4 ms·
I can't imagine that this would hold up in court. You might as well exclude blondes or people with a brother named "Mike." Just make it explicitly proprietary a
by pessimizer 5y ago
I can't imagine that this would hold up in court. You might as well exclude blondes or people with a brother named "Mike." Just make it explicitly proprietary and give out free licenses to the people who meet your criteria. Or equivalently to this, include a promise in the licensing that you won't pursue license violations against people who meet X, Y, and Z criteria.
This license isn't about restrictions on usage, it's about restrictions on identity. It's deeply weird. Even stranger, despite the insistence that "fair" is a meaningful term in this license, the definition "A fair price is a fair market price for a fair commercial license." tells on itself. The clarification that it means "more than one customer not affiliated with the licensor has paid that price in the past year" at first glance seems unsatisfiable (under the license), because somebody has to be the first to pay that price, and at that point it wouldn't be "fair."
edit: In trying to ape FOSS licensing, it has confused itself. You don't have to ape FOSS.
- tyingq 5y agoThe author is a lawyer, and appears to have experience in the space. https://work.kemitchell.com/ https://work.kemitchell.com/
- nbadg 5y agoI'm a friend of the author, as well as friends with (former) employees at some of his clients. I can vouch not just that he's a lawyer, but also that he has experience in the space. _A lot_ of experience in the space.
- AlexCoventry 5y agoWhy would it be legally invalid to exclude blondes or people with a brother named "Mike"? (Obviously it would be immoral and stupid, but that doesn't make such an exclusion legally unenforceable.)
- Hjfrf 5y agoIn the case of name/appearance, those things can be strongly correlated with protected categories like race and gender. E.g. Consider a similar legal exclusion to only people called Nguyen or Mohammed or Singh.
- lupire 5y agoIt violates civil rights laws in the US, likely.
- henryfjordan 5y agoCalifornia has the Unruh Civil Rights Act that applies to all commercial public accommodations which basically says "categorical discrimination of any kind is illegal". Saying "I won't do business with anyone named Mike" or putting up a "No blondes" sign is categorical discrimination. I have no idea how that law would apply to this license though.
- CalChris 5y agoBut I don't think people with a brother named Mike are a protected class according to the Unruh Civil Rights Act. Those are sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status.
- henryfjordan 5y agoThe text of the law reads: > All persons within the jurisdiction of this state are free and equal, and no matter what their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever. The important part is "All persons ... are free and equal ... and are entitled to ... equal accommodations". When you read it this way (which is how the courts read the law), the list is just illustrating some classes that might be discriminated against. It does not limit the classes merely to those listed.
- junon 5y agoThat's not how you read legal text. You can't just omit parts of the law to fit what you want.
- henryfjordan 5y agoThe alternative to my interpretation is "because there is a list, nothing not on that list is a protected class". That interpretation omits the parts of the sentence I highlighted as much as I omitted the list. As you can see from links/quotes elsewhere in this thread, the caselaw agrees with me.
- kadoban 5y agoAre you a lawyer or have specific knowledge in this area? This thing is weird enough to me that I'm not sure I'd have any idea, myself, and I've spent a good deal of time understanding and reading about copyright and licenses.
- School-Cotton 5y ago> You might as well exclude blondes or people with a brother named "Mike." AFAIU that would be perfectly legal in the USA.
- lmkg 5y agoYou can't discriminate based on membership of protected classes, and the doctrine of "disparate impact" means you can't have an imbalanced impact against a protected class (even if unintentional!), unless there's a reasonable business case. Excluding blondes has a disparate impact against race. Excluding people with a brother named Mike can be argued to have a disparate impact based on ethnicity or national origin. Excluding people with a brother named Mike but with no restrictions on the names of their sisters might be discriminating based on sex. The condition is also more likely to exclude people with larger number of siblings, which could be argued to have a disparate impact based on religion.
- School-Cotton 5y agoGood point, thanks.
- simmons 5y agoI'm a bit uneasy about some things in this license (including the "fair" bit), but I doubt there's any legal problem with discriminating licensees based on revenue or head count. (Disclaimer: IANAL, etc.) Microsoft already does this with Visual Studio licensing -- the free "community" license explicitly restricts on both critiera: https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/license-terms/mlt031819/ https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/license-terms/mlt031819/
- camgunz 5y agoAll kinds of regulations have carveouts for small or family businesses. It's not legally discriminatory in the slightest.
- samatman 5y agoBoth of those are bad analogies for different reasons. I will limit myself to US law out of familiarity. Excluding blondes is prohibited due to the 'protected category', which is sweeping, covering most personal characteristics which are inherent. For a role, and this broadly includes things like waitressing, these limits can be imposed, but not in this sort of general contract. The problem with some "brother named Mike" contracts is that they're trying to get around some requirement to be general while targeting someone in particular. For most contracts you can in fact say, "anyone can use this except Anish Kapoor, because screw that guy" and that's going to hold up since refusing service or commerce outright to an individual is completely legal.
- tptacek 5y agoIs this definition of "protected category" in the license? Because hair color isn't generally protected in US law.
- samatman 5y agoThis question has been a) tried with some success against natural and locced hair in the US, and I wouldn't want to be a defendant in the no blondes case, and b) no. totally irrelevant. Hence I was saying it's a bad analogy, rather than a good one.
- kemitchell 5y agoWill courts enforce Creative Commons NonCommercial licenses? How about educational-use-only terms, often discounted? Software companies that sell downloads and licenses self-serve, with differential pricing for customers in poorer countries? If you want to throw shade on the basis of the law, please cite law. Re: "fair" and similar terms, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasonable_and_non-discriminatory_licensing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasonable_and_non-discriminat....
- cestith 5y agoUsage in a commercial context is different from usage in a noncommercial context. This has nothing to do with indelible personal traits. It has to do with whether users can take advantage of certain terms of the license base on how they organize themselves and to what use they are putting the software. All sorts of contracts and licenses treat commercial and noncommercial use differently. Look at game engines, graphics packs, etc. All sorts of software licensed to companies have discounts for certain sizes or types of business and per-user pricing.