11 ms·
Boston Dynamics’ Stretch robot can move 800 heavy boxes per hour
- nightshift1 5y agoThey have some videos on their youtube channel: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLlL_rsmcRMZd4EgwMU5kHy_prYkechODd https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLlL_rsmcRMZd4EgwMU5kHy_pr...
- mattfredfry 5y agoCan all boxes be safely picked up by suctioning the top? Seems like most packaging is designed to be supported from the bottom.
- smegsicle 5y agoidk what kind of sci-fi cardboard they're working with, but here they're picking up boxes from a single side: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yYUuWWnfRsk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yYUuWWnfRsk
- robocat 5y agoYeah, it seems like such a terrible constraint. Maybe okay for loading in a factory where: * in a factory the boxes can be changed to suit the robot (limited by how automated the box loading and top sealing is). If the boxes need changing then it makes selling the robot far more difficult. * in a factory the contents are of a predictable weight, and the boxes are predictable sizes * in a factory the loads are not mixed * the factory doesn’t palletise their boxes Is there a marketplace where you can bet against the success of an individual product? Although given than most products fail, then either (a) the odds are poor e.g. win 10% more than your stake, or (b) you pay out huge amounts if the product succeeds (similar to how you can lose a lot of money shorting a stock). They talk about a fence around the robot, which is only viable if the robot needs help very rarely. If the robot needs help a lot (boxes over 23kg, boxes of unsupported sizes like TVs) safety issues would quickly arise, and liability kills the product.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 5y agoThis seems more suited for a distribution center or cross-dock/3PL use case (where you’d be dealing with non-palletized mixed-box shipments in high-enough volume for it to matter.
- toss1 5y agoYes, I wondered that from the first demonstration months ago. I've got no doubt that sufficient suction can be generated for the needed lifting forces, but indeed, will the packaging tolerate it? While my shop doesn't do a huge amount of shipping and is not a big shipper, and most boxes can tolerate it, I can definitely think of both outgoing and incoming boxes I wouldn't want to see picked up by the top... .
- Kinrany 5y agoThey could be stored in small containers.
- ruste 5y agoI don't think this is as much of a constraint as you'd expect. Imagine you manage to pull 1 psi over a 10x10" patch of box. That's 100lb of lifting force. If you're worried about whether the cardboard can handle it spread the area and lower the pressure more. I don't think 1lb per square inch of cardboard would be an issue and it looks like they have more surface area for suction than that.
- BugsJustFindMe 5y agoWithout bottom support, contents might fall through an inappropriately supportive box. The answer is "no, not all boxes, but yes some boxes".
- dijonman2 5y agoLast time I moved I spent a fortune on double corrugated boxes. I bought a cardboard stapler and taped it. Heavy boxes still needed support from the bottom.
- malcolmwhite 5y agoNot all, but enough to make this a viable product. There are a lot of high volume, low-sku warehouses where each product is light enough for Stretch's arm. As with any robotics project, there are a lot of ways that this might fail, but my money is not on boxes being too heavy or flimsy.
- notatoad 5y agoi've only got limited experience working in a warehouse, but i think that yes, they can safely assume that any box packed loose in a shipping container or truck doesn't need to be supported from the bottom. suction on the side or top isn't really any different from a human packer grabbing it with a hand on each side. heavier things that really need bottom support would usually be shipped on pallets.
- abeyer 5y ago> isn't really any different from a human packer grabbing it with a hand on each side. heavier things that really need bottom support would usually be shipped on pallets. That certainly explains the sad state of a couple of heavy packages I've received recently after clearly making similar assumptions and being mishandled in shipping.
- taneq 5y agoI’d imagine if you’d just spent $$$$ on fancy robots ups probably fork out for nicer boxes if required to make the robots useful. ;)
- grecy 5y agoI spent a few summers working at a distribution center for all the cold and frozen food for every Safeway in the state. Upstairs people put boxes onto conveyor belts, the system sorted them into lanes and downstairs people put the boxes onto "per store" pallets. At least every 30 minutes someone would pickup a box of yogourt/orange juice/whatever and the bottom would fall out and they would wear the contents. Boxes are NOT usually designed to be pickup up from above.
