5 ms·
So basically, another billion dollars worth of business for ASML and other suppliers of equipment that TSMC needed? What I do wonder though, given ASML is a Du
by mschuster91 5y ago
So basically, another billion dollars worth of business for ASML and other suppliers of equipment that TSMC needed?
What I do wonder though, given ASML is a Dutch company, why no European governments are cooperating to start a new, European-owned chip foundry on European soil when the equipment is to a large degree manufactured in Europe. Something similar to Airbus/EADS in terms of setup.
Yes, there are GlobalFoundries and Bosch investing in "Silicon Saxony" aka Dresden, but the former is a US company owned by Emirati oil money and the latter is targeted to produce automotive chips. Europe needs independence from the US and security from China going full bonkers regarding Taiwan.
- tw04 5y agoLikely because it's BILLIONS of dollars of R&D with 0 customers at this point. You'd be building a factory HOPING to get design wins. If I'm Nvidia or Apple or insert company - am I going to risk an entire generation of chips on a startup in Europe with 0 experience beyond what they can poach from competitors? Whatever this European company is, they'd likely need to sell at a massive loss for a generation or 2, just to prove they can do it, and then hope to win some of the profitable contracts from an Apple or Samsung or Nvidia. I would imagine the investment would make a nuclear plant look cheap. And all of that is assuming TSMC or Intel don't build fabs in response to strangle you out of the market.
- dylan604 5y ago>need to sell at a massive loss for a generation or 2, Isn't this where gov't subsidies can help? Not only can gov't wave taxes which helps, but they can also just flat out buy the chips. Or they can add incentives to companies for buying these chips. Either way, it helps ease the transitional pains.
- pjc50 5y agoNot generally allowed under EU competition law.
- dylan604 5y agoThen they can do it like the LHC. Each country contributes, but it happens to physically located in one member country. Either EU feels like it is strategically important to not be dependent, or it's not. By your response, it is clear it is not an important agenda item.
- ido 5y agoIn fact that’s exactly how TSMC and Samsung got where they are - the Taiwanese and Korean governments decided to invest in semiconductor manufacturing at the national level. If a plan like the above goes through EU governments will likely subsidize the likes of Siemens and Philips with 10s of billions of €.
- mschuster91 5y ago> I would imagine the investment would make a nuclear plant look cheap. The disaster of Flamanville is projected to cost 13 billion euros. Even TSMCs biggest projects are smaller than that in numbers. > Whatever this European company is, they'd likely need to sell at a massive loss for a generation or 2, just to prove they can do it, and then hope to win some of the profitable contracts from an Apple or Samsung or Nvidia. Samsung, NVIDIA and AMD are currently blocked by the limitations of TSMC which is mostly caused by Apple paying upfront to reserve all of TSMCs 3nm output [1]. If Europe were to say "okay, we're putting up a 3nm fab and we will not sell to Apple at all" you can bet they would instantly join in to the collaboration, alone to have an alternative to a bidding war with Apple's unfathomably large war chest. [1]: https://www.heise.de/news/Bericht-Apple-schnappt-sich-komplette-3-nm-Kapazitaet-von-TSMC-4998256.html https://www.heise.de/news/Bericht-Apple-schnappt-sich-komple...
- anticensor 5y ago3nm chip production requires BEUV litoghraphy. That one is far out. The so-called 5nm nodes can currently only produce 14nm-sized features. If there is a customer that is willing to reserve the entire EUV and BEUV output of TSMC, so be it; but also keep in mind it is unlikely to see such a large project.
- mschuster91 5y ago> If there is a customer that is willing to reserve the entire EUV and BEUV output of TSMC, so be it A modern society cannot accept a single company gobbling up the entire supply of a constrained resource simply because it can. This stifles innovation.
- renewiltord 5y agoBecause there is precious R&D you need. ASML does not have the technology to do what TSMC does. There is no European company that has it. There are few non-TSMC companies that have it right now, and their tech is out of reach of anyone but them. It costs TSMC $12b to build their fab. It will cost a United European government a lot more money and a lot of time to even develop the tech and by that time semiconductors will have moved on.
- wobblykiwi 5y ago> ASML does not have the technology to do what TSMC does. ASML creates the technology that TSMC uses.
- renewiltord 5y agoIn the same way that TSMC creates the tech that Apple uses but TSMC does not have the Apple tech. That is the value creation chain.
- throw0101a 5y ago> What I do wonder though, given ASML is a Dutch company […] It should be remembered that they have an international supply chain, including lots of stuff out of the US. If the US wanted to, they could basically prevent ASML from shipping finished products. Not only is ASML a one-of-a-kind company, but so are a lot of their suppliers/partners. The Odd Lots podcast had a good episode on this for a general audience (click Manage Cookies > Reject all to get to the article): * https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-15/asml-the-obscure-powerhouse-at-the-cutting-edge-of-chip-technology https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-15/asml-the-... An earlier episode featured TSMC.
- oblio 5y agoThe US would only do that in case of a full blown US - EU trade war, which would probably paralyze the entire world, anyway.
- pjc50 5y ago> why no European governments are cooperating to start a new, European-owned chip foundry on European soil The boring answer is that EU governments are generally banned from subisising businesses, and the EU as a whole is very slow to move. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/eu-could-clear-state-aid-chip-production-amid-global-shortage-2021-11-18/ https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/eu-could-clear-state-ai...
