6 ms·
A national strategy for the “new normal” of life with Covid
- somewhereoutth 5y agoSummary: It would be far too much trouble to actually do anything about Covid, so we are giving up (and pretending it is just the flu).
- nradov 5y agoWhat would actually doing anything look like? Does rapid distribution of free vaccines not count as anything?
- somewhereoutth 5y agoUniversal vaccination, with mandates as necessary. Distribution (and enforcement) of N95 masks. Rebuilding schools with sufficient ventilation. WFH as the default. Hospitality moves outside. Restrictions as necessary to keep R below one until suppression/elimination has been achieved.
- dehrmann 5y ago> keep R below one until suppression/elimination has been achieved This likely isn't possible. R0 would only low because of the restrictions, so as soon as you ease up on them, it starts spreading again. What you're proposing was the April 2020 fantasy that if we just flatten the curve, cases will be gone by September.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoSo you get it to zero, or to low enough to test trace isolate. China is a good example of how this can work.
- marssaxman 5y agoIf Chinese-style totalitarianism is the means necessary for an elimination strategy, I'd much rather take my chances with the disease. I do not understand why people think it is reasonable to expect that humanity can completely control diseases. That has never been the case. Disease is a fact of life. We get better and better at managing our responses, as we learn more, but we can only reduce, never eliminate the risk.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoDisease was a fact of life -but since antibiotics and vaccines we live much more disease free than we did before. Covid is reversing this progress. We do not have to become totalitarian to stamp out Covid, we just have to enforce the necessary policies for a limited and specific circumstance. I'd like to think our democratic institutions are capable of doing so in this instance, as they did so in previous times.
- remarkEon 5y agoI disagree in varying degrees with all of your points, but I'm going to pick on this one because it speaks to a certain elitism and bubble thinking that's been increasingly rampant on this topic. >WFH as the default. The percentage of the population that can actually do this is much smaller than I think people realize. That percentage is highly over-represented on this website because we're part of the Laptop Class, and privileged as such. Regular people in the vast majority of the country, working hourly wage jobs and the like, cannot do this. Manufacturing, what's left of it in this country, cannot do this (fanciful aspirations of an impending automation revolution aside for a moment, and hey someone has to manufacture and install the robots). This is to say nothing of the fact that most people who aren't wealthy do not have the space at home to facilitate actually working from there.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoMany regular people work in offices, talking to a computer. Indeed it is offices that cause the most transmission risk, as they tend to be small and ill ventilated. Certainly WFH can be the default in those cases. Of course, this detracts from the social performative aspect of work - bosses with the corner office and so forth.
- refurb 5y agoYou realize this will not get us to zero Covid? You’re basically trying to stamp out the common cold (same virus, Covid-19 being more severe) which has been with us..forever?
- somewhereoutth 5y agoNot the same virus, but a similar virus. As much as we would like to wish, Covid is not going to become the common cold anytime soon, or indeed ever. We should act according to what we see with Covid, and understand that any naïve attempts reduce it to other known pathogens can only lead us into tragedy.
- dehrmann 5y ago> and pretending it is just the flu With vaccines, it's pretty close to that. What we learned from that past two years is that covid zero isn't possible. You'll never get enough people or countries to agree with the restrictions required, and as the article mentioned, there are animal reservoirs. Realistically, the amount of "trouble" looks like what China's doing right now.
- HWR_14 5y agoNew Zealand seems to be doing just fine.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoAnimal reservoirs don't seem to be causing trouble in China - my understanding is that animal to humantransmission has been observed only in minks. Vaccines have indeed been a great success - but we wait to see how much protection they give against long COVID, and how COVID might evolve to evade them. With wide circulation, there is a strong selection pressure for such evasion. Luckily Omicron was inherently milder than Delta, so the vaccines' protection against severe disease held up. Maybe we won't be so lucky the next time (and the next time, and the next time...)
- nradov 5y agoAre you sure animal reservoirs aren't causing trouble in China? The leading hypothesis for SARS-CoV-2 origin is zoonotic transmission from bats. Assuming that's correct, the bats are still out there somewhere...
- HarryHirsch 5y agoTo cope with pandemic, and eventually, endemic SARS-CoV-2 and to respond to future public health threats requires deploying real-time information systems, a public health implementation workforce, flexible health systems, trust in government and public health institutions, and belief in the value of collective action for public good. I agree with all that. Now - can we have paid sick leave and workers rights, so that someone who is COVID-positive can stay home and cure their infection instead of having themselves drag back to work after five days? The paper suggests data infrastructure. How about quarantine infrastructure? How about lower housing prices and better salaries so that only one parent has to work and schools don't have to be in session at a time of high COVID incidence? We can't even have access to proper testing - everyone remembers Jen Psaki pulling a smirk when a reporter asked why the government can't send tests to every citizen. Now we are promised a website where you can order two tests per adult. And real soon you can even get reimbursed for tests that you bought yourself, if you could get any. Sorry, trust in government is lost. Maybe it can be rebuilt, but it'll take two generations, by which time everyone who is susceptible to COVID has died of it and humanity has evolved to coexist with the virus. We are screwed.
- whoomp12342 5y agowhat about someone whose kids are sick with covid? make sure that is included.
- luckyscs 5y agoI mean my government got out a novel vaccine in a year and distributed 3 to four doses to those who have wanted it. I'm impressed. Ask any other entity in the world to accomplish that...
