3 ms·
The issue of side effects being downplayed by the media is entirely a response by public health and media to the large amount of disinformation about vaccines.
by dekhn 5y ago
The issue of side effects being downplayed by the media is entirely a response by public health and media to the large amount of disinformation about vaccines. It was a calculus that was identified and decided on quite some time ago- the reasoning being most people need to hear a simple, straightforward and consistent message to be compliant.
The media and public health leadership has to work on a very thin "knife's edge" when communicating with the public. They have to do 10X the work to debunk garbage than the people have to work to dissemination garbage. And then, a reasonable set of people who do have vaccines problems end up in the middle. The symptoms I had when I had combined Flu/Pneumonia were: could not use left arm for a week, felt super-sick and couldn'tr work for a week. I know that's probably better than getitng a bad flu or pneumonia, but my doctor couldn't even care. She was just happy I got vaccinated. i do think that is a problem.
But it's a different problem and raising that and having a rational discussion about it is not something that can happen in a venue like hacker news, or really any social media.
- throw10920 5y ago> The issue of side effects being downplayed by the media is entirely a response by public health and media to the large amount of disinformation about vaccines. That's your personal belief that may or may not be representative of reality. Another possible belief that one might have, that you can find evidence for in reality, is that side effects are being downplayed in order to push vaccine mandates through as a way of exerting political control and/or profits for certain organizations (e.g. Pfizer, which has done a lot of extremely questionable things in the past, like a lot of large pharma companies). > the reasoning being most people need to hear a simple, straightforward and consistent message to be compliant. ...and this line only adds more evidence to the second belief, as it's exactly what entities wanting control want - people to be "compliant" for its own sake, regardless of reality, ethics, or reason. In any case, downplaying the side effects is unethical and obviously wrong.
- dekhn 5y agoIf downplaying side effects had an overall greater outcome, would it be unethical and "obviously wrong"? Nothing is truly obviously wrong. In fact many things we think are obviously wrong, aren't. The ethics of these sorts of things are truly nontrivial. If you're suggesting we have hte vaccine policies we do so that pfizer etc profit, well I doubt I am going to convince you otherwise. I work in pharma, have a pretty good understanding of our leadership's thought patterns, and I think the vast majority of them would more than happily take a business loss if it meant the world became healthier, but they'd rather keep doing their research and development in the meantime.
- odshoifsdhfs 5y ago> If downplaying side effects had an overall greater outcome, would it be unethical and "obviously wrong"? Well, lets say that I will have the side effects for the rest of my life, or my kid (9y) will. So lying or hiding about the side effects is better for the big picture, and then fuck me/my kid? This is how you breed anti-vaxx and other people against goverment. 'We lied, but it was from your own good, sure, some suffered the consequenses of our lies, but hey, bars are open now, yay'
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoBut if 10 people suffer permanent consequences from Covid because they didn't push vaccines, then are they justified in pushing the vaccines? Mind you, I'm not claiming that they are justified. Just that pro-vax side of the question is a lot more than "but bars are now open".
- odshoifsdhfs 5y agoI am not against pushing vaccines. But if hiding/lying is the way they are doing, is it worth it? Will the public ever trust them again? Let's say (as an experiment) we know that 10% of people will have life-long problems if they take the vaccine, BUT hiding this fact means that 90% of the population will probably take the vaccine and thus, 'saving' a lot of people. Is it ok to 'sacrifice' 10% for the remaining 90%? (I know the values are less, but the questions is, where we draw the line where we should 'hide' things or not). I still hope the side effects will go away, but after one month, this has serious implications in my life, and I feel betrayed for not being informed on the side effects correctly. And for sure, I will not have any other boosters, no matter what mandates or what else they will come up with, and right now, I am recommending others not to get the booster after my experience (maybe wrong, but my experience and suffering trumps any 'greater good' that may put my close friends/family at risk)
- yucky 5y ago>the reasoning being most people need to hear a simple, straightforward and consistent message to be compliant. I notice the word "accurate" wasn't included in what people need to hear from their public health professionals. I think that's the problem.