6 ms·
Quantum particles feel the influence of gravitational fields they never touch
- bubblecheck 5y ago(Per the article): Is it correct to describe superposition as the probability of, e.g., an electron being in one of two places? In such an example, is it instead correct to say that superposition is a probability distribution of infinitely many possible locations?
- monocasa 5y agoIt depends. In the general case a superposition is a probability field with infinitely many options once the waveform collapses, but the specifics of the experiment might discretize that practically into two options.
- hilbert42 5y ago"The two theories that underlie this experiment, general relativity and quantum mechanics, don’t work well together." The Aharonov-Bohm effect alone is perplexing enough and there isn't full unanimity about the theory that underpins it. That we're seeing a similar effect with gravity is truly exiting as I reckon it will attract a great deal more research in this area. It seems to me that Aharonov-Bohm effect now has a gravitational parallel tells us that we're honing in closer and closer to having a quantum understanding of gravity. Excellent stuff.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- changoplatanero 5y agoI'm not sure how it's possible to "never touch" a gravitational field given that they extend throughout the universe and are impossible to be shielded.
- wilbdhm 5y ago
- criddell 5y agoThey touch on that in the article: > Notably, the particles weren’t in a gravitational field–free zone. Instead, the experiment was designed so that the researchers could filter out the effects of gravitational forces, laying bare the eerie Aharonov-Bohm influence. I'm no physicist, but I think they calculated the expected influence and compared that with a measurement.
- pdonis 5y agoThe "filter out the effects of gravitational forces" means that the measured particles were in free fall; in free fall there is no gravitational force.
- kenjackson 5y agoIs that the common way you'd express that they were measured in free fall -- that the effects were "filtered" out? That seems like an odd way of saying it, but I'm not a physicist.
- pdonis 5y agoI don't think it's a very good way of expressing that the objects were in free fall, no. Nor, as far as I can tell, does the actual paper (as opposed to the pop science article) use such an expression.
- PicassoCTs 5y agoOne, in theory could shield of them, by having the same field apply from the opposing direction and distance. So if one could create such a "mirror" copy of all attractors - one would have a L1 Lagrange point. The forces still interact, but chancel each other out.
- diontron 5y agoarticle goes on to state that gravitational pull effects surrounding objects without touching them, you know, like how we already know every fucking planet works? quantum physics: the biggest waste of time since philosophy
- JaimeThompson 5y agoWhat about the use of quantum physics in things like semiconductors?
- diontron 5y agosemiconductors don't "use" quantum physics, quantum physics just tries to explain how they work. semiconductors still exist without requiring quantum physicists to come in and try and steal credit for something they had no influence on whatsoever.
- pmontra 5y agoThey used to but manufacturers are starting to have to deal with quantum effects lately https://semiengineering.com/quantum-effects-at-7-5nm/ https://semiengineering.com/quantum-effects-at-7-5nm/
- evanb 5y agoNot for nothing but Shockley, Bardeen, and Brattain were physicists awarded a Nobel "for their researches on semiconductors and their discovery of the transistor effect". Bardeen also won a separate Nobel for a theory of superconductivity. Claiming they're not quantum physicists or had no influence on semiconductors is misinformed.
- klyrs 5y agoNow do Josephson Junctions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josephson_voltage_standard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josephson_voltage_standard
- 5y ago
- ianai 5y agoSounds more like a demonstration of an ability to detect the influence of gravitational fields at scales previously unavailable. Specifically, in testing something called the "Aharonov-Bohm influence/[effect]" previously demonstrated within EM fields and now for gravity. Quote: """ The study not only reveals a famed physics effect in a new context, but also showcases the potential to study subtle effects in gravitational systems. For example, researchers aim to use this type of technique to better measure Newton’s gravitational constant, G, which reveals the strength of gravity, and is currently known less precisely than other fundamental constants of nature (SN: 8/29/18). """
- mikewarot 5y agoThe wavelength of an atom (DeBroglie Wavelength) is much lower than that of a photon of visible light, so it follows that anything that makes the path of one beam even slightly longer, such as putting a mass near it, would be far more detectable in this manner. There might be a small, very hard to detect optical interference shift if the experiment were re-run with a coherent laser beam.
