9 ms·
Police Assisted Apple Investigators in Search of SF Man's Home
- ajays 15y agoAsk yourself: would 3-4 SFPD officers show up at the door of a suspected bike thief if someone claimed he had stolen a bike worth $500? Dear H-N readers from SF: you _can_ effect change by contacting your supervisors and asking them to raise questions with SFPD. You don't have to silently sit there watching bad things happen; you have an option, and that is to speak up. Sending an email to your supervisor is a very easy thing to do, and if enough of us band together and raise our voices, the powers-that-be will have to listen.
- potatolicious 15y agoI wish I shared you idealism. You're talking about the SFPD - the same SFPD that has gotten away with beatings, illegal arrests, blatant racism and bigotry for decades. If the mass beating of gays in the Castro and two dozen illegal arrests wasn't able to perturb the SFPD, what makes you think the illegal search of one man's home will? I get the feeling that in municipal politics the police-city relationship is very similar to the military-government relationship in many banana republics. On paper one answers to the other, but in reality one is so powerful by itself that it is essentially immune to prosecution.
- sigzero 15y agoFor the last time, it was NOT an illegal search. They asked and were given permission to enter and search. Does that need repeating?
- RexRollman 15y agoThe gave permission for cops to search, not Apple. They knew full well that they were creating the impression that all of them were police officers.
- scarmig 15y agoGroup of people show up in plainsclothes. One knocks on your door and identifies himself as a police officer and alludes threateningly to your family's immigration status. Two of the others ask if they can enter your house. You agree to it (and they find nothing). Everything in that series of events is incredibly sketchy and falls under the heading "if it isn't illegal, it should be." And if you go by the spirit of the law, the Apple employees should definitely be charged for impersonating police officers, given this narrative of events. Note that it would still be incredibly goonish even if (a) they made sure the dude understood they were Apple employees and not police officers or (b) everyone involved actually is a police officer. Pure nastiness on the part of Apple and the SFPD.
- _debug_ 15y ago"According to Dangerfield, the officers "did not go inside the house," but stood outside while the Apple employees scoured Calderón's home, car, and computer files" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_impersonation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_impersonation
- ajays 15y ago"I wish I shared you idealism. You're talking about the SFPD - the same SFPD that has gotten away with beatings, illegal arrests, blatant racism and bigotry for decades." I know what you're saying: but that shouldn't stop us from trying! Look at it this way. If we don't raise questions, then things continue on the trajectory they're on (Newton's Third Law? ;) ). However, if we do raise questions, in sufficient numbers, then we have a chance, however small it may be, to effect change. So why not try to effect change? We have nothing to lose! At the worst, things are no different; in the best case, things get better. So please! Contact your supe from this page: http://www.sfbos.org/index.aspx?page=1616 http://www.sfbos.org/index.aspx?page=1616 It'll only take a minute.
- jquery 15y agoHe granted permission for the Apple employees to enter his residence to search. Nothing in the article indicates any civil liberties were violated. Ask yourself: would an iPhone 5 would get $500 on the open market? More likely it would be worth $100,000 or more. And if someone stole a $100,000 device of mine with a GPS device that was tracked to a residence, I would hope the SFPD would help me. Anything less would be a miscarriage of justice. Now onto guilt, this person admitted he was at the bar from which the iPhone was allegedly stolen. Now while this might not be enough to convict someone in a court of law, it's certainly enough to investigate further. I do not understand why this story is getting any traction except the standard internet hatreds for police and corporations.
- RexRollman 15y agoThe main problem, as I see it, is that he didn't know the two men who searched their home were not police officers. Worse, the cops allowed the man to have the impression that they were. And the fact that the cops themselves didn't go inside shows me that they knew what they were doing was questionable.
- ajays 15y ago"And the fact that the cops themselves didn't go inside shows me that they knew what they were doing was questionable." EXACTLY! Have you ever, ever known the cops to back off from doing something, and let a civilian handle it? In my few observations of such situations, I've always seen the cops take charge, and shoo the civilians away. For them to just stand at the boundary line and watch the Apple goons go in and search, to me, is clear evidence that the cops knew fully well what they were doing.
