10 ms·
This strikes me as someone who formed a conclusion and went out to go find supporting evidence to write about. It is also wrong. The key to feeding the world
by colechristensen 5y ago
This strikes me as someone who formed a conclusion and went out to go find supporting evidence to write about.
It is also wrong.
The key to feeding the world was the Green Revolution, the system of plant variety and hybrid development, fertilization, pest management, and mechanization with related techniques which developed the capacity to feed the planet in the mid 20th century. Without it the world’s population would have been limited by starvation billions of people ago.
There are good arguments that those techniques can be significantly improved upon, but the people pushing for them generally don’t have very much of an idea of how things work and just tend to repeat each other’s “bro science”.
https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Revolution https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Revolution
- adityaathalye 5y agoNot to dispute your assertions, but perhaps it's worth looking at an alternate viewpoint. I found Masanobu Fukuoka's "The One-Straw Revolution" quite compelling. In it, Fukuoka argues for finding ways to diversify plant variety, improve soil quality and fertilization, manage pests such that external input (mechanization, fertilizers, pesticides, heavy irrigation) is not needed in the first place. All while improving yields year after year. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/976905.The_One_Straw_Revolution https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/976905.The_One_Straw_Rev... A dear friend has been applying the so-called "natural farming" principles for about a quarter of a century now, and swears by it. His farm is beautiful in a wabi-sabi sense, and is abundant like a forest. (edit: language, clarified sentence)
- kickout 5y agoIt's clear these practices don't scale. It's like saying you only need to hire 1 software dev and have them do everything, perfectly. When you find that 1 dev, it looks great. Your friend's farm is likely a well run operation and he might be a top 1% farmer (how ever you would quantify that). Also you make no mention of profitability, most farms are for profit and need to generate positive cash flow, regardless of practices. Oftentimes these sustainable practices are antagonistic to profitability, a complicated problem people in ag/tech/engineering/policy are working to resolve.
- adityaathalye 5y ago> It's clear these practices don't scale. Citation needed. Agriculture is one of humanity's largest-scale activities.[1] The vast majority of the world's farmland is smallhold. [2] The practices in Fukuoka's books are fundamentally smallhold practices. My friend's farm is a wee 10 acre plot. > Also you make no mention of profitability, most farms are for profit and need to generate positive cash flow, regardless of practices. Depends on how you look at it. If you see the state of agriculture worldwide, the evidence points to the contrary. Farming is unsustainable sans debt. As a system, farmland does not obey economic laws. In my opinion, the state of US agriculture is telling. 1% of the country's population operating giant farmlands needing super-high direct input costs, benefiting from just the massive available landmass not yet homesteaded, and indirectly beholden to subsidy that goes to Oil & Natural gas. The sector flounders under crippling debt. [3] Perhaps the purely profit-oriented standpoint is worth questioning. What would the world look like if agriculture, like education, healthcare, air, and water be thought of as a public benefit enterprise rather than a private profit-driven enterprise? And might this public-benefit attitude also change labour dynamics? It is hard work, but plenty of people are happy working with their hands. Many would live peacefully, if the economic and social environment weren't so hostile to human labour. The contrarian viewpoint is this: The reason why agriculture is hard is because it is capital intensive and wide open to tail risks. The antidote would be to minimize capital investment, and diversify the "portfolio" in holding size, crops, trees, communities and so forth. [1] https://ourworldindata.org/global-land-for-agriculture https://ourworldindata.org/global-land-for-agriculture [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallholding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallholding [3] https://time.com/5736789/small-american-farmers-debt-crisis-extinction/ https://time.com/5736789/small-american-farmers-debt-crisis-...
- kickout 5y agoThere are plenty of citations demonstrating organic practices cannot realistically replace even 50% of current production. You clearly know how to Google. This comment reads like socialism fan-fic. How well did communal/collective farms work for the Soviet Union and or China? The only way that has been proven to not starve millions of people has been to incentive food production in a pseudo-capitialistic manner (and yes, they are usually heavily subsidized for great reasons). If you made millions doing ad tech in silicon valley and want to play farmer on your 10 acre plot, great. Agriculture and food production are scaled to the gills currently. They got this way through incredible innovation. People were doing 'organic practices' for hundreds of years. It didn't scale. Mechanization, synthetic fertilizer, and plant science _did_ scale, however and that's why our systems looks like they do. The innovations needed to accomplish this were truly mind bending from several disciplines. Instead of celebrating these achievements, the conversation has been hijacked/lost because for profits companies took advantage of murky/poor regulation and are currently rent-seeking to squeeze every last dollar out of the system. Those problems can be fixed, but nobody is focusing on that, there too busy imagine some irrational alternate that simply cannot exist with ~9 billion people, many of which will begin eating more calories and more input intensive calories (meat) as time moves forward. Embrace that scale, and innovate from there.
