6 ms·
> We need work. Not sure I follow. It's amazing how these little bits of social knowledge ferment the flavor of the story. It's a lot like learning to taste be
by kelseyfrog 5y ago
> We need work.
Not sure I follow. It's amazing how these little bits of social knowledge ferment the flavor of the story. It's a lot like learning to taste beer or wine. Once you take the time to sit down and learn to pay attention to your senses, you can identify things like acetaldehyde, diacetyl, and mercaptans. It's fun teaching people how to sense things they weren't aware of before.
The author seems to have done a little trick. By assuming this little fact, it serves as a rationalization for Dad's emotional neglect. It explains his behavior in retrospect, and I get why that makes sense. But that doesn't mean it's true, it doesn't have any predictive power because it reverses subject and object. "We need work" is a social fact, nothing more, and it's only true as much as it's believed to be true. To me it stands out like pickle in pancake, maybe it can for you too.
- systemsignal 5y agoIt’s not a social fact, it’s a fact of thermodynamics. Every system breaks down, unless it is maintained through energy/work. At the most basic level, we need food to maintain our system. How will you get it without work?
- DarylZero 5y agoMost people don't consider e.g. worms etc. to be working.
- amw-zero 5y agoWork is generally a proxy for survival. Do you agree that you need to eat in order to survive?
- ehutch79 5y agoFilling out TPS reports is not a survival skill
- emaginniss 5y agoThis is a function of specialization. You fill out TPS reports to generate value for a company which allows you to purchase food created by people who specialize in food generation.
- nostrademons 5y agoNot all work involves filling out TPS reports. A lot of workplaces have completely automated this aspect. And you should feel free to quit jobs that haven't for jobs that have; by doing so, you're making the economy more efficient.
- nomel 5y agoHonestly asking, how is it not a survival skill? It's a high level abstraction that's part of the "need" for the company, which is why they're paid to fill out that report, with the skill being all the intelligent/understanding required for that high level abstraction. It's literally paying for all the needs and squishy comforts of life for that individual, most likely much squishier than an average individual.
- amw-zero 5y agoThat's why I said proxy. The vast minority of members of our society take care of our actual physical needs. The rest of us do other things to provide other kinds of value, so that the farmers can do things like enjoy a nice TV show at the end of their day without producing it themselves. For some of those other companies, a TPS report is required.
- kelseyfrog 5y agoEveryone agrees that people need to do certain things to survive. What complicates this line of thinking are the social facts that are assumed when we conceptualize work. The way that work is conceptualized is culturally specific across space and time. The construction "eating implies survival implies work" doesn't imply that our culturally specific conceptualization of work is implied. There are many interesting ways to have conversations about work means, how it changes, and what factors influence how people think about what work is and isn't.
- amw-zero 5y agoI buy this. Maybe this is what people mean when they are anti work - they're just anti modern work? I think it's good to be critical, we can always improve the system. But I also personally believe our society is actually incredible at self-optimizing, and we are pretty darn close to an ideal system in practice. It's easy to focus on the bad, but our society has produced truly immeasurable good (very little relative violence, hunger, boredom, etc.) Of course it can be improved, and there are some real problems, particularly around wealth inequality. But I can't help but think that we're doing pretty damn good.
- DarylZero 5y ago> I buy this. Maybe this is what people mean when they are anti work - they're just anti modern work? It's not "modern work" but work-the-social-institution. Which is the primary definition of "work." What they don't mean is productive activity. Every productive activity that takes place within the social institution of work also takes place outside of that social institution. For example, farming, building construction, cooking, cleaning, education -- all of these take place both inside and outside of work.
- Bancakes 5y agoTechnology has allowed the rise of "made-up", survivally unnecessary jobs like Metaverse programmer, pop singer, and marketing specialists. If anything, the pandemic proved we don't need restaurants and tourism to survive.
