23 ms·
Study finds no detrimental effects of psilocybin in 10mg or 25mg dose
- 01100011 5y agoJust keep in mind you can get a headache the next day. Psilocybin dose-dependently causes delayed, transient headaches in healthy volunteers: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3345296/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3345296/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- j4hdufd8 5y ago> The remaining 29 participants acted as the control group and received a placebo, also with psychological support. How do you do placebo with psychedelics? Doesn't it quickly become obvious that you are tripping (or not)?
- ThePowerOfFuet 5y agoTypically they receive something like methylphenidate, and they are psilocybin-naïve so they don't know which they got.
- _moof 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Active_placebo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Active_placebo
- 542458 5y agoDumb Question: How would you know that you're not just measuring that detrimental effects are identical across both substances?
- dasv 5y agoI have read that niacin is used as a placebo, it has a very noticeable physical effect but no psychedelic properties.
- skrtskrt 5y agoyou can gain psilocybin benefits without taking enough of it to trip
- ruined 5y agoshort answer, no. longer answer, dose-response varies, subjects don't necessarily know what the effects should be, or may not be able to identify the experience, and also it's pretty easy to get yourself into an autocthonous psychedelic headspace, especially if you expect "something" to happen
- Rastonbury 5y agoIt's obvious, I've participated in a such a study (not psilocybin). It has to be done though
- letitbeirie 5y agoI wonder if the control group being disappointed they're not tripping has any effect on these kinds of studies
- dvngnt_ 5y agomy friend had a psychotic break while on it. we later found out he was bipolar. The title seems accurate, but you never know what disease you may have until it actually manifests so be careful
- jabej 5y agoExactly what I was thinking. “In healthy people”… how do you know you don’t have latent schizophrenia? Slightly related https://old.reddit.com/r/HPPD/ https://old.reddit.com/r/HPPD/
- friendly_chap 5y agoWhy did you link that HPPD subreddit? I used to have visual snow a lot, does it have anything to do with latent schizophrenia?
- jabej 5y agoNo, I linked to it to show how using these drugs can have permanent effects on you. Only slightly related to the rest of my comment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wrinkl3 5y agoAfaik HPPD and schizophrenia are distinct conditions, most people with HPPD don't report any symptoms common in schizophrenia.
- otherme123 5y agoFunny how intolerable are those "latent" diagnostics for illegal drugs, and meanwhile the totally legal and widely prescribed trazodone (an antidepresant) is known to cause, among others 1) suicidal thoughts, 2) insomnia, 3) hallucinations, 4) and paranoia. Other common drug, bromazepan, turns you into a half zombi, loss of ability to remember and amnesia, hallucinations... And it has a bad widthdrawal. Of course you have to be careful when taking LSD, psilocybin or whatever. But don't replace info with FUD: just study, legalize and put the info in the box when sold. They are not worse than 95% of widely prescribed drugs. They are illegal just because they are also enjoyable.
- misc213 5y agoDoes anyone know of a resource to help convert from the MG they report to the dried product?
- theli0nheart 5y agoThere's no surefire way to estimate the actual weight of psilocybin save for extracting it chemically. It can vary widely between species, between flushes, and even between individual fruits.
- clsec 5y agoDried product varies pretty widely in strength, even from stem to cap. Things like strain and spore lineage also contribute to strength of the dried product. A good place to find more info is here: https://www.shroomery.org/ https://www.shroomery.org/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- james_burden 5y agoThey are using synthetic psilocybin. It would be impossible to make a translation between grams of dried vs. synthetic. Different species have diff content, liberty cap vs. penis envy etc. also stalks vs. caps typically differ in str.
- misc213 5y agoDosage guides for dried shrooms are already universal in recommendation of dosage typically speaking in terms of grams without bringing up the individual strain. This leads me to believe that a generally close conversion should be reasonable from the dried natural to that MG number.
- emteycz 5y agoIt's more like the measurement is off so much the differences don't even matter.
