17 ms·
California Considers Doubling Its Taxes
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agocompletely bad faith titling. "CA considers publically funded health care" would be just as accurate. please fix this.
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoIf it actually provides down cost in healthcare insurance that makes it cheaper, then I think many people wouldn't mind it. Otherwise, I don't see how middle class will not revolt and leave the state. So glad I'm not a californian lol.
- dragonwriter 5y agoCalifornia's health spending per capita is about double it's tax receipts per capita, and the majority of that spending is private spending, so even if this analysis is accurate, doubling taxes to fund full public healthcare would be a significant overall cost savings.
- vondur 5y agoI can't imagine something like this working out well here. In the current environment, I'd imagine a big chunk of the tech force that can work remotely will simply leave the state. This would devastate the states income tax collection.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _moof 5y agoLike most states, nonresidents owe California tax on income from California sources.
- KerrAvon 5y agoThe actual law is a bit more complicated than that. California is unusually aggressive about tax enforcement compared to the IRS and most other states, but if you're for example working for a California-based FAANG in Austin, you're probably not paying CA tax. (This is not tax advice, I'm not a tax advisor, etc.)
- dragonwriter 5y agoNo, like most states, nonresidents owe California tax on income earned from work in the state, regardless of the source, not based on the source of the income.
- jjav 5y agoWhy you think so? As a highly paid tech worker, if this were to pass (I doubt, insurance companies have too much political influence, but let's dream) it would make me stay in CA forever.
- alexjray 5y agoThis is insane. People are already leaving the states in droves. If this passes they are literally shooting themselves in the foot.
- distrill 5y agoThey really aren't. 100 people moving to a town in Idaho makes a big impact on that town in Idaho but is not felt at all by California.
- alexjray 5y ago38% decrease in people moving to California 12% increase in residents moving out of state last year. In San Francisco Bay Area, it's even more stark. There was a 45% decrease in entrances from other states to the Bay Area and a 21% increase in residents leaving for other states.
- alexjray 5y agohttps://www.capolicylab.org/pandemic-patterns-california-is-seeing-fewer-entrances-and-more-exits/ https://www.capolicylab.org/pandemic-patterns-california-is-...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- distrill 5y agoPeople halting moves into a dense population center because the city shut down for covid is not the same thing as people "fleeing in droves for taxes". There are absolutely some people doing this, but you are making up connections and this is a lazy talking point.
- alexjray 5y agoIt's a combination of a lot of things. But the data is clear people don't want to move to California and the people who do live there are leaving.
- uejfiweun 5y agoIf this happens, I will most certainly leave the state. I mean this is ridiculous. These people have consistently shown that their ability to spend our tax dollars is literal dog shit. People and companies are leaving the state in droves. And their response is to literally double taxes?
- kvetching 5y ago
- Zigurd 5y agoCompared to your insurer?
- qaq 5y agoLooking at housing availability hard to believe there is an actual net outflow from CA
- Guest42 5y agoAgreed, the numbers indicate a pretty significant exodus although it seems as though the supply has decreased and the pricing has increased on both rentals and homes for sale. Mathematically, the extent to which it happens and the duration don’t make much sense to me.
- coding123 5y agoRich FANG employees don't sell their bay area homes, they are just buying a second (and third) one to have their remote job location outside of the bay area. (Anecdata only- family members not me personally)
- thatfrenchguy 5y agoEveryone wants to leave, that’s why houses sell for 2-3m$ clearly
- 5y ago
- no_wizard 5y ago> to fund a first-in-the-nation single-payer health-care system. This is key here. So instead of paying this out to a private insurance company I pay it in taxes, there by my actual change is net zero, in most cases. I have a feeling most reactions might be headline driven here. I think it’s worth doing the math on how much it costs you in healthcare coverage before really judging a book by its cover here. If my compound deductions are the same who cares if it’s just taxes?
