7 ms·
I don't see where it is not ethical. At any point you can decide to pursue or stop maintaining the code and anyone can decide to fork and take over. It is just
by prmoustache 5y ago
I don't see where it is not ethical.
At any point you can decide to pursue or stop maintaining the code and anyone can decide to fork and take over. It is just naive to think you will always find fun in working on it or pretend you might make a living out of it unless you have a strong business plan.
- ReleaseCandidat 5y ago> I don't see where it is not ethical. And that's the problem. Many people like the idea of 'helping' other people for free, even if these users never 'give something back' (because they can't program, don't have the time to translate something, ...). But helping other people (companies) make money for free that already have not only enough but way more than you, and you even do the less rewarding work like fixing bugs is not what moste people thought of when making OSS.
- sitkack 5y agoTo explain it a different way, I think, is that releasing code under a permissive license where the end user is a large corp, doesn't make the world a better place, it just reduces the labor needed to achieve an end. OSS saves on headcount.
- mring33621 5y agoAt my company, a huge bank, where we use a ton of open source code, we were explicitly told that working on (contributing to) open source was a terminal offense.
- lumost 5y agoIn the case of industrial control, database tech, and other high cost fields it would be dubious to pitch an open source product and then abandon it. Getting a high adoption OSS project takes more than putting a repo on GitHub. In some cases like this one, it’s possible that the underlying cost of these activities is much closer to the licensed proprietary software than the OSS variant (aka free)
- zozbot234 5y ago> In the case of industrial control, database tech, and other high cost fields it would be dubious to pitch an open source product and then abandon it. Why? Open source projects are released with "NO WARRANTY", which includes the possibility of dropping maintenance at any time. If you want continued support you either fork the project and DIY, or pay someone to support you.
- mason55 5y agoAnd that is not something the companies using the software are interested in. This isn’t like a software company taking over some abandonware tool that they rely on. Building and maintaining software is not in the wheelhouse of these companies. They’d rather spend more or have fewer features in exchange for lowering risk.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- prmoustache 5y agoIt is the ethical problem of those companies, not of the people writing the original code.
- prmoustache 5y agoSo Google liberated kubernetes under the Apache License 2.0. Many companies are now relying on it for their workload and we see contribution from other big companies as well. Are you saying that it would be unethical if Google find out they'd now rather work on something newer/better, and stop having engineers contributing to it?
- phoronixrly 5y agoThe unethical part is that you've contributed (for free!) to the development of closed-source proprietary software.
- FpUser 5y agoStupid it may be but it is not unethical. We live in supposedly free world and one has full right to decide how their work is to be used. Don't like it, just use GPL or whatever license you might want to concoct to prevent / limit corporate use.
- akerl_ 5y agoWhat is unethical about contributing (for free!) to the development of closed-source software? And if you’ve decided that making open-source software inherently contributes to the development of closed-source software, what’s your recommendation? If it’s unethical to work on closed-source and open-source, do we all just go home and stop writing code?
- phoronixrly 5y agoWe're getting into technicalities here, but in my opinion the ethical thing to do is to share your code freely for everyone else to use, however at the same time use a license that requires them to do the same with any code they derive from yours. This is absolutely nothing new, ref. the GPL.
- akerl_ 5y agoIt’s clear that your preference is that people do that. What’s not clear is why the MIT license and closed source software are unethical. Not everything we dislike is a violation of ethics.
- rbanffy 5y ago> What’s not clear is why the MIT license and closed source software are unethical. Is it ethical to allow unethical behavior?