8 ms·
It's forward progress, but nowhere near being useful. By "more energy out than they put in", they mean passing "theoretical breakeven", generating more energy
by Animats 5y ago
It's forward progress, but nowhere near being useful.
By "more energy out than they put in", they mean passing "theoretical breakeven", generating more energy as heat than they put in as electricity. Not converting that energy back to electricity and making the thing self-powered. Brief periods of theoretical breakeven have been achieved before.
Ahead lies "sustained theoretical breakeven" - the thing can be kept running for a while. So far, other tokomak experiments have achieved 70 seconds of plasma containment (Korea) and 120 seconds (China). That's below ignition temperature, though. Then "self-sustaining breakeven" - the thing can power itself. Then, someday, "economic break-even" - it can pay for itself. Then, maybe, useful power generation.
There's the problem of getting the energy out in some useful form. This begins with the "first wall" problem of finding something that can survive the conditions just outside the magnetic field. Those conditions include huge numbers of neutrons, which tend to split atoms in the first wall material and cause unwanted transmutation. This causes radiation embrittlement, which is not good for materials.
It's going to be a long haul.
- danuker 5y ago> and cause unwanted transmutation This is a syntagm I did not expect reading on Hacker News in a comment about technology, but about a roleplaying game.
- david_draco 5y agoSabine Hossenfelder essentially called the nuclear fusion PR a fraud, because they do not report true (full-system) efficiencies. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJ4W1g-6JiY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJ4W1g-6JiY
- mlindner 5y agoShe also overstated things and made things out to be worse than they actually are. Getting to fusion plasma power breakeven IS the hardest part. And it's always been so far away, setting and talking about realistic goals is better than trying to immediately jump to the far end goal. This is the difference between ITER and projects like SPARC though, they both plan to get fusion plasma power breakeven, but ITER's design has zero hope of ever being economical.
- pfdietz 5y ago> Getting to fusion plasma power breakeven IS the hardest part. I believe the engineering after that is harder, and likely intractable.
- tsimionescu 5y agoExtracting useful energy from the plasma, and protecting the reactor (magnets, control etc) from neutron bombardment are also hugely difficult problems. Not to mention, trying to fool public opinion about how far away we are from any chance of a fusion power plant is still ethically wrong. Let's not forget that even if ITER achieves all of its goals and milestones, we will be able to start on the power extraction problem in 2030. And let's also not forget that inertial confinement fusion, while also being presented as a potential fusion power plant concept, with great fanfare occasionally, is simply a weapons research program with no imaginable way of progressing to economical power generation.
- gulikoza 5y agoHow about space propulsion? Maybe I'm naive, but inertial confinement fusion seems like a great candidate for a space engine.
- dflock 5y agoIf you have the gigawatts of electricity required to run the inertial fusion lasers, there are probably better ways to use that power to get around. Massive ion engines, or powering the pumps for a nuclear salt water engine, maybe, depending on how exciting you want your ride to be.
- tsimionescu 5y agoInertial containment fusion relies on firing a laser at an extremely precisely machined piece of heavy metal (called a hohlraum), heating it until it emits X-Rays, and using the X-Rays to create 2 implosion shockwaves in a tiny pellet of tritium + deuterium that have to meet in the dead center, so that where they meet they can start a fusion reaction, and ideally have the fusion reaction consume the whole pellet before the shockwaves dissipate enough to stop confining the plasma. A few microseconds after the laser blast, you get a puff of helium (+hydrogen if the reaction wasn't complete) and a mangled piece of metal, and some heat that in principle you could capture somehow, though no one has yet tried. Then, you throw away the now useless hohlraum, get a new one and a new pellet and you fire again for another little burst of energy, over and over. The hohlraum is the biggest problem here: the level of precision needed to achieve the exact geometry inside the pellet to actually ignite a plasma means that every hohlraum is (a) extraordinarily expensive (currently in the millions of dollars range), and (b) entirely useless after a single shot - while continuous operation for a 1500 MW plant is estimated to require ~20 hohlraums/second). For a spaceship design, this would mean that your engine would have to include a smelter and high-precision machining bay to constantly create new micrometer-smooth hohlraums from spent ones. Not even close to a promising technology.
- mlindner 5y agoIANANS (I Am Not A Nuclear Scientist) > Brief periods of theoretical breakeven have been achieved before. Source? I'm not aware of any reactor that has done that. > Ahead lies "sustained theoretical breakeven" - the thing can be kept running for a while. So far, other tokomak experiments have achieved 70 seconds of plasma containment (Korea) and 120 seconds (China). That's below ignition temperature, though. Ignition temperature is not set just by the time you run it. The larger you go the longer you need to run before you can get to ignition. ITER will need something like 1000 seconds, but SPARC will only need 10. > Then, someday, "economic break-even" - it can pay for itself. For ITER-like designs that's impossible because the massive manufacturing cost. > This begins with the "first wall" problem of finding something that can survive the conditions just outside the magnetic field. Those conditions include huge numbers of neutrons, which tend to split atoms in the first wall material and cause unwanted transmutation. This causes radiation embrittlement, which is not good for materials. Radiation embrittlement is only a problem for certain types of materials. Some material types do not absorb neutrons at fusion energies and simply pass them through. This is a complex materials problems and you can't just use steel but there's already many designs that people are experienced with for this and it's well known because of the history of fision energy research with neutrons.
