5 ms·
Human geneticists curb use of the term ‘race’ in their papers
- kenneth 5y ago
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoMaybe that leveling is itself justice.
- dendriti 5y agoWhat science in particular is not getting done now, due to the replacement of the term race in scientific papers? Be specific. You seem deeply passionate about this issue, so I'm sure you have plenty of examples.
- twofornone 5y agoAny sort of science which may suggest differences among ethnic groups, regardless of how useful it may be to study those differences.
- joebiden2024 5y agoWhich difference are you alleging that isn't being talked about?
- ibeckermayer 5y agoIt’s a nonsense standard to demand “examples” of science not being done, which would be impossible to know precisely, and OP didn’t even claim specifically. The point is that our prominent scientific institutions are occupying themselves with nonsense woke red herrings. That constitutes a corruption of their telos (rigorous pursuit of the rational truth) in principle and the consequences are predictable, “examples” are beside the point.
- femiagbabiaka 5y agodid you read the article?
- nradov 5y agoIs this change in scientific language really a matter of political correctness? It seems more like an attempt to increase precision.
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoHow is this making science worse? It is replacing an objectively broad and misleading word with more precise language.
- userbinator 5y agowhile countries like China overtake us. It makes one wonder who is really behind this movement. That said, it seems to come from only one direction of the political spectrum, so it's not like there isn't any opposition.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- joebiden2024 5y agoWhat information does "race" tell us that "ethnicity" and "ancestry" does not? Does saying something is of Ghanian or Inuit origin less informative than saying they're black or native-American?
- Maursault 5y agoIt has nothing to do with political correctness or wokitude, science bra. There's simply no genetic basis for "race." All humans today have 99.9% identical DNA, with an extraordinary lack of genetic variation compared to that in other species. There is no person on the planet that is a further relation to you than about 37th cousin. Ever seen race used for differentiation in other animal? Race is a recent invention, essentially nothing more than folklore, to be generous, and not a product of scientific research or discovery. The concept of race has it origins in the context of African slavery. So from it's inception, the concept of race was always racist invention.
- aaronbrethorst 5y agoPlus race is malleable, and the definition of ‘whiteness’ has shifted over time. https://www.newyorker.com/news/postscript/noel-ignatievs-long-fight-against-whiteness/amp https://www.newyorker.com/news/postscript/noel-ignatievs-lon...
- akomtu 5y ago"...those scientists who objected the dogma have been sent to a reeducation facility in Alaska."
- bytelines 5y agohttps://archive.ph/2EhuB https://archive.ph/2EhuB
- jevoten 5y agoIs this effort shared by, for example, Chinese and Russian geneticists, or is it purely a Western endeavor? Edit: It seems my suspicion was correct, and at least Chinese anthropology does not share the Western aversion to 'race': https://lesacreduprintemps19.files.wordpress.com/2011/07/on-the-concept-of-race-in-chinese-biological-anthropology-alive-and-well.pdf https://lesacreduprintemps19.files.wordpress.com/2011/07/on-...
- polski-g 5y agoThe latter. The problem with this line of thinking is that race is a genetic term. Crime investigators can determine race from a blood droplet. NHS has a monthly begging campaign for "black blood" donations. And the biggest thing is that race corresponds to generic ancestry with 99.86% accuracy: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1196372/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1196372/
- rectang 5y ago> Crime investigators can determine race from a blood droplet. Such as determining that a person who is ~75% "white" and ~25% "black" is in fact, "black"? If "race" is a "genetic term" it is certainly not only a "genetic term".
- Aeolun 5y agoIn other words, it corresponds 100% with genetic ancestry, it’s just asking people to self identify their race that’s problematic.
- nefitty 5y agoThat's what confuses me. Some people say race is a construct, but then why do ads for sickle cell medicine only have black actors in them? I don't see how cloaking or censoring ideas of race benefits humanity. I know there's specific problems that are more common in my race. I WANT doctors and scientists to acknowledge that and use that information to improve treatments. I don't feel outraged, just sort of confused as to what the incentives at play here are.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoAbsolutely absurd, and shows how politicized by the state, and its official ideology, science has become. It reminds me of this example of life immitating satire: https://twitter.com/TitaniaMcGrath/status/1421619700312809473?s=20 https://twitter.com/TitaniaMcGrath/status/142161970031280947...