- lax4ever 5y agoDo you actually pay that much a year in insurance premiums? I don't live in CA, but I sure don't and my health coverage is pretty good. Keep in mind, this is also just the insurance premium, there's no talk of what co-pays or deductibles would be. In addition, your employer now has to pay more based on their gross receipts and if you make more than 150k a year you are paying even more.
- spamizbad 5y agoI mean, my employer technically sponsors part of mine, but to cover my family I'm still paying roughly $10K each year in premiums.
- lax4ever 5y agoMy employer sponsors some of mine as well, but even if they weren't my premiums are still around half of what they listed in the article ($12.5k I think is listed in the article if I read it right). This is with coverage that has a minimal deductible and that includes great mental health coverage amongst other things.
- KZerda 5y agoKeep in mind as well that your employer probably pays a significant chunk of your insurance premiums right now, usually around 3/4 of the full costs of providing you insurance. This is what tends to bite people when they need COBRA coverage or other gap coverage when changing jobs, etc.
- 5y ago
- bitwize 5y agoIf you want to live in a nice society that has nice things, best learn to pony up.
- qaq 5y agogiven how much CA collects already where exactly are those nice things?
- kvetching 5y ago
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoIs California nice and has nice things?
- ryan93 5y agoThe Congolese need to pony up if they want a nice society!
- jppope 5y agoThe healthcare system in the United States is debatably one of the worst in the world. Cheers to California for trying to find a way to guarantee that all Californian's have access to the worlds worst healthcare system.
- likeabbas 5y agoThe US health care treatments are the best in the world, just the costs are higher than the rest of the world.
- baq 5y agothe system is one of the worst in aggregate even if top percentiles are the best. it's extremely unbalanced.
- _moof 5y agoPlease elaborate on what you mean when you say that US health care treatments are the best in the world.
- likeabbas 5y agoWhen you have a good insurance provider, the health care is top notch. You're able to choose your doctors, hospitals and that can make a big difference in your health care coverage. You're also able to get coverage for things that most single-payer systems won't cover. Last year I was able to choose my surgeon who operated on my knee last year and my total out of pocket expenses were less than $500 for a $20k surgery. In most single-payer health care systems I wouldn't have been able to get the surgery because it was elective and only a partial tear of my patellar tendon.
- ARandumGuy 5y agoWhile the US does contain some stellar hospitals and surgeons, by broader metrics the US performs poorly. From 2010 to 2015 (before COVID messed with the data), the US ranked 43rd [1] in overall life expectancy. This is behind countries like Cuba and Slovenia, and well behind other rich countries like Japan, Canada, or the UK. Healthcare costs and outcomes can't be separated from each other. The more expensive it is to receive treatment, the fewer people will get the treatment they need. Having good service isn't sufficient if that service isn't available to everyone. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_past_life_expectancy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_past_life...
- jamestimmins 5y agoAs a taxpayer I don't actually have a problem with this. However, as a California resident who has seen this state's inability to think through regulations effectively or solve housing problems, I'm incredibly skeptical of California's ability to implement single payer healthcare effectively. I would likely leave the state because I assume California would fail to deliver, and taxes would get raised for nothing.
- ravenstine 5y agoExactly. Leave it to California to foul something up. No matter what one's stance is on health care, I don't get how Californians can have faith in their establishment. The things we have that are relatively turnkey ways of bringing in money like the ports, the farmland, Hollywood, and Silicon Valley serve to paint over the rot. If we had none of those things and we governed ourselves the way we have been for decades now, we'd be the Venezuela of the United States.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y ago> the ports, the farmland, Hollywood, and Silicon Valley serve to paint over the rot. In what universe are these things a coat of paint? In California's economy, these things are the whole damn tree: the roots, the trunk, the leaves, all of it. It might have a couple rotting branches, but it yields so much fruit that people just don't care.