- xfour 5y agoSeems super practical for something that likely is difficult to create a one-size fits all conveyor.
- lp0_on_fire 5y agoI'm curious how this works on the other side of the warehouse - in shipping. Especially once you start thinking about the games of tetris that are played when loading the container. Boxes are often not uniform in dimensions or weight, nor should they be loaded like they are in the picture if it can be avoided. They need to be interlocked (assuming non-cubic boxes) so that the entire load doesn't come crashing down if it shifts.
- mattlondon 5y agoThe article mentions this - TL;Dr: not yet for the robots due to planning complexities that you mention.
- sb057 5y agoSpeaking from experience, there's two main strategies: 1) Diligence, care, time, and luck on the part of the loader, carefully stacking boxes in such a way to make sure there isn't any room for the boxes to shift in transit or fall over when unloading. 2) Just throw it all in a big pile and hope nothing breaks. Both are roughly equally common.
- tomcam 5y agoYeah, I use UPS too
- awofford 5y agoI used to work at a factory that was doing this (loading the trucks for shipping with a robot). It took much longer to implement than expected, but eventually worked pretty well. In the beginning, we would test by driving the loaded truck on a typical route and then checking the contents. The first few times were a disaster with boxes thrown all over the trailer. It was very cool to watch the robot work.
- narrator 5y agoPerhaps we can use the golden hammer of deep learning for this? Maybe the input layer would be a 3d tensor with a 1 for the of space taken by each box, or the edge of each box, and a zero for everything else. The output layer would be a quality score that would be the result of a simulation of how badly the boxes were damaged given the truck shifting wildly. Then the model, when sufficiently trained, could be used by the packer robot to iterate solutions on the boxes it had for packing to achieve the best predicted quality score?
- pickler_85930 5y ago[dead]
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoI'd love to learn a little more; I'm unlikely to move family from Michigan to Massachusetts but I'm professionally curious. What's your stack like? Are you building your own motion control gear to run on off-the-shelf manipulators, running ROS, RoboDK, or similar on commercial arms, or something in the middle? I've got lots of experience with "off-the-shelf" robotic arms like Fanucs, Densos, and Epsons, as well as experience with embedded and general-purpose programming languages like C, Lua, C#, and Python. Achieving reasonable fault tolerance and flexibility is hard enough in controlled environments of the automation cells I've built, but I estimate that fully automated trailer load/unload would be almost completely intractable without access to a general-purpose programming language. The disparities between the two fields have lead to lots of frustration with the hamstrung vendor development environments that either make it impossible to type text at all, or restrict you to idiosyncratic Basic-but-not that's been chained to a slow-moving manufacturer since the 80s. It almost makes me want to throw out the vendor's kinematics and IO to just hook the servos directly to an EtherCAT bus, or to throw out the robot controller replace it with a generic CNC controller. Have you finally done that? Programming robots in Python as you describe would be blissful in comparison to some of the vendor tooling I've used! The arm in your videos looks a little like the Tormach ZA6 arm that I've been following; is that the OEM you are using?
- pickler_85930 5y agoOur stack is exclusively Python, which has been working out beautifully, and we use off the shelf robots from Kuka and Universal Robots. In my opinion, the vendor kinematics for these robots is pretty good, and we get nice control over our motion.
- klyrs 5y agoSounds cool, but I'm only doing remote work going forward.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoI thought it was going to be a robot for cleaning toilets .
- hellbannedguy 5y ago
- iwanttoknow 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- geijoenr 5y agoFinally Boston Dynamics is releasing a robot that looks like a regular industrial robot. It seems the pressure to generate sales is forcing them to produce more down to earth products that can be marketed easily.
- BbzzbB 5y agoI find the introduction video [0] better shows what it does/can do. So... I guess inserters [1] are a thing, wonder how long until we get the tech for fast and stack inserters. Glad we skipped the burners, good strategy as it is such a mess to reconfigure. 0: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yYUuWWnfRsk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yYUuWWnfRsk 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FLb8TJ6-Z2M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FLb8TJ6-Z2M
- p_l 5y agoOn one recent project we had a stacking robot arm we nicknamed inserter-zilla. It was large, powerful (800kg max moved mass), and it killed few bits of industrial machinery before we patched in enough interlocks.
