5 ms·
"I do not understand why articles like these consistently score poorly on HN?" Because the article pisses me off. This is not something helpful to us average p
by giantg2 5y ago
"I do not understand why articles like these consistently score poorly on HN?"
Because the article pisses me off. This is not something helpful to us average peasants. No shit you can become a multimillionaire if you're pulling in over half a million per year. Maybe some of the advice I'd good, but it would be worth more coming from someone who actually is average so we can see it as evidence. Otherwise it's some rich person telling us what works based on their theory and an experience that's nothing like our's.
- AYBABTME 5y agoThe average joe who'd write this blogpost wouldn't be an average joe anymore. The reality is that most of us in tech can aspire to the author's outcome, with high probability of success. The odds are stacked in our favor. If we're willing to do the moves and do the "sacrifices", most of us can pull it off. But in the end you need the right attitude, and some advice about good strategies, like the author is giving out. I think the cynical perspective is entirely exaggerated in the software industry. It's also an awful way to look at things, almost guaranteeing a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- giantg2 5y ago"The reality is that most of us in tech can aspire to the author's outcome, with high probability of success." This simply isn't true. Most people cannot retire after 12 years of working, even in tech. The median software dev salary in the US is about $105k. You cannot reasonably earn $2.4M when you make about half of that during those 12 years.
- AYBABTME 5y agoIt's not hard to move up the quantiles if you put the effort. It doesn't require ivy league education, a rich family, or a particularly genius mind. The mean salary is useless in quantifying wether you, as an individual, have any agency in influencing your outcome. Your attitude toward it, however, has a lot to do with it. And surely starting with the assumption that it's impossible doesn't put the odds in your favor. In any case, 105k median income just goes to tell how big the opportunity is.
- giantg2 5y ago"It's not hard to move up the quantiles if you put the effort." The statistics paint a different picture - there are only so many jobs above the median. "In any case, 105k median income just goes to tell how big the opportunity is." You mean limited? Clearly this is multiples lower than the author. "The mean salary is useless in quantifying wether you, as an individual, have any agency in influencing your outcome." No, not really. It allows you to set realistic expectations and understand the job market.
- AYBABTME 5y agoI'm not going to change your mood but I hope someone else reading this interaction early in their career will come out of it with an optimistic mindset instead of a cynical one. It pays off better.
- lordnacho 5y agoKeep in mind you can be disappointed in more than one way. Either you tried the impossible with an optimistic mindset and failed anyway, or you failed at something doable because you took pessimistic choices. It's not actually obvious which category this is in.
- gxespino 5y agoYes, but the optimistic mindset would probably have a better outcome than the latter regardless if they failed to meet their original expectations or not.
- dan-robertson 5y agoThe implication of the article, that such compensation is reasonably possible to a moderately competent software developer working for big companies in the United States, seems pretty reasonable to me. Another thing one could note is the bump in compensation in recent years, which could be a combination of stock going up, more experience making the author a more valuable employee, or market rates for software engineers at large software companies have gone up. None of the numbers strike me as particularly unusual for the author’s circumstances, so if they strike you as unusual (and you are able to work in the US), then it might be worth considering trying to get yourself into similar employment, if that’s what you’d want. If you can’t work in the US, things are different and potentially a lot worse, but the other thing the OP states is that a professional on a more modest income ought to be able to do well making sensible investments[1] and cutting costs. I think that’s true in basically any developed country. You claim that the author’s route was not average, but I think it probably was reasonably average for a software engineer working at large US tech companies in NYC/SF/Silicon Valley. The less average thing is perhaps saving lots of money, making reasonable investments, and not having a load of expensive kids. [1] e.g. 60% of the increase in net worth between 2020 and 2021 comes from investments rather than the ‘earning half a million dollars a year’ and those investments came from earning less than that (obviously such incomes still generally aren’t available to people who aren’t software engineers at big US tech companies, and it may be reasonable to complain that a path that >100k people follow is unreasonable but within this path I think it’s pretty reasonable).
- giantg2 5y ago"I learnt that even an average engineer with a five-figure salary can become a millionaire by her late 30s, through financial discipline and investment planning." Then why doe the article mention average as part of the target audience? "The implication of the article, that such compensation is reasonably possible to a moderately competent software developer working for big companies in the United States, seems pretty reasonable to me." I'm moderately compentent and work for a large company. Why do I make under $100k? It seems your perspective might be skewed as it is not common, as evidenced by the median dev salary of about $105k. "None of the numbers strike me as particularly unusual for the author’s circumstances, so if they strike you as unusual (and you are able to work in the US), then it might be worth considering trying to get yourself into similar employment, if that’s what you’d want." Again, I think there's a drastic perception issue here. These number are by definition unusual or rare given the median. It's simply not possible for an average person like me to make that kind of money. "60% of the increase in net worth between 2020 and 2021 comes from investments rather than the ‘earning half a million dollars a year’ and those investments came from earning less than that (obviously such incomes still generally aren’t available to people who aren’t software engineers at big US tech companies, and it may be reasonable to complain that a path that >100k people follow is unreasonable but within this path I think it’s pretty reasonable)." And again, the majority of the US devs fall at or below the median, putting them right around or under that $100k number. So yeah, use "normal" people get a little pissed off with people telling us that it's not unusual to be making multiple times our salaries and we could easily achieve this too if only we were "moderately competent".