- ravenstine 5y agoThey're gold mines. Even if you're a mismanaged mining company, you still have guaranteed access to gold. That is until you've mined all the gold, and then what? Oh, what's that? You spent all the money you made and your business is designed in a way that it only can survive when there's a gold surplus? Well, now. What California has is not the norm. Other states and countries might have one of those things; maybe they've got ports, or maybe they've got farmland in an optimal climate, or they've got something else. But until things change (which they will), no one has been able to have Hollywood or Silicon Valley as well as everything else. Once those things are sufficiently dissolved and others drink from our milkshake, it will suddenly be apparent how few of the people in California cared, to use your words; when the money dries up, it will be apparent how few things we actually have better than other parts of the country, as well as other countries. It's easy to ignore outdated and crumbling infrastructure, the crime and the homelessness, and budget being utterly wasted when the money keeps rolling in and the beach is no more than an hour away.
- mdavis6890 5y agoI do not believe single-payer is a good idea, but then lots of people DO seem to think it is, and the state is probably the best level at which to conduct an experiment this way. As a Californian, I'll be happy to see the experiment conducted, sad that it happens in my state, and excited to be a guinea pig. My only hope if we do this is that the federal govt or other states do not leap quickly into this and give it a good 10 years to see how things work out for us.
- Maxion 5y agoWhy do you believe single-payer is a bad idea? The model works very well in most European countries.
- oa2022 5y agoIt works in the sense that I go to a private clinic when I have an issue. Likewise with the great public school system, where families pay 30k per year so they can avoid a public school
- baq 5y agoMe too, but only because my employer pays for that extra, and on multiple occasions it was easier and quicker to get an appointment in the public health care system - which shouldn't be too surprising, since there's a personnel shortage in healthcare full stop.
- dillondoyle 5y agoIn most countries that have public care you can still do this, just like opting for private schools. Britain people buy private insurance for any additional services they want. But I don't think they usually get a tax incentives like private school does can in the US? https://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tips/college-and-education/tax-tips-when-sending-kids-to-private-or-public-schools/L8TJdgFAH https://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tips/college-and-education/t...
- 5y ago
- SllX 5y agoThis will be one of the easiest “No” votes I’ll have ever filled out on my ballot. For those following along at home, this resolution would take the form of a Constitutional Amendment, if passed by Californians on the ballot that would raise per household taxes by $12,500/year. The important thing here is that Californians have to agree to pass it.
- jjav 5y agoSince my current health insurance (blue shield) costs ~$30K/year, that would be a huge win.
- sam0x17 5y agoI pay $1.3k/month for private insurance for myself + my husband, so it would be an easy yes vote for me.
- SllX 5y agoI pay less than half of that. So in effect you’re seeking to drive up my costs in order to drive yours down. I can at least understand why you would want to, but I won’t be your ally.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoDo you mean less than one quarter of that? Parent is paying for two, and it looks like you are paying for one?
- mjrpes 5y agoEverything in the bill is a highly progressive tax based on percentage of earnings/revenue by individual/business: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220ACA11 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm... $500,000 income (at 50+ org) would be taxed $7500+4500+750+2000 = $14,750/year $300,000 income (at 50+ org) would be taxed $3750+2500+$750 = $7000/year $150,000 income would be taxed either $1000 (<50 org) or $2875 (50+ org) a year $50,000 income would be taxed either $0 (<50 org) or $625 (50+ org) a year So it's around $450,000 income that you hit that $12,500/year amount (2.7% of income) Excise tax is separate factor.
- distrill 5y agoThis is going to be a fun comments section.
- mrkentutbabi 5y ago
- trdtaylor1 5y agoEveryone who makes ~>250k would assumingly lose on this idea. Cost of insurance + maximum out of pocket would be smaller then the tax increase. I assume it would also be restricted to Cali without procuring a reciprocity agreement with a national insurer. If Dems managed to repeal the SALT deduction cap OR Cali just codes it to get around it (payroll tax direct to company only, and independent contractor business tax), this would be a much better idea.