- standardUser 5y agoFrom what I'm reading, there are 5-20mg of psilocybin in a gram of mushrooms. So the 10mg and 25mg doses from the study are around 1-2 grams worth of mushrooms. The average recreational dose (in my experience) is usually between 1.75 and 7 grams (so anywhere from 10-140mg). But potency varies significantly in real world scenarios.
- mediocregopher 5y agoI'd always thought 1g was a single dose. Maybe the people around me are lightweights... (legalization so we can accurately dose these things yada yada)
- tpfour 5y agoMinimum I've seen was 1.5g. Usually between 2 and 3.5. The issue with psychedelics is not that their ingestion might kill you, but rather what you will do to yourself or others while on them. No amount of reading and Youtube videos can prepare you for a strong psychedelic experience. Once in it, you have to go through it, and accidents do happen. I've found that people who do psychedelics in repetition usually _think_ they are some sort of key to their problems, they'll help them fix themselves, yada yada yada. One trip is enough for people for whom that is true. If you have to do them repeatedly, the issue is elsewhere. I am against full-on prohibition, but also skeptical about the "pro-psychedelic" sentiment in vogue.
- stephenitis 5y ago> One trip is enough for people for whom that is true. you state this like fact but you’re sourcing this from your personal anecdote. I agree 1.5 - 3.5 seems about the normal range for a single dose. 2.0g is therapeutic for me. 3.5 I am floored by the experience in a non productive way.
- detritus 5y agoIt really does depend upon what strain and type you're talking about. There's a fundamental world of difference between a gram of dried Cyanescens and a gram of fresh Cubensis, for instance.
- fdgsdfogijq 5y agoHighly highly doubt this. Anyone who has spent significant time around people who have done alot of mushrooms knows that they have cognitive "peculiarities". The shift towards peace, love, and hippie-ish personality traits is clearly a neurogloical effect of mushrooms. Its clearly a deterministic effect that nearly everyone who has done them alot converges on. EDIT: I assert it is detrimental. There is a "mystic" "spiritual" shift as well, that I really dont think is grounded in reality. Just because current science cant measure these changes dont mean they dont happen. I would also describe the effect as "loopy" One last piece of information, I really dont believe anyone claiming these effects as purely positive have spent time around heavy mushroom users. My evidence is anecdotal, but spans years and tens of people. I was involved in a community that had alot of experience with this. The effects to me were clear, and I am skeptical of anyone, including researchers, who have not seen this first hand. I first hand witnessed the mental changes in friends who went down that path, and really dont think they were the same person at the end.
- rileyphone 5y agoThe Aztecs were very fond of mushrooms but definitely not hippies. You’re describing a mimetic cultural phenomenon facilitated by the neuroplasticity the drug confers.
- diatomaceous_ 5y agoThis is the correct answer; people whose only understanding of psychedelics draws from media portrayals of the 60s have a dramatically warped and puritanical perspective on what is a pharmacological effect vs a cultural effect
- blamestross 5y ago> Psilocybin has no short- or long-term __detrimental__ effects in healthy people
- usmannk 5y agois that a detrimental effect?
- whilestanding 5y agoI definitely think Psilocybin gave me negative long term effects. I wish I would have never taken Psilocybin. I didn't even have a bad trip, it was the ideal kind of experience a lot of people seem to strive for. I had the cliche "spiritual awakening" type of experience. It make me incredibly narcissistic and allowed my brain to think in a very "the universe is on my side" kind of way, and I was open to a lot of magical thinking and woo woo after the trip. I made a lot of goofy choices with too much idealism and gusto and not much of a plan and it set my life and career back when it didn't work out. It took almost ten years to slowly realize what was obvious to me before the mushrooms which is that I am not the center of the universe, and the world is a harsh place that doesn't owe anyone anything.
- scarby2 5y agoThat's probably outside the scope of this study. You were probably not in a regulated setting or under the care of a psychiatrist at the time. I'd imagine there's some guidance involved in the whole process that recreational users would miss.