- whoomp12342 5y agosigh, here we go again with extra loss to civil liberty
- geofft 5y agoYup, abandoning "zero covid" is abandoning the one thing the government should do - protect us from external threats to our life. If some country were threatening to invade, the government would use every means at its disposal - including temporarily suppressing the civil liberties of certain people by drafting them into the military - to protect us. When a couple thousand people died twenty years ago, the US jumped headfirst into a twenty-year war against a country loosely linked to the people behind it and an uninvolved neighboring country that we didn't like, too, just in case. But now that we have a hundred-fold more deaths in this country and no signs of it stopping, just because we can't see the enemy, we're surrendering? It's nonsense. And besides the actual cost, it's going to make a lot of people feel like the only government that can fulfill the legitimate limited role of government competently is a giant authoritarian one. A whole lot of people are saying things like "I wish the government would tell me what to do to keep safe. I find it exhausting to figure this out for myself." They aren't going to be particularly open to pro-civil-liberties arguments after this experience.
- nradov 5y agoGiven that the current vaccines don't prevent transmission, and there are multiple animal hosts, how exactly could "zero covid" be accomplished? https://www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/covid-rampant-deer-research-shows-rcna10181 https://www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/covid-rampant-d...
- HarryHirsch 5y agoTesting and quarantine, as well as work-from-home where possible and proper ventilation/masking where not possible. Why on Earth do we have schools open at a time when Omikron is rampant?
- 5y ago
- legerdemain 5y agoA 5-year plan for a (hopefully happy) new normal: - Reduce unnecessary social contact to a minimum: all-remote workplaces, ubiquitous and fast grocery delivery, a culutre of avoiding "window-shopping" and mall-going. - Significantly reduce residential density: reduce the need for work commutes, dismantle crowded public transit, minimize public spaces and the need for them, preferentially live at a distance from the urban core, incorporate more single-family homes into natural wilderness and parklands. - Reverse the "unbundling" of family and home activities: prefer to home-school children instead of packing them off to overcrowded schools, or at least share private instructors with a few other parents in your "pod," eat out less and cook at home more (or hire an in-home cook, as many of my peers did). Disease needs density and crowding. Get more fresh air and put more space between people, and we'll all get healthier and happier.
- legerdemain 5y agoBefore someone comments that not all of these measures are affordable or accessible to everyone: you're right! But don't let perfect be the enemy of good! Lots and lots of people, many people on HN among them, can pursue many of these changes in their lives. And improving the lives of an entire class of people is surely a better outcome than inaction and defeatism, no?
- onecommentman 5y agoThe operative word is “can”…people should be informed of risks and then they can/may choose to restrict contacts and the like. Not must, but can respond in helpful ways. Many people will be personally motivated to “do the right, and feasible, thing” and feel good in the process. If it turns out to be overkill, they won’t be resentful, just bemused. Any external social incentives should be taken with great care. A heavy-handed or meat-ax approach, especially in situations of significant uncertainty, will cause more long-term harm than good. Translation: don’t be an overbearing buffoon if you aren’t very certain about the consequences of what you are doing or requiring of others. You can be a buffoon (there is still a lot of “fog of war” on this and inaction is an action itself), just not an overbearing one. Defer to individual choice, it really is the Americasian way. (Want a descriptor for all the Americas, North and South, so trying Americasian. Too clunky?)
- mindslight 5y agoGiven that Omicron is swamping hospitals to the point that getting healthcare has become questionable, it's a bit premature to talk about any "new normal". Like sure we can look ahead and try to plan, but don't assume we're heading towards some steady state where things make sense again. For example, would this "new normal" include the expectation that you'll be promptly treated after a serious car accident, or not? Right now that's kind of indeterminate, depending on how bad the nursing burnout is. This article is also talking like there is some overarching policy that is perhaps being overcautious and could be dialed back. But there is no coherent policy - rather there is the dumpster fire of laissez faire, and there are those who can avoid it. So we've got a bifurcated society with some people having the power (or making sacrifices) to insulate themselves. And those who cannot just end up in harm's way regardless of the absolute risk being low or high, possibly rationalizing their predicament. cf "What Keeps Mankind Alive". Planning wise, if you're continuing to be cautious spring and summer will most likely be the time to go out and enjoy a year's worth of social activity in open air. That's about the extent of what you can rely upon right now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- onecommentman 5y ago“In delineating a national strategy, humility is essential. The precise duration of immunity to SARS-CoV-2 from vaccination or prior infection is unknown. Also unknown is whether SARS-CoV-2 will become a seasonal infection; whether antiviral therapies will prevent long COVID; or whether even more transmissible, immune-evading, or virulent variants will arise after Omicron. Another part of this humility is recognizing that predictions are necessary but educated guesses, not mathematical certainty. The virus, host response, and data will evolve. Biomedical and public health tools will expand, along with better understanding of their limitations. The incidence of SARS-CoV-2, vaccination rates, hospital capacity, tolerance for risk, and willingness to implement different interventions will vary geographically, and national recommendations will need to be adapted locally.” I was ready to reject any policy recommendation from the AMA as biased and self-serving. Their track record over decades has not been flawless. This is the most succinct, coherent and downright wise guidance for managing COVID in 2021 I’ve read. And a call for humility by the medical community? That’s downright unprecedented. Of historic import, like acknowledging that the new-fangled “germ theory” might have some merit after all. Science-informed, not “science”-determined.
- peteradio 5y agoNo new humility developed for the vaccine strategy: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2787946 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2787946 Mandate full steam ahead.