15 ms·
Why Restaurants Are So Fucked – Part II
- efficax 5y agoWhat is this guy talking about? Workers are not getting COVID benefits of any kind right now, not unemployment, not relief checks, nothing, in the US. If you quit voluntarily in most states you don't even qualify for normal unemployment. The improved unemployment benefit was ended in September 2021, and it did not result in increased employment!
- voisin 5y agoI concur. Where are all the employees? Labour force participation has collapsed over a number of years, but where are all the people if not getting some unemployment somewhere? It seems every retailer I pass in every city has a sign up right now looking for employees.
- daleco 5y agoSome stayed at home to take care of the kids. Others upleveled and went for jobs that pay better wages. A bunch of people died as well, I wonder of this affected the job market. I'd love to read a study on this specific topic.
- lotsofpulp 5y agohttps://www.bls.gov/charts/employment-situation/civilian-labor-force-participation-rate.htm https://www.bls.gov/charts/employment-situation/civilian-lab... Labor force participation has not collapsed, the population pyramid is simply aging. The trend was clear since 10 years ago, but pandemic accelerated it for some people, but still not a collapse.
- voisin 5y agoI don’t think the link you’ve provided confirms that it is simply due to the population aging, though I don’t disagree that may be a component of it. The link just doesn’t help explain what relative contribution comes from aging vs participation. If you click male or female over 20, participation rate, the numbers drop over the last decade quite a bit. What are these people doing if not working?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoYes, the BLS graph was meant to show it has not collapsed. Nov 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019 participation rates were 62.7%, 62.7%, 62.9%, 63.2%, and Nov 2021 is 61.8%. Also, over 20 also includes people over retirement age, so they have stopped working. See graph labeled "age ratio". If you hover your mouse over it, you will see working age portion of population starts to decrease after 2010, and had flatlined prior to that. https://population-pyramid.net/en/pp/united-states-of-america https://population-pyramid.net/en/pp/united-states-of-americ... Here is more information, but large portions of the population aging out of working years is one of the reasons mentioned: https://www.thebalance.com/labor-force-participation-rate-formula-and-examples-3305805 https://www.thebalance.com/labor-force-participation-rate-fo...
- jaarse 5y agoNote that the author is Canadian. Very different up here right now. For example, Ontario where the author is based is entering complete lockdown tomorrow for at least 3 weeks. Restaurants completely closed to indoor dining, and workers will receive government assistance that is greater than they were making when working.
- endlessvoid94 5y agoIt's astounding to watch consumer "activists" just demand higher wages without the willingness to pay more for what they buy.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoI regularly suggest restaurants pay people more. I will not be shocked or upset when the prices go up. Hopefully way up so we can retire the silly process of having to tip while we're at it, and the restaurant can, in fact, actually pay people. (Note that with pickup orders, the tip line on the receipt is incredibly stressful for me: I shouldn't tip because there isn't table service, but I should tip because the restaurant staff are still getting underpaid...) And yeah, it's probably going to cause some people to reevaluate going to restaurants. They might cook more at home, and better appreciate the higher cost when they do eat out, and in turn, the world moves forward.
- Clubber 5y agoI'd be willing to pay more for a better experience. When you go to a restaurant who treats their employees like shit, those same employees seem to not give a shit, because they aren't paid well enough to give a shit. I'd rather go to a great restaurant once than a shit one three times. It's pretty hard to be hospitable to your guests when you aren't treated hospitably by your employer. Inhospitality trickles down too.
- pkaye 5y agoIt's astounding to watch businesses just demand workers without the willingness to pay what the free market demands. Some of those restaurant workers upskilled to better jobs so don't expect them to go back to lower paying jobs if they can.
- fishtacos 5y agoIt's even more astounding to witness the entitlement of someone running a "small business" in LAS VEGAS complaining about paying living wages and related business costs all the while married to the co-founder of Shopify and financially more stable than 99.99999+% of her employee base... the lack of self-awareness is shocking, though not that surprising given the bubble she lives in.