- notch656a 5y agoDo you think it was psilocybin that gave you those thoughts or do you think the idea of psilocybin gave you good cover to experiment in idealism of youth? Your realism and experience sound more like the practical wisdom a lot of people gain over the 10 years of their 20s.
- whilestanding 5y agoThe psilocybin gave me a God complex delusion due to the hallucinations ideas and feelings I had during the trip. unfortunately I didn't shake the fundamental world view I gained after the trip until objective reality tossed me around enough to snap out of it.
- diatomaceous_ 5y agoThis is the correct answer; psychedelics enhance aspects of your personality that were already quite present
- bserge 5y ago
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoI doubt this, and I think it's detrimental to state so in the long run. I used Psilocybin, and it was worth it. I would recommand people to give it a try, and I helped people around me, including one parent, to take it. Yet. Every time I took it, I could feel my speech ability to decline for a while. The side effects faded slowly, and disapeared eventually every time. But traces of it are noticeable after even a month or two sometimes. It's like when people claimed that marijuana was not addictive. The deny didn't help at all. I know of several people that are addicted to smoking pot now. It's a negative side effect on their life. There is no such thing as a free lunch. Powerful products have powerful effects, and this means some harm can exist. Yes, psilocybin is way safer than the reputation is has been given in the 70'. Yes, taking it (in the right conditions) can benefit you a lot. But pretending there is zero detrimental effects is wishful thinking and will lead to people abusing the thing, believing it's just funny candy, and they may end up damaged.
- shrimpx 5y ago> marijuana was not addictive It's "not addictive" in the sense that physical withdrawal symptoms are minimal compared to booze, nicotine, and other drugs. But you can make a daily habit out of anything pleasurable and ruin your life around it. I've seen people ruin their lives with both gaming and gambling habits.
- giantg2 5y agoI think there are some other rare side effects, like vision abnormalities. The proper way to phrase their findings is that psilocybin has a favorable safety profile and should be studied in more detail with larger numbers of participants.
- Quarrelsome 5y ago> It's like when people claimed that marijuana was not addictive. I quit both weed and nicotine and only the nicotine was the problem to shift. Weed can be habitual, sure but there's a huge difference in physical and habitual addiction.
- tudelo 5y ago
- usaphp 5y ago10-25mg is nothing, it’s like 5-10x lower than people usually take
- Synaesthesia 5y agoNope.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- RandomThrow321 5y agoThe study used synthetic psilocybin. In some estimate I've found online (I don't know how accurate) it claims 10mg is about 1.5 grams of dried shrooms of common varieties.
- yboris 5y agoI suspect you're thinking of 3.5g amount - which is a typical amount of magic mushrooms to consume. The study is using psilocybin directly. Wikipedia states "The concentrations of psilocin and psilocybin ... [is] 0.37–1.30% (dry weight) in the whole mushroom". Assuming about 0.5% concentration, 3.5g of dry mushrooms is about 18mg of psilocybin/psilocin.
- rkk3 5y ago> Psilocybin, in 10mg or 25mg doses How does that translate to illicit recreational doses? > 89 healthy participants Not sure how they define healthy... Like others on this thread, have witnessed plenty of seemingly 'healthy' cause a lot of damage to themselves with Psyches. > a potential treatment for a range of mental health conditions, including treatment-resistant depression (TRD) and PTSD. Are they going to test if it has detrimental effects on people with TRD or PTSD? I would imagine they'd be substantially more at risk for adverse effects.
- Synaesthesia 5y agoIt's varies in strength but that corresponds to about 1-2.5g of dried mushrooms. So a normal amount.
- VeninVidiaVicii 5y agoFrom my casual reading of these journal articles over the past several years, it's easy to make such statements about "healthy" people. Any underlying psychiatric disease discovered _after_ psilocybin can be retroactively applied to the participant. "Oh, that guy had underlying bipolar disorder and therefore wasn't healthy."
