5 ms·
There are many milestones and at each one there are going to be people saying “but it’s not …” without really adding any information. What we have now that we
by colechristensen 5y ago
There are many milestones and at each one there are going to be people saying “but it’s not …” without really adding any information.
What we have now that we didn’t have before is the ability to draw a line around an area inside a test reactor and say we can, for very brief periods, get more energy exiting that area than enters it. This is major progress.
It isn’t a self-powered plant, it isn’t a plant that can sell power at any price, it isn’t a plant that is economically viable, and none of that is important to point out.
We have a baby taking its first steps being criticized for not running a marathon.
- chii 5y agonot if the parents of the baby keeps saying that the baby could be walking any minute now, for the past 50 years. it's likely that this will take another 50 years to reach the success level. Pushing too optimistically a story to the public might make them feel that it's closer than it really is, and possibly modify public policies that would otherwise not have been modified.
- denton-scratch 5y ago> it's likely that this will take another 50 years to reach the success level. There's another technology that's been hyped relentlessly for 50 years, and is always "just around the corner": general AI. Call me when you think you can build a reactor that can contribute power to the grid AND make a profit for the operators. I won't be holding my breath.
- DantesKite 5y agoWould you say we're at the "transistor" stage of nuclear fusion production?
- gogoincar 5y agoI’m not quite sure what the analogy you’re considering is, but if we’re equating fusion power plants to transistor-based circuits, I think we’re currently proving different types of solid state diodes are possible to create in a lab.
- colechristensen 5y agoI suppose you could make a timeline of technology development, fusion is still in the lab stage but past the conceptual and experimental stages and into the early making it practical stage with several approaches competing for first to actually achieve something useful. What’s left isn’t just straightforward work, but a lot of finding and fixing inefficiencies and that sort of work.
- pfdietz 5y agoNo, because transistors were clearly going to be useful. Fusion (especially DT fusion) has a good chance of never being useful (except for H-bombs). These comparisons with old embryonic technologies also miss the point that lots of embryonic technologies never go on to success. Focusing on the rare ones that did is survivor bias.
- vinceguidry 5y agoBabies grow into humans which are clearly capable of running marathons. This science has no such birthright and may eventually prove to be truly unfeasible.
- ncmncm 5y agoIndeed, this is no baby, but a random blob of cells. Two things we can be certain of: 1. No economically viable hot-neutron Tokamak fusion plant will ever be built; 2. Every cent wasted on this, instead of being spent on building out solar, wind, and storage, brings climate catastrophe incrementally closer. It is just barely possible that something learned while fooling with this stuff will turn out to be helpful for making a practical non-Tokamak fusion system for spacecraft propulsion. The plasma fluid-dynamics physicists employed on these massive boondoggles are who would make that. But the longer they bumble about with this, the longer it will be until they can get started on that.
- Joeri 5y agoEvery cent wasted on this, instead of being spent on building out solar, wind, and storage, brings climate catastrophe incrementally closer. But in the real world the money going into this is on top of that going into solar / wind / … and not instead of. The nature of the climate crisis is such that we need to stop debating which things to do and just do all the things unless we genuinely run into limits of what we can spend, which we are nowhere near reaching.
- ncmncm 5y agoWe need to spend the money on things that will help, and take away the money from things which are not helping. Those latter things include weapons, internal-combustion vehicles, Portland cement, and Tokamak fusion projects.
- dredmorbius 5y agoFusion research spending is de minimis. For the past decade, total US spending has been at or below $600 million/year, or 0.003% of total US GDP. Even with my low expectations of success or viability, the research itself is worth pursuing. US spending is a large fraction of global fusion spending, and though I don't have an aggregate total, it is also in all likelihood too small to matter. http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2021/ph241/margraf1/ http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2021/ph241/margraf1/ There are vastly larger areas of expenditure that are far more harmful to achieving a sustainable, renewable, carbon-neutral energypath. Pressent fossil-fuel based infrastructure and exploration is among the leading candidates. You should be focusing your ire there, or other similarly significant areas.
- worldsayshi 5y agoI feel that people want to point out just how much more work remains because it can potentially be one of those wishful thinking-blockers for climate action. Fusion power will continue to be high on our agenda and it should but it should never be seen as a solution for climate change because that is wishful thinking. Fixing climate change has a much tighter timescale than we can expect for fusion power.
- endymi0n 5y agoBoth can be true at the same time. None of us should _count_ on nuclear fusion being available as an energy source until at least the very first critical demo reactor _that actually generates useful electrical energy_, and we as a society need to move on as if it wasn't happening. That being said, my mind was stuck in Animat's state as well for a long time, mainly because of neutron flux. Neutrons were the ultimate end boss at the end of the goal by laughing at your fusion progress and just destroying every containment that comes their way. What excites me these days are modern contenders like HB11 Energy and Helion Fusion jumping directly to aneutronic fusion. This is the stuff most physicists didn't dare to dream of as of late, mostly because they weren't even close to sustaining the simplest D-T reactions for long, and aneutronic fusion takes even considerately hotter and denser plasmas — as well as being plagued by fuel availability concerns (HE3). But it's something that's within reach due to massive advances in ultra-short laser technology, coil breakthroughs and some other clever hacks like breeding HE3 on site. That, combined with the other advance of direct electrical harvest instead of thermic conversion puts fusion into territories of believable reach for the first time in my mind. After decades of disappointedly following the status quo, I'm getting seriously excited.
- colechristensen 5y agoThat’s the definition of a straw man argument. Is anyone actually saying “let’s not do anything and keep pumping carbon into the atmosphere because fusion is almost here!” ? I mean I’m sure you can find someone saying it (like anything) but there’s no reason to argue against an imaginary opposing viewpoint which isn’t being expressed. What’s actually happening is people like to argue against things because naysaying is fun and people genuinely don’t really have a solid concept of what progress is being made and what progress is still needed, but go on with their vague impressions and defend their ideas anyway (and often against imaginary opponents).
- d0mine 5y agoThe "baby" is making its first steps for literal decades now. It is old enough for its own children, grandchildren, and perhaps even great-grandchildren. It always "success just around the corner." Skepticism is warranted.
- Grismar 5y agoWe have something that might be a baby taking its first steps. It might also be a weird freak that won't live past its first few years, dying of some painful deformity. Time will tell - I'm hoping for baby, but won't be surprised by circus freak.