- excalibur 5y ago*Deux
- Arainach 5y agoThis again. >Ok so, here’s the plan: you pay $15 for a sandwich and I give my whole team a raise. Sweet. You’re the best! The money’s gotta come from somewhere. People seem to forget that part. But yes, I like this idea. In fact, Chipotle has recently increased both wages and pricing. McDonald’s as well. Now our turn, LFG! And yet, if you go to the source the article links directly in that paragraph: "Chipotle Mexican Grill has hiked menu prices by roughly 4% to cover the cost of raising its workers’ wages...In May, Chipotle said that it would raise hourly wages for its restaurant workers to reach an average of $15 an hour by the end of June." 4% price increase to get to a living wage. Not $15 sandwiches, just $7.28 instead of $7. Pay your employees. It's that simple.
- jwagenet 5y agoYea sure, but you ignore that Chipotle and McDs have magnitudes larger supply chain optimizations, cash reserves, and operate in high and low cost markets such that there is more margin to keep the business afloat when there is a squeeze.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> Yea sure, but you ignore that Chipotle and McDs have magnitudes larger supply chain optimizations, cash reserves, and operate in high and low cost markets such that there is more margin to keep the business afloat when there is a squeeze. Aren't most McDonalds franchises? You definitely see individual owned stores going out of business.
- jwagenet 5y agoFranchisees still benefit from the supply chain. Even if individual stores wouldn't be subsidized by the company, they benefit from brand recognition and already operating at the price floor for food you dont make yourself.
- MangoCoffee 5y ago>Aren't most McDonalds franchises? his point still stand. https://boxaroundtheworld.com/mcdonalds-supply-chain-management/ https://boxaroundtheworld.com/mcdonalds-supply-chain-managem... "McDonalds is a fine example of how vertical integration can keep costs down and profits up. They grow their own beef through contracted producers, process their own meat, create their own spices and mixes in factories that they contract, grow their own potatoes and other vegetable through contracted producers, transport their goods on their own. McDonalds owns the land that their restaurants are situated on, so they do not have to deal with leases and landlords. They have taken control of their supply chain nicely." edit: a mom and pop operation can't compete with McDonalds. McDonalds can increase employees wages thus force others to do the same even if mom and pop doesn't have a vertical integration like McDonalds. by increase wages, it force smaller operators to cut staffs or shut down. McDonalds can keep their competition down.
- tptacek 5y agoSomehow, I don't think that people coming to restaurants with ingredient lists hoping to order off-menu is a real driver for economic problems.
- edmundsauto 5y agoDidn't she put that in the section about why it's been hard to re-staff? I don't think it was related to the economics argument except indirectly.
- paulpauper 5y agoyaawn another one of these rants >Let’s start with the government paying our workers to stay home. First, let me say that anyone high risk, or with young kids at home, I understand. This isn’t about you. But I’m talking about the restaurant industry here. We employed 1.7M teens in the US before the pandemic. Of course they rather get paid to Netflix & chill than scrub dishes. I don’t blame them. I’m not exaggerating. I know this. How? Cause they told me. They’d ask to only work a few shifts a week or else they’d stop getting their ‘free money’ (ie our tax dollars). This made it nearly impossible for us to stay open. It’s gotten a bit better as these programs wrapped up, but in Canada at least, they are talking about bringing them back. I don't think a couple of infrequent Covid stimulus checks is the equivalent of paying people to not work. Even minimum wage pays a lot more than Covid checks. This article is full of generalizations and assumptions that are wrong or exaggerated. Lettuce being 15% more expensive does not mean the final product is 15% more expensive. That is because there are a lot of inputs that go into determining the price besides the raw materials. Where I live I only noticed 2 restaurants closed out of probably 50. Some cut hours or only do drive-though. A long way from being fucked as the title suggests.