- josephcsible 5y agoExactly. These kinds of papers are a great example of the no true Scotsman fallacy. And even if it were just "revealing" mental illnesses in people who already had them latently, most of them probably could have gone their whole lives without it had they never used drugs, so in practice even that's no different from just causing the illnesses.
- 71a54xd 5y agoThis article and the study it's drawing from is certainly cherrypicked or naive. There's been significant research to investigate the known cardiotoxicity of Psilocin [0][1]. Basically, for some unknown reason, micro-dosing too often or for too long with non-perceptive (very small doses, small enough to not elicit any perceptible effects) doses of psilocybin can lead to the degeneration of critical heart muscle tissues (specifically observed in heart valves). 0 - https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287756303_Psilocin_multiple_intake_resulted_and_in_cardiotoxic_effects https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287756303_Psilocin_... 1 - https://drbillsukala.com/psilocybin-heart-valve-damage/ https://drbillsukala.com/psilocybin-heart-valve-damage/
- pfortuny 5y agoI find it honestly strange that 12 weeks is deemed “long-term”, or am I missing something?
- pengaru 5y agoPsychedelic/"breakthrough" doses of psilocybin seem like non-lethal overdoses to me, based on some experience. It seems both useful and consistently safe/predictable consumed more as a supplement/vitamin, as one already can with OTC Lions Mane. If they legalized psilocybin I'm 100% certain we'd have Lions Mane+Psilocybin combo supplements on store shelves practically overnight. And like Nutmeg, nobody would be reporting ill effects unless deliberately swallowing an excess of them, something we don't bother preventing with Nutmeg or Dramamine despite some pretty nasty potential outcomes.
- josephcsible 5y ago> something we don't bother preventing with Nutmeg or Dramamine despite some pretty nasty potential outcomes That's because Nutmeg or Dramamine don't have as strong of an incentive to abuse.
- pengaru 5y agoI've met a surprising number of people who upon discovering the psychotropic effects of Nutmeg started using it daily as a low-cost alternative to marijuana. And it doesn't take much digging to find reports of teens accidentally taking lethal doses of the spice, largely due to its exceptionally long "first alerts" delay.
- sethammons 5y agoI grew up in a house that loosely held to beliefs that taking hallucinogenic substances could follow you into subsequent lives (reincarnation type thing). You could literally stain your immortal soul by taking it. That was a scary prohibition. I don't follow those views really any longer, but the worry lingers. Humans are strange.
- stephenitis 5y ago“Stain” Stain has a negative connotation in your context. Maybe adopt less opinionated language. It can color your mind/soul in positive directions if you take great care in your setting and intention. if done recklessly it can potentially color it in negative ways. With a small chance to bring out other forms of latent mental illness. If you do ever decide to attempt go slowly. I’d recommend going cautiously into these experiences starting at 0.8g. Also have a sober mature person who is experience with shrooms around just in case. It’s shrooms is possibly the kind of drug that may help loosen firmly held beliefs in the right setting and mind set.
- brailsafe 5y agoThe effects to those around you are that they have to hear the same story that everyone else has told them about your profound ego-destroying trip and how everyone should try psychedelics for x reason. /s (truth though amiright)
- _zfxr 5y agoI would argue that opening the doors of perception in and of itself can be a detrimental side effect. They don't close. Live without the delusion. forever. Both are worth it. Its always worth it. But to act like it hasnt impacted certain areas of my life in a negative way, would be a hunka buncha bullshit.
- lostmsu 5y ago> Live without the delusion. forever. Sounds like a pretty hard delusion right there.
- bjt2n3904 5y agoGosh. Judging by the articles that come up so frequently, HN seems to want... - Universal Basic Income - Psychedelic Drugs - Suicide Pods And I can't help but feel all three of these are intricately tied together. UBI to pursue legal hedonism, and a "painless" exit when the drugs don't do it anymore. I don't think anyone who advocates for these things explicitly wants such a nihilistic view of life. They want the freedom to create unbridled, and an end to poverty, hunger, mental anguish, and suffering -- but that isn't the outcome they will get.