- mgcross 15y agoHe granted SFPD permission, not Apple employees. $100k? That sounds like a stretch. Are you saying the residences of everyone present at the bar that night should be subject to search?
- ajays 15y agoHe granted what he assumed were the SFPD to enter his house. And just because he doesn't know the law, it does NOT mean that it doesn't apply to him. The laws still apply. The cops knew that they had absolutely no evidence or reason to search his house; which is why they wisely stayed outside. But they also knew that they had created a false impression that the Apple goons were also SFPD, which allowed them to enter the guy's house. As far as the value is concerned: so what? If I put a value of $1000000 on my Bic pen, does that mean I'm allowed to break the laws in finding out who took it?? If it really was that valuable, then what the heck was an Apple employee doing with it getting drunk in a sleazy bar? Will the Apple employee be docked $100,000 from his paycheck if the phone is not found? Get real!
- epistasis 15y agoThey wouldn't show up for a typical $500 phone, either, as is amply documented by many people's accounts of trying to recover phones that have been precisely located. But it's extremely disingenuous to say that this is just another phone, it's value is much higher than $500.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- scarmig 15y agoDiscussion when news first broke: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2955087 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2955087 New information: San Francisco Police Department spokesman Lt. Troy Dangerfield now tells SF Weekly that "three or four" SFPD officers accompanied two Apple security officials in an unusual search of a Bernal Heights man's home. ...plainclothes SFPD officers went with private Apple detectives to the home of Sergio Calderón, a 22-year-old resident of Bernal Heights. According to Dangerfield, the officers "did not go inside the house," but stood outside while the Apple employees scoured Calderón's home, car, and computer files for any trace of the lost iPhone 5.
- Steko 15y agoiOS 4.3.6: Fixed a bug with Find My iPhone that caused it to randomly show phones as being at Sergio Calderon's house.
- patrickod 15y agoWhat legal issues are there with the Apple employees and not the plainclothes police officers carrying out this search ? Are Apple in the clear here seeing as Calderon agreed to the search ?
- 0x0x0x 15y agoYes, I would think so. Anyone basically has any right to anything you allow.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- shabble 15y agoGoing completely off topic, there are, at least in some places, irrevocable rights which cannot be overruled by consent. In the UK, R v Brown[1] "ruled that consent was not a valid legal defence for wounding and actual bodily harm". I believe there is also law (again, varying by jurisdiction and treaty obligations) to prevent a person from consenting to their own slavery. https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Indentured_servant#Legal_status https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Indentured_se... seems to cover it briefly, but I can't find a better reference immediately. [1] https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Operation_Spanner https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Operation_Spa...
- sdkmvx 15y ago> Reached this afternoon, Calderón confirmed that only two of the six people who came to his home actually entered the house. He said those two did not specifically state they were police officers. > However, he said he was under the impression that they were all police, since they were part of the group outside that identified themselves as SFPD officials. The two who entered the house did not disclose that they were private security officers, according to Calderón. I wonder if they had the same badges, uniform on? Or did the Apple people have their own security uniform on and Calderón just didn't notice the difference. Maybe Apple's people could have been more explicit that they were not the police, but this reads like a big misunderstanding.
- runjake 15y agoThe article said they were in plainclothes. No uniforms.
- mscarborough 15y agoAn official SFPD spokesman said "three or four" SFPD were involved in the actual search? How many SFPD resources were involved in the run-up to the search? This sounds worse than a poor engineering post-mortem: only "three or four" hours or days went into the work, but that could easily involve another "three or four" that were not included in the estimate, so are not counted for the total effort involved. I'd hope a publicly-funded department has greater accountability than a random development task, but here we are.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>I'd hope a publicly-funded department has greater accountability than a random development task// Presumably these police carry GPS devices (that would eg give their location when they call in and such) and so the whereabouts of any officer on duty should be traceable in their database?