- thatfrenchguy 5y agoYou only loose out though if you’re employed and you assume you’ll always be employed over 250k and never end up in a situation where your income drops and you loose your health insurance. There are no national insurer btw, except for self insured employees.
- caslon 5y agoMedian household income (in 2019 dollars), 2015-2019 $75,235 Per capita income in past 12 months (in 2019 dollars), 2015-2019 $36,955 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/CA/INC110219 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/CA/INC110219 Your median Californian, and significantly above your median Californian, makes below $250k.
- creato 5y ago> (1) An annual excise tax is hereby imposed upon a qualified business, as defined by the Legislature, for the privilege of doing business in this state at a rate of 2.3 percent of the gross receipts of that qualified business minus the first two million dollars ($2,000,000) in annual gross receipts of that business. This part seems insane. Any business with slim profit margins and out of state competitors is screwed. Also, does this mean multi-state/multi-national companies have to pay 2.3% of their nation/world-wide revenues to California? That's obviously absurd...
- rubyist5eva 5y agoI'm sure all the Silicon Valley multi-millionaires are going to love losing their world-class healthcare benefits so the junkie on the corner in LA gets the same level as care as they do.
- SSilver2k2 5y agoIf this passes I will be the first to move to California. I am happy to pay high taxes if it means it will better my lives and the lives of others.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- reghtlkjlkj 5y ago
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoI mean, I will move too, because OP will pay for mine.
- txsoftwaredev 5y agoIf you are looking to offload some money I'll take it! It would better my life.
- SSilver2k2 5y agoAfter looking at your comment history I don't think money would better your life. Travel would.
- sneak 5y agoYou don't need to move to contribute to charity that helps others.
- SSilver2k2 5y agoCharity helps specific people. Taxes help everyone. I always vote to increase my property taxes. Libraries, Schools, Emergency Services all get better with that increased revenue.
- 5y ago
- city17 5y agoI'm curious to see how a single payer system will work when the entire industry is profit-based. In most countries that with a single-payer healthcare system, all the medical institutions are either publicly funded or owned, or have some sort of cap on profits and monetary incentives. California as a single state with a single-payer funding having to then give all that money to profit-driver medical institutions seems like a very tricky situation.
- thatfrenchguy 5y agoNah, lots of countries have single payer and for profit institutions. France has private PCPs and specialists, private hospitals and public hospitals.
- TMWNN 5y ago"Single-payer" means one insurance plan for everyone. France, as you know, has multiple plans for its people. So it's not single-payer. But you are of course correct in France having private doctors and hospitals as well as public hospitals. Speaking as an American, city17 makes the common mistake of thinking that Canada and the UK, the two foreign countries we are most exposed to, are representative of the rest of the developed world. Since both countries have single-payer systems with zero/minimal cost on delivery (and more or less 100% public hospitals in the UK), many Americans think that that's the way all countries' healthcare systems work. They have no idea that a 30% copay is normal in France, or that Germany/Austria/Switzerland/Netherlands all have Obamacare-like mandates to obtain insurance from one of dozens/hundreds of competing plans, or that Australia has a government plan but *strongly* encourages people to get a private plan.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ravenstine 5y agoLovely. If this passes, I'll be paying more than I do for catastrophic, unless I decide to make significantly less money. If this is as it sounds, my future is definitely not in California.
- bell-cot 5y ago> A proposed constitutional amendment (ACA 11) in California would increase taxes... However literally true that might be, the chance of the amendment being passed by voters seem neigh-zero. And the article seems to carefully avoid that subject. So file this one in the "if we had a metal which could easily contain the temperatures and pressures needed for economical hydrogen fusion..." bin.
- NDizzle 5y agoThese same voters that kept Newsom from being recalled?! Good luck, Californians. I'm sure they'll spend this money wisely!!!! Who knows what's next. Perhaps this will help the bullet train reach Fresno, Merced, or maybe Modesto. By 2050. Maybe.
- francisofascii 5y agoA more balanced approach would be to increase property taxes. CA already has a high income tax.
