9 ms·
> Cultural norms can also encourage poverty cycles. I often wonder about these. Growing up I watched friends whose families had what you might describe as a c
by duxup 5y ago
> Cultural norms can also encourage poverty cycles.
I often wonder about these.
Growing up I watched friends whose families had what you might describe as a cultural distrust of institutions, including schools, or even anyone who seemed to “think they’re better than us” (translation anyone who did well in school or a career).
They constantly made self defeating choices and seemed destined to have the same problems/ poverty as their parents.
Their distrust of institutions like schools could maybe be justified… but they were capable people who made choices that reduced their opportunities.
As an adult I watch my local schools reach out to provide services, help of all kinds and struggle to find more than a handful of takers or folks who want to try…
By no means does that mean there are no other barriers, but even trying to address those barriers/ help, you can encounter some surprising resistance/ challenges.
- zdragnar 5y agoI was fortunate to not experience this myself, but my best friend struggled with his peers in school bullying him for "acting white" when he actually tried to do well. Fortunately for him, his dad was a firm believer in education, so he moved up out of poverty when most of his childhood friends ended up in gangs or worse.
- sh4un 5y agoPoor people are used to being victims so it's hard to trust other people. When you look at it deeper, if these are poor minorities in a white mans world, no matter what there will never be trust. Hard to trust the same people who are oppressing you. Many policy maker are born well off, so it's hard to relate. When the social workers are driving in BMW's and talking to you like you're retarded... It's ongoing. I have done a bit of outreach work in the past and it's totally wacky on so many levels.
- duxup 5y ago> When the social workers are driving in BMW's and talking to you like you're retarded... Man what social workers get BMWs?
- anamax 5y agoThere are "tourists," well-off people who "slum" as social workers or on projects. Managers can also do well. And then there are the fraudsters.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nopenopenopeno 5y agoAs it happens, My neighbor in my apartment building is literally a social worker who drives a BMW.
- bigmattystyles 5y agoI mean, it could be a 2006 318i with 200k+ miles. BMW means nothing.
- hackcasual 5y agoOr they could have generational wealth. This whole thing reminds me of the ugliness that was the anti-welfare propaganda of the 70's
- BitAstronaut 5y agoIt could also be that they prioritize their car and have a budget adjusted for it.
- tudorw 5y agothe only Lambo owner I ever met had saved since he was 14 and had nothing else but his car...
- dijit 5y agoJesus christ, even a 16yo Lambo is $100,000 (which is an unthinkable amount of money for a British person on average salary). For context my mums 2 bed house in Coventry was not much more than that, and she's still paying off that mortgage.
- ralusek 5y ago> these are poor minorities in a white mans world If we're in the reality of accepting that culture, patterns of behavior, and what thoughts are inculcated in people actually impact the outcomes they'll net in life, then I hope we can start legitimately talking about the harm that comes from attitudes like the one you've laid out. The idea that, say, a black person need not even try, because they'll just be attempting in vain in what is ultimately a white man's world...it's horseshit, and it does far more harm than good. The reality is that almost every elite institution is geared for precisely the opposite of what you're describing. For better or for worse, being a black person applying to college or a job at Google will actually be advantaged on the basis of their race. And if we acknowledge that the first step towards seeing a black person in poverty becoming a black software engineer is knowing that this is even an option for them, and that they have more than a realistic chance of achieving that goal, then maybe we'd be more cautious with the sort of oppression rhetoric we deploy.
- xwolfi 5y agoYeah it's very americano centric. In China where I emigrated, white people arent poorer than their yellow counterparts in average because immigration is done differently (no slavery, no low income, leave if you cant make it etc). The problem is more complex than color, it's just the immigration origin of the population that drive the current state. A better sentence maybe would be "to be a descendant of slaves in a world of descendants of masters", and even then would probably be unfair to people who actually wanted to end slavery and are now guilty of succeeding.