- Stevvo 5y agoIs it meant to get distracted by dancing with another robot after 60 seconds of work?
- BbzzbB 5y agoThey're just not properly tamed yet, they'll call in Cesar to instill some discipline and work ethics.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoUnion rules.
- matsemann 5y agoI work with the systems on a warehouse where robot arms similar to these are doing stacking of boxes. It's not really that efficient. Using robot arms is the natural improvement when automating a previously manual step, but rethinking the whole process instead yields a much bigger boost. At least that's what we hope with our new process soon up and running.. If anything, the new automation process is much simpler at least, there are sooo much that can go wrong with big robot arms. They look cool, though, great for recruiting.
- ibejoeb 5y agoSimilar to Energy Vault and other potential energy storage schemes. Conceptually it's sound, but the implementation is weak with respect to real-world constraints.
- ozim 5y agoI have never seen driving robot arm. Ones I have seen were always mounted in place. If this one can drive around as I understand -"omnidirectional mobile base"- with a box it is different game from my point of view.
- matsemann 5y agoTrue. But given the complexity and also safety considerations for a stationary arm, I'm not envying those having to deal with a mobile one, heh.
- syntaxing 5y agoYou can get a mobile base for a UR arm. Forgot the company name but it has omniwheels too
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoThe industry term is "mobile manipulator". For example the Google X robot for Everyday Robots, which I helped work on for a while, is such a robot. https://everydayrobots.com/ https://everydayrobots.com/
- deadmutex 5y ago
- miki_tyler 5y agoI saw the video and it can move the boxed out, but, can it grab boxes from the conveyor and pile them inside the container?
- amelius 5y agoHow useful is this when e.g. opening the boxes takes 10x the amount of time? Wouldn't it make more sense to first put robots where the bottleneck is?
- robotresearcher 5y agoReceiving is a serious bottleneck. The perimeter of a building is limited, with the number of docks growing as the square root of the floorspace. All else being equal, your I/O scales worse than your interior production capacity. This is one of the limits on the maximum size of a facility. Speeding up I/O flow is really good because you can’t parallelize it as much as other work. This robot is not super fast, but (assuming it works well) it is relentless. They'll get faster and better.
- amelius 5y agoGood points!
- AaronM 5y agoThey say they aren't planning to replace humans, instead of one human unloading one truck, it will be one human supervising robots unloading 4 trucks. Sure seems like a replacement to me.
- PhileinSophia 5y ago
- mandeepj 5y ago> unloading one truck The Stretch robot (shown in the article) can't unload a truck. It's not designed to lift itself up and enter a truck. Although, the other robots from BD (shown in the dancing video) might be able to do so.
- drusepth 5y agoA truck with some mild modifications (a belt on the floor, for example) could probably queue a full load of boxes/contents to a reachable position for unloading. Stretch looks like it's got a pretty tall/long acquisition range. Obviously wouldn't work OOTB, but definitely seems doable in some niche truck modifications (and likely little-to-no Stretch modifications).
- Victerius 5y agoWhat you're missing is that each human who used to move heavy boxes will be replaced by 4 robots. No business wouldn't want to increase their total productivity.
- chillingeffect 5y ago>“Typically, you’ll have two people unloading each truck. Where we want to get with Stretch is to have one person unloading four or five trucks at the same time, using Stretches as tools.” GP is correct. 1 supervisor + 8 robots replaces 8 people.