- dubcanada 5y agoThose are just popular topics of any discussion. Since other "more important" topics are banned via rules (ie politics).
- Flankk 5y agoDamn kids and their suicide pods. Back in my day, we hung ourselves using a rope and we liked it that way.
- yboris 5y agoI explicitly want all three things you list. I also would like to see Open Borders ;) https://openborders.info https://openborders.info For psychedelic drug decriminalization: the alternative is status quo, which results in tremendous amount of suffering (thousands of people in jail who are then disenfranchised by their "criminal" record). You vaguely gesture at the possible good outcomes people like me want, but then boldly claim "that isn't the outcome [we] will get". I'm puzzled why you have such a pessimistic view of it all. Portugal decriminalized all drugs 20 years ago and they are doing great (by comparison to surrounding countries that have not). Assisted suicide has become legal in several countries with presumably no negative outcomes you are warning us against. UBI has been successful and loved by Alaskans for decades. What problems are you worried about?
- the-dude 5y agoYou forgot static web blogs.
- stephenitis 5y ago
- uptownfunk 5y agoI think the key phrase here is "in healthy people" which ought to mean both physically and mentally healthy people. Now, of course, it becomes complicated. Especially if you are healthy but at-risk for certain conditions (say schizoaffective/schizophrenia). I have seen this compound work miracles, I have also seen it send some very close friends of mine off the deep end. Of course, those friends were always a little different, let's say.
- loveJesus 5y ago
- GeekyBear 5y agoThere was in interesting UK study done that attempted to quantify how harmful various drugs were to the user and also to others. Psilocybin was found to be the least harmful drug that they considered. >The study involved 16 criteria, including a drug's affects on users' physical and mental health, social harms including crime, "family adversities" and environmental damage, economic costs and "international damage". https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-11660210 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-11660210
- xdfgh1112 5y agoAnd yet it's still class A. The study has been ignored entirely by the government
- stanislavb 5y agoThere should be more studies on micro-dosing as well. Many of the modern drugs that one can buy from the pharmacy would have serious bad effects if you take 10-20 pills at the same time. Yet, you take take a small dose from a package, and you are OK. i.e. micro-dosing (1/20 => 1/10 of a "regular dose") could give one all the benefits of Psilocybin without any detrimental effects - at all. p.s. most probably you won't be "converted" into a hippie (as some people are worried about it) if you are micro-dosing.
- stephenitis 5y agoThere are several in progress. Some run by private for profit companies. Stay tuned.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwawaypkjhg 5y agoAnecdotally, I have longterm visual side effects from taking magic mushrooms once 16 years ago (halos around objects, static on the walls, patterns pulsing, etc.) It's possible they were there prior but I didn't notice them, but these are not that uncommon from what I glean (see HPPD). I also had semi ego death for a year or two.
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoI was terrified of HPPD when I was first dabbling in psychedelics. 15 years and many trips later I notice the occasional perceptual oddity, but I feel like this is how my perception has always worked and pre-drug-use-me was just ignoring the debug output. Not to diminish any accounts of HPPD to the contrary, maybe I'm just lucky.
- throwawaypkjhg 5y agoI think this is a good theory. As mentioned in my other reply, my symptoms didn't start until about a week afterwards when I started having panic attacks. From there, the anxiety caused the visual symptoms (I may have even read about them online). It's entirely possible that I just inadvertently trained myself to see the unfiltered raw output from my visual cortex, which I previously ignored. If you read about any HPPD communities it seems inextricably linked to anxiety, but hard to know which is the cause and which is the effect.
- stephenitis 5y agoWhat was your dosage? Was it a single dose? Age at the time? any other drugs were in play? Have your HPPD faded over time? I’m curious and if you don’t mind answering.
