6 ms·
Isn't this Google's job? Are developers a small but lucrative target and so the suits at Google don't see the benefit of improving that experience by cleaning u
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
Isn't this Google's job? Are developers a small but lucrative target and so the suits at Google don't see the benefit of improving that experience by cleaning up the spam?
Can we just nudge them to do so under the threat of an influential minority leaving due to their use case being affected?
- tjpnz 5y ago>Isn't this Google's job? Or more fundamentally perhaps this is just the system working as Google intended?
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI think the disconnect comes from people expecting perfect search results as curated by humans, whereas Google necessarily must optimize for automated results. Automated results will never be perfect.
- MarcelOlsz 5y agoWorst case scenario if Google drops the ball I just go back to the library.
- jstx1 5y agoI'm sure they have great books on stackoverflow answers, reddit reviews of products and opening times of local stores.
- akho 5y agoLuckily, stackoverflow, reddit, and your favorite mapping thing have their own searches.
- MarcelOlsz 5y agoHey it might take me 30 years to find the answer but at least my eyes will thank me!
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoIs there a word for this tendency to say, "it's someone else's job" as a justification for doing nothing at all to help or improve one's own circumstances? I see more and more of it in the public discourse over the last years and it kind of bothers me. I see it a lot in conversations related to poverty or climate change, but it is as we see here by no means exclusive to those topics. To the original replyer: you could wait for Google to do something, but if they were going to fix the listicle issue, and it were fixable on their end, they'd probably have done it by now. I'm disappointed in the situation too but if there is a workable solution on our end it would be silly to ignore it because fixing the problem is someone else's job. To the OP: I worry that the number of domains pumping out crap might be far greater than we know, and that might hamper the effectiveness of this. If the collaborative block list ever got big enough you might also have to deal with spam. But I think it would be a great thing to try. This is one of those issues that annoys me, but it's just below my action potential threshold. My biggest objection right now is the spammy recipe websites.
- jazzyjackson 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bystander_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bystander_effect
- geofft 5y agoI think the question was specifically about declining to improve one's own circumstances because someone else could, not declining to help someone else. That's different from the bystander effect as usually conceived. The theoretical bystander effect is something like "Someone is being attacked, I could call 911 but someone else will;" this is perhaps something like "I am being attacked, I could scream for help but other people will notice anyway" - but really more like "I can't cross the street in front of my house because the storm drains by the crosswalk are clogged, I could rake them but the city is supposed to do that."
- jazzyjackson 5y agoFair enough, maybe Learned Helplessness is a better fit.
- ziggus 5y agoI think you're wildly overestimating the influence of the minority within HN (or other similar communities) that actually care enough to switch to another search engine. This reminds me of the Linux gamers who claim that they can influence game development companies by purchasing games with Linux ports, but wind up being less than 0.5% of sales of most games with Linux ports, which leads manufacturers to ignore that customer base almost completely.
- yellowsir 5y agogame companies might have ignored us, but in the end it created a space for valve and codeweavers to fill.
- fileeditview 5y agoNot disagreeing with you.. big companies truly mostly ignore Linux but there are more than a few indie devs who support Linux as a platform. And I tend to play only indie games these days anyways because all the big commercial games have been reduced to some kind of click-and-succeed or free-to-play-and-milk-some-whales crap. I personally am kinda happy where Linux gaming has come to be. Sure it could always be better but I remember times where there were only like 3 games for Linux and you had to compile them yourself..
- nottorp 5y ago> Isn't this Google's job? Have you searched anything on Google lately? The answer is "no". Their new job seems to be to stuff your results with anything even remotely related (and sometimes related in a way that only machine learning can see) so you have things to click on. Edit: with the lone exception of "find me this bussiness nearby".
- goodlinks 5y agoIf I search for a business name its normally not the first result any more. Usually an advert for another company in the same space I dont want to use (basically an offensive / scamming result from user perspective) and then also the standard "buy search term on amazon".
- mikevin 5y agoIt's very obvious Google is no longer the equivalent of grepping the web. There's some ML/NLP interpretation that's rewarded for returning the substring/interpretation that returns the most/highest ranking results. It's very noticeable if your search contains a short keyword that has to interpreted in the context of the other keywords. As an example, if I search for 'ARM assembly' plus another keyword (macro, syntax etc) it will see 'ARM assembly' without the extra keyword has way more high ranking results and happily show me how much it knows about armchairs that don't require assembly. Ignoring the fact that the extra keywords are there specifically to limit the search results. It's tiring, a lot of time I previously spent browsing the limited but valuable results it returned I now have to spend mangling the keywords enough to outsmart their ML/NLP interpretation and get it to admit I am actually asking for the thing I am asking for so I can finally get to the part where I have to solve the modern captcha: click all the results that are: 1. Not stolen/rehosted 2. Not a "Hello World" level Medium blog 3. Written by an actual human
- moneywoes 5y agoNo, google wants more clicks so they would prefer poor results that keep users searching
- alangibson 5y ago> cleaning up the spam I'll be happy to be proven wrong, but I think Google is now fully in the 'optimize for engagement' camp. If that's what they're doing, it's by definition not spam (from their point of view) if people are clicking on it more than the non-spam results. Again, only my guess as to what's going on. I don't see another good explanation for them only serving cloned Stackoverflow and top X lists for basically everything now.