- happyhacker 15y agoHeads need to roll for this little stunt.
- tlrobinson 15y agoHe voluntarily let them search his home, right? Does it matter whether they were police or not?
- boucher 15y agoWell, nobody broke a law by entering after permission was given. But, they may have broken the law if they impersonated police officers (and how that law is drafted I do not know). They may also have broken the law (or, alternatively, the officers may face some penalty) for misuse of police resources -- I don't really know what kinds of rules there are about getting police to aid in private investigations, but I imagine there are some. In any case, the person in question certainly didn't have to let these people in, and probably shouldn't have. But, it can be tough to justify refusing entry to the police if you think you haven't done anything wrong.
- tlrobinson 15y agoIf standing next to a plainclothes officer who identifies himself as police is considered impersonating a police officer something is wrong with the law. It sounds sketchy but I doubt anyone broke the law here.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoSuppose you go on to the gridiron at the start of a match dressed as one of the team - you're just there right, not impersonating a member of the team? Anyone who things you're in the team is just mistaken, the team shouldn't need to make it clear?
- ajays 15y agoYou probably have never seen this happen, hence your naiveté. When a bunch of cops show up at your door, each of them doesn't identify themselves separately as a cop. The leader will usually announce, "SFPD! We are here to investigate blah blah blah...", and probably show a badge. His other comrades will just stand there. They don't go down the conga line, each swearing an oath that they are cops. It is assumed that the first announcement is enough to establish authority.
- codex 15y agoIf a stolen iPhone phones home that it is at particular house that very instant (or recently), is that probable cause to search the house without a warrant? If the officers think that the phone is likely to stop phoning home imminently, seems like the answer would be "yes," but these devices are so new I wonder if courts have ruled on it.
- karipatila 15y agoWhy would they need a warrant if they are given permission to enter and search the premises?
- burgerbrain 15y agoApparently the actual police involved were well aware of what little legal right they had to be in the building. The "permission" they got would not hold up in court and they knew it.
- trying 15y agoConsidering that billions of dollars worth of revenue are at stake here, and that Apple is likely a major target for industrial espionage, I have no problem with the government getting involved. Apple is a major contributor to both the local and national economy, and the government should help to protect their common interests.
- wunderfool 15y ago?? you must be trolling. i don't recall the section in the legal code where we waive rights for local employers
- Pointsly 15y agoSniff a big lawsuit in the making - sounds like their might be an illegal search and seizure going on here - BIG RIGHTS VIOLATION. I believe this is a strict liability case - meaning - would the normal guy think that his rights were being violated and he was the victim of an illegal search? In what capacity were the cops and everyone involved identified at the time of the 'crime'? Should they have gotten a warrant? I definitely want to know what kind of documentation was taken - sounds to me like a good old fashion ILLEGAL police state shake up? Anyone else? Take care of these cops - this is ridiculous.
- Robin_Message 15y agoHorrible, horrible corporatism. That's not the stuff the American dream is made of.
- slowpoke 15y agoI don't mean to be offensive, but George Carlin summed this up pretty decently: It's called the American Dream because you have to be asleep to believe it.
- sneak 15y ago> In an interview with SF Weekly last night, Calderón told us that six badge-wearing visitors came to his home in July to inquire about the phone. Calderón said none of them acknowledged being employed by Apple, and one of them offered him $300, and a promise that the owner of the phone would not press charges, if he would return the device. I wonder if it was the Apple-associated people who spouted this lie (my guess would be yes). Individuals (e.g. victims) do not have any say in whether or not a prosecutor charges a suspect with a crime. This is a common misunderstanding - there is no such thing as "pressing charges" if you are not a prosecutor. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
- terrapinbear 15y agoI can't seem to find any mention regarding how Calderon came to hold the iPhone 5 prototype in his possession. Can anyone shed light on this? The media never seems to report on this aspect of the case.
- jquery 15y agoHe was at the bar the night it went missing. Likely Calderon pickpocketed the phone.