6 ms·
There is a similar social issue waiting to blow up regarding genetic screening. Estimates are that 10-15% of children are from infidelity
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
There is a similar social issue waiting to blow up regarding genetic screening. Estimates are that 10-15% of children are from infidelity
- User23 5y agoI believe that's the rate for people who seek out a paternity test, which is to say are already suspicious. The overall population nonpaternity rate is about 3%[1]. As an aside, obstetricians often notice nonpaternity because of the child having an impossible blood type for the putative father. The ones I've spoken to prefer to stay silent when they notice it. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19320216/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19320216/
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThank you for the correction.
- onphonenow 5y agoParental testing should be mandatory at birth perhaps for these issues. Or at least if someone is going to go claim child support.
- resoluteteeth 5y agoIf it was going to be mandatory it would be much better to do it before birth using amniotic fluid. Waiting for the child to be born and then suddenly telling one parent that it's not their biological child isn't a great idea.
- bluecalm 5y agoWell, it's always the potential father that gets the news not one of the parents. Maybe it's not ideal to tell them once the child is born but it's still better than not telling them at all.
- onphonenow 5y agoThat's an interesting idea, but a fair number of families don't want to do amniotic fluid testing. Paternity and maternity issues are pretty low incidence issues, but is VERY rough if it pops up with a 4 year old in the mix. If you've got wrong dad in the picture, at birth is a good time to chase down the right father! Get him paying child support if needed. Non-bio dad could still decide to stay around if desired - but transparency / honesty on the table.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoIt can be done with a noninvasive blood test of the mother. I am a firm proponent of mandatory testing so fathers aren’t financially responsible for children that aren’t theirs (without their knowledge and consent). Historically, if a father later determines they're not the biological parent, family court will still stick them with child support until the child is 18 (or even older, sometimes requiring college support). https://americanpregnancy.org/paternity-tests/non-invasive-prenatal-paternity-test/ https://americanpregnancy.org/paternity-tests/non-invasive-p...
- onphonenow 5y agoWow, NIPP testing is very cool - didn't know about that.
- mbreese 5y agoWhat will that accomplish? If a putative father is already suspicious (and doesn’t want to be a father), sure, then having a NIPT would make sense. But there is already an avenue for that. You would want to make that mandatory for all pregnancies? Not everyone wants to know that information and having a mandatory test could force people (fathers) into situations they don’t want to be in. Kids are more than a financial responsibility.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoIf it's not your kid biologically, and you're not a willing participant, it's not your responsibility. Pursue the biological parent for support. To do otherwise is equivalent to fraud. We don't force foster kids on people without their informed consent. This is no different. Edit: We agree to disagree. I fall firmly in the mandatory testing camp for accuracy of paternity for all involved parties. Trust but verify.
- mbreese 5y agoIf you’re not a willing participant, then you can still have the test. If you’re the type where if the kid isn’t your biological kid, then you wouldn’t want to be a father to them — then get a test. The question is — should it be mandatory for all pregnancies? Willing participant or otherwise. I’m not saying no one should have paternity testing. It should certainly be available. I just don’t think you should mandate it.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoAmniocentesis carries a small, but real, risk of miscarriage
- mdavis6890 5y agoThe father - and should be - is the one who raises the child. It is for this reason that (in the US) "father" of record is always the husband unless it is explicitly questioned and investigated. Assuming we're talking about a happy family with two eager parents, what is helped by investigating the child's genetic "paternity," when the father is right there holding the baby?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- avgcorrection 5y ago> The father [is] - and should be - the one who raises the child. We’re implicitly dealing with two senses of the word “father” in this context which makes most of your sentences seem both commonsensical and ambigious.
- onphonenow 5y agoBecause he may be victim of a fraud? ie, the baby is someone elses? Because the actual biological father may want a role in his childs life? Because the state has a bit of interest in accuracy in its medical / birth certificate and other records? Because many births are to single mothers and the absent father may have certain financial and other responsibilities for the child?
- awakeasleep 5y agoOn paternity attestation forms in the usa there is a clause saying the marriage/legal father is not the father of record if the mother was in another relationship 9-10 months ago.
- susiecambria 5y agoIn Washington, DC years ago, there was a bill before the DC Council that basically said that any man having sex with a woman who ended up with a child was presumed to be the biological father until paternity was ruled out. So if a woman had sex with several men, all would have presumed paternity. I don't recall whether this applied only to public benefits and paternity.
- 5y ago
- astura 5y ago>Estimates are that 10-15% of children are from infidelity Extremely Misleading, from the studies I've seen these high numbers are percentage of people seeking paternity tests, not from the general public as a whole. If you're seeking a paternity test you already are suspecting infidelity.
- felix_n 5y agoThat's a very astute observation, one that I've personally seen overlooked several times by people using that data point to support their argument. That kind of statistical begging-the-question annoys me to no end. The number I've heard from people who quote it is all over the map, sometimes it's 10%, or 20%, even as high as 50%, but I've not once seen a citation of any of them. So I'm inclined to treat that statistic as BS unless proven otherwise. But as you say, even a legit number is probably misleading due to the circumstances surrounding the data gathering.
- astura 5y ago>but I've not once seen a citation of any of them I have, which is why I brought it up. Any time people throw out such absurdly high numbers and provide "evidence" there always is "...seeking paternity testing..." in the methodology. Always. It's absurd how people could overlook this, it's like if you counted the times Maury Povich says "you are not the father" and used it to say anything about the general population.
- throwaway6734 5y agoI'm surprised genetic testing isn't always performed at birth