- steelstraw 5y agoA new analysis by Peter Ganong, Pascal Noel and Joseph Vavra, economists at the University of Chicago, uses government data from 2019 to estimate that 68 percent of unemployed workers who can receive benefits are eligible for payments that are greater than their lost earnings. They also found that the estimated median replacement rate — the share of a worker’s original weekly salary that is being replaced by unemployment benefits — is 134 percent, or more than one-third above their original wage. A substantial minority of those workers, particularly in low-wage professions like food service and janitorial work, may end up receiving more than 150 percent of their previous weekly salary. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/many-americans-are-getting-more-money-from-unemployment-than-they-were-from-their-jobs/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/many-americans-are-gett... A Bank of America Global Research report published in April estimated, nationwide, workers who earn less than $32,000 annually could make more money on unemployment than they could from work. An analysis of California Employment Development estimates showed $31,200, or $15 an hour, was the break-even point in the state, not accounting for differences in how the money might be taxed. The state portion of benefits is capped at $450 per week for higher-income earners. “You could potentially earn $750 a week maximum in California using unemployment. That can be a disincentive to some workers especially some of those workers in lower-paid jobs,” said Roccato. https://www.cbs8.com/article/news/verify/verify-can-you-make-more-on-unemployment-or-working-for-minimum-wage-why-theres-more-than-just-money-to-consider-childcare-covid-pandemic-safety/509-ed19ee74-28da-439c-8deb-24803649b664 https://www.cbs8.com/article/news/verify/verify-can-you-make...
- regnull 5y agoHere's what I don't understand. I the example the author gives, a sandwich is $11, and at let's say 9% profit margin the restaurant makes $1 on it. Why not make the sandwich $12 and double your profit? Sure it doesn't make a huge difference for the customers.
- bell-cot 5y agoThe profit margins are not that different all sorts of consumer goods - restaurant meals, groceries, gasoline, etc. And there are zillions of restaurants, grocery stores, gas stations, etc. Maybe a few of 'em tried that strategy, and found that it usually didn't work out so well.
- acdha 5y ago> Maybe a few of 'em tried that strategy, and found that it usually didn't work out so well. We know that's not the case because if there was even a shred of data driving this decision they would have been crowing about it. This happens every time someone proposes that businesses be better members of their communities — some reactionary will say that they'll be unable to create all of those jobs, but they're never asked why they're less wrong than everyone who very confidently said the same thing on the previous iteration. You can copy-and-paste that for so many issues — wages, benefits like sick leave or health insurance, pollution, banning indoor smoking or serving drinks to obviously intoxicated people, etc. The flip side of this is that it only looks at a single part of a complex system: for example, how much does staff turnover cost the average business? You'll never, ever hear someone whining about the prospect of paying a living wage acknowledge the businesses who've found that treating their workers better saved them money because they saved money from not having to constantly be hiring and people were more productive.
- callmeal 5y agoBut that would mean he would have to pay his workers more. How will he keep his employees in their place when they don't have to kowtow to him for shifts and payments?
- jwagenet 5y ago
- bdzr 5y agoThis series keeps pretending that restaurants are the only source of food. Restaurants aren't grocery stores. Restaurants are great, and they're a big part of our economy, but they're a luxury. Sorry your margins aren't higher, but I won't be terribly upset if cheaper non-chain restaurants go the way of the dodo bird.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bambax 5y ago> For context, when I wrote the first post, we had just the one Wolf Down location in Ottawa. We’ve since opened our second location, in Vegas of all places (we raised funds for this, that’s another story for another post), and launched ghost kitchens in Toronto and Calgary (in partnership with REEF, no upfront cost to us). That doesn't seem much fucked to me. In fact it sounds like business is going great.
- sascha_sl 5y agoIt's a lot of complaining and blaming other people, presumably from the same people that'd object to being told they're exploiting labor by saying they're assuming all the risk.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- monkpit 5y agoTitle differs from the source for whatever reason. Maybe the author edited out the misspelling.
- darth_avocado 5y agoI’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. The problem of low wages isn’t that your margins are low and you’ll have to increase price of a sandwich to pay people enough. The real problem is restaurants artificially lowering prices of a sandwich by paying people less for decades to the point people don’t realize that eating out used to be expensive. All the full service restaurants in my small town still do well. The ones that don’t are the sandwich shops where you pay $14 for a cold sandwich. Eating out is expensive and should be expensive if you want businesses to sustain themselves when there’s turmoil in the industry.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y ago> Eating out is expensive and should be expensive if you want businesses to sustain themselves when there’s turmoil in the industry. Why is it only expensive because there can be turmoil? Isn't it primarily expensive IFF labor is expensive?