- AussieWog93 5y ago>In China where I emigrated, white people arent poorer than their yellow counterparts in average because immigration is done differently (no slavery, no low income, leave if you cant make it etc). Not saying you're wrong about white people, but I've heard some very different stories about Filipino/Indonesian maids in HK, as well as Black and Domestic Migrant labourers holding a rural hukou on the Mainland.
- wiseowise 5y ago
- inglor_cz 5y agoAs usual in the American racial discourse, this argument entirely ignores the huge gaping hole in its side that is the Asian community. Casual racism against Asians is pretty strong, not just in the US, in Europe, too. (My own country has a significant Vietnamese community and casual racism against them was absolutely shocking in the 1990s. It has since become less pronounced, but is still there.) And yet they thrive in your so-called "white mans world" and within two generations, sometimes only one generation, after arriving from formerly colonized and impoverished countries, they become MPs, ministers, professors and investors.
- refurb 5y agoIndeed. And these are communities that were banned from immigrating at one point, put in camps and their assets stolen during WW2. Clearly poverty and even oppression doesn’t explain a groups eventual standing.
- wobblybubble 5y agoIt isn’t surprising that groups like descendants of chattel slavery who have had the same legal rights as white people for about half a century are systematically worse off than groups like middle class immigrants from East Asia.
- inglor_cz 5y ago"middle class immigrants from East Asia" That is just a small part of the entire picture. Plenty of Asians arrived as low wage manual workers or refugees (boat people) from then-strongly underdeveloped countries. Sometimes as orphans or incomplete families with all male relatives killed. Or you can look at Jewish people, terrorized, oppressed and killed by their neighbours for centuries. Expressions like "pogrom" and "ghetto" come from a long, bloody history of violent antisemitism.
- dustintrex 5y agoThere are clear differences between these groups that reflect their circumstances though. Indian Americans tend to be well educated offspring of the Indian elite, and they're also the richest Asian-American subgroup. Hmong, Laotians and Vietnamese mostly descend from penniless refugees, and surprise surprise, they're at the bottom of the income table. Working your way from nothing to owning a nail salon or a donut shop is an achievement, but in financial terms it pales compared to the income of the IIT grad Brahmin who did their master's at Stanford and went on to work at Microsoft.
- fhe 5y agoHave you seen people manage to breakout from the poverty cycle? I have lived long enough to actually see a handful of people doing just that, and I often wondered what made them different. One trait I often observed is risk-taking. The ones that broke free from their upbringing always seemed to have high tolerance for risks. So maybe it's simply statistics -- if you have a group of people taking a lot of risks, some of them are bound to end up doing well (with a comparable subset end up doing worse).
- double_nan 5y agoRisking is one option, but there is another one: the breaking might take more than one generation an that is something which is often overlooked by the modern discourse. Every next generation might end up a bit better off and on the timespan of 50 years the poverty cycle will be broken.
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y agoI remember reading something about this, apparently it’s takes about five generations to escape poverty and about three generations to dissipate family wealth. I don’t know how to check the robustness of these figures, sounds a bit headliny, maybe sounds approximately sensible at first glance. Probably something in it.
- saiya-jin 5y agoI can confirm this - I moved twice within Europe, once after a year of working (software dev), and then after 5 more years. First time I went financially to 0 at the time first salary came, not a nice feeling. I don't have anybody rich in family, rather poor university educated parents (the beauty of communism and some time afterwards - when you are highly skilled engineer, hardworking and manage 200+ people you may get half the salary of some common agriculture worker or trench digger; or when being head of economic departments of 3 high schools combined you deserve even less). I had to adapt 'fuck it' mentality to make this step, otherwise the risks were too high. With kids for example this wouldn't be possible, parents generally move to very risk-averse mindset. Second move didn't ruin me completely since I've saved up a little, but I had running mortgage which was eating my savings constantly. Plus I've moved to Switzerland and started looking for work - even when living on tuna cans and pasta in flatshare my expenses skyrocketed. Going through this for 2.5 months with very real option of failing and coming back and trying to not lose the mortgage takes some nerves. Again, 'fuck it' mentality helped, this time hardened with 6 months of backpacking in India and Nepal. In both cases, I've had plenty of folks who were dissuading me from the moves (its hard to find job, more competition, foreign country and language etc. - all true at that time). None I know made similar move to mine. Many of those were talking about it, trying to find some super convenient way through it, asking me after move if I can find some work for them. When I explained to them its not an easy feat and they probably have to move beforehand they ignored the advice. Needless to say all remained where they live. When comparing my first 100% software dev salary ever and the first after second move, my net income jumped 20x. I was extremely lucky when picking up my university studies to go for software development - it was not popular, we were unattractive geeks to girls, the salaries at least at home sucked and not too much work. What I want to say with all this - its possible to move out of poverty, but one needs luck (at least with timing of actions), some tungsten balls help, and the less responsibility one has the easier the choices and hardships are. Generally its worth taking risks, but one has to know when to push hard and when rather accept losses and retreat.