- throwawaypkjhg 5y agoThanks for the note. I was 15 and took an eighth in a single dose as tea. I had been smoking a lot of weed too for about a week. Ironically the trip wasn't that intense, but I had a panic attack because my friend (who was also on mushrooms) started having seizures. These side effects also didn't appear for about a week, which adds to theory that most people 'see' these things but their brains ignore them. I was always extremely sensitive to marijuana too (similar medium-term ego death, etc.)
- 0000011111 5y agoPsychedelics are the opposite of additive. In general, when a healthy person does a higher dose with the correct set and setting they do not want to do a high dose again for months and sometimes years and in some cases ever. Do not take my word for it. Research drug addiction statics. Compare Synthetic Opioid overdoes to Psilocybin overdoes. Look at how the drug war has fueled the industrial prison complex and the expense of POC. With a broader frame, of the risk profile, it's clear that Psilocybin is low on the list for healthy people. And that the drug war has manifested as a modern cast system within the united states.
- smk_ 5y agoAmong the people I've talked to that has taken psilocybin, it seems common to believe in nonsense such as reincarnation. That's why I'll never take it, it seems as if you lose grip with reality.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoMeh. People have all sorts of beliefs about the afterlife. Nobody knows what’s going to happen. Unless you know somebody who came back from the dead and reported on it?
- tasty_freeze 5y agoI never took any drugs until my mid 50s. Part of the motivation was to experience this spirituality that others report that I've never experienced. I'm a cautious person by nature, so I did a series of stepped doses, spaced a few weeks apart, of various lysergimides and tryptamines. In short: LSD was quite interesting and not at all spiritual for me. 4-aco-dmt (a close relative to psilocybin) was entirely different: much more dreamy, confusing, and it gave me a brief taste of that spiritual feeling. All in all, over a couple years, I did about 20 experiments, and have done only small doses twice in the past two years. I'm not sure if I'll do either again, as I probably have found all I care to see from them. Experiencing things first-hand has only reinforced my prior beliefs in a material world. If a simple, small molecule can to drastically change your mood and perception, it seems all the more clear that there is no magic. On the flip side, people who were prone to believe in the woo experience the same things I did, but because of their prior framing found confirmation of their own prior beliefs as well. I don't think you have anything to fear should the opportunity present itself to you. The main benefit for me was this: I'm very good, too good, at compartmentalizing my emotions. My wife suffers from anxiety and depression. Having experienced hours-long states where my emotions ran loose that my intellect was unable to reign in, I can now empathize, and not just sympathize, a bit with my wife's experiences.
- yboris 5y agoThank you for sharing! A related experience I had was when I took LSD and smoked weed for the first time. At the time weed would sometimes give me paranoid thoughts (I've only smoked about a dozen times at this point) - and the LSD exacerbated the effects. I had almost an hour of severe paranoia, but as time went on I realized how irrational it was (and discovered useful a strategy of "make a prediction, and if it doesn't happen, stop being afraid - rather than keep thinking the scary thing is just behind the next corner"). The takeaway for me was similar to yours: a better empathy for people who may (without psychedelics) have a higher tendency to be worried/anxious. A realization that despite all the rational thoughts you can have, the fears can persist (as they are irrational - and continue to have force even when the rational side of the brain insists so). Since then I've been continuing to enjoy both drugs separately and together - now-a-days it's mostly bliss and joy. I particularly recommend LSD & MDMA -- candy flipping ;)
- stevebmark 5y agoThis smells like when society generally thought weed had no long-term effects and wasn't addictive. Mushrooms anecdotally seem to have dose dependent long term effects, including disconnecting from reality, sometimes in destructive ways.