- lend000 5y agoThis. Higher property taxes might encourage more density and productive use of land, too.
- aidenn0 5y agoI'm cautiously supportive of single-payer health care, but gross-receipts taxes are one of the dumbest ways of apportioning taxes...
- gjsman-1000 5y agoCalifornia has a golden goose in the wealthy megacorporations and billionaires who live there. Every tax that California adds risks killing that golden goose. Tesla has already left as highly publicized, but others are too. Apple is building a billion-dollar campus in Austin, Texas. Oracle has moved its headquarters to Texas.
- sam0x17 5y ago> Apple is building a billion-dollar campus in Austin, Texas That they're already seriously regretting doing now that the promises of the remote economy are starting to be truly realized and the pandemic shows no end in sight. Billion dollar campuses are worth $0 in a fully remote economy. Turn them all into high quality public housing and move on. The office is dead.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoIn which case, if I'm a business, why am I in California again? Why pay their taxes? Time to move out (if that's true).
- sam0x17 5y agoNot much you can do about it even as a remote org. One employee living in Cali and you have to pay cali taxes.
- hermannj314 5y agoThank you California! I now know where I will be spending the years of my life when I have no income and insanely high medical bills. Gonna stick in PA with our 3.07% while I am earning bank and healthy though.
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoDon't steal my idea! California is one of my retirement choice!
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoThat's really why states can't do universal healthcare on their own. It is too easy to move between states to find the best deal.
- jjav 5y agoAgreed. Very unfortunately, this is why these solutions can't work at the state level. It needs to be country-wide for it to work. Same with e.g. homelessness solutions.
- cagey 5y agoExactly! I moved out of CA at the end of 2020. I've recently retired, and have structured most of my spendable income in retirement to be tax sheltered, so if this passes (and depending on the taxation specifics of this plan, if it passes, vs my retirement income stream), it could easily make sense to move back: no more COBRA or other unsubsidized OOP health insurance payments for us! Of course, even if the proposal becomes law, it might take a decade or two to come into full force (someone else mentioned CA's High Speed Rail project, but healthcare as it exists today is a far larger Gordian Knot), so I think I'll watch from the sidelines to see how such a grand plan works out in reality.
- reghtlkjlkj 5y ago
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoWhy SalesForce? How tall is SalesForce Tower?
- reghtlkjlkj 5y ago
- throwaway946513 5y agoGolden Gate Bridge has suicide nets to (significantly) reduce chances of death should you desire to jump. (Though if I remember from my last visit correctly, they also have rather tall fencing for the walkway.)
- toss1 5y agoDeceptive title, kind of designed for clickbait The first sentence: >>A proposed constitutional amendment (ACA 11) in California would increase taxes by $12,250 per household, roughly doubling the state’s already high tax collections, to fund a first-in-the-nation single-payer health-care system. It completely omits that this move would simultaneously remove every resident's healthcare & insurance costs. Pretty obvious bad-faith writing, and it is disappointing to see it echoed on HN. Edit: I'm happy to read about and discuss the merits and problems of such a proposal, but this kind of title is just irritating - it's what I try to come here to avoid.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThere's a lot of contextless scaremongering in the article. Here's one example. > For instance, the payroll tax exempts employers with fewer than 50 resident employees, punishing small businesses for expanding and creating a meaningful tax cliff. Imagine, for instance, the overly simplified hypothetical of a company with 49 employees making $80,000 each. At 49 employees, the company has no payroll tax burden. Hiring one additional employee generates a tax bill of $90,000—more than that employee’s salary! Wow! NINETY K, MAN! That's a lot of money, says Joe Q Public. Except....revenue per employee is ~$100k for small businesses, with larger companies being $200k or more. At 49 employees, your business has likely $4.9M in revenue or more. That means that additional big scary $80k represents 1.6% of your revenue. Yawn.