- ulfw 5y agoAnd what are 'the Europeans' going to do with said chips? Bosch is investing in automotive as Europe has plenty of world leading car companies. What world leading mass-market hardware tech companies does Europe have, which would warrant domestic chip production?
- pjc50 5y ago> warrant domestic chip production There are already loads of plants serving the domestic electronics industry? ST? Siemens? NXP? Infineon? https://www.ft.com/content/f946703e-5d1e-4328-bd54-63f30ff49d9b https://www.ft.com/content/f946703e-5d1e-4328-bd54-63f30ff49...
- turbinerneiter 5y agoYou could argue that the lack of mass-market hardware is because of, not due to missing domestic chip production. Not sure if it would be true tough.
- mschuster91 5y ago> What world leading mass-market hardware tech companies does Europe have, which would warrant domestic chip production? AMD actually used to have a fab in Dresden, they spun it off to GlobalFoundries in 2012. Europe as a market of about 450M people should have enough demand to saturate a fab with GPUs and CPUs.
- numpad0 5y agoElectric vehicle inverters? Each motors in an EV require its own 1kV/1kA programmable switching supply to operate.
- philipkglass 5y agoYes, those are valuable but power electronics don't need/use leading edge processes with EUV photolithography. Building more European fabs for power devices would be affordable and useful but it wouldn't compete with TSMC for advanced CPUs and GPUs.
- amelius 5y agoWhat I don't understand is why ASML/TSMC doesn't start a more aggressive monetization model, taking e.g. 30% of the profits of their customers like Apple does.
- jjoonathan 5y agoBecause Intel struck back and NVidia managed to punch upwards by an entire node. The moment TSMC can say "our node makes the king -- start bidding" their margins will expand exactly as you describe. They got close. Very close. Desperate, extreme action by the other players prevented them from fully capitalizing on the trophy. This time. In truth, the 20% price ramp still reflects a partial victory.
- mlindner 5y agoNVidia isn't a fab company or a EUV lithography machine manufacturing company.... Perhaps you mean Samsung (which also uses ASML). And no, Intel didn't "strike back". They forced an existing manufacturing technology to run even hotter and still manage to work.
- jjoonathan 5y agoNVidia is a customer of fab services, and it's customers, not nanometers, that decide which processes are competitive. Nobody would say Samsung 8nm was on equal quality footing to TSMC N7. NVidia, however, proved that they could ship products on Samsung 8 that successfully compete with products shipped on TSMC N7. That's what "punching up" means. It obviously wasn't easy, but it gives them leverage in the next round of negotiations with TSMC, because it proves that TSMC isn't an exclusive kingmaker. Not yet. Yes, Intel did "strike back" -- they shipped competitive products and earned money. Like NVidia on Samsung 8nm, they had to punch up. Once TSMC is a kingmaker, they will charge a king's ransom -- but they aren't. Not yet. Competitors are still holding on, though they certainly have the disadvantage at the moment. The 20% price hikes (which are actually more than 20%) reflect this dynamic almost exactly: TSMC is the champ, but not the undisputed champ, so they can start hiking prices but they can't actually squeeze out their customers' margins yet.
- izend 5y agoi.e. Europe does not care if 24 million Democratic Chinese are suddenly forced into an authoritative society against their will as long as they receive their cheap goods?
- mathverse 5y agoPretty much just look at european take on Ukraine. "Not my chair not my problem".
- phatfish 5y agoIt's nothing to do with "Europe" or anywhere else, or consumers. The reason the Chinese government is uninterested with the "bad press" around repression of minorities in their country is because the know corporations will always take profit over ethics, and will happily contract Chinese factories in the name of being "competitive" -- which boils down to bigger payouts for the executive class.
- pjc50 5y agoThe disaster of Afghanistan has made everyone very wary of interventionist foreign policy.
- mschuster91 5y agoPersonally, I'd support more European backing of Taiwan, and if it needs to be by deploying a bunch of troops there, then that's fine by me. The problem is that the German automotive industry has only China as market to grow (Europe/US/Canada are saturated, South America, most of Asia and Africa don't have enough rich elites, Arabia wants ultra-luxury/sports cars), and the automotive industry is extremely well connected to our politics - even if the CDU/CSU aren't in government any more, liberal FDP now is, and they'll bow to the whims of the industry... meaning Germany will not consent to anything that threatens the automotive industry. Italy and Greece have been forced to sell off harbors, airports and other infrastructure to China as a consequence of the 2008ff crises, Croatia has sold a large and important bridge project to China, and Hungary's Orban is effectively China's puppet. The result of that, combined with the 100% consensus requirement on European foreign policy decisions, is why Europe will likely rather stand aside than show China the well-deserved boot. Especially disgusting given that the European Union's foundation was the lessons-learned of the NS dictatorship and we all swore "never again" - and now we're staying silent as China is building concentration camps for Uyghurs and Tibetans.
- tlamponi 5y agoFWIW, there are some initiatives, specifically there's an Important Project of Common European Interest (IPCEI) microelectronics and a European Chips Act (semi-conductors) in planning. > According to the European Commission work programme for 2022, released on 19 October 2021, > a proposal on a European chips act will be published in Q2 2022. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train/theme-a-europe-fit-for-the-digital-age/file-european-chips-act-(semiconductors) https://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train/theme-a-eur...