- nefitty 5y agoThis is sort of like when doctors prescribe ibuprofen without explaining the research backing their decision. Are these decisions based on research or purely ideology? I'm starting to see my faith in these institutions erode at an alarming rate. The other day I rewatched an old episode of Bullshit, and it turns out smoking bans in the early 2000's were predicated on bad science. There was no significant evidence that second hand smoke causes cancer. Throw in COVID, political correctness, Omicron and the reproducibility crisis hitting cancer research and I'm suddenly feeling really fucking alone on the plane of authority.
- adolph 5y ago> suddenly feeling really fucking alone on the plane of authority. Maybe you are in fact alone on a plane you call authority.
- nefitty 5y agoTo clarify, I meant that as a figure of speech. As in, there's different contexts of reality that individuals can look to, for example family, work, etc. On my personal view of the context of authority figures, it seems to be more and more vacant as time goes on. I did not mean I'm physically in an airplane. Sorry for the mix up.
- adolph 5y agoIn terms of ways of understanding described in David Deutsch’s “The Beginning of Infinity” you are on a path that may lead to understanding the world more clearly. Relativism The misconception that statements cannot be objectively true or false, but can be judged only relative to some cultural or other arbitrary standard. Instrumentalism The misconception that science cannot describe reality, only predict outcomes of observations. Justificationism The misconception that knowledge can be genuine or reliable only if it is justified by some source or criterion. Fallibilism The recognition that there are no authoritative sources of knowledge, nor any reliable means of justifying knowledge as true or probable.
- civilized 5y agohttps://outline.com/KLUktE https://outline.com/KLUktE
- nharada 5y agoI don't understand how the criticisms in the comment section here are at all related to the actual journal article. From the abstract of the paper: Throughout The Journal’s 70-year history, “ancestry” and “ethnicity” have increased in use, appearing in 33% and 26% of articles in 2009–2018, while the use of “race” has decreased, occurring in 4% of articles in 2009–2018. Although its overall use has declined, the odds of “race” appearing in the presence of “ethnicity” has increased relative to the odds of occurring in its absence. Forms of population descriptors “Caucasian” and “Negro” have largely disappeared from The Journal (<1% of articles in 2009–2018). Conversely, the continental labels “African,” “Asian,” and “European” have increased in use and appear in 18%, 14%, and 42% of articles from 2009–2018, respectively. Am I missing something? Is it not more accurate in genetics to describe populations based on their originating location rather than the color of their skin?
- civilized 5y agoYeah, I'm really not following all the talk of "wokeness" here. Race is a social category that often says something about your ancestry, and about certain traits like skin color and statistical predisposition to certain genetic diseases. But ancestry is the actual genetically meaningful thing. So why would we want researchers to use the outdated concept of race? Is it woke to prefer oxygen to phlogiston?
- wrp 5y ago"Race" when referring to humans is equivalent to "breed" when referring to animals. Both terms, as used in biology, refer to groupings of heritable traits. Is "breed" an invalid concept because a Poodle can mate with a Labrador?
- civilized 5y agoBy this standard, the African bush and the villages of India should be full of thousands of "races" because of the high genetic diversity and relative reproductive isolation of many populations therein, which far exceeds that which delineates our conventional racial classification. But in the real world, race always refers to the same old Negroid/Caucasoid/Mongoloid classification that a few Westerners came up with in the 1700s. Why is that? Does it feel plausible that Science fixated on the Biologically Correct racial classification of humans over a century before Mendelian genetics and the germ theory of disease became widely accepted? Or is it perhaps more plausible that racial classification came into vogue for other, more unfortunate reasons, which are now well-known and documented, and then persisted by mere inertia and conventionalism/conformism?
- jimbob45 5y ago> The decline in usage of “race” reflects how geneticists slowly came to understand race as “a social category with biological consequences,” the team writes in its paper, published today in AJHG. Soooo…a biological category. The ironic part of all this is that it would be very easy to put the ultimate kibosh on any racial superiority claims by simply acknowledging race and then studying the hell out of racial intelligence and physique gaps. I don’t want to fall prey to confirmation bias but it seems abundantly clear from the evidence so far that there are definitely gaps between races…but not gaps large enough to make any sort of useful difference to anyone.
- golemotron 5y agoThe sad thing is that once they find a substitute term it will eventually be considered problematic too. This is the "euphemism treadmill." [1] [1] -https://stevenpinker.com/files/pinker/files/1994_04_03_newyorktimes.pdf https://stevenpinker.com/files/pinker/files/1994_04_03_newyo...
- fundad 5y agoIt’s called progress.