- vinayan3 5y ago
- tyrfing 5y agoIt's a little unfair to call this 80% of a solution, but it pretty much is. The demonstrated speed is awful, which is alright in theory since you can just run more of them in parallel, but it does pose an issue if it's added to a facility that is running near capacity and can't put more trailers on doors. 50 lb limit is below state of the art (humans), but some companies have that as a limit. It's ok. The real deal breaker is that it seems to be designed solely for cube volume, and not just any cubes, perfectly regular cubes. The demo videos also seem to be very light stuff (10-20 lbs?) and have a lot of impermeable surface like tape, I'd guess that 50 lbs is only doable under very good circumstances. Maybe even dusty boxes would be a problem. edit: 40-50lbs is plenty for cardboard cubes to warp, flex, start breaking apart, etc depending on the contents. This happens even with a human holding onto opposite corners, relying on a single flat surface just isn't very robust. I think grip is the big problem. When a robot can reliably toss poly bags, strapped printer paper boxes, and tubes, it's going to get a lot of use. I've seen that sort of stuff for smaller things, but it seems to be extremely hard to scale up to heavier weights. It's a bit funny, but this is probably 5x as useful in reverse, loading trailers and pallets.
- gtsop 5y agoIs there a problem if you keep using both machines for a big chunk of the workload but also humans for the edge cases you describe?
- sokoloff 5y agoMany warehouses do have the limit you mention: limited dock doors. It seems like building pallets and loading the trailer with a forktruck is a better plan than this thing. (You can build pallets anywhere inside the warehouse, not just in a trailer on a live dock. You give up maybe 6-9% of maximum volume that way, but humans/this robot aren’t packing to 100.00% either. To hit 4.5 seconds cycle time on average, this thing is going to be cranking. I wonder what the centripetal acceleration required from the outside of the box is to let the arm complete its rotation in ~2 seconds is. That’s 180° of motion, with a start and stop ramp. Maybe I’d give them 3 seconds loaded if they can achieve 1.5 seconds unloaded. Will have to wait til after dinner to work it out, but it seems not a trivial force.
- daenz 5y agoI'm getting real factorio vibes[0] from this 0. https://wiki.factorio.com/Fast_inserter https://wiki.factorio.com/Fast_inserter
- andrew_barger 5y agoSeems like this is a competitor to my company's ULTRA Loader: https://www.bastiansolutions.com/assets/1/6/ultra_cutsheet_3.6.pdf https://www.bastiansolutions.com/assets/1/6/ultra_cutsheet_3... I work in a different division, so I can't really speak to how this was developed. But, it's interesting to see the different design decisions, particularly the decisions to integrate or not integrate conveyor with the robot itself. Our robot is much larger due to the integrated conveyor, but from what I understand this simplifies navigation. We remain stationary on the outside of the trailer, so we sidestep the problem of navigating in an arbitrary trailer. This is a big challenge according to some of the AGV vendors I've spoken to. Maybe it comes down to mapping techniques - not my area.
- jcims 5y agoAny interesting design or engineering challenges that the HN crowd might not be aware of (but certainly are willing to opine on :)?
- brink 5y agoI worked on something similar over the summer. The most difficult thing about this problem is mixed size boxes. Knowing where every box is is easy when they're all the same dimension and stacked neatly, but what about when they're packed randomly, many boxes are askew, and they're all different sizes? Then you need to get into complicated time-of-flight sensors, point clouds, surface/box recognition logic/AI, etc..
- chairmanwow1 5y agoWouldn’t a strobe lidar be perfect for this? Or would you just want CV segmentation?
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoWhen I worked at a grocery store, our solution for re-stacking pallets of merchandise was to place the largest boxes at the bottom and build upward with smaller boxes. Obviously this wouldn't be a great way to do things in a shipping container given the amount of vertically wasted space, but it worked in a warehouse. Of course, the reason we were re-stacking pallets is because our original managers were so bad at managing inventory that the 20ish backstock carts were full, so we would routinely have 15-25 pallets of backstock in the warehouse... when ideally the carts should only ever be half full. Saved their jobs when I took the order gun from them, lol.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thamer 5y agoIs this a sponsored article? It reads like an advert, gushing over this technology with no mention of downsides, limitations, or competitors. It's all great and perfect and the future is awesome. I believe the term "advertorial" applies pretty well here.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoSeems typical for Boston Dynamics, heavy on marketing, light on detail, everything is awesome, no mention of customers. I'll bet they can program the movements of several robots and set it all to music, everything is cool when you're part of a team.