- walshemj 5y agoYou would consider Homer "survivally unnecessary" (the poet not the cartoon character)
- kube-system 5y agoArt, entertainment, and communication are not new human creations. These jobs are the result of psychological needs that humans have. Maslow's Hierarchy is more than a cave, nuts, and berries. Furthermore, not everyone can survive without specialization of labor. Prior to specialization of labor, it was much more common for people to die young, and the world's population reflected this.
- adamcstephens 5y agoWas it the specialization of labor, or the harnessing of vasts quantities of stored energy in fossil fuels? I’d wager on the latter.
- kube-system 5y agoAgriculture brought 2 or 3 orders of magnitude in population growth. Industrialization of fossil fuels brought about 1.
- adamcstephens 5y agoAgriculture alone, or fueled by fossil fuels?
- Bancakes 5y agoSpecialisation of what labor? We've always had hunters and gatherers, and still do. We've always been specialised. What I'm saying is Maslow's scale is tipped upside down with an overabundance of leisure and scarcity of high quality basic fulfillment. There's so much entertainment, that we can afford for a few markets to crash and disappear, hence why I called them "made-up".
- DarylZero 5y agoWork is not a proxy for survival. Sometimes have to take time off work to keep your baby alive. Taking care of the survival of your family isn't work. Changing diapers isn't work. Work is a social relation.
- amw-zero 5y agoWork is much more than that - it enables you to feed your family. If there wasn’t a service economy and you had to grow or gather your own food, sometimes you would have to choose between changing a diaper and going to find more food. That’s just what it takes to live, we forget that because of how far removed we are from actual survival. But take away modern society, and the world is much harsher and much less fulfilling.
- Ancapistani 5y ago> "We need work" is a social fact, nothing more, and it's only true as much as it's believed to be true. Having gone through a handful of periods of a few months where I wasn’t working and was also not engaged in an existential struggle for survival, I have to disagree here. Personally, I know that I need a focus for my intellectual life. It needn’t be employment, but “work” is a fair way to describe it. I can spend two or three weeks idling most of the time, but after that I need something to direct my energy and concentration toward. I need a goal that stretches my abilities, or I find myself constantly battling a depressive spiral.
- aulin 5y agoThat's not work, that's life. The opposite of working is not idling, it is spending your time in activities that realize your self without being constrained by the survival struggle.
- as300 5y agoI think his point (and the broader point being assumed by the author) was that "spending your time in activities that realize your self" does, in fact, feel a lot like work.
- aulin 5y agoAnd that's true for a limited subset of people lucky to work in a field where the two aspects overlap.
- as300 5y agoI still don't think you understand. If your passion is painting, and its something you would do for free, then fulfilling your artistic potential is still work. It still requires hours upon hours of deliberate practice. The great masters would spend years working on a single painting. You don't think there would be times when they just didn't feel like making progress? Where they wanted to just take the day off and hang out at a bar with their friends? Part of the human condition is struggle, imo. That's what I think the OP is getting at when he says that human beings need work. Maybe not a 9-5, but we all need something worth staving off instant gratification for.
- redis_mlc 5y ago> "We need work" is a social fact, nothing more, and it's only true as much as it's believed to be true. Nonsense. Most men derive purpose in life from work (ie. providing) - this is basic psychology. Even male millionaires start new companies so they have something to do with their time. Women have entered the workplace, but they're mostly driven by insecurity, not purpose. As one woman programmer told me, "You want to be world-class. I want to sit in my garden patio." Also, give the fruity prose a break, this is HN, not Lapham's Quarterly.
- nostrademons 5y agoI don't think that was the author's message at all. Rather, I think that this post is about balance, and about being emotionally present. He's saying that it should be a constant struggle to balance off things that you care about, because that shows you care. The only way to avoid the struggle is to cease caring, and that means you push something out of your mind that you really should be paying attention to because it's uncomfortable. I've got plenty of stories about a dad who went the other way - full time househusband, gave up his career entirely soon after my sister and I were born - but they're a bit too personal to share on HN. It's not all roses and sunshine on that side either, though.
