14 ms·
Is Space Pixelated? The Quest for Quantum Gravity
- somewhereoutth 5y agoGiven that the real number line exists (as a mathematical construct), and has powerful properties (as a mathematical construct), it would be surprising if 'nature' did not take advantage of it.
- lostmsu 5y ago> real number line exists (as a mathematical construct) Not according to constructivism it does not.
- a-dub 5y agoi've always wondered if all the weirdness that occurs at small scales where classical mechanics breaks down was just the effect of a sort of spatial aliasing where the continuous universe is undersampled onto some kind of discrete substrate. this confirms that i'm ignorant of real physics.
- suifbwish 5y agoUltimately everything has to be convertible to everything else. Kinetic force must be convertible to particles and even time must be inherently material if it can interact with space and material.
- anonymousiam 5y agoI am not sure why you were down-voted. What you are saying is a consequence of Einstein's General Theory of Relativity.
- criddell 5y agoYou might find this[1] interesting: > However, Savage said, there are signatures of resource constraints in present-day simulations that are likely to exist as well in simulations in the distant future, including the imprint of an underlying lattice if one is used to model the space-time continuum. They did their experiment and did not find anything that would indicate an underlying lattice, but I can't find the paper right now. [1]: https://www.washington.edu/news/2012/12/10/do-we-live-in-a-computer-simulation-uw-researchers-say-idea-can-be-tested/ https://www.washington.edu/news/2012/12/10/do-we-live-in-a-c...
- Optimal_Persona 5y agoI'm also ignorant of (though extremely curious about!) real physics, and have had the exact same thought since learning audio DSP principles! I'm always amazed that quantum mechanics was developed before Claude Shannon's theory of information and Hartley and Nyquist's sampling theory. I guess the question is whether Planck time is an actual physical limit or "just" about measurement.
- a-dub 5y agoi come from the same angle. linear systems and dsp (initially audio). basically it's how computers percieve the physical world. it's also where a lot of theory arises from in neuroscience.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoIn general, I'm curious devices that detect/measure things at super small scales can have both very high accuracy ratings and very high confidence. Presumably these devices measure things previously unmeasurable - or at least with as good of accuracy. I mean, I get that we have hypothesis and have reason to believe nature is going to behave in some way. And then you build the device to measure it, and it comes within some range that's not surprising, and it is inline with previous devices that weren't as accurate. If you're building a conventional scale - it just seems more reasonable that you can have high confidence and high accuracy because the stuff you're measuring is big enough to physically see and interact with and there's almost limitless things you could use to cross-reference, etc. Is there an ELI5 for how you can measure things subatomic with ridiculously high accuracy and confidence? I guess I'm just in complete awe of how this is possible - not doubting that it is.
- lumost 5y agoAt a large scale it is also very difficult to create high accuracy. Simply defining a meter or kilogram is a high difficulty task, however there is a canonical "kilogram" that you can go and visit in France. Along with a carefully maintained set of proofs that were built off of the canonical "kilogram" which in turn are used to make the calibration weights we all work with. We then measure/calibrate the accuracy of any weight measuring system by how well it tracks to the canonical kilogram. Similarly, for any "new" measurement, there will be a number of "calibration" measurements performed to ensure that the results are in-line with other measurements of well known things.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoInterferometers are nature's vernier calipers.
- pixl97 5y ago>In general, I'm curious devices that detect/measure things at super small scales can have both very high accuracy ratings and very high confidence. In many cases you cannot. Speed and position for example. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncertainty_principle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncertainty_principle
- drsnow 5y agois there any reason to believe space is in fact quantized? why should it be? genuine question!
- Zenst 5y agoIf you look at it with the analogy of vinyl records and digital representations of that music. You can reach a point in which you are quantizing something that equally can represent the original in a way that is not discernable in difference (maybe 192khz 32 bit float for some but still quantized). You equally, hit limits in human perception and technology/physics limitations more so. Maybe the universe is always N+1 with N being the best sampling rate known to man. Sure we can infer, but when you want to know the answer to the exact decimal point, sometimes you have to accept that 1/3 is 1/3 and never exactly 0.333333333333 however much recurring you have.