- vorpalhex 5y agoThe problem is that a lot of people are used to eating out being cheap. Kitchens have dwindled in size, as have the basic skills of grocery shopping and preparing meals. It might be longterm good for eating out to be expensive again (especially for waistlines) but it will come as a big shock and do short term harm.
- criddell 5y ago> Kitchens have dwindled in size Is that true? In a lot of new homes where I live the kitchens are one of the places the builders spend money. It's pretty common to see multiple ovens, a high end stove top, big dishwasher, gigantic refrigerator, etc...
- maxsilver 5y ago> In a lot of new homes where I live the kitchens are one of the places the builders spend money. Regular people generally can't afford new homes. Working class professionals usually get shoved into apartments (usually small ones) with small kitchens in 5+1 buildings or renovated industrial buildings. Stuff like this is pretty common - https://images1.apartments.com/i2/5Wguguo1YZBzaUo30bfX2jUIY6wfpriwgayikEX-pXo/102/28grand-detroit-mi-building-photo.jpg?p=1 https://images1.apartments.com/i2/5Wguguo1YZBzaUo30bfX2jUIY6... or this one https://images1.apartments.com/i2/PuDTEuad8QYuGVJfUJAbGHCZISjR3khFzF3U_EJP7LU/102/philip-houze-detroit-mi-kitchen.jpg?p=1 https://images1.apartments.com/i2/PuDTEuad8QYuGVJfUJAbGHCZIS... It's not impossible to cook here, of course. But it's designed around the idea that most of your big meals will be "out" somewhere else.
- dkobia 5y agoSo many of these restauranteur articles. One thing is certain -- it is not the governments job to fix this. This is the market playing out in a pandemic. Restaurants are non-essential and faced with this level of distress should perhaps consider shutting down and coming back when the market can support them. Unless one has deep pockets or the will power, I'm not sure how many can survive. With the thin margins, most can't afford to pay more and many customers aren't either regardless of how much they want to eat out. I love restaurants and it has been sad to see some of my favorite ones shut down -- hopefully they'll be back!
- x3n0ph3n3 5y ago> It is not the governments job to fix this. This is the market playing out in a pandemic But in many ways, the government is contributing to this via: - Government benefits competing with wages - Government-imposed shutdowns / reduced-capacity.
- Invictus0 5y agoI predict the Republican party will make an about-face on immigration. Businesses have come to depend on a semi-infinite supply of cheap labor, and the only way they're going to get it is by letting in a new flood of unskilled workers.
- HideousKojima 5y agoThe Republican party has always been two-faced about immigration (with the exception of Trump, and even he didn't live up to all his anti-immigration promises). The Republicans in congress have always been wishy-washy about enforcing immigration laws because they don't want bad optics and they don't want to piss of corporate backers, despite the rank-and-file membership being extremely anti-immigration (especially illegal immigration). The constant lies from party leadership about actually enforcing immigration laws was a major factor in Trump's rise.
- monkeynotes 5y agoThis article is utter BS. Just read her other posts and you'll see she's been raking it in over COVID, her business is doing better than ever and she opened a Vegas restaurant. I think she's looking for publicity more than anything, seems to me she's as manipulative and cynical as she is wealthy and successful.
- aldebran 5y agoThis article smells like it’s coming from a well off person pretending they have it bad and pointing to bullshit reasons.
- smm11 5y agoIndustry difficulty: Increased costs passed down to consumers. Shipping difficulty: Increased costs passed down to consumers. Restaurant difficulty: Increased costs passed down to consumers. Cry me a river.
- voisin 5y agoI agree. If your customers won’t pay your new, increased prices, then you or one of your competitors goes out of business. The competitive set consolidated and trims the day until prices can come down to a point where consumers will pay. The problem is that the bulk of businesses have grown fat and lazy on the good times that have lasted seemingly forever. It’s time for a reset. This time we won’t be able to be bailed out - interest rates are already rock bottom and inflation is at a 30 year high. We are in for massive upheaval.
- cafard 5y ago> We employed 1.7M teens in the US before the pandemic. Of course they rather get paid to Netflix & chill than scrub dishes. Most of the teens are probably in school and working part time. Are such employees eligible for unemployment benefits? I do like the royal "we".