- romwell 5y ago>He's saying that it should be a constant struggle to balance off things that you care about, because that shows you care Yay, survival should be a struggle, because it shows you care (about increasing the ROI for the shareholders you'll never see)! "We need work" is justified by "we need shelter and food". The only thing a constant struggle shows is that you don't have the freedom to choose how you spend your life. What people need is a vocation, a calling, fulfilment from creativity or helping other people out. The things that we call hobbies, that is (and people who enjoy them - amateurs). Work is an exchange of about half of your waking hours for the privilege of not dying in this society (because as far as food and shelter go, yes, we actually do need them, as well as healthcare, education, transportation, etc). The only way to avoid struggle is to be rich - and that's because the rich had set it up that way. Van Gogh never even had a career to give up, and his struggles weren't because it was hard for him to divide his attention.
- xupybd 5y agoI think we need work for more than food and shelter. We need a place in the world, something to strive for and something to help us find meaning. You complete with others to stretch yourself. People that build huge businesses keep push and building for more. Many like the money but are more motivated by the Vision of what they're building. There is something built into us that wants to strive that wants to work. Hobbies don't satisfy the same need. Hobbies are self directed and motivated. You don't get the same sense of achievement. That said grinding 40 hours a week as a process worker is life sucking. That is not a good long term way of being. You need a hope of moving up to make that worth it.
- dionidium 5y ago> "We need work" is a social fact, nothing more, and it's only true as much as it's believed to be true. To me it stands out like pickle in pancake, maybe it can for you too. Something I believe, but can't really prove is that this is completely wrong and there's very little about the need for "work" that's socially determined. We are biological creatures that evolved under very specific circumstances. And "work" in the most basic sense is a big part of that. We need to be struggling to feed ourselves (or simulating it) -- every day. Most of us wither and die when that need is removed.
- ryeights 5y agoWho’s to say that the work we do is a good simulation? Most jobs are not fulfilling, and our country is in the midst of a mental health crisis
- dionidium 5y agoProbably this is true. Something about specialization, maybe.
- what_is_orcas 5y agoThat's cute, but it doesn't make sense. Most (I avoid saying all, because I'm not that smart) animals, when not surviving (finding food, consuming food, finding sex, having sex) are super idle. It's energetically expensive to work, and, so far as I can tell, nothing has evolved to be energetically stressed. If we're throwing around words like "evolution" we need to understand that we're talking about genetic survival (passing genes on through generations). The state of "struggling to feed ourselves" is directly antithetical to the goal of having sex. At best you could argue that the hypothesis that peacocks attract mates with their flamboyant tail feathers suggests that they've survived to maturity as intact as they are because of their good genes (survival in spite of being an easy, colorful target for predators), but that's a stretch.
- dionidium 5y ago> Most (I avoid saying all, because I'm not that smart) animals, when not surviving (finding food, consuming food, finding sex, having sex) are super idle. It's energetically expensive to work, and, so far as I can tell, nothing has evolved to be energetically stressed. "[F]inding food, consuming food, finding sex, having sex" is the work I'm talking about. So, yes, animals are either working or they're "super idle." There's no third mode where they're, like, finding their true selves. They're either working or they're asleep.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoIt's more than a social fact. It's a consequence of living in a physical reality with physical wants and needs that require action to be satisfied. The best we can do is move the work around, and have someone else do it. (We can harness physical forces to take care of most of the work in the force-times-distance sense, but we're still a long way from moving the rest.) And the ultimate problem with moving it around so that we don't have to do any of it will be that it is likely to result in some outside entity having outsized power over our lives.
- Barrin92 5y agoOP talks about 'work' in a particular way, as does the author of the piece. What we need is food, shelter and so on. 'Work' as in conflict with 'life' (i.e the work-life balance) is a social construct. It didn't always use to be that way, and it doesn't have to. That we have physical needs is a fact. That we have alienated work from life, or family, or expressing ourselves is not. That work created an absentee father is not in the laws of physics, obviously, but that it's hard to perceive it as anything else is what OP pointed out, and that's something worth paying attention to. The idea that you have to 'move work around' (kind of sounds like moving garbage around) wouldn't make sense to a person who is able to express themselves in their work. Ask a craftsman for example, an artist, or someone on a family farm. The fact that people are detached from their work, that they're objects of their work, that their work dehumanizes them in extreme cases, that is a result of a particular mode of production we are living under. Someone for whom their work is an extension of their life, who are not detached from the products of their work, and for whom work strengthens their social relations, there is no work-life balance, because there is no work-life conflict.