- pfdietz 5y agoAll materials have problems with fusion neutrons. The neutrons from DT fusion are sufficiently energetic to cause (n,alpha) and (n,p) reactions, causing hydrogen and helium gas to accumulate. Helium in particular is a problem, because it collects into tiny very high pressure bubbles that rip the material apart from the inside. Simple elastic scattering of neutrons off the atoms cause them to scatter many atomic diameters in the material, scrambling its crystalline structure. There are also just a few elements that do not produce unacceptably long lived radioisotopes under fusion neutron bombardment. This greatly limits the choice of elements from which to make the reactor structure. Right now, the best choice is RAFM steel, but it has a number of serious drawbacks.
- mlindner 5y agoLate response, hopefully you see the comment, but you seem to be assuming a solid material. If the material is a liquid, why are hydrogen and helium gas a problem?
- maccam94 5y agoCommonwealth Fusion Systems plans to hit Q>10 net energy gain in their SPARC reactor in 2025, and then turn on a continuously operating ARC power plant around 2030. They plan to use a steel vacuum chamber which will need annual replacement. The rest of the ARC reactor will be shielded by a FLiBe molten salt blanket which will absorb neutrons and convert their energy into heat.
- pfdietz 5y agoA reminder again about this: The ARC reactor described in the 2014 arxiv paper uses a lot of beryllium. To provide the 18 TW of primary energy used by the current world economy with these reactors would require 10 million tonnes of Be. The annual mine production of Be is just ~200 tonnes, and the global estimated (by USGS) Be resource (not reserve) is 100,000 tonnes. The gross fusion power density of ARC from that paper is 0.5 MW/m^3, vs. 20 MW/m^3 for the fission power density of a PWR reactor vessel. ARC is going to be a much more complex and expensive way to boil water than a fission reactor.
- kingcharles 5y agoMy only counterargument would be that a lot of technology starts out requiring some rare or expensive element to function, but through improvement is later able to transition to some less exotic replacement.
- DennisP 5y agoIn this case, lead would be more difficult but would still do the basic job of multiplying fusion neutrons. Last I saw, General Fusion was planning to use lead.
- pfdietz 5y agoLead (or lithium lead) would not work for ARC, because it is electrically conductive. It would not be possible to pump it in the strong magnetic field because of the back EMF generated. This is also why PbLi with vanadium structures was abandoned for DEMO: it proved impossible to make an insulating coating for the metal structures that would prevent the induced currents from flowing. Even slight cracks in the coating were found to be ruinous.
- colechristensen 5y agoThere are many milestones and at each one there are going to be people saying “but it’s not …” without really adding any information. What we have now that we didn’t have before is the ability to draw a line around an area inside a test reactor and say we can, for very brief periods, get more energy exiting that area than enters it. This is major progress. It isn’t a self-powered plant, it isn’t a plant that can sell power at any price, it isn’t a plant that is economically viable, and none of that is important to point out. We have a baby taking its first steps being criticized for not running a marathon.
- chii 5y agonot if the parents of the baby keeps saying that the baby could be walking any minute now, for the past 50 years. it's likely that this will take another 50 years to reach the success level. Pushing too optimistically a story to the public might make them feel that it's closer than it really is, and possibly modify public policies that would otherwise not have been modified.
- denton-scratch 5y ago> it's likely that this will take another 50 years to reach the success level. There's another technology that's been hyped relentlessly for 50 years, and is always "just around the corner": general AI. Call me when you think you can build a reactor that can contribute power to the grid AND make a profit for the operators. I won't be holding my breath.
- DantesKite 5y agoWould you say we're at the "transistor" stage of nuclear fusion production?
- gogoincar 5y agoI’m not quite sure what the analogy you’re considering is, but if we’re equating fusion power plants to transistor-based circuits, I think we’re currently proving different types of solid state diodes are possible to create in a lab.
- bobsmooth 5y agoGeneral Fusion is trying a crazy approach of using liquid metal as both the containment vessel and the means to capture the heat. Magnetic containment isn't the only path to fusion being tried.
- tim333 5y agoThere's maybe "Helion has a clear path to net electricity by 2024, and has a long-term goal of delivering electricity for 1 cent per kilowatt-hour. (!)" - Sam Altman.
- pfdietz 5y agohttps://vixra.org/pdf/1812.0382v1.pdf https://vixra.org/pdf/1812.0382v1.pdf "The Helion Fusion Engine will enable profitable fusion energy in 2019,” from NBF 7/18/2014. “If our physics holds, we hope to reach that goal (net energy gain) in the next three years,” D. Kirtley, CEO of Helion, told The Wall Street Journal in 2014. “Helion will demonstrate net energy gain within 24 months, and 50-MWe pilot plant by 2019,” from NBF 8/18/2015. “Helion will attain net energy output within a couple of years and commercial power in 6 years,” Science News 1/27/2016. “Helion plans to reach breakeven energy generation in less than three years, nearly ten times faster than ITER,” from NBF 10/1/2018. ---- Having quoted that, I consider Helion a less unlikely bet than the DT fusion approaches.