- kerneloftruth 5y agoThe restaurant industry is notoriously high-risk to start with, and they certainly have been impacted more than most other industries. Many other businesses were simply shut down (i.e. you can't have customers), which is devastating on its own. But, that period lasted a relatively short time. With restaurants, they had to make new investments in plexiglass crap, outdoor dining areas, etc..._and_ they were partially or fully shut down, or had to adapt to takeout only -- all of it costing time and money, and adding risk. The rules for them changed more frequently and unpredictably, and have been in effect throughout these 2 years. The author should also mention another factor limiting the number of patrons who show up, and aggravating those that do: turning the restaurant into an enforcement arm of The State in demanding proof of vaccination.
- seryoiupfurds 5y agoConsider the opposing factor: many more people might be unwilling to visit restaurants if they thought they would get covid from unvaccinated fellow customers. Proof of vaccination is what enables restaurants to be open at all; without it, they might still be closed as an unacceptable risk.
- TheGigaChad 5y ago
- citilife 5y agoIt's been painful watching my family members who own a restaurant and a bar. I think this post still misses the mark. Food prices are not up 5-15%, based on what my family is seeing it's up 40-50%. They're desperately trying to find cheaper solutions. In addition to that, when the restaurants were forced to be shut down in 2020, people switched roles. People started working at Amazon and other companies. Now there's a shortage of cooks, bar-tenders, etc. Previously, they were paying $7/hr + tips for a bar-tender. Now, they can't get people to apply for under $15/hr + tips. My one family member cannot even find a cook and they're offering 50% more than they were in 2019 -- $30/hr. So they're working 12-14 hr days, 7 days a week to keep the place running. Combined with increased costs, there was a drop of 20% or so of patrons (compared to 2019) and patrons are more price sensitive. To me, it's clear from reading this comments that many people do not understand the economics of a restaurants. Which are far different than chain fast-food place locations.
- fishtacos 5y ago>>To me, it's clear from reading this comments that many people do not understand the economics of a restaurants. Which are far different than chain fast-food place locations. How much clearer can it be than if the financial balance of the restaurant is not profitable, it is time to shift into a different menu and price points, or shut down all together and find a different avenue of work. The restaurant owners are in the same predicament as their workers. If it's not worth pursuing for your time and money, then pursue something else more worthwhile. Adjust or die.
- citilife 5y ago> The restaurant owners are in the same predicament as their workers. If it's not worth pursuing for your time and money, then pursue something else more worthwhile. Adjust or die. Oh I (and my family members) agree, they're trying to sell the businesses. Typically small time businesses like this are highly tied with personal finances. You can't just "close up shop" when you have a $50k loan and no job lined up. Again, it's more complex than people recognize. For instance, you can raise your prices (and my family has), but they have to compete with other chain restaurants. So they can't raise prices too much faster than the competition.
- aldebran 5y agoI stopped reading at the part that blames the “free money” for sitting at home. Fuck that. This is especially obnoxious when part 1 said let’s raise margins. So you want more money but don’t want to pay sufficient wages to the staff? Fuck that! You lost complete credibility and just appear to a greedy person. Edit: I’m calling the restaurant owner greedy for not wanting to pay decent wages. Why is that controversial?
- steelstraw 5y agoWho is greedy? The one who is offering a service to people or the one sitting home not offering a service to other people while consuming resources?
- voisin 5y agoI have zero problem with the lowest paid members of society holding out for more. I have a hard time calling anyone greedy who is looking to make a living wage.
- aldebran 5y agoWe agree then. Staff should be paid a living wage, right?
- aldebran 5y agoThe one paying poverty wages and wanting to keep their profits.
- DarylZero 5y agoEveryone is consuming resources. Running a household on a poverty budget isn't labor free. The work it involves is even much like that of a restaurant.