- culi 5y agoFor companies like Boston Dynamics, the main customer is usually government contractors. And the sad truth is that those are often as easy or easier to trick than general consumers. It's a big key to Elon Musk's success imo. See: all of Musk's hype plans that are really infeasible (e.g. hyperloop). The only plausible customers are governments yet somehow he's still managing to land incredible contracts for plans that are all hype
- faangiq 5y agoAll articles are sponsored. The internet is one giant ad.
- KineticLensman 5y agoIt reminds me when they made a big things of their robot 'mule' being evaluated by the US army/marines. It wasn't accepted. Reasons that I picked up included: * tactically unacceptable noise * short range before being refuelled * not as autonomous as advertised * Increased maintenance / oil leakages. These issues of course won't be such a problem in the warehouse environment but I'd be keen to see an independent assessment of the thing's utility.
- anaganisk 5y agoI mean we have brightest engineers working in biggest companies for building more intrusive apis and AI ML or data lakes to show more Ads.
- monkeydust 5y agoSo they are finally going into the pick-and-place robotics market. Anyone know how much this robot will retail for?
- black_13 5y ago
- jcims 5y agoSeems like with some modifications it could be a decent semi-autonomous platform for construction work. Haul/place/fasten/tape/paint drywall. Drill/set anchors/place hangers for mechanicals/drop ceiling. Might even be able to make walls with metal studs, especially if you could load it with rolls of galvanized steel and let it fold/stamp to length.
- beambot 5y agoCan move != Does move. All this talk, but not a single customer mention. Seems like Boston Dynamics' MO: Flashy demos, YouTube videos, great R&D, lots of PR, but light on the customer testimonials.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoThere was a big blue Yaskawa robot arm sitting in the entry hall in Google X for a while that they used to do this kind of thing with some years ago. But there was so much reshuffling it became a display piece. A lot of the engineers that worked on it were bummed it got shelved. Glad to see it is finally going somewhere, it seemed like a neat system.
- weffwe 5y agoI keep hearing "robots will take your job" for 15 years now, yet there is shortage of truck drivers in the EU... and in Germany, floor tilers without education make more money than many software engineers.
- peter303 5y agoIf itcan guarantee too break every dish in abox, then its ready for moving companies.
- Ericson2314 5y agoIf Boston Dynamic were really clever, they would discretely fund the organization of Amazon warehouse employees. A Fordism for the 21st century.
- jdblair 5y agoIn the early 90s I had a minimum wage summer job loading boxes of just manufactured aerosol cans onto pallets. The boxes were uniform and there was a prescribed stacking pattern, so that part was simple. The hard part for me was that I was not accustomed to the repetitive physical labor. I quickly learned the minimum movement required. The challenge came when the forklift operator failed to show on time. I would have to use a pallet jack to move the full pallet so I could start stacking the next (it wasn't worth the extra movement to carry the boxes to a farther pallet). There was a conveyor that could buffer about half a pallet worth of boxes. I then worked double-time to catch up. This would be a perfect application for this robot if the cost aligns. I assume as these robots come down in price these kinds of jobs will disappear.
- Ericson2314 5y agoIf the costs of the robot came down...or the wage of the worker came up.
- elihu 5y ago> “Typically, you’ll have two people unloading each truck. Where we want to get with Stretch is to have one person unloading four or five trucks at the same time, using Stretches as tools.” That sounds really stressful for that one person. Great when everything runs smoothly, but the moment something breaks down you might easily get overwhelmed, unless there are more workers on-site that can be pulled in from other tasks. Cool technology, though. Anything that reduces the necessity of people to work unpleasant jobs seems like generally a good thing.
- ryanmercer 5y ago>Cool technology, though. Anything that reduces the necessity of people to work unpleasant jobs seems like generally a good thing. The problem there though is that companies like FedEx and UPS employ a lot of college students. Historically a part time handler position, at least here in Indiana, pays 2-3x minimum wage with sort operations frequently at night allowing people to work part time and make a nice chunk of change while going to school during the day. I'd say in Indy 60% of my high school class worked as a handler for FedEx at some point in the first few years after turning 18 because of that. Sure, it's going to save a lot of wear and tear on people's bodies but when minimum wage is $7.25 and a package handler here in central Indiana will start around $18.45 part time... sometimes people are willing to bust their butts for one reason or another.