy
- iso1210 5y ago> especially its partisan news reporting on the current government Is that pro-government or anti-government in your view?
- fiftyacorn 5y agoThey are pro-government, pro-union - but the point is BBC news should be non-partisan
- Proven 5y ago
- midasuni 5y agoThe government doesn’t appear to have noticed this bias
- Freskis 5y agoI would say most UK people consider the BBC to be impartial and neutral, except perhaps for people with more extreme political opinions.
- pessimizer 5y ago> except perhaps for people with more extreme political opinions. Like the people who supported Corbyn, or Scottish independence? You're characterizing people who were a few points from winning as extremists.
- cracrecry 5y agoOne of the great things of the Licence fee was that the Government does not get to control the national TV like it does when the one who pays is it directly. In places like Spain the national TV(and regional TV too) becomes a propaganda machine for the exclusive service of the Government(s, national and regional). It is awful to have your taxes redirected for the private interest of the Party in charge. In fact with the crisis and private TV also being subsidized, the Media is being captured like the Gramma, Pravda, or Global Times, when the government never can go wrong or do mistakes.
- cromka 5y ago> In places like Spain Spain? Spain pales in comparison with Poland. Where they collect the license fee, too.
- tyingq 5y agoDepends on what you compare. State control of television given things like the Catalonian crisis probably swing the bar.
- EL_Loco 5y agoPoland? Poland pales in comparison with Brazil, where there's a R$5.7 billion (about 1 billion US$) 'Electoral Fund' used for political campaings by the thirty something registered political parties. All paid for by the taxpayers. And let's not forget that there's also a 'Political Party Fund'. And I just love the reason for the creation of the 'Electoral Fund', but that's another story.
- Hokusai 5y agoAre not that funds created so taxpayers are there ones in control of party finances instead of corporations? The USA seems a good example of what happens when politicians are fully dependent on corporations if they want to be elected, and it's servitude to the interest of the few.
- 5y ago
- mcintyre1994 5y agoI’m not sure how much cut through this has had outside of the UK, but the government are currently in serious trouble because of constant leaks about parties in Number 10 Downing Street during the pandemic - including a particularly poorly timed one the day before the Queen was photographed at her husband’s funeral alone. The leaks are ongoing, so we know that this particular plan is part of “Operation Red Meat”, which might be familiar if you’ve heard “red meat for the base”. That’s what this is. It’s going to cause serious problems for the BBC while this government remains in power, but this isn’t a serious proposal for the future of that organisation. It’s an effort to get furious Conservative supporters back on side and secure Boris Johnson’s position. Other aspects of Operation Red Meat are reported to be military involvement at the Channel Crossing, and a ban on alcohol in Number 10. There’s another set of plans called Operation Save Big Dog too, which mostly seem to involve firing a bunch of other senior figures. Some more info: https://www.politics.co.uk/news-in-brief/pm-working-on-series-of-policy-announcements-dubbed-operation-red-meat-to-win-back-voters/ https://www.politics.co.uk/news-in-brief/pm-working-on-serie...
- HWR_14 5y agoOnly to answer your question about the party scandals - it totally made its way across the Atlantic. The severity of the scandal has been stated but is not obvious (Boris May lose his prime ministership over this?) However, it was drowned out by the ouster of Phillip.
- onphonenow 5y agoWhat I don't get is why the conservatives were so draconian over covid. Your partner is dying, you can't see them. Folks couldn't walk around outside. Some guy driving to walk around outside was like national news. I mean, if you go to this extreme, and then are throwing parties. (Rules for thee, not for me) it would make me furious as well. Let me go sit on the beach with sunshine and fresh air instead of having to cram into a grocery store or whatever. In the US DeSantis or whatever right wing politico could easily go to a public event, not because its a good idea, but because they haven't banned others from going to activities.
- blowski 5y agoI don’t like discussing politics on here, but… i am extremely sceptical whether he has the political capital right now to see through such a radical move. This is part of “Operation Red Meat” in which Boris Johnson attempts to hold on to support of his party by giving the right-wing of his party everything it dreams of. In other words “turn a blind eye to the corruption and incompetence, and we’ll prioritise every policy you’ve ever dreamed of”. It’s been the same strategy from mainstream parties in UK and US for the last few years, particularly well-executed by the right. If it works again, Boris Johnson will be the winner, while the British political system will be the big loser.
- barcoder 5y agoThe yearly licence always seems like a hefty amount to pay. Whereas other services offer month to month with special deals. It's still a crying shame watching the BBC be destroyed by the Conservatives, but hopefully the BBC will rise to the challenge. With some funding from government and a decent worldwide subscription model they could be a real content force.
- dijit 5y agoWhat is interesting is that the BBC have been reporting recently on the sitting government's complete disregard for their own rules w.r.t lockdowns. It began with Matt Hancock breaking COVID distancing rules and cheating on his wife with his aide. Now it's a slow burn leak of more and more damning evidence that they've held parties- while the police force have openly stated that they "do not prosecute crimes retroactively". All in all it's a bit of a shit-show and I'm not convinced that this isn't a form of retribution, especially since yesterday a tory backbencher accused the BBC of trying to incite a coup against the conservative government: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/michael-fabrican-coup-attempt-bbc-boris-johnson-b1993807.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/michael-fabri...
- neilsense 5y agoThis issue has been going on well before C19. The BBC have abused their power and it is absolutely ridiculous that people have to pay license fees to them when media has changed so much.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoHappy about this. I decided to never pay it again after buying a TV on Amazon (for videogames only) and that action and my address being shared with the BBC so they could harass me to pay it. Insane breach of my rights and privacy from what is essentially a TV Channel. Still get harassed by them once every two years or so where you have to tell them again that no you are not interested or they’ll “open an investigation”. Of course BBC like to pretend this isn’t them by having a fake organization “TV Licensing” to make it sound like some government arm. BBC is a shadow of its former self, I’d have been happy to pay in the 90s and 00s but I haven’t seen them produce anything of quality in the last decade.
- gsmith7890 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- LatteLazy 5y agoThe death of over of the last great British institutions
- beardyw 5y agoIt seems to me that this might encourage the rank and file at the BBC to wish for a change of government. I wonder if they have considered that?
- i5heu 5y ago
- nickhalfasleep 5y agoCan they run advertisements? For Curries, football, and other English things?
- amriksohata 5y agoState funded media is outdated and then model is all about subscription now. Why force people to pay for a TV licence!! Just for having a tv
- simonblack 5y agoBritain is following the Australian Government model of reducing funding for the national broadcast commission. There is no mention in the article, but in Australia at least the funding to the ABC and SBS networks was reduced because of heavy lobbying by the Murdoch Media in order to reduce competition to their Foxtel cable/satellite TV media. Murdoch is powerful in Britain too. I would not be at all surprised to discover that there has been 'behind the scenes' pressure on the Government from Murdoch to phase out the BBC also.