- mattzito 5y agoThis is the second time I've posted a comment on a similar article [1], so I'll try to make this one a little different. First, there's a lot of genuine pain that restaurants are feeling that's not their fault. But I will say that the restaurant industry has been due for a reckoning for 10-15 years - they became addicted to 1) lower and lower margins, 2) a workforce ready to deal with the low pay, terrible hours, and abusive environments, and 3) a seemingly endless stream of customers. All of this combined to create a world where #1 forced many restaurants to become dependent on #2 and #3 to be profitable - which was clearly unsustainable, but no one was willing to recognize that. Part of the dynamic for #1 is that you had a flood of first-time operators coming on the market with lots of capital and a long runway for profitability. Restaurant concepts that make no sense if you're a traditional owner/operator might be fine if you have cash to cover the losses for 1-3 years. There was also a huge shift from solo location operators to people with "concepts" that are built out of the gate with dreams of building an empire - everyone saw Shake Shack and Chipotle and said, "How hard can that be?" All of these well-funded, inexperienced operators got their restaurants out the door, optimized for growth rather than sustainability, and then the pandemic hit, and suddenly the sand that their business was built on began to slide out from underneath them. This is a generalization, of course, and only reflects a subset of the restaurants that have been hurt/closed by the pandemic. I'll absolutely say that another big swath of restaurants that closed are restaurants that have been around a long time and were probably running on fumes already, and unable to adapt. But at the heart of both groups are businesses that were built on unsustainable foundations and poor business practices. Running a restaurant is _hard_ - comparing it to running an accounting business is laughable (as the author did in their first essay). The best restaurant operators can look at a menu and know_ exactly how much they are going to make on each dish, have a professional level nderstanding of electrical and mechanical maintenance, understand a forest of local laws and regulation, and can hire and attract quality talent AND keep them interested and engaged. On top of that, in major metro areas, they also have to be branding, social, and marketing experts. Covid has been hard for everyone, especially restaurants, but the best-run restaurants were able to dig in and adjust and adapt, because they had a solid foundation and a strong leadership team. Complaining that teenagers don't want to work a shit job for low pay and terrible hours totally misses the point. 1 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27135057 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27135057
- kpennell 5y agoFWIW, this author's husband is Daniel Weinand, Chief Creative Officer/Co-Founder, Shopify Inc. Net worth 1B. So this might color her thinking a bit
- psmirnov 5y agoThis should be higher up. Without any judgement on the author as a person, they live in different circumstances than 99% of the employers, employees or customers in the restaurant business. Knowing this is an important part of understanding their social commentary.
- mbfg 5y agothank you.
- UncleMeat 5y agoImagine being a billionaire and complaining about paying employees more at a small business.
- parkingrift 5y agoThis is ad hominem.
- vannevar 5y agoI thought it was a little odd for someone to write an article about how the restaurant industry is "so fucked", then proceed with a dramatic expansion of their business during the pandemic, and then write another article about how terrible things are in the industry. Not to say the article is wrong, but it certainly undercuts the argument. Knowing that she had virtually unlimited access to additional capital makes the apparent contradiction more understandable.
- jaarse 5y agoAm a Canadian myself. Lived in the US for 6 months last year, but am back living in Canada since June 2021. I will agree that the Canadian labour market is utterly $^%$ed right now, and it is entirely due to the way our government has handled this situation. The government of Canada gave money to anyone who (1) was over the age of 15, (2) made more than $5000 in the year prior to the pandemic and (3) lost at least 50% of their wages. CERB was $2000/4 weeks * 6 periods, CRB was $900/2 weeks for up to 54 weeks So do the math ... you're a 18 year old student that made $5000 the year before the pandemic. The government potentially has paid you upwards of $30,000 to stay home over the past year and a half. You could go back to a $15/hours job (that's Ontario's minimum wage), but you have more money in the bank than you ever thought you would at this point. It's not the older, "full time" worker staying home. It's that none of the students feel the need to work anymore. And it's not just restaurants. I went to a very large, major chain, grocery store last night at 7pm. Half of the shelves were empty and they had ONE self checkout open (with a line of customers). No staff there either ...
- 908B64B197 5y agoNo way that's good for inflation. Let me guess, there has also been a massive surge in consumer prices and real estate? Also, what are the odds this "shortage" will result in even larger immigration quotas, especially close to election time?
- jaarse 5y agoCanadian real estate price rose 20% in 2020 and another 20% in 2021, although I think that has more to do with interest rates staying at effectively zero for the past decade. Canada never had their correction in 2008 to reset everything like the US did.