- algo646464 5y agoI sometimes think, one way to break this cycle is to send the all the kids to boarding school or military school. It could put them in an environment free from their background circumstances. It is of course a harsh thing to do, but I think maybe it could work.
- dustintrex 5y ago"Breaking the cycle by sending the kids away" has a long history of well-intentioned attempts nearly always leading to disastrous outcomes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stolen_Generations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stolen_Generations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Indian_residential_school_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Indian_residential_sc... https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-55238090 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-55238090 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kidnapping_of_children_by_Nazi_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kidnapping_of_children_by_Nazi...
- algo646464 5y agoThat is a good point. But all these had racist reasons at their core. Can this be better implemented today? With extensive supervision and scrutiny. For example, teenagers routinely join the army, and spend time learning and training at what is essentially a boarding school. It seems to work quite well.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoI'm not sure replacing racism with classism (oh, you are poor, you need to go away to school) is much better. Extensive supervision and scrutiny? I mean, are we not doing some of this with public schools now? And if not, why not? And seriously, we (in the US) allow lots of options for troubled kids without supervision ("work the bad out of you), we've allowed conversion therapy for LGBT+ children, have little oversight on for-profit schools and we allow folks to force their religion on their children, even if the 16- or 17-year-old doesn't believe. I highly doubt there would be oversight. I'd also like to point out that the Canadian schools were really, really recent, and I don't think much has changed since.
- anovikov 5y agoIsn't it the trick in every social class? Society is built in a way that tries to prevent members of each social class from moving up, and that goes from lowest to highest classes alike. Poor people are taught to distrust everything and everyone, and to think strictly short-term because nothing you can't hold in your hands here and now can be trusted to be real, this prevents them from moving to the middle class. Middle class people are taught to get a most expensive degree (sinking them forever in debt) and get a stable job with benefits, and buy a house, which all prevents them from making good money by getting an inexpensive degree in area they like, and/or contracting and making top $, and investing into the stock market. Upper class people are taught to be gentlemen and do the respectable things expected from one: follow their parents' role in the company, or do civil or military service, or do other bullshit, which prevents them from becoming the like of Elon Musk and moving even further up. Poor are not alone: beliefs and cultural norms of all classes alike are built to prevent people from succeeding just because doing otherwise would result in too much of a dog-eat-dog society. Trick is to learn to ignore norms of your class and follow your own way.
- mrjin 5y agoIMO it has not much to do with how every social class are taught but rather the Mathew effect. Put aside those exceptionally smart or dumb ones, most people are more to less with the same capabilities and the class they were born to almost define who they will become. The reason is simple: upper class have maybe 10 times the resource a middle class have and in turn a middle class may have 10 times the resource a poor people have. So the upper class can easily have enough resource to develop themselves, and provision for the risks and still have lots to invest. For middle class, they have enough to develop themselves, a little bit surplus to insure themselves and/or to invest. For the poor people, what they have is barely enough to make ends meet, little or none for personal development or invest. So if everything goes well, the upper classes can get decent investment returns even if they do nothing actively. For the middle classes, it's not too bad, they can still get a piece of the cake, though not much. For poor people, they might be able to save a couple of bucks but nothing much. If things go side ways, the cut of the cake for the upper class at worst is slightly smaller as they are impacted but as there are already provisions for that so they don't really lose much. Sometimes their portfolios actually grows a lot because central banks print lots of money and the inflation skyrockets. For the middle class it really depends on how lucky they are. Lucky ones' asset grows, average ones are not impacted or lose little bit. If they made wrong decisions, they might become poor people. For the poor people, the best case would be their savings eaten by inflations. If other bad things happen, they might become homeless. Just take a look at statistics around the world, almost exactly the same story.