- ncmncm 5y agoHint: 44100 Hz is plenty to exceed any human's perceptual resolution.
- Zenst 5y agoThat was my point, just because you can only perceive at one limit, does not mean there is nothing beyond that like Ultrasound. Anyhow, was analogy about perception and sample rates and what your measuring. Clearly didn't make it that clear and sorry for that.
- Taniwha 5y agoAnd yet I can flash an LED that fast, then turn my head from side to side and see the modulation ....
- JohnBooty 5y ago>> 44100khz > And yet I can flash an LED that fast You have an LED that flashes 44,100 times per second, and you can perceive this?
- nathias 5y agoIf space is relative (ie. not a separate thing itself) it seems so, you have the shortest possible distance, so that delimits what the chunk of space is.
- Extigy 5y agoAs far as quantum gravity theories go I’m personally quite partial to Causal Dynamical Triangulation [1] [1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/1905.08669.pdf#page79 https://arxiv.org/pdf/1905.08669.pdf#page79
- Cupertino95014 5y agoOne thing that's always irritated me about popular explanations of string theory, like Brian Greene's, is that they'll use phrases like "It turns out that..." I think, "Wait a second! Nothing has 'turned out', because there are no experiments." So now there will be. I applaud this effort. If something is untestable, then ignorant people who equate "faith in religion" with "faith in science" are right. Let's get some data that can only be explained by Theory X, and then see if Theory X predicts more things that also turn out to be true. If Theory X turns out to be one of the many variations of string theory, then you've got something there.
- serverholic 5y agoIn the same vein it bugs me when physicists “explain” the interior of black holes. Until we have a quantum theory of gravity we really don’t know what’s inside a black hole.
- cmarschner 5y agoQuestion in this regard: current theory seems to predict a singularity with “infinite” space-time curvature (IIUC) in the center of a black hole. This seems utterly improbable to me. Is it common sense to treat this as a given or is it considered a weird quirk of general relativity that is sought to be overcome?
- zarzavat 5y agoIt’s generally regarded as major flaw with general relativity - and that general relativity is only an approximation for a better theory. You don’t need anything as exotic as a black hole, general relativity can’t say anything about how gravity works at small scales at all.
- lumost 5y agoIn this universe of ours, there isn't anything profoundly improbable about a point particle with a mass of a million suns. We commonly treat electron's as point particles with tiny mass - and there isn't yet any hint in theory or experiment that this model is incorrect (when the particles dynamics are calculated through QM). That being said, physicists dislike discontinuities. A theoretical point particle with high mass means that there must be a mechanism to merge large quantities of mass into black hole matter. If it is a point particle with extremely large gravitational fields, these final interactions would also require some version of quantum gravity to predict. In fact, it's entirely plausible that what we observe as black holes are actually not GR singularities at all https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole#Alternatives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole#Alternatives There is hope for improving observational data on black hole interiors by measuring the gravitational waves of merging black holes. Different types of black hole singularities will have different event horizon shapes, and the merger of these black holes should produce different gravitational waves, amongst other observable effects. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerr_metric https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerr_metric
- EamonnMR 5y agoIt would be hard to do aliasing without losing or gaining energy wouldn't it?
- crehn 5y agoI’ve always wondered what happens when I move my hand. If I zoom in close on my hand, does it move like a sprite in a 2D video game? Always on a “grid”, with no way to be in between pixels?
- frutiger 5y ago> does it move like a sprite in a 2D video game? Always on a “grid”, with no way to be in between pixels? There is no compelling evidence to suggest that this is the case, at least down the scales we have been able to zoom into.
- pixl97 5y agoThe Plank scale is very tiny and we are a long way from being able to see near that level.