- squeaky-clean 5y agoI know this is a trope that comes up in half of the posts involving a journal article, but scientific journal pricing is so confusing to me. I can pay $30 for digital access to a 4 page article (it says Vol 375 pg 226-229). Or I can pay $15 and get the entire issue of Vol 375 in print? Or I can pay $80/yr to join AAAS and get "50 issues of Science", but which issues? I assume they mean the upcoming year of issues, but I still want to read issue 375... I consider buying or joining every once in a while when a cool article like this links back to a paper I can't find on Arxiv. But then I remember how expensive individual articles are and how confusing it is to sign up.
- krastanov 5y agoYour confusion is warranted, the system has twisted incentives. I am a scientist working at a rich university. I still mostly use scihub unless the article is on arxiv, even for articles which have my name in the byline. All this to say, I consider pirating these papers the moral highground and you should not feel bad doing it. Thankfully, I have the job security and funding to demand my work be open access (a whole other can of worms).
- ambrozk 5y agoJust use sci-hub. It always works, and it's very easy. There's no good reason to give the journal your money to read an article they had no hand in writing or funding.
- cashsterling 5y agoi think a possible startup idea would be to start a "Github for science" (replace "science" with any academic or interest area really). Encourage folks to post their papers in latex or markdown. Post their data, code, mechanical and electrical drawings, videos and pictures of their experimental setup, videos explaining their research, videos performing the experiment?, and so on. Allow others to comment on research with questions, concerns, suggestions for enhancement, or link it to their own supporting work, etc. Allow other researchers to fork people's research (but all forks link back to the original to give full attribution). The core focus is open up access to academic papers and research, foster better communication between people, and set a higher bar for communication of research. Going the non-profit route: I think it would be cool for the site to be federated/distributed so universities & countries could host replicated nodes. It would be best if somehow the software system development and hosting costs could be underwritten by governments and universities. Going the for-profit route: The site could have an inexpensive PRO account to help support the site and software development. The site could be add supported, but zero tracker, with adds that would be small and content-based purely on the content of the paper topic. Add Examples: Reading an article on Julia numerical programming... maybe show an add for the upcoming JuliaCon or Julia Computing Reading a metallurgy analysis paper... maybe show a small add for an x-ray fluorescent system for metal composition analysis or advertise an upcoming metallurgy conference ... the idea being that these adds are (1) not targeted at users, just targeted at content, (2)small, dismiss-able, and not annoying (3) hopefully actually useful and interesting to the reader. The site could also sell "advanced API access" to interested parties for knowledge management/search on fast trending research and topical areas, research community graph analysis (maybe for recruiting?)... kind of the LinkedIn layer of the site.
- sandworm101 5y agoI don't see the new. All this tells me is that entangled particles react to things that impact some but not all of their various superpositions/entanglements. Sounds like basic double-slit stuff to me. The particle that goes through the slit A reacts to its partners going through slit B. The particle that passed through gravity field A reacted to its partners going through field B.
- notfed 5y agoQuantum mechanics news hasn't been giving us anything new for decades. Every modern article is about a new speculation, or at best an or experiment that reconfirms what we already knew. Yet, articles will never cease to use click-bait to make you think a revolution has occurred.
- sandworm101 5y agoThe closer you can get the words "quantum" and "gravity" together in the title the better.
- amelius 5y agoThere was an article about China reaching quantum supremacy some time ago, so I suppose we achieved something.
- quantum_state 5y agoCompletely misleading and eye ball gripping “article’ …
- dang 5y agoQuite possibly, but a comment like this is only helpful if it explains how the article is misleading—i.e. if it provides more correct information on the topic. Otherwise it's just another low-quality dismissal, which we're trying to avoid here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html