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> The idea that you have to 'move work around' (kind of sounds like moving garbage around) wouldn't make sense to a person who is able to express themselves in their work. Ask a craftsman for example, an artist, or someone on a family farm. When I go over to the printmaking studio, I recognize that in principle someone else might be able to grind the limestone slabs I intend to use for printing, maintain the printing press, clean up the ink, or perform any number of tasks incidental to the expressive portion. I am just as sure that anyone on a family farm knows they can, in principle, get someone else in the family to do work, and that hired hands exist, and can take care of many tasks or unpleasant chores. They may prefer to do the work themselves, so that they get better results, or have more control or feel useful, or because they have a duty to contribute productively. In every job that must be done, there is an element of fun. It is essentially never entirely fun.
- disambiguation 5y agoI think you're also doing a trick here. While it's not necessary that everyone works, some work is necessary. If people stopped showing up to the farms, or the water treatment plants, everyone would die. So, someone has to work. Labeling "we need work" as only a social fact is a misguided kind of relativism. "Society has created arbitrary weights and values on which work gets rewards, therefore we only need work if we believe we need it". The logic is just plain faulty.
- supernovae 5y agoI've always wondered why we don't switch to a 20-30 hour work week or 4 work days a week... And not in some bs "part time vs full time" but that we have enough humans on this freakin planet that you should only need to work 30 hours a week to live a healthy, balanced life.
- nradov 5y agoIf you want that lifestyle then go ahead. Most anyone can do it. Move to a cheap area and you can survive on a part time job. https://www.kiplinger.com/real-estate/602609/cheapest-small-towns-in-america-2021 https://www.kiplinger.com/real-estate/602609/cheapest-small-...
- sokoloff 5y agoYou can and some people choose that. Same as you can choose to have only one adult in a pair do paid work. What happens is that other humans do more hours of work per household and outbid you on things that you might otherwise want. Some people are OK with that and go on to live happy lives. Others get frustrated and join the race to keep up with the others. (Which I think is a choice that people should have; I would strongly oppose taking that choice away, but the end result is that lots of people are working lots of hours to buy lots of things.)
- refurb 5y agoWe certainly could but every one then needs to accept a lower standard of living.
- 5y ago
- new_stranger 5y agoWell, "work" is a broad term. It can mean a paycheck, the gulag, or that todo you've been putting off because you want to finish the show. Lots more as well. Some are meanings are constructs, but some are limitations of complete communication from a single English world.
- teekert 5y agoFwiw, I felt exactly the same.
- blitz_skull 5y agoI disagree that it's a social construct. I'm not saying that we all need to work for hyper-capitalistic machines. Or even anything remotely resembling a "business". But humans need to do semi-regular things that approximate work. Whether it's something like running a farm, coding programs, or passing lessons on to the next generation—we all need something semi-recurring, with some perception of value. I do agree that the sense of duty towards work that is stereo-typically cultivated in Silicon Valley is a social construct and not at all a universal truth. THAT we can both agree is definitely a social construct.
- DarylZero 5y agoThat's not what work means. Productivity isn't work. Hence why people take time off work to take care of their kids or house. Work is a social relation. If you don't have that social relation, then nothing you do will be recognized as work.
- yeahh8hjd 5y agoI think some specificity is needed. To me when you write “we need work” is a social fact, I read “we need jobs/full employment.” Work to me is a term that applies to any system doing a task; input->(processing)->output. So like you’re saying, it’s “work” in a “biological sense” to learn wine. Inherently we need to “work” but our social idea of work is arbitrary, a lot is busy work. Police violence, don’t let government have weapons of mass destruction to police global violence, wind down superfluous industrialism, deflate chads whose dads own dealerships and be humans.