3 ms·
Yes income is income, regardless of how obtained. This mainly gives Federal prosecutors an additional tool to nail criminals. Even if prosecutors can't meet the
by nradov 5y ago
Yes income is income, regardless of how obtained. This mainly gives Federal prosecutors an additional tool to nail criminals. Even if prosecutors can't meet the legal burden of proof for theft they can still get the thief for tax fraud.
- dry_soup 5y agoIt's how they got Al Capone!
- cecilpl2 5y agoThis is famously how Al Capone was taken down, since they couldn't pin anything else on him.
- jeremyjh 5y agoI’m sure local police and prosecutors could have gotten him for murder etc. but he had them all on salary.
- jd115 5y ago
- Dma54rhs 5y agoThis is not reddit, please stop...
- mschuster91 5y agoFor the (ultra-)rich and well-connected, the wheels of justice tend to turn slower than for ordinary people, mostly because rich people have the resources to hire enough lawyers to swamp courts with all kinds of bullshit petitions and impediments, to submit expert "interpretations" or to argue about formalities. Not to mention that a lot of what surrounds the Trump presidency is unchartered territory in a legal sense - there exist laws, but they have never had to be tested before.
- DarylZero 5y agoWas there no federal murder statute at the time?
- xyzzyz 5y agoFeds cannot prosecute someone for murder if it’s not under federal jurisdiction. It would have to be murder of federal officer, or on tribal lands, or something like that.
- DarylZero 5y agoUh I don't think that's true? They just don't do it by policy usually. Remember those federal CA prosecutions for (state-legal) medical marijuana? And the federal prosecution of the police who assaulted Rodney King _after_ their state level acquittal?
- arcticbull 5y agoTo my knowledge, that's possible because the Feds have jurisdiction over inter-state commerce. If they can connect the crime to any kind of cross-state-lines activity they can claim the jurisdiction.
- bcrosby95 5y agoHas there been any case where the commerce clause has let the federal government down? It's a hole large enough to drive a country through.
- nradov 5y agoYes that is unfortunate. It appears that President Roosevelt forced the current expansive interpretation of the Commerce Clause by threatening to pack the Supreme Court with political cronies if the justices ruled against his New Deal legislation. Hopefully some day the Supreme Court will have the courage to overturn those precedents and limit federal government power to what the Constitution's authors originally intended.
- bluGill 5y agoWhich is easy to do when the locals don't support the law. Al Capone mostly opporated in areas with a large beer culture.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- habeebtc 5y agoThat tool is double sided as well: 1. Don't report stolen property as income? Tax evasion. 2. Report stolen property as income? Proof of theft, readily shared to other TLA's
- otterley 5y agoYou don’t have to admit or declare that the property was stolen. There’s no line for stolen property on a tax return, after all. There’s a catch-all line for “other income” on Schedule 1 that the value must be reported on.
- themitigating 5y agoYou don't specify stolen items
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe IRS, in theory, isn't allowed to share the information. https://money.cnn.com/2013/02/28/news/economy/illegal-income-tax/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2013/02/28/news/economy/illegal-income... > If you tell the IRS you made $1 million from stealing money or dealing drugs, does the agency tip off the cops? > Legally, it can't, unless a law-enforcement agency gets a court order granting it access to a specific taxpayer's return. The IRS isn't supposed to proactively alert other agencies about misdeeds unless terrorism is involved. In that case, it still needs a court order to disclose anything, but the IRS can initiate the legal process on its own.
- SilasX 5y agoTechnically, that would mean they aren't allowed to volunteer the information; the source says they do share it once ordered to. Which, IMHO, violates the Fifth Amendment, as any compelled testimony shouldn't be admissible against you, but of course our jurists gave the government a pass on that.
- acdha 5y agoI would bet that most of it probably comes down to this part specifically: > such as money from dealing illegal drugs Given the number of states which have legalized some drugs, there will be a growing, non-trivial number of people who have some income which is legal in their state but not at the federal level. I don't know what fraction of them would be trying that purely as a tax dodge but I could very easily believe someone at the IRS wanted to have an FAQ to point to in that situation.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoI’d like to see the opposite play out: government bungles the criminal case, and the criminal actually filled taxes correctly on stolen goods so they can’t get nailed for fraud
- lvs 5y agoYes. And it particularly may confer federal jurisdiction to a state crime.
- el_nahual 5y agoIt's also a disincentive to steal instead of paying taxes. Otherwise one could choose to steal money (say, embezzling from a family business instead of paying oneself) with the idea of "I'd rather go to jail for 5 years than pay X million in tax"