- onionisafruit 5y agoFrom a user point of view, a search engine’s job is to link you away from the search engine, so how does a search engine measure engagement? Is it time on page or maybe number of searches performed? When you don’t have viable competitors both of those are improved by worse search results. Even number of ads clicked would be improved with worse search results because ads don’t have as much competition for your attention when there are no relevant results on the page.
- alangibson 5y ago> From a user point of view, a search engine’s job is to link you away from the search engine That hasn't been true for a long while. Users are there for an answer to their query, not to be directed anywhere. Frequently this comes in the form of search vertical response that doesn't lead the user anywhere. From Google's point of view, you want the user where you can show them ads, full stop. Google does not exist to provide you with answers to your queries, it exists to make money for shareholders. > When you don’t have viable competitors both of those are improved by worse search results. I don't think "worse search results" is the way to think of it. From G's point of view they're better because they make them more money.
- beepbooptheory 5y agoGoogle has a fiduciary responsibility to shareholders, which is so much work as it is! Why are you trying to ask them to do more?
- sanketpatrikar 5y agoIt is Google's job, but they either aren't doing it or are failing at it. We could do something about it at least until a better alternative or a solution appears. > Can we just nudge them to do so under the threat of an influential minority leaving due to their use case being affected? Many influential people have tried and nothing seems to have transpired from it. Google.com is the most popular website. I don't think the leaving of any minority group we manage to create would even matter to Google, let alone force them to fix the issue. Not that I discourage using alternatives.
- tut-urut-utut 5y agoInstead of spending energy to change Google, why not just leave them for good? Start with changing default search engine to DuckDuckGo or something else, install uBlockOrigin and Privacy Badger to disable tracking, and gradualy reduce using every Google or application, starting with Chrome. Be the change you want to see.
- sanketpatrikar 5y agoI relate to this opinion. There are two reasons why my suggestion might still be useful: 1. DuckDuckGo too is affected by these SEO-gaming sites, so maintaining a blacklist will help us make that experience better too. 2. There are times when only Google can find us what we're looking for, so this will prove useful when we go back to it.
- omnicognate 5y agoAre you paying them to do it?
- BuyMyBitcoins 5y ago>” Can we just nudge them to do so under the threat of an influential minority leaving due to their use case being affected?” I sense Google is too big to cater to us like this. Despite a steady decline in quality, Google is still the dominant search engine and the competition isn’t even close to its market share. Not only would they not notice many of “us” leaving, the amount of change they would have to implement in order to satisfy our desires would end up changing the product for the rest of the market. On some level, the product managers must be satisfied with the metrics as they stand since Google is continuing with their current course.
- ineedasername 5y agoGoogle's goal isn't to create the best possible search engine, it's to have a search engine that is good enough that people won't actively seek an alternative at the same time that they put as much ad content as possible in there, again before it's so much that people seek an alternative. I doubt many advertisers like the status quo very much either. They basically have to pay for ad placement to ensure the first results for their product aren't ads for competing products. On mobile when I search for Boox the first result linking to them is an ad. Same for Kobo. In other instances I'll search for company or product and a competitor ad is the first to show. So vendors get stuck paying for ads when their own site should probably be the first organic result, above the ads.
- reaperducer 5y agoAre developers a small but lucrative target and so the suits at Google don't see the benefit of improving that experience by cleaning up the spam? Google doesn't make money from people finding what they're searching for. Google makes money by keeping people searching.
- anigbrowl 5y agoCan we just nudge them to do so under the threat of an influential minority leaving No. This is a classic mistake of intellectual types, who are impressed by each others' cogent arguments. But there is a much wider pool of people who are not, and among whom the intellectual types actual have very little influence, due to being boring and hard to understand (plus, it has to be said, kind of snobbish about how smart they are). Now, you might reason that Google is full of smart people who should care about cogent arguments. But that assumes as an unspoken premise that Google's internal goal is to maximize the quality of the service and profit from being The Best. They passed that goal years ago are now so awash in money that it's cheaper to just squash competition than to innovate. They can be moved by threats to advertising revenue got up by angry crowds on social media (a market when they have little direct power), but Google would probably be delighted if grumpy nerds wandered off somewhere else. If they need talent or access to some compelling technology they can just throw a pile of cash at the problem.