4 ms·
To provide more insight, this is what the process is: * There are two new entitlements related to this, which you ask Apple to give you if you're a dating app.
by saagarjha 5y ago
To provide more insight, this is what the process is:
* There are two new entitlements related to this, which you ask Apple to give you if you're a dating app.
* Once you get the entitlements, you need to create a new version of your app (it cannot be the same as your international one) that will ship exclusively in the Netherlands with that entitlement.
* Details of how this entitlement work will come at a later date.
* Apple will still charge a commission on these purchases, the details of which will also come at a later date.
* It is your privilege/responsibility to conflict resolution with regards to refunds and such.
In essence, Apple complied with the law in the narrowest terms they could, but they did indeed change things and I suspect many companies will go through this process even if it's made somewhat inconvenient. I guess what remains to be seen is if these entitlements slowly get rolled out in other countries as they also enact legislation to require it.
- imchillyb 5y ago> ...Apple complied with the law... This is the only part that matters here. Doesn't matter how narrowly the law was complied with. Laws are the purview of lawmakers. If the lawmakers leave loopholes in their legislation all companies that can will avail themselves of these loopholes. Blame the legislators. Those assholes left barn-door sized loopholes in their legal requirements for Apple's compliance.
- solarkraft 5y agoYou can be pretty sure that Apple lobbied hard to leave these holes. The legislators are happy they can tell their voters they finally did something and that they found a compromise. It's a bit on us, the public, to not accept those alibi-type compromises.
- Maarten88 5y agoI think Apple does not hold much sway over lawmakers here in the Netherlands. US tech companies are not very popular in general, and politicians are not corrupt for the most part. Many laws originate in Brussels. Incompetence/cluelessness and lack of resources around tech is the bigger problem here.
- Maarten88 5y ago> Blame the legislators. Those assholes left barn-door sized loopholes in their legal requirements for Apple's compliance. Well that remains to be seen. The court just applied existing law for this specific conflict. Apple was found not complying, which is why the court issued this ruling. After implementing this narrow change they probably still do not comply. It would surprise me if dating apps would somehow be legally different from any other app. Apple is just stalling here. The next court case is going to cost money in addition to broadening the requirements on Apple, I think.
- saagarjha 5y agoI think they did a rather good job and personally expected almost exactly this outcome given Apple’s position, to be honest. I was concerned that we’d get some sort of weird “you’re making these rules about us but we actually follow the rules” that they did elsewhere that was a real headscratcher.
- HWR_14 5y agoI'm not sure it makes sense to blame legislators for loopholes. Bugs exist all the time in a variety of products. And few have to withstand the scrutiny of trillion dollar companies paying experts to pour over every aspect to find them.
- Y-bar 5y agoI wonder if Apple restricting this to Netherlands only complies with the EU Digital Single Market: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Single_Market https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Single_Market > The Geo-blocking regulation adopted by the EU in February 2018 prohibits any attempt to restrict consumers access to goods and services on e-commerce websites on the basis of their nationality or country of residence and establishment.[31]
- maccard 5y ago> It is your privilege/responsibility to conflict resolution with regards to refunds and such. Every time the apple fee comes up, this part of the discussion rarely comes up. This is a huge part of what you pay Apple/Google for. Lets say you roll your own on top of stripe [0]; each dispute/chargeback costs you $15 on top of the transaction cost. On an app with $0.99 purchases, each dispute will undo 15 purchases. If you get enough of these you _will_ be banned, quickly and with very little warning. I'm not going to claim that this on it's own is worth the full 30% whack but it does neet to be taken into consideration. [0] https://stripe.com/docs/disputes https://stripe.com/docs/disputes
- ericpauley 5y agoI would imagine all purchases to be a low dispute risk, as the merchant can simply offer refunds to all no questions asked. After all the marginal cost of goods sold for an app is probably effectively 0. That being said, a $1 purchase through stripe likely has an effective fee higher than 30%, so this would only make sense for larger purchases.
- nexuist 5y agoThe problem is that even with a no-hassle refund process some customers will still call their credit card company and ask for a chargeback because it's a process they're familiar with and it's easier for them to do than to go through any kind of custom process you've built for them. I imagine after dealing with customer support BS enough times your goodwill is eroded and you're just going to choose the path of least resistance for yourself.
- maccard 5y ago> I would imagine all purchases to be a low dispute risk, as the merchant can simply offer refunds to all no questions asked. That only works if you offer a no questions asked refund, and even at that, that doesn't imply 0 risk. Cards get stolen and tested on low value purchases all the time; if a scammer decides to check 1000 credit cards on your app, you're going to have a very bad time.
- threeseed 5y ago