- umvi 5y ago> no short- or long-term detrimental effects And yet, all my friends who started using mushrooms now post pseudo-spiritual/pseudo-philosophical/pseudo-mystical yet completely nonsensical thoughts on social media. You can tell they think it's super deep and meaningful, but for us sober folk it just seems a little nutty. Stuff like: "We are the UNIVERSE. For the universe is within us." or "The Matrix is a system. That system is our enemy. The very minds of the people that need to be saved are not ready to be unplugged. They will fight to protect their truth, as they should. The saving can only come from within." From my sober perspective, it seems like psilocybin causes some users to lose a degree of grip on reality/rationality which I consider "detrimental" (though the users themselves claim it's "enlightening")
- zozbot234 5y ago> You can tell they think it's super deep and meaningful, but for us sober folk it just seems a little nutty. Stuff like: "We are the UNIVERSE. For the universe is within us." or "The Matrix is a system. That system is our enemy. The very minds of the people that need to be saved are not ready to be unplugged. They will fight to protect their truth, as they should. The saving can only come from within." Sounds exactly like what "us sober folks" would say after an intensive meditation retreat in the Vipassana tradition. Maybe the entheogen users are just taking a convenient shortcut.
- literalsunbear 5y agoDo you reject the idea that you and I are both the universe experiencing itself? You seem overly concerned with how often people decide to engage in the positive and apparently harmless practice of indulging in the idea. Are you this scrutinizing toward other spiritual practices such as Christianity or Islam? Not trying to do a whataboutism or anything, just trying to get a good read on exactly how humorless you are.
- aqme28 5y agoAnd anecdotally i've found shroom use more common among my smartest friends. And the people posting antivax facebook memes or whatever are a totally different set of people.
- superfamicom 5y agoA few comments pointing out the correlation to spiritual / mystical communities. I know many engineers who use or have used and have fallen deeper into their hustle life style. I would say that it helps you explore yourself, be that chakras or crypto.
- gringoDan 5y agoThis study lasted 12 weeks. That is not a good definition of "long-term". I'm reminded of this recent ACX post about the phrase "No Evidence". It means 2 very distinct things: > 1. This thing is super plausible, and honestly very likely true, but we haven’t checked yet, so we can’t be sure. > 2. We have hard-and-fast evidence that this is false, stop repeating this easily debunked lie. Different people will read the same article and choose their interpretation based on their previous bias. https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/the-phrase-no-evidence-is-a-red-flag https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/the-phrase-no-evidence...
- theptip 5y agoJust to be clear, the title is incorrectly editorializing the article. Lots of people in this thread are correctly objecting to the unsupported overly-broad claim that there are no long-term effects. What the paper actually tested: > The trial is the first of its kind to thoroughly investigate the simultaneous administration of psilocybin. 89 healthy participants with no recent (within 1 year) use of psilocybin were recruited. 60 individuals were randomly picked to receive either a 10mg or 25mg dose of psilocybin in a controlled environment. In addition, all participants were provided with one-to-one support from trained psychotherapists. The remaining 29 participants acted as the control group and received a placebo, also with psychological support. > Participants were closely monitored for six to eight hours following administration of psilocybin and then followed up for 12 weeks. During this time, they were assessed for a number of possible changes, including sustained attention, memory, and planning, as well as their ability to process emotions. So the study did not find any deleterious effects in N=89, from _one_ dose, in a supportive environment, over a fairly short follow-up period. This not surprising to me and I'm not updating my model of the world in any way. This does _not_ prove that Psilocybin has no detrimental long-term effects. It just suggests that if they occur, they probably don't occur frequently enough to show up in the cursory glance that this study gave to the issue. Psilocybin is an exciting treatment for mental health issues; it's great that it's being destigmatized. It should be decriminalized, and it is much safer than alcohol and many other recreational drugs. However, like any drug, it has risks and can be misused. We need to be honest about the risks, understand that nothing is safe, and particularly, understand how to detect and respond to those risks when they do occur. edit: The title has now been changed, so this comment will read weirdly.