- Dig1t 5y agoHonestly this is a great sign IMO. Rather than forcing this kind of system on a nation-wide scale, something that would undoubtedly make a lot of people unhappy for a bunch of different reasons, we can trial this kind of system on a smaller scale and see how it goes. Obviously the good people of California are okay with paying high taxes, and this is just the kind of thing that the majority of CA people seem to want from their policy makers, as they are repeatedly elected, so it seems pretty perfect to me. I, personally, am very happy with my employer health insurance and am glad that I left CA for a state with no income tax, but for the people remaining in CA it sounds great. If this ends up happening Americans will have the ability to choose to live in a place with universal healthcare or not while still living in the US, which is pretty cool IMO.
- sneak 5y ago> Rather than forcing this kind of system on a nation-wide scale, something that would undoubtedly make a lot of people unhappy for a bunch of different reasons California is nation-scale. You are still forcing this kind of system into a nation-amount of people.
- Nevermark 5y agoNationwide (only one option) vs. nation-like quantity of people (other states, other systems, as options) are very different situations.
- medvezhenok 5y agoYes, but unlike a true nation, there are no immigration restrictions barring you from moving to a different state if you don’t want to opt in.
- txsoftwaredev 5y agoAnd how much will the cost of health care increase now that the insurance companies have the state government footing any bill?
- john_moscow 5y agoSo, we are not building new hospitals, not creating new ICU beds, not investing into more medical programs at universities (or making them more affordable), not cracking down on opaque pricing and exponentially growing hospital administration. Instead we are introducing another bureaucratic layer to manage access to an extremely limited resource that has not been keeping up with the increasing population. What could possibly go wrong? /s
- onphonenow 5y agoOr relaxing licensing rules?
- larkost 5y agoThis would not be creating another bureaucratic layer. It would be replacing the portion of the system that is currently a private bureaucratic layer (insurance companies), and replacing it by expanding (and modifying) the existing governmental bureaucratic layer. If you don't like the switch from private bureaucrats to public bureaucrats then please state that and make your argument why. Don't pretend the private ones don't exist.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sam0x17 5y agoThis is key when you note that for good private insurance for self+one, you typically have to pay out $1.2k / month at least. Did that for a number of years.
- andrethegiant 5y agoChange the title here please dang?
- ___q 5y agoEven the author walks it back in the article. CA is "practically" or "roughly" doubling its taxes (and removing insurance costs). The clickbait headline though? "DOUBLING"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TheMagicHorsey 5y agoDamn, this is gonna increase housing prices in Texas. Need to buy a house there quick, before all the Bernie brothers realize that US governments have no capability to execute. (You'd think they would have learned seeing the performance of the CDC with Covid, the State Dept. with Afghanistan, the Military with every campaign since WW2, NASA with the Space Shuttle and ISS, CA govt with unemployment and parental benefits over Covid, CA public schools, SF and LA local governments on nearly every metric. Like these are failed institutions kept alive my the infinite tax payer money faucet. Turned this socialist into a capitalist in just 25 years. Government is absolutely hopeless on execution, but great on selling the vision to people with no experience in execution ... e.g. me at 25.
- standardUser 5y agoA few things to keep in mind/think about... - Employer-sponsored healthcare is aggressively anti-entrepreneurial and any universal program would be a massive boon to independent workers and those who own or want to start their own business. - In addition to the $400-$600 us and/or our employer pay every month (for one person), we also have to pay for copays, coinsurance, deductibles and so on. I'd hope that under any universal system these would all disappear. And no more HSAs and other unnecessarily complicated programs we've designed to deal with our bizarre system. - CA already has a variety of healthcare systems that are universal for those who qualify and are very expensive. I'm curious how these might operate under a statewide universal system, especially fully federal programs like the VA. - More than anything, I'd love to leave behind our byzantine and unpredictable system of trying to determine which providers accept our insurance (goodbye "networks") and how much a given treatment will actually cost us. Even as a person who does not often need medical care, I've still encountered many unexpected bills, in some cases despite direct assurances from the provider and/or insurer that I would not have to pay. Then comes the appeals... another absurd aspect of out system we could leave in the dustbin of history.