- innocentoldguy 5y agoThat was sort of my experience. I grew up in poverty and stayed in poverty until I was almost 25 years old because I didn't know any better. My parents didn't distrust institutions. Instead, they mocked things they couldn't afford, so I grew up thinking college was a "stupid waste of time and money" and unimportant. For me, the things that broke me out of my family's cycle of poverty were a public library, a love of reading, and a determination to learn a valuable skill that people would be willing to pay me for. I read everything from medical journals to books on auto mechanics to baking. I was willing to do anything to make more than the $5.85 an hour I was, at the time, raising my family on. Eventually, I picked up a copy of "Sam's Teach Yourself C Programming," which was weird, since I didn't know what C was and didn't own a computer. But, for some reason, the book clicked. I kept reading and studying programming books from the library and eventually got my first programming job with Intel. In my case, the public library was the key to breaking the poverty cycle, not just for me, but for my children as well. I eventually got a college degree in my early 40s and graduated with a 4.0 GPA. I don't think I could have done that in my 20s though, due to the way I was raised. I had to get there via another route; the public library. Because of the benefit they've been to my life, I love public libraries and recommend them to anybody wanting to improve their current situation. I'm sure there are other resources available too. That's just the one that worked for me.
- fallingknife 5y agoCollege is a stupid waste of time and money. Unfortunately, it's usually not unimportant.
- innocentoldguy 5y agoWithout college, I wouldn’t know anything about rococo though. Ah, wait! I see your point!
- SamPatt 5y agoGreat story. Congrats on good choices.
- vpilcx 5y agoI'm one of those people living in poverty that distrusts school institutions. My main philosophical gripe is that it doesn't seem to really matter what your major is. "Oh, you got a bachelors in Biology? Well, I guess that's fine. Come work at my tech company in a way that is completely unrelated to Biology." In this particular situation, it seems like the only purpose of college is to create arbitrary classist hurdles for poor people to jump through. Now, obviously, that's not the case with all education, but my next gripe with it is the seemingly insurmountable debt that said education brings. Literally, all of my friends that have gone to college are no where near paying their debt off and I'm in my late 30s. Finally, that in of itself, ya know, maybe that's like the licks you gotta take when you're trying to rise up in the world, but the fact that educational debt in America can never be voided through bankruptcy seems like a conscious systemic decision to create debt slaves. And, while my parents, have been relatively ambivalent about education, almost everyone else in my family has gone out of their way to emphasize the importance of education. I just can't get over the previously mentioned hurdles.
- beebmam 5y agoI'm seeing a lot of anecdotal evidence you're using to justify your biases. This isn't an attack on you; I think you would have a tremendous amount to gain from a science education. Please consider it for the future of you and your family.
- vpilcx 5y agoIt's anecdotal evidence because I was responding to an anecdote someone else was giving with my own personal perspective.
- randomdata 5y agoGoing beyond anecdotes, the data is clear that there is no economic benefit. Wages are stagnant and job quality is in decline alongside the rise of post-secondary attainment. While there is no doubt an entertainment benefit to be gained, that is not likely the best choice for someone without the means to take on nearly a million dollars of opportunity cost.