- 908B64B197 5y agoDid wages grow at all during that time?
- 5y ago
- purephase 5y agoIdea here, not sure if this is available now or not, but something I was thinking about throughout COVID + restaurant industry. They're a huge employer, particularly of some of the lowest paid sector. Why didn't the government consider tax subsidies to restaurants that kept 80-90% employees on to help keep food and other costs down? If takeaway costs could have stayed the same or even lower, it would have pushed people to keep patronizing restaurants at the same level, and keep staff employed (re-purposed somewhat to support takeaway from in house service) but keep that tax revenue + light CERB load (this is in Canada) and the whole industry could have hopefully weathered this better. Seems doable? Also, seems like a model that could be potententially used in other businesses too, particularly smaller ones.
- hourislate 5y agoThe restaurant business is awful to begin with. Don't even think about it if you don't own the property. You do not want to be in this business trust me (family owned a few restaurants). It requires the longest fucking hours you can imagine, employees that could give a shit no matter how much you pay them, unstable food costs and add to that an expiring product, insane red tape (licensing), etc. Incredibly lucky that we were able to sell both remaining businesses in NOV-DEC/19. Dodged a bullet, buyer has since closed down and gone out of business. I predict that 90% all the restaurants (privately owned) in Toronto will be out of business in the next year. Corporate owned have incredibly deep pockets and will survive. Complete slaughter.
- danielodievich 5y agoA very good scream of rage. This past year's christmas special from The Economist has a well though-out history on what restaurants used to be and where they are heading. https://www.economist.com/christmas-specials/2021/12/18/an-economic-history-of-restaurants https://www.economist.com/christmas-specials/2021/12/18/an-e.... Archive accessible https://archive.fo/zaHMc https://archive.fo/zaHMc One interesting quote from the end appropriate for HN: What does the history of the restaurant say about its future? People have relished their reopening. In recent weeks global restaurant reservations have been near their pre-pandemic levels. The best ones are booked up for months: Silicon Valley nerds have created automated bots which instantly reserve tables. But of course someone is botting their way to reservations...
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoI was in Chipotle at the height of COVID. They had two production lines: one for in-house shoppers, and one for the delivery services. What shocked me is that the in-house consumer experience was AWFUL. The Burrito was bad even for Chipotle, they were slow. The other production line was cranking away and of course the burrito was "better". Yet they are making, what, 30% more on me? And I have a chance of buying a fountain soda which is pure fucking profit to a fast food joint. Truly an example of misaligned incentives. I'm not saying to short the delivery services, but at least provide a bit... extra... for the people that are delivering good margins. You know, the margins that are the difference between the restaurant staying open and not? I get that the UberEats supply is ... some money ... and it is kind of advertising, but why not offer ... something ... ANYTHING to reward people that get out of bed and give you 30% more money.
- rootsudo 5y agotl;dr Author writes for both sides, made unwise investment decisions, doubled down, surprised it didn't work out, wants to blame customers. https://joelleparenteau.medium.com/why-restaurants-are-not-fucked-80383594c593 https://joelleparenteau.medium.com/why-restaurants-are-not-f... -- In the end, maybe the writer, is just a bad operator and being in an unsustainable business. Being a restaurant operator is not for everyone. Not everyone wants what you want as an operator. In the previous article, he went on about how much more protein his meats have over whatever next door restaurant had and that there was a labor cost of $2.58 per sandwich made. Even at $15/hr wage, that means en employee was expected to make shy of 6 sandwiches an hour at $60/hr gross revenue for $6 in net profit. Personally, once an item surpasses $15, I will go and make it myself in my kitchen from grocery goods. Scale of Economy is supposed to reduce labor, cost and make a product consistent. Even before pandemic, I don't like not being aware of everything in my food and hidden sugars in sauces. I even think $10 is expensive per dish when compared to wholesaling shopping and making my own food - but I understand, this is a food business. I don't understand why I, the reader, am supposed to feel sympathy for a poor business operator, especially when the new article linked above writes: "For context, when I wrote the first post, we had just the one Wolf Down location in Ottawa. We’ve since opened our second