- jjav 5y ago> Employer-sponsored healthcare is aggressively anti-entrepreneurial and any universal program would be a massive boon to independent workers and those who own or want to start their own business. Can't emphasize this too much. I'd rather start a small startup of my own, but the only thing that always keeps me away is health insurance in the US. I have enough savings that I could afford to pay all my expenses for many years so I'd be comfortable with no revenue for a long time. Except for health insurance, which currently is $2500/month through company group plan, surely even more expensive for a new tiny startup. Can't do it. I guess I need to wait until I qualify for medicare to try my hand at my own startup.
- standardUser 5y agoAnd god forbid a person has actual health issues, which is not uncommon for people in their 40's and 50's, a time when a lot of people first have the savings and/or experience to start their own business.
- nomendos 5y agoI am US Citizen living in CA, while also have lived (and am citizen) of other 3 countries, Canada as one prior to US. To remind all, Michael Moore's Sicko documentary is huge misrepresentation of how good socialized HC is, while it did point huge issues with the current privatized/greed-based private US HC with crooked HC+insurance industry. So as not all is BW, from my experience with Canadian HC, socialization of the health-care system shall produce the following: 1. significantly lower the quality of services (same or lower number of staff, material, equipment serving higher number of people) 2. waiting lists shall start appearing slowly and then progress over the years 3. HC shall deteriorate slowly (look at the UK and many other countries) 4. Extended/add-on/"bridge" HC shall become popular to fill in the gaps for the working people who demand at least better minimum (in Canada this is the norm, where typical Canadian pays just for this add-on HC similar per paycheck amount as US employer for the whole today's HC!) Populist government "figures" shall play any card to live for another day and "please voters" including "changing realities" or avoiding the real "put all on the table and have open conversation" approach.
- Dig1t 5y agoYou are totally right, I've also heard the same thing from the many Canadians I've been friends with over the years as well as my family in the UK. I don't know if most people realize it, but there is definitely a tradeoff between 100% equal access and quality. But it does seem that's a tradeoff that many people want to make so idk
- nomendos 5y agoNo, most people do now know this. Michael Moore's Sicko movie did good criticism of the current dysfunctional US HC and it is even worse than that. Government is not doing the job to "govern" to fight monopolies, greed and outright corruption and Medical Industrial Complex has Washington swamp in their pocket (together with other monopolies mafias). So, US is increasingly dysfunctional and there will be consequences from that up to possibly fall of the whole "western civilization" (US+Eu+UK) and 1st chaos, then multipolar opportunistic world. People vote for "short term sales pitch" instead of what is optimal and right for long term and their kids and grandkids. Key factors are missing: - Political manipulation is dominant. - Fact, logic rational based dialogue is vanishing. (i.e. indirectly and directly stimulated by interests, so left does not talk to right and any rational thought is attacked/labeled/censored and anyone who provides criticism of any or both sides in different ways is painted/pushed "polarized" often each side paints such people both ways whatever suits them, so echo chamber effect gets amplified until the system blows up). - People, through generations, are conditioned to be driven by emotions vs face logic/facts/rational. This starts from the early age kids conditioning them into 'ideal consumers' (some call this "idiots" and I understand it but it will be hard to wake them up by reason only, as past tells the only unfortunate way to wake up is catastrophe/calamity/hinger/war) I can tell a lot of information to anyone that can be add on to Michael's Moore documentary and can paint the complex truth. It is not black and white at all and from my long life experience, best would be to fix the current US HC by breaking monopolies and unfair practices (such as price gauging, etc,...) and this could get US to way better HC than any socialized system can be. But my predictions is that "populism hustling" in the atmosphere of forbidden rational dialogue and political hustlers will go worse direction. I guess it is that 4th degenerative phase of the empire, where "soul&spirit" of the people's mind falls (obvious all around us). I just hope US does not go the way of Balkan.