- camgunz 5y agoThis reminds me of this video I watched about a farming family in Wisconsin. It's obviously high-level and anecdata, but I think it's along the same lines as your post and OP: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sRPP4Ilpxso https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sRPP4Ilpxso
- colechristensen 5y agoWhen the description of your book includes "purifying the human spirit" the immediate reaction is that you've found a way to sell books to hippies, and your advice on farming is perhaps suspect. There is a lot of speculation out there about how things might be done, but the reality is how things have actually been done were with the Green Revolution a.k.a. conventional farming. A few individuals with a hobby farm selling food to rich people isn't a solution to world agriculture problems. Most of these techniques are labor heavy and replacing machines with people either creates an underclass of slave-like labor or makes food cost a huge portion of where your income goes to. They also often use fertilizers, pesticides, herbicides, etc. but ones which are considered "natural" but not necessarily (and often definitely not) any less poisonous than synthetic alternatives. Like I said before, there are techniques, opportunities to improve, but these things aren't going to come from hippies thinking their garden is going to save the world or there 1/8 of an acre operation is going to scale to thousand acre farms. Their plans usually would involve completely reorganizing the world economy in infeasible ways only possible if everybody was an angel and shared exactly the same ideas.
- adityaathalye 5y agoYours is a valid critique. I'm not a fan of woo language either. At the same time, it's hard to ignore the results I've seen first-hand. Let's ignore the woo language and ignore the book and ignore my suggested misunderstanding of how any of it is supposed to work. What is the long-range systems outlook of current ag practices? Is it sustainable? If not, what scale of economic policy change will we have to undertake to make it work sustainably? We are of course talking about the entire system and not a few oddball smallhold farmers.
- colechristensen 5y ago>sustainable This is a bit of a weasel word overloaded by usage without much understanding of what is meant. Agriculture is not one thing. A whole lot of modern practices are indeed quite sustainable over very long periods, some others... less surely so, some, like burning down rain forests to farm for a few years and then moving on, obviously not. A whole lot of people get a little bit of information and just keep repeating "modern practices are unsustainable, we need to do X!" but this is vague and involves almost no understanding. What you need is actual scientists studying particular practices in particular areas commenting on the long term viability of certain behaviors and how they might be changed. But like many things the popular narrative is a good vs. evil where one vague thing is seen as bad and another good without really getting into what they're talking about. It's a complex field, I'm no expert but I know more than enough to see when somebody doesn't know anything, and unfortunately most of the conversations are by people who don't know anything. There are a lot of things which could be better and are indeed getting better. Automation needs to get better for non-grain farming so that the ratio of grains vs. other foods is altered in production and consumption. Automation could get better so you could have large fields growing multiple species at the same time without intensive human labor. Automation could get better so that weeds could be mechanically picked instead of whole fields getting sprayed with herbicides, so individual weeds could be sprayed with herbicides instead of crop plants. Understanding of soil fungi interactions with minerals and plants and how to grow and maintain this fungi and how to select for species of fungi which result in higher yields. There's a lot, it involves knowing and understanding specifics with an interest towards long term and not attaching broad labels to vague terms.
- mellavora 5y agoOr, perhaps, the key to feeding the world in the short term is petro-chemical based agriculture, leading to massive overpopulation and total collapse. while another key to feeding the world over a longer time span would involve permaculture-style methods and slower population growth, TIED TO ending corruption in distribution networks and much of the world's governments.
- kickout 5y agoDistribution networks is key. We are plenty of food to feed everyone in the world, right now. Petro-chemical based agriculture was one of the greatest innovation of humanity. But it's been misapplied and abused, mostly in the name of profits and slow/bad policy makers. Does not mean those tools and techniques can't be more properly applied. Can we feed them American style diets? No, but I would argue that diet is not worth scaling as we see several negative health outcomes as the result of our quantity and quality of calories. Link to my blog in my profile where I write about some of these things.
- HPsquared 5y agoIt only is needed for a short time. Fertility is already below replacement in most of the world, only a few areas are still growing rapidly. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_transition https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_transition
- noduerme 5y agoLet's not tie everything too much together. Tying everything together is how people become unhinged conspiracy theorists. Let's take one subject at a time. 1: >>the key to feeding the world in the short term is petro-chemical based agriculture, leading to massive overpopulation and total collapse. Let's assume this is because the profit is there to make more grain, not because anyone wants overpopulation or collapse. What you're saying is that it works, it does create more food. More food for more people. People are less likely to starve. Okay, good. Until the overpopulation and collapse part. What evidence do you have that that will happen? You're suggesting limiting food to decrease population. I just want to be clear about that. You're saying that people should starve. Even though we could farm enough food to feed them. Because you disagree with the farming methods. Right?