- golemotron 5y agoIt's more like a turntable skipping. You always end up back where you started.
- dhosek 5y agoOf course all the initial commenters are going to declare that this is political correctness gone amok who haven't actually read the article (it was behind a paywall for me), but here are some things that I know from my own reading: 1. "Black" is a not especially useful categorization as there are multiple genetically distinct strains of ancestry within Africa. It's likely that there's a greater difference genetically between an African-American (who is likely of Western African origin mixed with European genetics) than, say, a recent immigrant from South Africa or East Africa. 2. As a sociological term, most people would consider Indians and Europeans to be of different races, but it turns out that genetically they're very similar (which should not be surprising to anyone who's made it through a 100-level course in anthropology or linguistics). 3. That said, the peoples of the Indian sub-continent are also genetically diverse within themselves as there were multiple waves of in-migration there (so you might find some Indians who are not genetically similar to Europeans, and yet, they would end up being treated as the same race as their neighbors who are genetically similar to Europeans). 4. Many of the markers of race end up being selected out in a surprisingly short period of time. Lactose tolerance, for example, evolved in just 2,000–20,000 years and it's likely that a lot of things that we consider fundamental to race similarly appeared in relatively short time frames like this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ravenstine 5y agoI'm cool with that. Now if governments can not ask what my race is on forms...
- ixacto 5y agoExactly. Don’t ask about it or collect it. Yes race existed but it should but be the detriment of anything else.
- jonnybgood 5y agoSo they’re moving from overly-broad, archaic, and imprecise terms to more precise terms that better reflect the human gene pool? That’s great! Not understanding why some have issue with this.
- subroutine 5y agoWhen I was a pd in a genomics lab, I took notice of these debates on twitter. I was curious to understand why "race" was a term some people were adamant should be recognized in almost all contexts except for genetics. From what I've gleaned, it's because people loath the idea of biological factors setting constraints on personal identity. I get it. The same debate has transformed scientific vernacular wrt. sex/gender. And I'm ok with changing the verbiage to whatever people are comfortable with, and if it adds more precision to what scientists are referencing. The terms do not change what is observed in the lab- People with certain genotypes tend to cluster into very distinct observable phenotypes, with regard to ancestry and sex. For example, here are the first 3 principal components plotted from one of the largest genomic data repos available... https://youtu.be/iegYpOG6mQI https://youtu.be/iegYpOG6mQI
- _od5n 5y ago
- rectang 5y ago"Created equal" doesn't mean cloned. Even in the 18th century nobody would have thought that. It means that regardless of whether you are an athletic prodigy, someone with developmental disabilities, or anybody else, you are deserving of equal share in governance — in contrast with aristocracy where some are considered more worthy to rule over others by dint of who they are. With a different version of "created equal", the whole meaning of the rest of your post changes.
- _od5n 5y ago>It means that regardless of whether you are an athletic prodigy, someone with developmental disabilities, or anybody else, you are deserving of equal share in governance — in contrast with aristocracy where some are considered more worthy to rule over others by dint of who they are. What does "an equal share of governance" mean? The question right now isn't enfranchisement, it's whether racial groups-- or ancestral groups, or ethnic cateories-- should have forced proportional representation in things like college admissions, med school admissions, or criminal arrest rates. The assumption put forth by self-labeled antiracists is that disproportionate representation is by itself evidence of racism. That's their core axiom, and it totally ignores signficant heritable (or cultural or environmental) differences between groups. It's an inherently disingenuous ideology, as nobody complains about the overrepresentation of NFL players with African ancestry, for example, but it's an idea with a whole lot of capital behind it.
- alphabettsy 5y agoI’d prefer if people like yourself were forthcoming with what you’re ultimately advocating for instead of pretending to entertain honest intellectual discussion using tired “scientific” propaganda. From my experience people belonging to a certain group of concerned citizenry seem to be complaining about over-representation of black people in the NFL quite regularly.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nobody9999 5y ago"Race" is an outdated term that is rightly being supplanted by terms such as "geographic locus," "ethnicity" and "ancestry." There is, AFAIK, only one sentient primate "race" on the Earth, Homo Sapiens. And the members of that species are, genetically, incredibly closely related. Differences in melanin content, bodily proportions and other immutable traits don't rise to the level of a different species for Homo Sapiens. As such, referring to disparate groups by their geographic locus, ethnicity or ancestry is much more precise than using outdated terms like "race." It's not about "wokeness" or "political correctness." Rather, it's about precision and more useful groupings of individuals.