- uberman 5y agoCalifornia would increase taxes by $12,250 per household Let's take it at face value this is fact. For my healthcare plan I pay 6k a year on top of what the company pays (more that 20k). Then I pay copays on top of that. It seems perfectly plausible to me that I would come out ahead if the company and I switched from paying about 30k a year in healthcare costs to a single payer system with only 20k a year in costs to me and my employer! We can split the difference and each is ahead 5k. I think people need to do more than just read a headline.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoThat is $12,250 on average. If you are a FAANG tech worker, it will be much higher than that, you will less likely to be coming out ahead on this the more money you make (though, to be fair, they are only proposing to fund this partially with an income tax increase).
- uberman 5y agoFor me the surtax would raise my taxes payroll from 12.05% to 14.05% or roughly 10k and all things considered I make a lot of money. If my employer stopped providing health insurance and instead paid the approximately 4.5% (estimated as I don't see the actual schedule of payroll tax only that it kicks in at 50k and tops out at 2.25%) business side of this. We still come out about even.
- Justin_K 5y agoAlso think about how providers won't accept lower rates, so your new discount plan will only give you access to bottom of the barrel providers willing to take any patient at any price.
- larkost 5y agoYou are forgetting that insurance companies are a middleman eating up some of the costs, both as profits and as costs. It is a slightly unfair comparison (Medicare has more older people who have large single-issue costs, so less admin work), but Medicare costs about 2% of its costs in administrative costs. Whereas private insurance usually is more like 12%-18%. There are a lot of details in that to sort, and no-one expects a final single-payer system to wind up quite as good as Medicare is... but there is a lot of fat to trim off the private insurance system. And note please: we are only talking about admin fees (salaries and the like for people working there), this has nothing to do with the actual costs of care. If anything this is unfair against Medicare, since they are ruthless in negotiating their actual costs (something private insurance is not really incentivized to do at all).
- _8j50 5y agoBuild caves and tunnel houses in the mountains for the poor to live in and bullet trains to the valley and the deserts. Rich people want to live on the coast and they will pay to keep the poor out. That won't change, let's accept reality and fix root causes. More housing and development. More investment in water security!
- ryan93 5y agoDoesn't seem like a serious thing. Almost zero chance of passing.
- jimbob45 5y agoThe best proposal I've heard is not to have government-run single-payer but to instead have a public option. That way, if insurance companies truly are colluding and providing a worse product, then the government can compete and bring costs down to a reasonable level by providing baseline competition. Compared to a government potentially mismanaging and ruining care for millions, it seems the safer alternative. I've never heard a solid argument against the public option and both sides in general seem to agree on it. The fact that it was Lieberman and not a Republican that killed it in 2010 [0] makes me very hopeful that a public option would be highly politically viable now 12 years later. [0] https://newrepublic.com/article/73683/the-public-option-still-dead https://newrepublic.com/article/73683/the-public-option-stil...
- unstatusthequo 5y agoSo happy I left California and the crushing tax burden.
- mrtweetyhack 5y ago
- France_is_bacon 5y ago[dead]
- danielrpa 5y agoPlease help me understand one thing, while having in mind that I'm not particularly for or against single payer. My problem is that I don't buy the top argument for single payer I'm seeing here. Many people here are arguing that healthcare is expensive, is a basic human need and it's really hard to get it in the US if you don't have a job paying for it. Even when jobs help out with the premiums, it's still hard to pay for it in California. All true. Do you know another basic human need? A place to live. Without a place to live, you are homeless - which is normally seen as even worse as not having access to healthcare. A place to live in the bay area is really expensive, more so than healthcare. I don't live in the bay area, but it appears that a reasonable rent for a place for 3 people is around $3500/mo or 42K/year. This is more than out of pocket (no subsidies) Kaiser + average healthcare expenses. If the government is supposed to pay for healthcare in California, why isn't it supposed to pay for rent? Both are basic needs and quite expensive. Serious question.