location, in Vegas of all places (we raised funds for this, that’s another story for another post), and launched ghost kitchens in Toronto and Calgary (in partnership with REEF, no upfront cost to us)." They essentially limited liability on opening a restaurant, crowdsourced investors who bought into the sympathy scheme and then continue to write about how unsustainable it is running this sort of business. I still don't get it. Are these articles just an excuse, to mitigate liability and risk to the investors and saying "Hey guys, thanks for believing me in - but today's market circumstances are x,y,z - no profit but thanks for the money!" Then with the conclusion: "But I can’t do it alone. We have to do it together as an industry. And we need you, our guests. I ask for your help." Why? This is the same mantra that /r/WSB has been sprouting about pubic companies, privatize profits, publicize debt and liability. While it goes on to blame customers - a business itself survives on customers. Restaurants aren't a right or a guarantee. Customers vote with their money and social media reviews. Owning a business isn't a right or guarantee to make a profit or living. All in all, learning to cook for yourself is simply the best. Fast food, restaurants and related food companies really do seem overleverged right now in terms of the debt they've taken on for the profit potential. High risk and low reward, But here's the kicker, the same author also wrote this just right after publishing "Why Restaurants are fucked." https://joelleparenteau.medium.com/why-restaurants-are-not-fucked-80383594c593 https://joelleparenteau.medium.com/why-restaurants-are-not-f... lol back and forth. "COVID-19 was a wake up call. A catalyst for change. We were caught in a vicious cycle. Now our day of reckoning has arrived. And I, for one, am optimistic we can come back stronger than ever. Besides low margins, there’s another critical issue we ignored for far too long: the restaurant industry is over-saturated. And too many restaurants cause hyper-competition and undercutting — triggering the race to the bottom. "
- sfc32 5y agoI suppose it's good as clickbait, but do we have use swear words in blogs?
- sascha_sl 5y ago>We employed 1.7M teens in the US before the pandemic. You mean you exploited 1.7M teens, and they figured out it's not worth it, not worth getting long covid and not worth it for the "wage" they're paying. Large parts of the US economy worked simply on the threat of your existence ceasing if you run our of money. Turns out it's not that bad. Blaming teenagers for not wanting to work if you barely made it worth their time is pretty disgusting. Maybe your industry needs to thin out and raise prices.
- mlatu 5y ago> Maybe your industry needs to thin out and raise prices. I have the feeling that is actually their point. Perhaps they did not consider the thinning out part but the last part is clearly their point.
- jeffrallen 5y agoMaybe the problem is there are too many restaurants and too many people who think they want/need to eat at a restaurant. In Switzerland, restaurants pay a living wage, and sandwiches cost $15. If you can't afford to eat out, you don't. There are plenty of low cost grocery stores like Aldi and Lidl. One even has an advertisement showing how a grandma can serve 5 grandkids a homemade spaghetti lunch for.... wait for it... $15.
- Mikeb85 5y agoI see a lot of comments about "Just raise prices". And it's true, that's what restaurants have to do to survive on an individual level. The problem is aggregate demand across the entire economy. Consumers are getting squeezed by inflation for, well, everything. Quicker than wages are going up in the economy. So overall demand isn't rising as quickly as restaurants need to raise prices. Consumers are still eating out and paying those higher prices, they're just doing it less often or, even worse, ordering less per visit. This isn't necessarily the death knell for restaurants with a specific competitive advantage but it does mean lots of restaurants won't make it.
- fundad 5y agoThe hospitality sector is over saturated and pressure on wages is a result of PPP money to restaurants that would otherwise not be around to hire now. I wish they would stop being such babies about relief checks though. The same type of people in the US pretended not to notice price increases directly caused by the trade war. They even defended it because they had their guys in charge: “need some pain for some gain” There was a constituency for a trade war, a very powerful one. And NOW they want to blame their opposition for the logical outcome of those cost increases, more cost increases! There’s a constituency for UI benefits, the “nobody wants to work” crowd has lost all good will with workers for the whole industry. Any critic of “defund the police” will tell you not to bash a social service that is so damn popular. Whether it’s a social service that offers free policing or direct checks, people LOVE free stuff from the government.