3 ms·
> There is so much stuff on the Internet it's easy to start thinking there is guaranteed to be good results for any search, and that just doesn't seem to be the
by pjc50 5y ago
> There is so much stuff on the Internet it's easy to start thinking there is guaranteed to be good results for any search, and that just doesn't seem to be the case.
I'm increasingly of the opinion that Google (the advertising engine) has destroyed Google (the search engine), by the two step process of making it profitable to produce blogspam then forcing search to remove blogspam - and a lot of the useful content has gone out with that bathwater.
Not to mention the rise of unsearchable platforms. Google can't search inside Discord.
- kreeben 5y ago>> Google can't search inside Discord. Can anyone, even in theory? Are there open APIs to all systems of discord? Does Discord have one? Wouldn't that open up all of these systems to systematic classification of all users? Also, is there a web link you can construct that will open up e.g. Discord's desktop app when you click it?
- krageon 5y agoSearching Discord externally is not possible AFAIK. It's an actively user-hostile platform, which is doubly irritating because most community efforts (e.g. modding of games) mandate Discord and allow for nothing else. Frequently they don't even accept communication from another space, such as bug reports via email or GitHub.
- ciphol 5y agoThat is good for privacy though.
- lpcvoid 5y agoNo - anonymous accounts are good for privacy. If you're contributing information about something, having that information index-able is just common sense.
- krageon 5y agoIt's practically mandatory to "verify" your account with a phone number for many servers. Discord is incredibly anti-privacy, the fact that it is not transparent to people that aren't currently using it is a vendor lock-in measure.
- neutronicus 5y agoYou're probably much less likely to leak PII to non-community members through Discord than a forum. I also think ephemeral-by-default seems to result in much fewer long-running fights than you would have in public-record-by-default communities like forums. Like when a thread gets heated in a forum, it keeps getting bumped and none of the people involved can resist picking at the sore. On Discord it seems like someone steps away, the channel moves on, and the fight actually dies
- darkerside 5y agoThe world wide web is not the world. If it exists you can search it. Even if you need to open a client, run Discord search, and execute OCR to interpret the results. In tech, it's never what's possible, it's just what costs area reasonable.
- AmericanBlarney 5y agoOr what's legally allowed by the ToS...
- darkerside 5y agoExplore a partnership, figure out how to mask your usage, etc. Not impossible. If you're looking for defeat, you will find it.
- nikanj 5y agoEven Discord can’t search inside Discord
- remus 5y ago> I'm increasingly of the opinion that Google (the advertising engine) has destroyed Google (the search engine), by the two step process of making it profitable to produce blogspam then forcing search to remove blogspam - and a lot of the useful content has gone out with that bathwater. If you're looking for someone to blame google seems like the wrong party here. Surely the people abusing the system (i.e. blog spam) should at least share a good chunk of the blame.
- pjc50 5y agoSure, but emergent bad actors exploiting features of a system that pay them are kind of inevitable, faceless, and there's an endless supply of them. The internet would be a very different place if it wasn't for this phenomenon of human behavior. Google are just the most powerful and most visible actor in this, and replacing the early less profit orientated web with a dark forest of advertising and tracking is to a great extent on them. (I don't think the web3 people have realised how important it is that the cost/benefit ratio of "ham" (good content) needs to be above the cost/benefit ratio of spam, by quite a large margin, or spam drives out ham)
- cromwellian 5y agoI’ve been on the internet since the 80s and the bad actors were still around back then. USENET was made unusable at one point by people spamming, mass cross posting, and playing cancel wars. This was well before ads or profit existed on the net.
- acdha 5y agoThis is all true but Google and later Facebook made it easier to monetize spam and were clearly unconcerned about the impact on communities unless advertisers stopped buying. An unethical immigration law firm still needed to sign up clients but a teenager in Moldova could scrape someone else’s content, SEO it, and make a decent income without knowing who the money came from. I think pjc’s point is extremely important: micropayments could dramatically change things but it’s quite hard to set values which will deter enough spam to be effective without excluding innocent people or simply increasing the damages when someone is compromised. That was what killed proof-of-work email spam concepts decades ago: even if you could get adoption, it wouldn’t have hurt the people using botnets to spam as much as many legitimate users.