- noduerme 5y agoThis is a clickbait article that doesn't deserve a place on HN. So let's forget the "bro" aspect. Some methods of soil rejuvenation are very compatible with modern farming, and some farming in the US still depends too heavily on chemical fertilizer. In the mid-1800s, the "Great American Desert" was rebranded the "Great Plains" in a marketing campaign designed to get poor Irish people to go out and populate/farm it. That whole mess ended up with the topsoil getting blown off after a single generation of farming. Meanwhile, we now understand "soil" as a very complex substance, more organic than mineral. If they had understood that then, they would have had a better yield and the Army Corps of Engineers wouldn't have had to come in and rebuild Oklahoma and half of Arkansas from scratch[0]. For all the wonderful development of the 20th Century, lots of mistakes were made and lots of land was destroyed to achieve a brief burst of productivity, and lots could have been made more sustainable, and still could be. [0] https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/citations/ADA637016 https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/citations/ADA637016
- nerdponx 5y agoAre there any good books on this topic? Plenty has been written about "The West" in general, but specifically the agricultural history of America seems like it'd be both interesting and enlightening.
- littlestymaar 5y agoAnd this isn't limited to the US, the soviet did the exact sale things in Khazakstan[1] with the same consequences… [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin_Lands_campaign https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin_Lands_campaign
- noduerme 5y agoAlso in Argentina. It's a settler/imperialist pattern. https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conquista_del_Desierto https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conquista_del_Desierto (Not in Israel, though; when I say "settler/imperialist" I suspect some people might draw that conclusion. Israelis don't waste the land or practice these kinds of short-sighted farming techniques.)
- artificialLimbs 5y agoOr more people could grow their own food.
- colechristensen 5y agoContrast this with the constant flood of HN comments about how every desirable city is morally obligated to become a hyperdense megacity. I don't know how much food you're going to grow in your 400 sq ft closet in an apartment tower.
- bluGill 5y agoI can grow a lot of food in that much space. The problem is plants need light which is cheap from the sun, but there isn't enough in my closet so I need expensive lights on all the time. It is much more energy efficient to grow plants in open fields and fly the results to me (and using trucks, trains and ships is cheaper yet)
- deltarholamda 5y ago>the system of plant variety and hybrid development, fertilization, pest management, and mechanization with related techniques You're correct, but there turned out to be second order effects that were not accounted for because we didn't know that much about it. For example, chemical fertilization in the Midwest turns out to all flow into the watershed and dump out into the Gulf via the Mississippi. Which creates a dead zone for marine life. Which translates all the way down that food chain. It's a real problem. So much so that I'm surprised that the Gulf States haven't tried to sue the Midwest States for economic damages. Any "feed the world" solution really has to deal with the problem of "exactly how much of the world do we actually need." It sounds grim, and it is, but if the ecological problem is real and serious, it's a question that has to be dealt with.
- colechristensen 5y ago>You're correct, but there turned out to be second order effects that were not accounted for because we didn't know that much about it. Everything does. People fall into the pattern of "doing things this way is bad for all of these bad reasons" and "we should do things this other way for all these good reasons" failing to recognize the full spectrum of effects of various plans and pretending that their hopeful solution for the future won't itself have consequences too. It's an optimization problem that has been turned into a polarizing morality problem which doesn't lend itself to solutions (largely because most of the moralizers have only very superficial knowledge of the issues). >For example, chemical fertilization in the Midwest turns out to all flow into the watershed and dump out into the Gulf via the Mississippi. Which creates a dead zone for marine life. Which translates all the way down that food chain. It's a real problem. So much so that I'm surprised that the Gulf States haven't tried to sue the Midwest States for economic damages. I wonder how much extra carbon could be fixed in the Gulf of Mexico if we left ag runoff as it is and put enormous aquarium bubblers at the bottom of the ocean around the Mississippi delta. >Any "feed the world" solution really has to deal with the problem of "exactly how much of the world do we actually need." It sounds grim, and it is, but if the ecological problem is real and serious, it's a question that has to be dealt with. It really doesn't. Unless you're willing to advocate for suicide or genocide, it's not a problem that food policy needs to be concerned with. People feel resource constrained in other ways and nearly all advanced economies have seen birth rates fall to below replacement rate. Overpopulation is the hot button issue of decades past and the dire predictions aren't coming to pass as growth rates seem to be doing a fine job limiting themselves.
- bmitc 5y ago> The key to feeding the world was the Green Revolution... Without it the world’s population would have been limited by starvation billions of people ago. Do you have references for this particular assertion? Do you mean that without the Green Revolution, billions of people alive then would have starved or do you mean that without the Green Revolution, billions of people wouldn't have been born?