- worik 5y agoPsilocybin is very safe. It is short acting so the distress that often accompanies major psychedelics is short and wears off quickly (unlike, say, mescaline which drags on for hours) There does seem to be a effect where taking magic mushrooms several days in a row produces deleterious effects, I am not sure that is due to the psilocybin but it is unpleasant physical side effects that are not apparent if doses are spaced. Repeated use (even when spaced enough to avoid the above physical effects) usually resulted (in my anecdotal observations of other people) in sever paranoia developing. That faded as quickly as the effects of the drug. It should be available and it should be widely used. Psychedelic drugs are good for the mind, which is why people take them.
- handsaway 5y ago"In healthy people" seems to be doing a lot of heavy lifting here. I've done mushrooms three times and the first two were fun (but not enlightening or life-changing) experiences. The third time I had a bad trip. It was "my fault" in that in retrospect I did not have the right set/setting to take them, but it triggered a massive panic attack that spiraled me pretty severely into a months long anxiety episode. Before the mushrooms I was fine and after them I was having nightly panic attacks that lasted hours. I have a panic disorder but it was "in remission" previously. Now having a panic disorder may disqualify me as a "healthy person" but given that the study is analyzing it as a treatment for mental disorders it seems that that's not what they mean. I don't know if panic/anxiety is included in "a range of mental health conditions, including treatment-resistant depression (TRD) and PTSD". I'm just saying that it definitely _can_ be harmful to your mental health based on my experience. I don't know whether or not complementary talk therapy would have changed my outcome.
- fdwizard 5y agoAs someone who invests in psychedelic-assisted therapy companies and follows the space pretty closely, I am shaking my head at some of the comments here. A lot of anecdotal stories wrapped up as "wise" warnings against psychedelic use. Recreational use does not apply in this clinical setting context, at all. Nor can it be extrapolated back to a recreational scenario. Granted, the title of this article reads click bait-y and I can see why there were visceral reactions. Additionally, the article lacks some context which I'll try to provide. I've been following Compass Pathways for about a year now, and what I can tell you is this: 1. The purpose of this study was NOT to prove psilocybin has no deleterious effects in healthy subjects. It's purpose is as a supplementary/complementary study to their ongoing clinical trials for treatment-resistant depression and post-traumatic stress disorder. Basically, the more "ammo" they have surrounding psilocybin's safety the better, as they are headed into meetings with the FDA on their upcoming phase 3 trials. 2. The second purpose of this study was to prove that one therapist can administer doses to multiple patients at the same time. Cost is a huge, ongoing concern for commercialization in this space. To have a therapist watch over one patient for a 6-8 hour trip makes this treatment difficult to scale, and this gives Compass possibly a little more leeway and broadening in their treatment protocol. 3. Mystical type experiences are currently believed to bring about a greater chance of positive outcome in patients treated with psychedelic-assisted therapy. This is NOT dictated by what you thought was a "mystical" experience - it is determined by the MEQ (Mystical Experience Questionnaire) that is sometimes administers in these studies. 4. "Healthy" subjects - please keep in mind that in this context, the definition is narrow and shouldn't be interpreted in any way other than what the trials' inclusion/exclusion criteria listed. In these studies, it usually means no history of mental illness, ESPECIALLY schizophrenia. Beware of applying "healthy" to any other marker. 5. I urge people here to read Compass' recently completed phase IIb study on treatment-resistant depression (= patients who've failed at least 2 antidepressants). There absolutely are mild adverse - serious adverse events that occur, even in controlled and supportive settings. Please take this current studies statement as strictly as it reads "The results also showed there were no short or long term detrimental effects on thinking patterns or processing of emotions".
- stephenitis 5y agoThanks for your viewpoint on the underlying reason why this study exists. How do you stay informed in this space? What companies are on your watchlist?
- baroninthetrees 5y agoAs a suburban dwelling dad, where on Earth would I find some? I have been intrigued for a while.
- stephenitis 5y agoIf you know someone who buys weed illegally they might have a source. Darknet. A ridiculous amount of drugs are just delivered using usps. I grew mine from a small kit from the Netherlands. I’m in the EU. It’s legal to grow them for decorative purposes here but not consume them.lol.