- 5y ago
- candiodari 5y agoI don't get this attitude. Sounds pretty great, these institutions you talk about! What happens to children these institutions care for 100%? Oh wait ... https://www.kansascity.com/news/special-reports/article238206754.html https://www.kansascity.com/news/special-reports/article23820... You're assuming blanket good intentions on part of institutions and schools. Does it really need to be said this is exceptional, rather than the norm? Here is a study that quantitatively compares really bad home situations to many forms of institutional care. https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.97.5.1583 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.97.5.1583 Here is a study that correlates the "help" given by institutions like schools with betterment or worsening of symptoms. And again, we see: beyond giving information to children ALL institutional help is worse than no help at all. So I wonder how you justify these good intentions? More institutional involvement makes lives of children worse, not better. (And yes, I get it, some problems evolve in dramatic fashion, and tend to worsen, such as anorexia. However, again, no institutional help has better outcomes. It's just no help results in a slowly worsening situation, institutional help results in a fast, dramatic worsening of the situation). Therefore, I question why you criticize children and parents for refusing help. For the large majority of help provided this is the best choice for the child. Do people overreact? Yes, absolutely. Especially CPS is famous for "one wrong move, one second of trusting the wrong social worker, locked up for years" situations. It's almost funny, but these institutions are a recurring theme IN HORROR MOVIES. I realize it's only one aspect of the problem you're identifying, but institutions, especially schools, really aren't good for children. Otherwise we'd see a lot of effort preventing this situation (and therefore a lot of tolerance for suboptimal home situations). Yet we see the reverse: defunding institutional care, defunding actual help, taking away information (talking with any social worker as a child can result in getting locked up for up to 27 years in New York, yes, really), fund 1000 new efforts for getting more kids into institutional care, because the kids never want to, not even when they are deep in abusive situations, and force everyone and everything to "report" kids for institutional care. I recently found an article that hairdressers are to watch for signs of child abuse. Obviously that article never once mentioned just how bad the institutional alternative to "child abuse" situations is. The arguments are that it's about "justice" (the many suggestions for punishing families, by "helping" the children (because criminal law makes touching the parents very hard) for example, for not vaccinating. Or for "disturbances". Or ...). Systematically we see the effects of this: youth crime is dropping like a stone. Crimes against children are dropping like a stone. And ever more kids are forced into institutional care. Schools are a big part of that. > As an adult I watch my local schools reach out to provide services, help of all kinds and struggle to find more than a handful of takers or folks who want to try… As illustrated above, most social help programs at school are meant to trap kids and force them into institutional care. And if 1 school program has this intention, nobody will trust other efforts. Besides, I don't get this attitude. In low primary school, perhaps this is true. But starting at something like 2nd-3rd grade the teachers, in my experience, are not sufficiently competent to effectively help children learn. And there's too many kids in a class to do it even if you do have the odd teacher that really does make a difference. At home, kids can be taught by parents, and by a great many people on the internet. Pedagogical studies have always shown that parental teaching produces far better results (to the tune that some studies claim 1h of teaching by parents is roughly equivalent to ~14h of school, or 1h daily work by a parent makes kids advance far faster than in school). And, essentially all parents aren't incompetent and really care about their children. And yes, there are bad and abusive parents. You know what is MUCH more common? Bad and abusive teachers (look up how many gym teachers are convicted for sexual assault yearly ...). Bad and abusive classmates is more common still (one UN study claimed 70% of kids have been victims of violence from classmates, done under teacher supervision. And whilst I'm not claiming teachers often cause or supervise violence, they are still failing to care for these children). And yet ... never is anything done about those teachers or schools.
- causi 5y agoThat's a harsh truth that's easily ignored, especially by people who didn't grow up in diverse communities. During my education the "behavioral bell curve" for each culture was clearly not centered in the same place. One population had a lot less free time at home than the rest of us, and their grades and eventual careers reflected that. Another population made up a majority of the disruptive pupils who didn't seem to care all that much about their performance. A third was far less driven than the first but much better behaved than the second. The trajectories of these populations largely reflected the manner in which they were raised. To be clear, there was nothing inherently superior or inferior about any of these kids. All the populations had outliers in both directions. That's also not to say the academically maladapted nature of some cultures are exclusively or even primarily the fault of those cultures. I do, however, believe the continued determination to not address these disadvantages represents a failure on the part of educators just as surely as a refusal to address visually-impaired students would be a failure.